War with Iran

AIPAC has been opposed to him for ages.
He lasted 14 years, longer than the average.
So obviously, "say anything against AIPAC and you immediately are removed" is completely wrong.

It’s not just wrong, it’s completely fictional. That’s a quote you invented. Try to be credible and deal with reality.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
No. My original claim was that U.S. politicians are bought and owned by AIPAC. Again, semantics.
Nobody thinks politicians are literally property.
"Owned" is common political shorthand for politicians who consistently do a lobby's bidding instead of representing their own country's interests.

It's not just semantics, though. Saying politicians are "owned" implies they have no independent agency and that AIPAC alone determines U.S. policy. That's a much stronger claim than saying AIPAC is an influential lobbying organization. If you're using "owned" as political shorthand, then the discussion becomes about the extent of AIPAC's influence and not whether U.S. politicians are literally controlled. Those are different claims, and they require different levels of evidence.

Oh, big whoop.
They issued statements criticizing settlements and abstained on a UN vote.
Meanwhile, they continued funding and arming Israel while settlement expansion continued unabated.
That's not a meaningful change in policy.
It's empty statements, rhetoric accompanied by policy continuity.
Talk about setting an extremely low bar lmfao.

No, It wasn't just empty rhetoric. The Obama administration publicly clashed with Bibi over settlements, delayed diplomatic meetings after settlement announcements, negotiated the Iran nuclear deal despite fierce Israeli government opposition, and abstained on UN Security Council Resolution 2334, allowing it to pass. You can argue those measures were insufficient, but it's inaccurate to say there was no divergence at all. Foreign policy isn't limited to cutting military aid; diplomacy, public pressure, and UN positions are also policy tools. If you stand back and remove your "I can't stand Israel goggles," you will see it differently. If something were being said falsely about Iran, I would call it out as well.


Everybody thinks they were weak and insufficient.
But I was challenging your assertion that these disagreements resulted in meaningful shifts in U.S. foreign policy.
They didn't. A genuine foreign policy shift would look like conditioning or suspending military aid, imposing consequences, or consistently voting against Israel in international forums.
If your actions don't fundamentally change policy and all you have are statements of disagreement, you cannot credibly call that a shift in foreign policy.

You're redefining "meaningful shift" so narrowly that only one specific policy outcome counts. A foreign policy shift doesn't require completely reversing an alliance. The U.S. has frequently adjusted its posture toward allies through diplomatic pressure, public criticism, changes in voting behavior, sanctions, or negotiations without ending military cooperation. It's reasonable to argue Obama's approach wasn't as forceful as you'd like, but saying there was no policy shift because aid continued ignores the broader range of foreign policy instruments governments use.
 
This could also be said of the supporters of Iran and terrorism. They could go join the IRGC. Unless of course, you're a woman or gay, then I wouldn't suggest it.

Here, squeezie, why don't we take the politics out of the label of terrorism and just define what it means.

Do you agree that:
Terrorism is the use of violence on civilians and civilian infrastructure for political goals?

Or do you have a different definition.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
The Isrealis aren't terrorist they just want to live in Isreal without attacks from the palestinians.

This info that I heard extremely bothers me because that would start world war 3.

Zionists want to live in Palestine without any Palestinians so commit ethnic cleansing and terrorism to rid Palestine of Palestinians and take their land.
That's pretty much the wiki definition of terrorism and what we are seeing in Palestine, Lebanon and Syria.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
Here, squeezie, why don't we take the politics out of the label of terrorism and just define what it means.

Do you agree that:
Terrorism is the use of violence on civilians and civilian infrastructure for political goals?

Or do you have a different definition.

Hey Frankie, it's honestly impressive how you manage to find a way to defend literally any country, anyone or anything that's against Israel. Doesn't matter if it's a forum post, a news article, or a random comment section, you'll be there, ready to run interference. At this point, you're so predictable that I could guess your position before opening a thread or reading your post. I knew you were going to be the first to chime in.

So Iran, in your world view, has been doing God's work in the Middle East. They are not guilty of anything; they have been run by the greatest regime of all time. GOTCHA!

One question, though, has Iran ever committed any violence in the last 50 years against civilians domestically or abroad?
 
Hey Frankie, it's honestly impressive how you manage to find a way to defend literally any country, anyone or anything that's against Israel. Doesn't matter if it's a forum post, a news article, or a random comment section, you'll be there, ready to run interference. At this point, you're so predictable that I could guess your position before opening a thread or reading your post. I knew you were going to be the first to chime in.

