War with Iran

Why was the NRA allowed to be a powerful lobby?
Planned Parenthood? The AARP? The National Association of Realtors?
China? The Marshall Islands?
Other than the last two, those are donestic lobbies. As for China, whatever lobby they may have will be registered under FARA. Nice way to avoid my question. Let me repeat:

Why would any country willingly let another country have so much power over it?

You can argue semantics all you want. People can see the truth for themselves now. Israel is a problem for the US. AIPAC is a problem for the US. The noticing continues.
 
So you're arguing that just because occasionally people can last years before their careers are toasted by AIPAC it therefore proves that AIPAC doesn't toast political careers? Your defence just makes my point.

No it doesn't.
It points out that AIPAC is a powerful lobbying group with big pockets.
It isn't a mythic monster that controls all US politics.

You can take objection to the term 'owned' as you do, but trying to apply dictionary definitions to common usage in reference in politics is just you trying to play prof to shut down debate.

What debate have I shut down?
If anything, I've encouraged debate and you are upset that I didn't accept your framing uncritically.
 
Other than the last two, those are donestic lobbies. As for China, whatever lobby they may have will be registered under FARA. Nice way to avoid my question. Let me repeat:

Why would any country willingly let another country have so much power over it?

You can argue semantics all you want. People can see the truth for themselves now. Israel is a problem for the US. AIPAC is a problem for the US. The noticing continues.

I'm not arguing otherwise.
I am arguing that positioning it as a unique bogeyman is unhelpful.
It's a bad player in the region and one the US needs to rethink its relationship with, distancing itself from its historical position.
 
Other than the last two, those are donestic lobbies. As for China, whatever lobby they may have will be registered under FARA. Nice way to avoid my question. Let me repeat:

Why would any country willingly let another country have so much power over it?

You can argue semantics all you want. People can see the truth for themselves now. Israel is a problem for the US. AIPAC is a problem for the US. The noticing continues.

Its the only one not registered as lobbyists. And Val will always deflect on AIPAC. He doesn't want to admit that his precious Corporate Dems can be bought. That leads to them needing to be ousted.

How many other nations came within a hair of having their militaries permanently tied together? Have "tricked" presidents into regional wars?
 
No it doesn't.
It points out that AIPAC is a powerful lobbying group with big pockets.
It isn't a mythic monster that controls all US politics.

Its a monster that controls all issues they deem in their interests, so yes, technically not 'all US politics'.


What debate have I shut down?
If anything, I've encouraged debate and you are upset that I didn't accept your framing uncritically.

How many pages have you gone on the offensive to declare that AIPAC isn't really that big and powerful by trying keep all debate around the use of one word?

Before this recent vote, aipactracker and others were noting that only 10 members of congress refused AIPAC money.

 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
I'm not arguing otherwise.
I am arguing that positioning it as a unique bogeyman is unhelpful.
It's a bad player in the region and one the US needs to rethink its relationship with, distancing itself from its historical position.

If its not unique, list the other lobbying groups that have as much influence.
 
Absolutely. You're starting to get it. Well done! Now here's the rub: Who started the war with Iran? Who keeps dragging the west into these endless wars?

Do you see now that Israel is far more trouble than they're worth?


The part I still don't understand is why most Gulf Arab states have generally viewed Iran as a greater security threat than Israel. Interesting, eh?

So many people here are vehemently anti-Israel; they seem to foam at the mouth at the slightest post that isn't bashing Israel. Yet many of the countries in the Middle East that are most directly affected by Iran's regional ambitions have, at least on security issues, found themselves more closely aligned with Israel than with Iran.

I'm sure Franky will be along shortly to explain why, but that's a bit like asking the Pope whether God exists. I'm more interested in hearing someone make the opposite case.
 
I'm not arguing otherwise.
I am arguing that positioning it as a unique bogeyman is unhelpful.
It's a bad player in the region and one the US needs to rethink its relationship with, distancing itself from its historical position.
Yesterday it was the word owed. Today the word is unique. It’s a predictable and transparent filibuster strategy.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Valcazar
The part I still don't understand is why most Gulf Arab states have generally viewed Iran as a greater security threat than Israel. Interesting, eh?

So many people here are vehemently anti-Israel; they seem to foam at the mouth at the slightest post that isn't bashing Israel. Yet many of the countries in the Middle East that are most directly affected by Iran's regional ambitions have, at least on security issues, found themselves more closely aligned with Israel than with Iran.

I'm sure Franky will be along shortly to explain why, but that's a bit like asking the Pope whether God exists. I'm more interested in hearing someone make the opposite case.

Annual U.S. aid to Jordan has tripled in historical terms over the past 15 years. The United States has provided economic and military aid to Jordan since 1951 and 1957, respectively. Total bilateral U.S. aid (overseen by the Departments of State and Defense) to Jordan through FY2025 amounted to approximately $33.8 billion.

On September 16, 2022, the United States and Jordan signed their fourth Memorandum of Understanding governing U.S. foreign aid to Jordan. The seven-year agreement (FY2023-FY2029), subject to appropriations of Congress, commits the Administration to seeking a total of $1.45 billion in annual economic and military aid for Jordan.


 
I am arguing that positioning it as a unique bogeyman is unhelpful.
It's a bad player in the region and one the US needs to rethink its relationship with
What differenxe does your qualifier make? They need to rethink their relationship, as you've stated.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu and southpaw
I've answered you twice now in this thread. Why do you keep asking the same question over and over again?


It appears your position is that the U.S. should mind its own business and stay out of conflicts in other parts of the world. That's a legitimate foreign policy view, but it isn't how successive U.S. administrations, Republican and Democratic alike, have generally approached national security.

For decades, the U.S. has maintained military bases and alliances around the world because policymakers have viewed a forward military presence as serving American strategic interests, whether by deterring adversaries, protecting trade routes, supporting allies, or responding quickly to crises.

Whether that's the right approach is certainly open to debate, but it's been a consistent feature of U.S. foreign policy for a long time.

Plus, you're a Canadian, you HAVE no say in the matter via a vote.
 
Squeezer will keep asking until someone says its because Israel are the nicest and most trustworthy country in the middle east.

No, Franky, not at all, but it seems to me the Arab states are calling Iran the more diabolical of the two. Sorry, but you cannot deny it. I don't see Israel attacking Jordan, Kuwait, Dubai and others.
 
No, Franky, not at all, but it seems to me the Arab states are calling Iran the more diabolical of the two. Sorry, but you cannot deny it. I don't see Israel attacking Jordan, Kuwait, Dubai and others.

Sunni vs Shiite. Then couple that with Royal families choosing oil cash. It was all quite easy with the Shah in place right?

Deals were made after 1973 so another oil crisis didn't happen. The USA replaced the British as the defacto policy makers in the area. It also involved choices due to The Soviet Union. There are lots of reasons for this. And not a single one is because Israel is a "better" choice in their eyes.
 
The part I still don't understand is why most Gulf Arab states have generally viewed Iran as a greater security threat than Israel. Interesting, eh?

So many people here are vehemently anti-Israel; they seem to foam at the mouth at the slightest post that isn't bashing Israel. Yet many of the countries in the Middle East that are most directly affected by Iran's regional ambitions have, at least on security issues, found themselves more closely aligned with Israel than with Iran.

I'm sure Franky will be along shortly to explain why, but that's a bit like asking the Pope whether God exists. I'm more interested in hearing someone make the opposite case.

Because the Royal families see Islamic revolution in their own nations as a threat. Also Sunni vs Shiite.

They aligned with the USA, not Israel. Because they sell oil. Part of the deal is leave Israel alone. And they get protection, arms etc to stay in power.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter