War with Iran

Sunni vs Shiite. Then couple that with Royal families choosing oil cash. It was all quite easy with the Shah in place right?

Deals were made after 1973 so another oil crisis didn't happen. The USA replaced the British as the defacto policy makers in the area. It also involved choices due to The Soviet Union. There are lots of reasons for this. And not a single one is because Israel is a "better" choice in their eyes.
Because the Royal families see Islamic revolution in their own nations as a threat. Also Sunni vs Shiite.

They aligned with the USA, not Israel. Because they sell oil. Part of the deal is leave Israel alone. And they get protection, arms etc to stay in power.

I don't disagree with most of that. The U.S. relationship with the Gulf states is driven by a mix of oil, Cold War strategy, containing Iran after 1979, and protecting the ruling monarchies. But that doesn't really change my point.

If Israel were truly viewed as the primary threat, those governments wouldn't have spent decades quietly cooperating with Israel on intelligence and security while treating Iran as the more immediate danger. Whether they're aligned with Israel directly or aligned with the U.S. and, by extension, often on the same side as Israel, the practical result is the same: when forced to choose between Iran and Israel, they've generally treated Iran as the greater security concern.

That doesn't mean they like Israel or agree with all of its policies. It means their actions suggest they see Iran as the bigger strategic threat.
 
I am arguing that positioning it as a unique bogeyman is unhelpful.
It isn't unique because it's a foreign lobby.
It is unique because, while being a foreign lobby whose purpose is to advance the interests of a foreign nation and legitimize that nation's actions - including actions widely accepted as crimes against humanity - it is not even registered as one.
It is also unique because of its degree of influence on American foreign policy and the politicians it funds.
That's what makes it a unique threat to American sovereignty.
I believe Butler1000, Klatuu, southpaw, Frankfooter and several others have already brought these issues up with you and squeezer, but instead of addressing the core arguments directly, you guys keep obfuscating, filibustering, equivocating, and retreating into semantic debates.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
I don't see Israel attacking Jordan, Kuwait, Dubai and others.
No you don't.
Because they are allied with the US and Israel and allow their bases to be used to attack Iran, thereby becoming a security threat to Iran.
So Iran rightfully bombs them, and they consequently consider Iran to be a security threat.
This is a problem for which they only have themselves to blame.
Had they minded their own business, refused use of their bases to the US and Israel to attack Iran, Iran wouldn't be bombing them and they wouldn't have to consider Iran a security threat and vice versa.
See, how minding your own business solves most of the world's problems? lmfao.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
I don't disagree with most of that. The U.S. relationship with the Gulf states is driven by a mix of oil, Cold War strategy, containing Iran after 1979, and protecting the ruling monarchies. But that doesn't really change my point.

If Israel were truly viewed as the primary threat, those governments wouldn't have spent decades quietly cooperating with Israel on intelligence and security while treating Iran as the more immediate danger. Whether they're aligned with Israel directly or aligned with the U.S. and, by extension, often on the same side as Israel, the practical result is the same: when forced to choose between Iran and Israel, they've generally treated Iran as the greater security concern.

That doesn't mean they like Israel or agree with all of its policies. It means their actions suggest they see Iran as the bigger strategic threat.

I would suggest with recent events the gulf nations are rethinking things. They are now essentially targets. And with a lot of delicate, and very expensive infrastructure on the line. Those desalination plants are the real targets. And the power plants. They go and its game over for years.

And they can't be protected.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Its a monster that controls all issues they deem in their interests, so yes, technically not 'all US politics'.

So they are a lobby group.

How many pages have you gone on the offensive to declare that AIPAC isn't really that big and powerful by trying keep all debate around the use of one word?

Right.
You all have been furious about me not just accepting your framing uncritically.
You would far prefer no debate.
That's very clear.

Of course, what's funny is that this isn't a particularly useful debate.
Instead of discussing what to do about things, you are all obsessed with the rhetoric.

Before this recent vote, aipactracker and others were noting that only 10 members of congress refused AIPAC money.

And, according to you, that means everyone who has accepted any money from AIPAC (or any other Israeli group, since AIPAC tracker is up front that they don't just track AIPAC money) is "owned" by AIPAC and will never vote in any other way than what their puppetmasters command.
 
  • Like
Reactions: squeezer
What differenxe does your qualifier make? They need to rethink their relationship, as you've stated.

There is a big difference between rethinking a relationship and "This is the source of all evil and if we just reject it, everything will be fixed", which is how you all seem to want to present it.
 
It isn't unique because it's a foreign lobby.
It is unique because, while being a foreign lobby whose purpose is to advance the interests of a foreign nation and legitimize that nation's actions - including actions widely accepted as crimes against humanity - it is not even registered as one.
It is also unique because of its degree of influence on American foreign policy and the politicians it funds.
That's what makes it a unique threat to American sovereignty.
I believe Butler1000, Klatuu, southpaw, Frankfooter and several others have already brought these issues up with you and squeezer, but instead of addressing the core arguments directly, you guys keep obfuscating, filibustering, equivocating, and retreating into semantic debates.

I am going to assume that the way you phrased that is just deliberately awkward, and you aren't under the delusion that AIPAC is the only group that lobbies for a foreign country but isn't registered under FARA.

Your objection is purely "they are uniquely evil and powerful", yes?
So any counter argument that they aren't uniquely powerful or spend more than other groups or so on is moot, yes?
They are the most evil, therefore they are unique.
 
  • Like
Reactions: squeezer
No you don't.
Because they are allied with the US and Israel and allow their bases to be used to attack Iran, thereby becoming a security threat to Iran.
So Iran rightfully bombs them, and they consequently consider Iran to be a security threat.
This is a problem for which they only have themselves to blame.
Had they minded their own business, refused use of their bases to the US and Israel to attack Iran, Iran wouldn't be bombing them and they wouldn't have to consider Iran a security threat and vice versa.
See, how minding your own business solves most of the world's problems? lmfao.


That assumes Iran's hostility toward many of its neighbors only began after they aligned with the U.S., but the timeline doesn't really support that, does it?

The Gulf monarchies viewed the Iranian regime as a security threat long before there was open security cooperation with Israel. The Iranian Revolution, calls to export the revolution, support for armed groups across the region, attacks on shipping, missile and drone programs, and backing for groups like the Houthis all contributed to those concerns.

You can certainly argue that the U.S. military presence reinforces the rivalry. But it's equally plausible to argue that the U.S. presence exists because those governments already perceived Iran as a threat and wanted an external security guarantor, which the US was more than willing to provide.
 
ERETZ POS Nation…the London Edition

There is a big difference between rethinking a relationship and "This is the source of all evil and if we just reject it, everything will be fixed", which is how you all seem to want to present it.
Try something other than fictional quotes. It’s pathetic and amateurish. It’s a tacit admission that you can’t deal with the primary content and need to reframe it. Try using real quotes…I know it might be harder for you.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: southpaw
There is a big difference between rethinking a relationship and "This is the source of all evil and if we just reject it, everything will be fixed", which is how you all seem to want to present it.
I've never made such claims. I claim what is fact. AIPAC acts on behalf of a foreign country, and rhat foreign country is a massive liability to the US.

The people who support AIPAC have placed the interests of a foreign country above their own. Thats treason.

The vast majority of US citizens gain nothing from this relationship, except more enemies. They cannot make aliyah to Israel.
 
That assumes Iran's hostility toward many of its neighbors only began after they aligned with the U.S., but the timeline doesn't really support that, does it?

The Gulf monarchies viewed the Iranian regime as a security threat long before there was open security cooperation with Israel. The Iranian Revolution, calls to export the revolution, support for armed groups across the region, attacks on shipping, missile and drone programs, and backing for groups like the Houthis all contributed to those concerns.

You can certainly argue that the U.S. military presence reinforces the rivalry. But it's equally plausible to argue that the U.S. presence exists because those governments already perceived Iran as a threat and wanted an external security guarantor, which the US was more than willing to provide.

The Israeli alignment started at the Camp David accords, before the revolution. And that is proven by the Marine barracks bombing in Lebanon in the 80's. And the arms transfers that occured as a result of the Accords.

The US animosity occured because of support for the Shah.

The US presence exists to keep the oil flowing. Thats it. They could give a rat's ass about the politics there.
 
No, Franky, not at all, but it seems to me the Arab states are calling Iran the more diabolical of the two. Sorry, but you cannot deny it. I don't see Israel attacking Jordan, Kuwait, Dubai and others.

They want the cash, Jordan gets $1.5 billion a year.
Kuwait about $300 million

Jordan and Kuwait have the biggest bases and have been hit the most as a result.
They also hold much of the defences outside of Israel

 
No, Franky, not at all, but it seems to me the Arab states are calling Iran the more diabolical of the two. Sorry, but you cannot deny it. I don't see Israel attacking Jordan, Kuwait, Dubai and others.

That's your opinion, can you back it up with facts?

Every single gulf country voted to call the Israeli occupation of Palestine illegal and to demand Israel end it.

 
Of course, what's funny is that this isn't a particularly useful debate.
Instead of discussing what to do about things, you are all obsessed with the rhetoric.

So as a result you want to move it to this 'useful' debate:

And, according to you, that means everyone who has accepted any money from AIPAC (or any other Israeli group, since AIPAC tracker is up front that they don't just track AIPAC money) is "owned" by AIPAC and will never vote in any other way than what their puppetmasters command.

Straw man argument, val.
do better

The dems are moving away from AIPAC, that's good news.
 
There is a big difference between rethinking a relationship and "This is the source of all evil and if we just reject it, everything will be fixed", which is how you all seem to want to present it.

Genocide is the most evil crime known to humanity. Why should america continue to fund and support genocide?
 
That assumes Iran's hostility toward many of its neighbors only began after they aligned with the U.S., but the timeline doesn't really support that, does it?

The Gulf monarchies viewed the Iranian regime as a security threat long before there was open security cooperation with Israel. The Iranian Revolution, calls to export the revolution, support for armed groups across the region, attacks on shipping, missile and drone programs, and backing for groups like the Houthis all contributed to those concerns.

You can certainly argue that the U.S. military presence reinforces the rivalry. But it's equally plausible to argue that the U.S. presence exists because those governments already perceived Iran as a threat and wanted an external security guarantor, which the US was more than willing to provide.

Do you actually know the history there, squeezer?
Like the 1953 coup?

It reads like trump's Venezuela plan, and its what turned Iran against america.