Why I Am An Atheist

Definition of faith: belief in something for which there is no proof. In demanding evidence or logic or empirical proof you are simply misunderstanding the nature of religion.

I think she understands it quite well, she just chooses not to buy into it. Do you also believe in the Santa and the Tooth Fairy? How about Bigfoot?
 
I think she understands it quite well, she just chooses not to buy into it. Do you also believe in the Santa and the Tooth Fairy? How about Bigfoot?

I didn't say I believe in God either. i just understand the nature of faith whether or not I am religious. Someone who insists on proof of the existence of God does not understand the nature of faith.
 
I didn't say I believe in God either. i just understand the nature of faith whether or not I am religious. Someone who insists on proof of the existence of God does not understand the nature of faith.

People who believe in something that there is no proof for...what's the name for that? Oh yeah...gullible. Fact is most organized religon is fear based - if you don't do this God (or the diety of choice) will punish you. Organized religon is bullying. I understand the concept but choose not to buy into it, I like to think I'm stronger than that.
 
Yeah, the nature of faith makes people delusional.

You clearly do not understand the meaning or proper use of the term delusional.

But your position is an excellent example of how modern atheists are arrogant and wish to promote themselves as superior to others. And often don't know what the are talking about.
 
People who believe in something that there is no proof for...what's the name for that? Oh yeah...gullible. Fact is most organized religon is fear based - if you don't do this God (or the diety of choice) will punish you. Organized religon is bullying. I understand the concept but choose not to buy into it, I like to think I'm stronger than that.

By equating faith with gullibility you are demonstrating that you do not understand the concept. You need not buy into faith but to understand the concept you must understand that faith is belief without proof. That is not gullibility. Very big difference.
 
People who believe in something that there is no proof for...what's the name for that? Oh yeah...gullible. Fact is most organized religon is fear based - if you don't do this God (or the diety of choice) will punish you. Organized religon is bullying. I understand the concept but choose not to buy into it, I like to think I'm stronger than that.

Faith is an everyday part of life, whether you like it or not. Ideas like love, justice, fairness, charity, etc are moral concepts that are beyond the realms which science is qualified to answer.

In the same sense the Pope is not really qualified to tell me about the real nature of black holes, scientists are not at all helpful in the discussion on how to live a moral or meritorious life.

And do you suggest that there is no bullying in atheism, secular humanism, or science?
 
I don't care to convert people to atheism, but the mandate of Christianity is to convert non-believers. That's what pisses me off. Unless you can interpret 'spread the gospel' to something else like, "I'm going to fuck off and leave you guys alone now," I'm going to continue to look down at people subservient to religion.

I am curious, do you feel the same way about say...Coke? Or Capitalism? Or Liberals? Or Ford? Or Vegetarianism? Or Tampex?

They are all trying to sell you something, get you to believe in something. I guess you think we should all sit alone in our little hovels and not share ideas. One of the premises of a healthy democracy is the free marketplace of ideas. Do you think Christians or other religions should be banned from the public square, or should we just ban all ideas?
 
By equating faith with gullibility you are demonstrating that you do not understand the concept. You need not buy into faith but to understand the concept you must understand that faith is belief without proof. That is not gullibility. Very big difference.

No difference at all...let me be blunt - if you bought a house and were told that the house was a certain standard with certain featues and you had no way to confirm this other than what the seller told you...and you paid for it...and didn't get what the seller told you...you're gullible. You did the deal on faith, but you're still gullible. The concept is the same, the label on the concept is different depending on which side of the fence you are on.
 
No difference at all...let me be blunt - if you bought a house and were told that the house was a certain standard with certain featues and you had no way to confirm this other than what the seller told you...and you paid for it...and didn't get what the seller told you...you're gullible. You did the deal on faith, but you're still gullible. The concept is the same, the label on the concept is different depending on which side of the fence you are on.

That is because you equate faith with temporal matters which is simply wrong. If I take it as an article of my faith that if I lead a righteous lie my soul will go to heaven perhaps you can prove me wrong.
 
That is because you equate faith with temporal matters which is simply wrong. If I take it as an article of my faith that if I lead a righteous lie my soul will go to heaven perhaps you can prove me wrong.

It's your article of faith...prove it right.
 
Yes, of course with all of those things, there is ideology. Someone who blindly gives into advertising is just as much open to my scorn as someone who follows faith. Psychoanalysts like Althusser state that we are all, in the end, a slave to ideology in some form or another. Regardless, it is our job as enlightened, rational beings to strive to mediate through the bullshit as much as we can. Read an essay on how advertising works, or how political rhetoric works. Read an essay on how science and evolution works. And put together the fact that none of the latter were mentioned in the Bible.

Call it arrogance, but when people refuse to take empirical data, I see myself as a little better off and better equipped for reality than they are.

Many religious people are probably far better than you at "taking empirical data".

But you express anger at people trying to sell their religion. You don't express the anger at the same people trying to convince you their beer tastes better. It undermines the rationality of your argument.

The bible does not claim to be a science textbook. Should I reject the latest book on oh...the economics of WWII because it does not mention evolution? Should I reject the evolution texts I am reading right now because they do not discuss the nature of love, or charity?

Your arguments against religion are pretty thin. They just seem to prove you don't like religion, and not much else.
 
Religion, from a utilitarian perspective, was a great promoter of good morals at a time when there was no system of law to enact these morals in society.

