Which Jays play in all star?

Yoga Face

New member
Jun 30, 2009
6,307
19
0
If Jays had quality pen they would lead baseball in wins with six strong candidates for all star game

1 EE might get 100 RBI before all star - in for sure

2 JD OPS is almost 1000 which few achieve - in for sure

3 Saunders OPS is 922 and deserves mention but will such a no name get in with all the other jays?

4 Happ is 11-3

5 Estrada MLB Major League Baseball record 12 straight starts of at least 6 innings pitched in which he allowed no more than five hits was stopped by a bad back Saturday and has a WAR of 2.8 and WHIP of .99

6 Sanchez is 8-1

all three pitchers will not go so who is out?
 
If Jays had quality pen they would lead baseball in wins with six strong candidates for all star game

1 EE might get 100 RBI before all star - in for sure

2 JD OPS is almost 1000 which few achieve - in for sure

3 Saunders OPS is 922 and deserves mention but will such a no name get in with all the other jays?

4 Happ is 11-3

5 Estrada MLB Major League Baseball record 12 straight starts of at least 6 innings pitched in which he allowed no more than five hits was stopped by a bad back Saturday and has a WAR of 2.8 and WHIP of .99

6 Sanchez is 8-1

all three pitchers will not go so who is out?

I think Jays get 3 All Stars - Eddie (leads majors in RBI's and is close to the top in HR's - can attend the HR derby and is a crowd pleaser); Josh - close to the top in batting, great fielder, established "name" player; and Happ. Estrada's W-L isn't superb enough to get him to the ASG and now he has health issues.
 
I think Jays get 3 All Stars - Eddie (leads majors in RBI's and is close to the top in HR's - can attend the HR derby and is a crowd pleaser); Josh - close to the top in batting, great fielder, established "name" player; and Happ. Estrada's W-L isn't superb enough to get him to the ASG and now he has health issues.
All worthy but I suspect management would prefer if their starters get a rest. If any, Sanchez would be the most physically resilient and arguably very worthy (tonight's outcome pending [solid into the 3rd]).
 
I think Jays get 3 All Stars - Eddie (leads majors in RBI's and is close to the top in HR's - can attend the HR derby and is a crowd pleaser); Josh - close to the top in batting, great fielder, established "name" player; and Happ. Estrada's W-L isn't superb enough to get him to the ASG and now he has health issues.

Agree with all. I'd say Happ has a 50% chance.
He is well deserving after a fairly middling career until mid-2015. Ray Searage in Pitt straightened out his mental game and he is a superior pitcher since.
 
Last edited:
If Jays had quality pen they would lead baseball in wins with six strong candidates for all star game

1 EE might get 100 RBI before all star - in for sure

2 JD OPS is almost 1000 which few achieve - in for sure

3 Saunders OPS is 922 and deserves mention but will such a no name get in with all the other jays?

4 Happ is 11-3

5 Estrada MLB Major League Baseball record 12 straight starts of at least 6 innings pitched in which he allowed no more than five hits was stopped by a bad back Saturday and has a WAR of 2.8 and WHIP of .99

6 Sanchez is 8-1

all three pitchers will not go so who is out?

Edwin has 76 rbi's and six games left before the all-star break, so I think 100 rbi's is a bit of a stretch.
 
The way he's currently pitching Sancho deserves to go. He's also deserving of the title Jeffe (Ace).

I don't want to see EE potentially getting taken out of his rhythm by participating in the HR derby. Many an elite player has slumped after taking part.
 
I don't want to see EE potentially getting taken out of his rhythm by participating in the HR derby. Many an elite player has slumped after taking part.

they juice the ball
 
I think Jays will get only 2 all-stars.
Donaldson because he's the reigning AL MVP and having another great year.
Either Estrada or Happ, both are veteran pitchers who've been dominant the last 2 seasons. I don't' see both being picked with so many dominant relievers and starters available.
Yost is probably going to reward 2 of his own relievers so that limits the number of spots available on the pitching staff.
Also every team needs to be represented so a few spots will be taken up by players not really deserving.
 
Yup

Having non deserving guys in is crap and so is fan selection

Hard not to include EE

Do they have a DH in the game?

Good idea to keep the pitchers from hitting and possible injury

I say EE, JD and one pitcher


If a player is ailing like Estrada is he chosen anyways? Only fair as he can turn it down then say he was selected when negotiating contract but I go with Sanchez at 9-1
 
The way he's currently pitching Sancho deserves to go. He's also deserving of the title Jeffe (Ace).

Not according to Russell Martin.
He stated today that Marco Estrada is Toronto's ace.
 
I say EE, JD and one pitcher


Agree again, after Sanchez's dominant start, he is also in the running. But I think only one of Happ, Sanchez or Estrada will be chosen; in that order.

Sometimes, the AS pitchers selected is a recognition of the "staff". In 2013, they chose Cecil and Delebar from the Jays altho any of 4 guys could have been chosen. Kind of recognition for a great bullpen in the 1st half.

This year the Indians have a dominant starting staff so look for 2 starts to be chosen there D. Salazar and one of the other.
Toronto has 3 deserving guys so look for one guy to be chosen but not 2 or 0.
 
JD, EE and Marco all going to the All Star Game. Well deserved.
 
5 Estrada MLB Major League Baseball record 12 straight starts of at least 6 innings pitched in which he allowed no more than five hits was stopped by a bad back Saturday and has a WAR of 2.8 and WHIP of .99

Marco is of course very deserving for the reasons above. But has there been a starter with fewer than 5 wins chosen to the ASG? W's are obviously susceptible to run support and weak bullpen...
 
Marco is of course very deserving for the reasons above. But has there been a starter with fewer than 5 wins chosen to the ASG? W's are obviously susceptible to run support and weak bullpen...

Great for those going, but don't forget to take part in the Final Vote to get Canada's own Michael Saunders in the last roster spot.
 
Agree on Estrada deserving to be there and being selected in the first place - happy for the acknowledgment; however given his current injury issues, as a Jays fan, I'd rather him rest over the all star break for the second half of the season and the playoff push. I'd rather see Happ or even Sanchez take his place, but that's just me- I'm more of a big picture guy
 
Agree on Estrada deserving to be there and being selected in the first place - happy for the acknowledgment; however given his current injury issues, as a Jays fan, I'd rather him rest over the all star break for the second half of the season and the playoff push. I'd rather see Happ or even Sanchez take his place, but that's just me- I'm more of a big picture guy

He'll likely skip the game. Sometimes if a teammate is fringe, they use him as a replacement, so I expect Happ to be named.
 
At his current pace EE will reach 1000 RBI's by next Canada Day, I'd like to see him do that in a Jays uniform.
 
I'd rather see Happ or even Sanchez take his place,

He'll likely skip the game. Sometimes if a teammate is fringe, they use him as a replacement, so I expect Happ to be named.


Agree, both Sanchez and Happ are deserving to replace Estrada, but Happ will likely get the call since he's been toiling for as vet for many years. Sanchez just 23, has many ASG's ahead of him.
I shudder to think where the Jays would be without our top 3 starters.
 
Estrada's replacement in the all star game as selected by Royal's manager Ned Yost is Corey Kluber 8-8 ERA 3.79.
What an awesome choice:blue: