War with Iran

She didn't lose solely because of Gaza, although it may have reduced turnout among some voters and cost her support in parts of the Democratic base.

The election was decided by multiple factors, especially the economy, inflation, immigration, and perceptions of the administration's performance. Reducing it all to one issue is far too simplistic.

And your claim ignores that Harris also faced pressure from the other direction. Some Jewish voters were dissatisfied with her approach to Israel and shifted toward Trump, while others remained Democratic. The point is that she was losing support from different constituencies at the same time.

You also need to stop assuming your personal priorities reflect those of the electorate. Polling throughout the campaign consistently showed that for most voters, the economy and cost of living ranked well above Gaza as decisive election issues. FACTS MATTER!

First fact is she was a part of the cover up of Joe Biden's decline. Part of the job description of the VP is to step up. Next was her coronation. Next was her functioning alcoholism, then her lack of policy direction. Israel likely cost her Michigan from the numbers.
 
She didn't lose solely because of Gaza, although it may have reduced turnout among some voters and cost her support in parts of the Democratic base.

The election was decided by multiple factors, especially the economy, inflation, immigration, and perceptions of the administration's performance. Reducing it all to one issue is far too simplistic.

And your claim ignores that Harris also faced pressure from the other direction. Some Jewish voters were dissatisfied with her approach to Israel and shifted toward Trump, while others remained Democratic. The point is that she was losing support from different constituencies at the same time.

You also need to stop assuming your personal priorities reflect those of the electorate. Polling throughout the campaign consistently showed that for most voters, the economy and cost of living ranked well above Gaza as decisive election issues. FACTS MATTER!

She lost because her base stayed home, largely over the genocide.
I went through this with valcazar.
The dem autopsy head leaked that Gaza was a major issue and then the dems erased all mention in their autopsy report.
As a result, the guy who wrote it said he didn't approve of the report over what was missing.


80% of democrat voters backed ceasefire, student protests against the genocide were massive that year.
Harris chose to lose the election over support of the genocide.

 
You're conflating rhetoric with government policy.

Yes, Netanyahu has invoked biblical references, including Amalek, in public speeches, and those remarks have been widely criticized. Personally, I don't think religion has any business influencing government policy. But citing biblical imagery is not the same as proving there's an official state policy to carry out genocide or implement some centuries-old blueprint.

If you're going to argue Israeli policy, use actual government decisions, military directives, or legislation. not speeches and symbolic references. Otherwise, you're doing exactly what I criticized before: taking rhetoric and treating it as conclusive proof of intent.

You keep being given examples and then dismissing them for no reason.
You won't accept reports from the UN, Amnesty, HRW, B'tselem, MSF, UNICEF or WFP.

You won't take Israeli politicians for their words.
You won't hold them responsible for the actions, not for the occupation, apartheid or genocide.

Genocide is government policy.
You don't get more evil than that.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: squeezer
You're conflating rhetoric with government policy.

Yes, Netanyahu has invoked biblical references, including Amalek, in public speeches, and those remarks have been widely criticized. Personally, I don't think religion has any business influencing government policy. But citing biblical imagery is not the same as proving there's an official state policy to carry out genocide or implement some centuries-old blueprint.

If you're going to argue Israeli policy, use actual government decisions, military directives, or legislation. not speeches and symbolic references. Otherwise, you're doing exactly what I criticized before: taking rhetoric and treating it as conclusive proof of intent.

Um, its a Jewish state. And Judaism is the policy of the nation. When you conflate Anti Semitism with criticism of Israeli Govt policy you are stating that yourselves. And that is exactly what they do.
 
She lost because her base stayed home, largely over the genocide.
I went through this with valcazar.
The dem autopsy head leaked that Gaza was a major issue and then the dems erased all mention in their autopsy report.
As a result, the guy who wrote it said he didn't approve of the report over what was missing.


80% of democrat voters backed ceasefire, student protests against the genocide were massive that year.
Harris chose to lose the election over support of the genocide.


Right Frankie, because apparently the election boiled down to exactly one issue and every voter thought exactly like you. As for the ones that did stay home, as I'm sure you would've done, they deserve what they are getting and shouldn't be jumping up and down bellyaching on forums when Trump helps BIBI achieve his dreams and goals.

Meanwhile, exit polls consistently showed the economy, inflation, immigration, and cost of living ranked above Gaza for most voters. Gaza mattered to some voters, especially younger progressives, but pretending it was the reason Harris lost is a great example of confirmation bias.

