War with Iran

No, they are all mostly rational actors except for Israel, which is an expansionist state trying to take other people's land.
Iran hasn't started a war in 200 years, Israel starts one every few months.


Oh, I see. So if Israel is the only real threat, then why aren't the Gulf states lining up to treat Israel as their biggest enemy instead of Iran? 🤔

And we're pretending Iran's proxies haven't spent decades launching rockets and missiles at Israel, attacking shipping in the Red Sea, or targeting U.S. forces and partners in the region? That's a pretty selective version of history.

But sure... Iran has been a peaceful little choirboy for 200 years. :rolleyes:

For the record, I think Trumpshart was an idiot for helping start this war. I also think it'll be one more thing that helps sink him politically. Between this and the economy, he's doing a great job of dragging himself and the Republicans down for a very long time. Keep it up, DonShart.
 
Oh, I see. So if Israel is the only real threat, then why aren't the Gulf states lining up to treat Israel as their biggest enemy instead of Iran? 🤔

And we're pretending Iran's proxies haven't spent decades launching rockets and missiles at Israel, attacking shipping in the Red Sea, or targeting U.S. forces and partners in the region? That's a pretty selective version of history.

But sure... Iran has been a peaceful little choirboy for 200 years. :rolleyes:

For the record, I think Trumpshart was an idiot for helping start this war. I also think it'll be one more thing that helps sink him politically. Between this and the economy, he's doing a great job of dragging himself and the Republicans down for a very long time. Keep it up, DonShart.

Why do you think they are making deals with Israel? Israel is the price they pay for american weapons and oil sales. Most of those leaderships are authoritarian and thought putting american bases on their land would protect them from local wars. Israel is hated in the region. What does Israel offer any country in the Gulf?


 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
Then stop defending them.


Who am I defending?

A better question is: why are you so determined to defend Iran every time it's criticized?

I'm not defending Israel. I'm not defending Iran either. I'm pointing out facts as opposed to BUTT facts, even when they're inconvenient to either side.

I've said repeatedly that Trumpshart screwed up by dragging the U.S. into this conflict and doing so without meaningful consultation with key allies outside of Israel. I also think Bibi has made disastrous decisions that have damaged Israel's standing.

Apparently, if you don't pick a team and cheer for it 100% of the time, some people can't process that. I'm perfectly happy criticizing both sides when they deserve it. Deal with it.

Why do you think they are making deals with Israel? Israel is the price they pay for american weapons and oil sales. Most of those leaderships are authoritarian and thought putting american bases on their land would protect them from local wars. Israel is hated in the region. What does Israel offer any country in the Gulf?


So your argument is that all of these Gulf governments are too stupid to know what's in their own security interests, and only you have figured it out?

Maybe... just maybe... they see Iran's ballistic missile program, its nuclear ambitions, and its network of proxies as a bigger threat than you do. That's why they've deepened security ties with the U.S., and in some cases, with Israel.

And posting a poll showing Israel is unpopular doesn't answer the question. Public opinion and government policy are two different things. Governments make security decisions based on national interests, not Twitter likes.

You're still dodging the question: if Iran is so harmless, why do so many Arab governments spend so much time and money trying to contain it?
 
Who am I defending?

A better question is: why are you so determined to defend Iran every time it's criticized?

I'm not defending Israel. I'm not defending Iran either. I'm pointing out facts as opposed to BUTT facts, even when they're inconvenient to either side.

I've said repeatedly that Trumpshart screwed up by dragging the U.S. into this conflict and doing so without meaningful consultation with key allies outside of Israel. I also think Bibi has made disastrous decisions that have damaged Israel's standing.

Apparently, if you don't pick a team and cheer for it 100% of the time, some people can't process that. I'm perfectly happy criticizing both sides when they deserve it. Deal with it.




So your argument is that all of these Gulf governments are too stupid to know what's in their own security interests, and only you have figured it out?

Maybe... just maybe... they see Iran's ballistic missile program, its nuclear ambitions, and its network of proxies as a bigger threat than you do. That's why they've deepened security ties with the U.S., and in some cases, with Israel.

And posting a poll showing Israel is unpopular doesn't answer the question. Public opinion and government policy are two different things. Governments make security decisions based on national interests, not Twitter likes.

You're still dodging the question: if Iran is so harmless, why do so many Arab governments spend so much time and money trying to contain it?

My mantra has been there are no good guys here, just regional interests.

You want facts, start with who attacked Iran, move on to who attacked again, move on to who has repeatedly threatened to annihilate them during peace talks, who has manipulated makets for profit, who has abandoned gulf allies for Israel, who is paying Congress and the president through proxies for this war at the world's expense.

I've asked this before, let's see if you have the guts.

Given both sides aren't giving up, would you rather see Iran with control of the Strait, along with the gulf states, or a ground war for decades in Iran? Because at this point those are the choices.
 
My mantra has been there are no good guys here, just regional interests.

You want facts, start with who attacked Iran, move on to who attacked again, move on to who has repeatedly threatened to annihilate them during peace talks, who has manipulated makets for profit, who has abandoned gulf allies for Israel, who is paying Congress and the president through proxies for this war at the world's expense.

I've asked this before, let's see if you have the guts.

Given both sides aren't giving up, would you rather see Iran with control of the Strait, along with the gulf states, or a ground war for decades in Iran? Because at this point those are the choices.


You're presenting a false choice.

No, I don't want Iran controlling the Strait of Hormuz, and no, I don't want a decades-long ground war in Iran either. Those are not the only two possible outcomes.

My position has been pretty consistent. Trumpshart was wrong to drag the U.S. into this war, especially without broad allied support. I also think Iran's regime has spent decades destabilizing the region through its proxies, while BIBI has made decisions that have inflamed the conflict even further.