Today, in the west at least, we have legislative bodies to do that job. We can argue, with proof, in the court of law, about what is better or worse for society, without having to result to relying on shoddy 'interpretations' from some archaic text that is most likely made up.

I never claimed there was no bullying in atheism. All people are open to flaws and antagonism. If you're talking about those atheist ads on the subway, however, I don't see that as bullying, as I see Christian ads on the subway all the time.

I do have a problem when marriage commissioners PAID BY THE STATE refuse to marry gays on the basis that it would infringe upon their freedom of speech.

I work in the law courts. They are very limited as arbiters of morality and are not there to define how one should lead a good life. They are there to punish those who run afoul of the state's ideas, to regulate activities the state chooses to regulate, or to settle private disputes, and regulate the relationship between the government and the citizens. You think the legislature's role is to tell people how to live a virtuous life? That is a very troubling idea. I guess in your world the way to live a virtuous life changes every election cycle.

To suggest that the law courts are a reasonable substitute for sources of moral guidance on how to live your life...is the height of folly.
 
Probably not. The underlying premise of the Bible is that a) god exists, and b) he/she has revealed him/herself and his/her message.

God is a man, make no mistake about that. The bible clearly states that a woman is on this earth to serve her man.
 
You are missing the point of religion. Religion is based on faith which is the absence of empirical evidence. It is believing the face of what may appear to be insurmountable contrary evidence. People of religion generally also believe that they cannot necessarily comprehend their god's plan and so when someone say why do bad things happen to good people although we may not understand why the faithful believe that it is nonetheless part of gods bigger plan.

And this is the crux of the BS. The so called revelation of God, the bible, teaches through the parable of the good Samaritan, for example, that if you have it in your power to help someone and you do not do it that is evil. Yet God is purported to have all power (omnipotent), full of love/compassion (all loving), and yet chooses to let people suffer and be killed in all kinds of cruel ways - and I am close to a recent example of this. There is no bigger plan, no possible good in this. Even if it brings "people to the Lord" that would be a trick that makes the devil look righteous. It is actually easy to comprehend. There cannot be a loving and all powerful god with a world as it is.

Unless you resort to Orwellian double speak....which believers frequently do. Good is bad, bad is good, pain and suffering are good....all the while grovelling in the idea that you can't trust your mind to come to any simple conclusions but you have to rely on blind faith, contrary to any evidence. God is either non loving, and could care less, and most likely causes pain and evil, or it totally lacks power to do anything, hence is not the version of God I was once a believer in.

And that is why you have believers in umpteen different gods and religions. You cannot use reason to seperate conflicting and contradictory claims about god when you reject reason and logic and evidence in the first place.
 
Why do atheists feel the need to spread their religion around? They're worse than Jehova's IMO.

I checked out the site reddit the other day, and it is filled with atheist vitriol and cartoons. Please get a life!

Couldn't agree more. I find religious people far more tolerable than atheists simply because [for the most part] they do not insist on imposing their beliefs on other people. Atheists have to learn to shut up and just let people make their own choices. Here's a reality check: nobody cares why you think religion is wrong.
 
And this is the crux of the BS. The so called revelation of God, the bible, teaches through the parable of the good Samaritan, for example, that if you have it in your power to help someone and you do not do it that is evil. Yet God is purported to have all power (omnipotent), full of love/compassion (all loving), and yet chooses to let people suffer and be killed in all kinds of cruel ways - and I am close to a recent example of this. There is no bigger plan, no possible good in this. Even if it brings "people to the Lord" that would be a trick that makes the devil look righteous. It is actually easy to comprehend. There cannot be a loving and all powerful god with a world as it is.

Unless you resort to Orwellian double speak....which believers frequently do. Good is bad, bad is good, pain and suffering are good....all the while grovelling in the idea that you can't trust your mind to come to any simple conclusions but you have to rely on blind faith, contrary to any evidence. God is either non loving, and could care less, and most likely causes pain and evil, or it totally lacks power to do anything, hence is not the version of God I was once a believer in.

And that is why you have believers in umpteen different gods and religions. You cannot use reason to seperate conflicting and contradictory claims about god when you reject reason and logic and evidence in the first place.

Well of course everyone believes that his/her god os the one true god so the existence of multiple deities does not prove or disprove the existence of some true god. With respect to the good things/bad things dichotomy it is presumptuous for man to presume that he is capable of comprehending Gods true plan whatever that may be. Again faith is the ability in the face of misery and tragedy to believe that god has some bigger plan.
 
Many religious people are probably far better than you at "taking empirical data".

But you express anger at people trying to sell their religion. You don't express the anger at the same people trying to convince you their beer tastes better. It undermines the rationality of your argument.

The bible does not claim to be a science textbook. Should I reject the latest book on oh...the economics of WWII because it does not mention evolution? Should I reject the evolution texts I am reading right now because they do not discuss the nature of love, or charity?

Your arguments against religion are pretty thin. They just seem to prove you don't like religion, and not much else.

The bible may not claim to be a science text book, but many of its followers do. That is because they beleive it is the inspired and inerrant word of god. If it is to be taken as inerrant in any sense then it does make many claims about nature, origins, etc. If you take this all to be allegory, non-literal, etc. then good for you, but it then calls into question other aspects of historicity, etc. and the very existence of the man Jesus, or at the very least the results of the teachings attributed to him. And every other aspect of the so called "revelation" of god to man.