You're taking one issue you care deeply about and projecting it onto the entire electorate. Elections are usually a little more complicated than that.
 
You're conflating rhetoric with government policy.

Yes, Netanyahu has invoked biblical references, including Amalek, in public speeches, and those remarks have been widely criticized. Personally, I don't think religion has any business influencing government policy. But citing biblical imagery is not the same as proving there's an official state policy to carry out genocide or implement some centuries-old blueprint.

If you're going to argue Israeli policy, use actual government decisions, military directives, or legislation. not speeches and symbolic references. Otherwise, you're doing exactly what I criticized before: taking rhetoric and treating it as conclusive proof of intent.
*******************************************************************
If you think you are scoring debating points with the above, you are pathetically mistaken. I couldn't care less for any of the items you want me to provide for you. I look at the ACTIONS of the Israeli goverment and their results: I look at the number of DEAD CHILDREN.
But rather than wasting your time chasing your own tail, why not pick up a book of history by Israeli historians, preferrably Jewish historians. Try Avi Shlaim to begin with.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Um, its a Jewish state. And Judaism is the policy of the nation. When you conflate Anti Semitism with criticism of Israeli Govt policy you are stating that yourselves. And that is exactly what they do.



You're missing the point and trying to insert Butt facts again.

Israel may define itself as a Jewish state, but that doesn't mean every biblical reference made by its prime minister automatically becomes government policy. Those are two different things.

I have no issue criticizing Israeli government policy. I've criticized BIBI plenty. I've said numerous times that Bibi needs to go. What I object to is people taking a speech, a biblical quotation, or a think tank paper and claiming it proves the existence of an official policy without evidence.

BTW, did I mention Frankie is going to be door-knocking in Israel to push Bibi's opponent for the Israeli November elections?


If you're going to argue that Israel has adopted a particular policy, then point to actual cabinet decisions, military directives, legislation, or official government documents. That's how you demonstrate policy, not by assuming every rhetorical flourish is a binding state doctrine.

Imagine if every word that came out of Trump's pie hole or every Truth Social nonsensical post he posted automatically became official U.S. government policy. We'd have been invading Greenland, annexing Canada, and implementing a dozen other half-baked ideas by now. That's not how governments work.
 
*******************************************************************
If you think you are scoring debating points with the above, you are pathetically mistaken. I couldn't care less for any of the items you want me to provide for you. I look at the ACTIONS of the Israeli goverment and their results: I look at the number of DEAD CHILDREN.
But rather than wasting your time chasing your own tail, why not pick up a book of history by Israeli historians, preferrably Jewish historians. Try Avi Shlaim to begin with.


I'm not the one chasing my tail. I'm simply asking for evidence instead of assumptions.

I'm not a fan of how far Israel has taken this conflict. The scale of civilian casualties and destruction has badly damaged Israel's standing internationally and generated widespread criticism, including from many of its traditional allies.

I've said repeatedly that I think BIBI is hurting his own country. Whether intentionally or not, his government's conduct has made it easier for groups like Hamas to win the propaganda battle in the eyes of many people around the world.

You don't strengthen your argument by asking me to read a particular historian; instead, try providing evidence for the specific claims you're making.
 
You're taking one document and using it to "prove" a sweeping claim about Israeli motives. That's not evidence; that's your confirmation bias.
Either you're uninformed, or disingenuous. That wasn't "one document". That was the neocon manifesto. The same guys who wrote it ended up in the Bush administration, where they pushed for the Iraq war.

I don't know what your deal is. You obviously have some fealty to Israel. But I don't. My loyalty is to Canada.
 
You're missing the point and trying to insert Butt facts again.

Israel may define itself as a Jewish state, but that doesn't mean every biblical reference made by its prime minister automatically becomes government policy. Those are two different things.

I have no issue criticizing Israeli government policy. I've criticized BIBI plenty. I've said numerous times that Bibi needs to go. What I object to is people taking a speech, a biblical quotation, or a think tank paper and claiming it proves the existence of an official policy without evidence.

BTW, did I mention Frankie is going to be door-knocking in Israel to push Bibi's opponent for the Israeli November elections?


If you're going to argue that Israel has adopted a particular policy, then point to actual cabinet decisions, military directives, legislation, or official government documents. That's how you demonstrate policy, not by assuming every rhetorical flourish is a binding state doctrine.