There are no saints here. But pretending the only options are "Iran controls the Strait" or "permanent ground war" is just another made-up bullshit and nonsense. Reality is usually more complicated than that. I don't want either scenario.
 
You're presenting a false choice.

No, I don't want Iran controlling the Strait of Hormuz, and no, I don't want a decades-long ground war in Iran either. Those are not the only two possible outcomes.

Then what is the other scenario you see in play here and how do you get there?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Then what is the other scenario you see in play here and how do you get there?


I honestly don't know, because I wasn't the one who decided to start a war without a clear endgame. If there were a coherent long-term plan, I certainly haven't seen it.

That said, I have a hard time believing the U.S. or its regional partners would accept Iran effectively controlling the Strait of Hormuz and charging tolls or otherwise restricting passage. The Strait is one of the world's most important shipping lanes, and freedom of navigation has long been a core U.S. strategic objective.

Politically, it would also be very difficult for Trumpshart to accept an outcome that could be portrayed as a major victory for Iran. Whether you call it "losing the war" or not, I don't see him agreeing to a settlement that hands Tehran that kind of leverage.

So, no, I don't know what the eventual outcome will be. I just don't think the two choices are "Iran controls the Strait" or "a decades-long ground war." There are likely other diplomatic and military outcomes somewhere in between, even if they're hard to predict.
 
There are no saints here. But pretending the only options are "Iran controls the Strait" or "permanent ground war" is just another made-up bullshit and nonsense. Reality is usually more complicated than that. I don't want either scenario.
Nobody wants either scenario.
However, given the realities of today, I don't think there is another option, if the US and Israel continue to stick to their nuclear demands.
 
You're presenting a false choice.

No, I don't want Iran controlling the Strait of Hormuz, and no, I don't want a decades-long ground war in Iran either. Those are not the only two possible outcomes.

My position has been pretty consistent. Trumpshart was wrong to drag the U.S. into this war, especially without broad allied support. I also think Iran's regime has spent decades destabilizing the region through its proxies, while BIBI has made decisions that have inflamed the conflict even further.

There are no saints here. But pretending the only options are "Iran controls the Strait" or "permanent ground war" is just another made-up bullshit and nonsense. Reality is usually more complicated than that. I don't want either scenario.

At this point I don't see other options. You have two parties WHO WANT THE FIGHT.
 
Nobody wants either scenario.
However, given the realities of today, I don't think there is another option, if the US and Israel continue to stick to their nuclear demands.
At this point I don't see other options. You have two parties WHO WANT THE FIGHT.

I will definitely be a test of wills. So much so that now Trumpshart is set on rigging the elections because he knows this war is not going to end any time soon.
 
The REAL reason the US can’t beat Iran

 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
I will definitely be a test of wills. So much so that now Trumpshart is set on rigging the elections because he knows this war is not going to end any time soon.

Iran just hit a desalination plant and the electricity plant that supplies it in Kuwait. Gas in the USA is hitting over 4 and diesel over 5. National averages.
 
Question for you: if Israel is supposedly the source of all the Middle East's problems, why do so many Arab states view Iran as a greater threat than Israel?
When did I say Israel is the source of all the Middle East's problems? I'm saying Israel is the source of America's problems.

We've already covered why the Gulf Arabs hate Iran. Sunni vs. Shia. If they want to have a civil war within Islam, well, thats Allah's will. Who are we to interfere?

We can keep buying their oil, and they can keep buying our finished goods. The trouble with Israel is it creates massive blowback for the west.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
When did I say Israel is the source of all the Middle East's problems? I'm saying Israel is the source of America's problems.

We've already covered why the Gulf Arabs hate Iran. Sunni vs. Shia. If they want to have a civil war within Islam, well, thats Allah's will. Who are we to interfere?

We can keep buying their oil, and they can keep buying our finished goods. The trouble with Israel is it creates massive blowback for the west.



Fair enough.

But isn't the U.S. a sovereign country that gets to decide, through its own elected government, who it supports and what its foreign policy will be?

That doesn't mean I think Trump is making good decisions. Quite the opposite. Right now, U.S. foreign policy looks less like a coherent strategy and more like a three-ring circus run by Barnum.

Whether people agree with those choices or not, they're still decisions made by the U.S. government, not because Bibi is some all-powerful warlock poking a Trumpshart voodoo doll every morning.
 
Iran just hit a desalination plant and the electricity plant that supplies it in Kuwait. Gas in the USA is hitting over 4 and diesel over 5. National averages.


One more thing.

To the Iran supporters: if reports that Iran deliberately targeted civilian electricity and desalination infrastructure are accurate, would you call that a war crime too?

Because if Israel or the U.S. had struck the same type of civilian infrastructure in Iran first, I'm pretty sure this forum would be flooded with posts screaming "WAR CRIME!"

Just wondering if the standard is the same for everyone, or if it depends on who's launching the missiles.
 
One more thing.

To the Iran supporters: if reports that Iran deliberately targeted civilian electricity and desalination infrastructure are accurate, would you call that a war crime too?

Because if Israel or the U.S. had struck the same type of civilian infrastructure in Iran first, I'm pretty sure this forum would be flooded with posts screaming "WAR CRIME!"

Just wondering if the standard is the same for everyone, or if it depends on who's launching the missiles.

So is killing 160 school girls?

Yes. And btw the USA is hitting civilian infrastructure as well. At this point between both sides and Israeli war crimes the Geneva Convention is suspended for the duration. Iran is going to either win or take down the ME infrastructure for a decade.

No good actors.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shaquille Oatmeal