wanting to learn cantonese

I know a guy who lived in Hong Kong for 11 years. He can just say a few sentences and can't read, he has given up. Good Luck!
 
hinz said:
Many white people who are "motivated" to learn the "language/dialact" so to speak are the following,
.....
-too non-PC to say here....

Uh, dude, this is terb, a board about paying women for sex. There's pretty much nothing that's too non-PC to say here. Some guys learn a foreign language so they can bang foreign women. Plain and simple. You know what else? It works.

Though, you don't need to become fluent. Just a token effort is enough to get you into most asian chicks pants. Or indian chicks. Or whatever. Girls like that shit, and it gets you laid. If buddy's goal is just to get into some cantonese chicka's pants, all he needs is a basic phrase book, not a whole reading/writing/whatever thing.
 
fuji said:
If you don't find ways to speak and listen in Cantonese you will not make progress beyond the very basics, no matter what else you do.

I just wanted to add this is what I think you are in for, so you know:

-- The language is NOT HARD from a grammar point of view, it is simple and easy

-- It will be VERY HARD to get the pronunciation right because not only are the sounds different, but the tones will be very hard for you initially

-- The reading/writing is not that hard but it is very time consuming. It will take you years and years of steady progress to learn enough characters. You just have to keep at it.

Initially absolutely focus on your pronunciation and the tones. Once you get past that it's a lot easier. That was my experience with Mandarin and I assume it's even more true of Cantonese because of the extra tones.
My younger friends learn from Karoke songs & watching HK movies.


Cantonese is harder to learn. Mandarin with tons of formal training system & material for English spearkers. Harvard & UBC are major contributors.
 
goodtime said:
Cantonese is harder to learn. Mandarin with tons of formal training system & material for English spearkers. Harvard & UBC are major contributors.

Many Mandarin speakers consider Cantonese an "inferior" language :rolleyes: as many spoken Cantonese could not be written in Chinese, at least not formally.

It doesn't matter the criticism is from mainland China or Taiwan.
 
hinz said:
Many Mandarin speakers consider Cantonese an "inferior" language :rolleyes: as many spoken Cantonese could not be written in Chinese, at least not formally.

It doesn't matter the criticism is from mainland China or Taiwan.

I'm a (non-native) Mandarin speaker, and I can say this: That is plainly nationalistic mainland crap. It's an example of the sort of thing I mean when I say that Chinese people are among the most racist in the world. They don't even realize they're racist, they just take things like this for granted. It doesn't occur to them that having a Chinese only business is racist. It doesn't occur to them that thinking their particular dialect is "superior" is racist. It's just deeply in their blood.

And I say that as someone who really likes spending time in China, and with Chinese people. Sometimes, though, you have to slap them upside the head for their silly attitudes.
 
That is plainly nationalistic mainland crap.

Absolutely. And crap like that doesn't stop at China, take a look at Costa Rica, Japan, and even in Canada. The inter-regional bantering is just a sad part of human truth.

hinz , I suppose you have very much made your point , over and over again. If the thread starter has learning Cantonese in mind, just let him be. You are beginning to sound like a broken record.
 
fuji said:
I'm a (non-native) Mandarin speaker, and I can say this: That is plainly nationalistic mainland crap. It's an example of the sort of thing I mean when I say that Chinese people are among the most racist in the world. They don't even realize they're racist, they just take things like this for granted. It doesn't occur to them that having a Chinese only business is racist. It doesn't occur to them that thinking their particular dialect is "superior" is racist. It's just deeply in their blood.

Absolutely, except they are not as crazy as the Japanese and Germans in WWII to commit genocides.

BTW, all Chinese dialects are equal, except for historical reason Mandarin was voted to be the official language. It's all about consensus and unity, not Mandarin superiority to other regional dialects.

fuji said:
And I say that as someone who really likes spending time in China, and with Chinese people. Sometimes, though, you have to slap them upside the head for their silly attitudes.

Wonder why those silly people call the new boxer (Yìhétuán)?
 
hinz said:
Absolutely, except they are not as crazy as the Japanese and Germans in WWII to commit genocides.

Hopefully no-one is THESE days. As for history, you might want to read up on what Qin soldiers did when they arrived in the Jiangsu/Nanjing area. Pretty much the same as what the Japanese did when they arrived there. Hopefully the whole human race has learned that brutality like that is unacceptable by now, but you never know.
 
fuji said:
Hopefully no-one is THESE days. As for history, you might want to read up on what Qin soldiers did when they arrived in the Jiangsu/Nanjing area. Pretty much the same as what the Japanese did when they arrived there.