So Iran, in your world view, has been doing God's work in the Middle East. They are not guilty of anything; they have been run by the greatest regime of all time. GOTCHA!

One question, though, has Iran ever committed any violence in the last 50 years against civilians domestically or abroad?

Eretz POS Nation - the Jordan Valley edition

 
It's not just semantics, though. Saying politicians are "owned" implies they have no independent agency and that AIPAC alone determines U.S. policy. That's a much stronger claim than saying AIPAC is an influential lobbying organization. If you're using "owned" as political shorthand, then the discussion becomes about the extent of AIPAC's influence and not whether U.S. politicians are literally controlled. Those are different claims, and they require different levels of evidence.

Do you know how many american politicians have AIPAC 'handlers'?
How do you think its possible for 35 states to have passed laws making it illegal or banning you from state contracts if you boycott Israel?
You can boycott anything except Israel. Why?
 
Hey Frankie, it's honestly impressive how you manage to find a way to defend literally any country, anyone or anything that's against Israel. Doesn't matter if it's a forum post, a news article, or a random comment section, you'll be there, ready to run interference. At this point, you're so predictable that I could guess your position before opening a thread or reading your post. I knew you were going to be the first to chime in.

So Iran, in your world view, has been doing God's work in the Middle East. They are not guilty of anything; they have been run by the greatest regime of all time. GOTCHA!

One question, though, has Iran ever committed any violence in the last 50 years against civilians domestically or abroad?

First, lets take this deflection as an admission that you do know that targeting civilians is terrorism and you do therefore know that america and Israel commit far more terrorism than Iran or any other country in the world right now.

Second, sure, Iran is a shitty and repressive regime. I have Iranian friends who hate the regime and they have a history authoritarian acts. It would be far better if moderates could get in but there is zero chance of that happening while they are under constant foreign attacks and sanctions. But put that in comparison with american wars in how many countries in the last half a century and 78 years of war crimes, terrorism and land theft by Israel?

Again, I keep asking why it is that you think its acceptable that Israel is committing genocide while trying to take land from their neighbours?
 
This could also be said of the supporters of Iran and terrorism. They could go join the IRGC.
Absolutely. You're starting to get it. Well done! Now here's the rub: Who started the war with Iran? Who keeps dragging the west into these endless wars?

Do you see now that Israel is far more trouble than they're worth?
 
Thus, if I say AIPAC is a powerful lobby, but not a unique boogeyman, then I am pro-AIPAC and upset that they are being criticized.
I have a question. Why is AIPAC allowed to be a powerful lobby? Why would any country willingly let another country have so much power over it?
 
The story so far.

trump tears up the JCPOA (on Israeli orders)
trump declares Iran is then building the bomb
trump starts a war to stop them building a bomb
trump loses the war
trump restarts the war
trump loses the war and agrees that Iran can control the Hormuz
trump restarts the war

trump declares the war was to open the Hormuz that was open before his wars
trump declares that Iran can't build a bomb
trump fails at both and decides then that Saudi Arabia should also get the bomb

 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
Saying lasting 14 years is longer than average isn't make your case, val.


Sure it does.
You said that if you cross AIPAC you are political toast.
He did and lasted longer than the average spell in Congress.

Once again, no one says AIPAC isn't powerful and influential.
My objection is purely with "owned" as if they are a unique bogeyman unprecedented in US politics, an irresistible force that no one has questioned or resisted in anyway until now.
 
Sure it does.
You said that if you cross AIPAC you are political toast.
He did and lasted longer than the average spell in Congress.

Once again, no one says AIPAC isn't powerful and influential.
My objection is purely with "owned" as if they are a unique bogeyman unprecedented in US politics, an irresistible force that no one has questioned or resisted in anyway until now.

So you're arguing that just because occasionally people can last years before their careers are toasted by AIPAC it therefore proves that AIPAC doesn't toast political careers? Your defence just makes my point.

You can take objection to the term 'owned' as you do, but trying to apply dictionary definitions to common usage in reference in politics is just you trying to play prof to shut down debate.

In the history of american lobbying groups AIPAC has had way more influence than the NRA, tobacco or even oil&gas lobbyists, I'd argue. Those groups have been successful on specific issue related changes while AIPAC has gone way beyond just getting funding for Israel, through attacks on the UN, ICC, defunding of aid groups, laws limiting protest, laws limiting freedom to boycott, media influence and purchases, Palantir and flock implementation, direct police training and ICE training along with roping the states into the single stupidest and largest war failure in its history.

Feel free to show another group that has been more influential.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
It's not just semantics, though.
It is a semantic distinction.
This isn't the first context in which this kind of language has been used.
For example, when someone is called a "sellout" or accused of "selling out," nobody interprets that to mean they have literally put themselves up for sale and become another person's property.
It would be disingenuous to pretend a common rhetorical metaphor is intended to be read as a literal statement.
No, It wasn't just empty rhetoric. The Obama administration publicly clashed with Bibi over settlements, delayed diplomatic meetings after settlement announcements, negotiated the Iran nuclear deal despite fierce Israeli government opposition, and abstained on UN Security Council Resolution 2334, allowing it to pass. You can argue those measures were insufficient, but it's inaccurate to say there was no divergence at all. Foreign policy isn't limited to cutting military aid; diplomacy, public pressure, and UN positions are also policy tools. If you stand back and remove your "I can't stand Israel goggles," you will see it differently. If something were being said falsely about Iran, I would call it out as well.
So again, what were the actual consequences then, that materially changed anything?
"Obama clashed". "Delayed meetings". "Abstained from a vote"
These are not consequences.
These don't even count as a slap on the wrist for violating international law and committing crimes against humanity.
These are empty statements and rhetoric accompanied by policy continuity.
People rightfully cannot stand Israel, because Israel is objectively a racist, violent, repressive and manipulative nation.
If you removed your blindfold, which the majority of the world has already seemed to have done, you will see it differently.
You're redefining "meaningful shift" so narrowly that only one specific policy outcome counts. A foreign policy shift doesn't require completely reversing an alliance.
Its not a narrow definition, it is the only definition that actually counts as a shift.
You are defining lip service without consequence as a "foreign policy shift". It simply isn't.
Conditioning military aid, imposing consequences and voting against Israel at international forums on a case by case basis doesn't require an alliance to be reversed.
It simply means the alliance is conditional on Israel's conduct.
Infact many countries do exactly that. For example, many Russian allies, voted against Russia condemning Russian actions in Ukraine and still maintained their relations.
Maintaining an alliance and imposing consequences are not mutually exclusive.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
It’s not just wrong, it’s completely fictional. That’s a quote you invented. Try to be credible and deal with reality.

That has been the implication of the entire "owned" narrative.
Otherwise, AIPAC is just another large and powerful lobby group with a PAC. (And that only recently.)
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
It's not just semantics, though. Saying politicians are "owned" implies they have no independent agency and that AIPAC alone determines U.S. policy. That's a much stronger claim than saying AIPAC is an influential lobbying organization. If you're using "owned" as political shorthand, then the discussion becomes about the extent of AIPAC's influence and not whether U.S. politicians are literally controlled. Those are different claims, and they require different levels of evidence.

I'm going to nitpick, but that is "semantics", at least in the original meaning of the term that is about "what things mean".
Yes, Shaq is trying to dismiss our objection to the difference of connotation as being an argument about trivial differences in meaning, but I think he is very aware of the difference, which is why he is holding the line on that definition. The rhetorical advantage to saying these people are "owned" is one he doesn't want to give up, since he is all to aware of its power.

No, It wasn't just empty rhetoric. The Obama administration publicly clashed with Bibi over settlements, delayed diplomatic meetings after settlement announcements, negotiated the Iran nuclear deal despite fierce Israeli government opposition, and abstained on UN Security Council Resolution 2334, allowing it to pass. You can argue those measures were insufficient, but it's inaccurate to say there was no divergence at all. Foreign policy isn't limited to cutting military aid; diplomacy, public pressure, and UN positions are also policy tools.

He is allowed to have a model that insists anything less than the outcomes he wants is meaningless.
The question is whether or not he holds to that model consistently.

You're redefining "meaningful shift" so narrowly that only one specific policy outcome counts. A foreign policy shift doesn't require completely reversing an alliance. The U.S. has frequently adjusted its posture toward allies through diplomatic pressure, public criticism, changes in voting behavior, sanctions, or negotiations without ending military cooperation. It's reasonable to argue Obama's approach wasn't as forceful as you'd like, but saying there was no policy shift because aid continued ignores the broader range of foreign policy instruments governments use.

Again, that's fine if that is what he wants to use. You may not think it a useful model, but if it is a consistent one, then fine.
 
I have a question. Why is AIPAC allowed to be a powerful lobby? Why would any country willingly let another country have so much power over it?

Why was the NRA allowed to be a powerful lobby?
Planned Parenthood? The AARP? The National Association of Realtors?
China? The Marshall Islands?