Imagine if every word that came out of Trump's pie hole or every Truth Social nonsensical post he posted automatically became official U.S. government policy. We'd have been invading Greenland, annexing Canada, and implementing a dozen other half-baked ideas by now. That's not how governments work.

Lol, so invasions aren't government policy now?
 
  • Haha
Reactions: squeezer
Either you're uninformed, or disingenuous. That wasn't "one document". That was the neocon manifesto. The same guys who wrote it ended up in the Bush administration, where they pushed for the Iraq war.

I don't know what your deal is. You obviously have some fealty to Israel. But I don't. My loyalty is to Canada.

Are you ok? Take a chill pill and go see your doc to have your blood pressure checked because you're reaching.

Yes, some of the people who worked on A Clean Break later ended up in the Bush administration. That doesn't mean the document became a secret playbook that explains every Israeli decision for the next 30 years.

And the "you're loyal to Israel" line is just a cop out, nonsense, and bullshit. How dare I not shit on Israel with every word posted, eh? Instead of backing up your claims, you're questioning my motives.

Dude, my loyalty is to the facts not Bibi or any other batshit crazy leader. If Israel screws up, I'll say so, which I have. If Hamas, Iran, or Russia screw up, which they do, I'll say so too.

You seem to think everything has to fit your narrative, and it just doesn't and what you think of my opinion, I DON'T GIVE A RAT'S ASS!!!
 
Dude, my loyalty is to the facts
Okay, here's a fact.. Israel cannot wage its dirty little wars in Lebanon, and Syria, and Iran, without US support. Its too small on its own.

Here's another fact. US support is dwindling amongst US voters, which is now filtering to their elected representatives.

Do what you want with those facts. I'm done debating with you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Okay, here's a fact.. Israel cannot wage its dirty little wars in Lebanon, and Syria, and Iran, without US support. Its too small on its own.

Here's another fact. US support is dwindling amongst US voters, which is now filtering to their elected representatives.

Do what you want with those facts. I'm done debating with you.


Newsflash! Are you ready?

I don't disagree with you that Israel would have a much harder time sustaining military operations on multiple fronts without U.S. political, military, and logistical support. That's a fair point.

See? We actually agree on something. The difference is that I try to separate the facts from the speculation.


.
 
  • Like
Reactions: southpaw
Right Frankie, because apparently the election boiled down to exactly one issue and every voter thought exactly like you. As for the ones that did stay home, as I'm sure you would've done, they deserve what they are getting and shouldn't be jumping up and down bellyaching on forums when Trump helps BIBI achieve his dreams and goals.

Meanwhile, exit polls consistently showed the economy, inflation, immigration, and cost of living ranked above Gaza for most voters. Gaza mattered to some voters, especially younger progressives, but pretending it was the reason Harris lost is a great example of confirmation bias.

You're taking one issue you care deeply about and projecting it onto the entire electorate. Elections are usually a little more complicated than that.

Of course it wasn't one issue, but it was one issue where it was clear that should could have added more than the 1% needed to win.
All she would have had to do is say no to genocide.

You don't understand that enough people stayed home and didn't vote because they couldn't vote for genocide.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
If you're going to argue that Israel has adopted a particular policy, then point to actual cabinet decisions, military directives, legislation, or official government documents. That's how you demonstrate policy, not by assuming every rhetorical flourish is a binding state doctrine.

Intent to commit genocide is well documented at the ICC and ICJ, along with Amnesty, HRW et al.
The actions show they acted on that intent killing 80% civilians and targeting civilians and civilian infrastructure.
There are 64,000 videos online showing genocidal acts committed by Israel.

Its time for you to accept the facts.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
Newsflash! Are you ready?

I don't disagree with you that Israel would have a much harder time sustaining military operations on multiple fronts without U.S. political, military, and logistical support. That's a fair point.

See? We actually agree on something. The difference is that I try to separate the facts from the speculation.


.

You are ignorant of the facts.
Start with this one report, at least.

Amnesty International investigation concludes Israel is committing genocide against Palestinians in Gaza
https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/n...itting-genocide-against-palestinians-in-gaza/
 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
You are ignorant of the facts.
Start with this one report, at least.

b36d15cdc67ece1b1073e5abc1acca4a.gif


Go door-knocking in Israel and beat BIBI in November to break this vicious cycle you are trapped in.