The manchu were assimilated after 200 years over there but before that they were not "Chinese" and their descendants are still miniorities, non Han Chinese even though many of them only speak Mandarin.

fuji said:
Hopefully the whole human race has learned that brutality like that is unacceptable by now, but you never know.

History tends to repeat itself.
 
hinz said:
Absolutely, except they are not as crazy as the Japanese and Germans in WWII to commit genocides.

WHOA... really ? And according to Chinese histroy, where did the Japanese nation come from ? And who was China's major buddy buddy at the turn of the last century ? And China has been spotless over the years ?

That is one of the most stupid BS post I have ever read here, other than (X..X)'s . Well, I guess we've got another one here , again. :D

請 繼 續 費 言! hyms you read chinese, right ?
 
You don't have to look at Chinese history. China today is still a killing machine:

China has the death penalty for 68 crimes including murder, drug trafficking, rape, re-selling VAT receipts, pimping, habitual theft, stealing or dealing in national treasures or cultural relics, publishing pornography, selling counterfeit money, economic offences such as graft, speculation and profiteering and even killing a panda.
During the "Strike hard" campaign against crime in China during the Spring of 2001, Amnesty International recorded a staggering 1,781 executions. This figure is greater than the total number of executions carried out in the rest of the world put together.
China does not publish statistics about the death penalty saying these are a state secret.
Executions are often carried out immediately after a public sentencing rally and the criminal's family is made to pay for the bullet.
The prisoner's arms are shackled behind them and they are made to kneel down before receiving a single bullet fired at close range into the back of the head or neck by a soldier or policeman or by a bullet fired into the heart from behind using an automatic rifle. (Click here for photo)
Chinese laws do not specifically state the site of execution grounds and shootings are carried out at military target ranges and along river banks and on remote hill sides, the prisoners being transported in open lorries from the sports stadiums where they were sentenced.
Condemned criminals are not executed inside prisons because it is regarded as inhumane for other inmates to hear the sound of gunfire.
In a typical mass public execution in December 1995, 13 men and women convicted of murder and highway robbery were shot after the Court dismissed their appeals.
Chinese television showed the 9 men and 4 women being paraded at a sports stadium in front of a crowd of more than 10,000 before being taken to the execution ground on a nearby hillside.
Frequently the kidneys, hearts and corneas are removed from the dead prisoners and used in transplants at local hospitals. "Execution is one of the indispensable means of education," China's paramount leader, Deng Xiaoping, once said.
During 1997, China began experimenting with lethal injection and this is steadily replacing shooting.
 
Guys, I'm curious why any of you would want to learn Cantonese?

(Please don't say: to get better service with the Asian incalls :) ).
 
the chinese cultural centre (on sheppard, east of mccowan, www.cccgt.org, I think...it's on google, in any case)
has a cantonese course for english speakers.
the current session just started, so you might have to wait
for the next session.
I wouldn't be surprised if there was something available
through the Toronto school board's continuing education program, as well...they offer a lot of languages
 
Learning cantonese would be VERY hard considering there's no alphabet. You can learn different words, but to speak sentences would be difficult. Even though I've heard mandarin is easier to learn (don't know why since it uses the same characters), I would go with that first, then migrate to cantonese. Plus, for someone that speaks english, the pronunciation of mandarin is eaiser to get grasp of over Cantonese. Cantonese is more choppy sounding.
 
AudiA4Guy said:
Even though I've heard mandarin is easier to learn (don't know why since it uses the same characters), I would go with that first, then migrate to cantonese. Plus, for someone that speaks english, the pronunciation of mandarin is eaiser to get grasp of over Cantonese. Cantonese is more choppy sounding.

For speaking the pronunciation issue you pointed out is the only reason why Mandarin would be easier than Cantonese. For writing some Mandarin speakers (mainland) but not all (taiwan) use the simplified characters. There is a big debate about whether it's really easier to learn the simplified characters or not--certainly they are easier to write, but the loss of some important radicals may actually make it harder to learn to recognize them. The radicals often give you clues about the meaning of the character that can help aid memorization.

However, Chinese people I know all learned their characters by writing them over and over and over again, and it often takes a third as many strokes to write a simplified character as a traditional one, so perhaps there is some truth to "easier to write = easier to learn". It's debated by many people, though.
 
China is growing as a huge market - if I am an executive and know the language, I'll be on a more solid footing than other people in my organization and better able to interact with clients. Don't discount the effect of personal relationships in business.
 
It's really interesting following this thread.

First ,when one expresses interest in learning a new language, the feedback from the native tonguers are usually highly encouraging and positive. So for those who said the language is tough to learn, dialect this , dialect that, I don't know how many of you actually speak/read and or write the language.