US Senate Wimps Out

"Stronger background checks at gun shows" is a pretty vague, feel-good/fear mongering phrase which exploits the ignorance of the fence sitters...kind of like the term "assault rifle".

Not vague at all. You buy a gun at a guns show you get your background checked, just like in retail stores. Really plain english.
 
This is why it sucked and how it left a ton of loopholes for a national, centralized registry:

http://www.nationalreview.com/corner/345845/problems-toomey-manchin

Read through quickly what you offered an noted early that the Gotleib has input, not that anything he said was acted on. Then i read statement about Obamacare's responsibility for the bill and i say, thank god he didn't write it;


As for HHS, Gottlieb accurately cites the firearms protections in Obamacare: Wellness programs under the law cannot require information about the insured’s firearms; the law specifically refuses to grant the HHS secretary the authority to collect information about individuals’ firearms; Obamacare specifically does not grant the secretary the authority to create databases of gun owners; insurance rates may not discriminate against gun owners; no activity undertaken under the powers granted by Obamacare may require individuals to disclose gun-ownership information.


These are good and solid protections and, as long as they stay on the books, Obamacare cannot be used to create gun registrations. However, HHS isn’t an entity that sprang into being with the passage of Obamacare; it has myriad other statutory powers that long predate Obamacare, and nothing in the health-care law limits HHS from using those other powers for gun registration.


Moreover, nothing in the Obamacare statute limits other cabinet departments, such as Homeland Security, from asking doctors, insurance companies, or any other medical personnel to provide records of patients’ gun ownership.

Say wha?

The article is mostly a condemnation of Gotleib, little else, who didn't write the amendment.
 
Not vague at all. You buy a gun at a guns show you get your background checked, just like in retail stores. Really plain english.

Guess what? When an American citizen attempts to purchase firearms from a dealer (FFL) at a gun show, they already do perform a background check. A private sale; whether it happens at a gun show, in someone's basement, or an empty parking lot at night is still a private sale that the jackbooted overseers have no real business involving themselves in. They still have to prove that the transaction was illegal, as it should be; anyone remember "innocent until proven guilty"? Much of the amendment was already law, however, there was also wording, which prevented the creation of a registry by specific organizations (ATF) but left loopholes for other government organizations to do so.
 
Read through quickly what you offered an noted early that the Gotleib has input, not that anything he said was acted on. Then i read statement about Obamacare's responsibility for the bill and i say, thank god he didn't write it;




Say wha?

The article is mostly a condemnation of Gotleib, little else, who didn't write the amendment.

Your reading comprehension needs quite a bit of work if that's all you got from it. It illustrates several loopholes, introduced by the amendment, which would facilitate a national registry. The background checks proposed already exist.
 
Uh, yes at gun shows. Don't believe me? Go to one in the States and try to purchase a firearm from an FFL but don't agree to the background check and see how far you get.

I could not do that because I'm not an american resident. From a FFL?

So all these reports on the lack of background checks at guns shows are lies and all the undercovers video showing transaction are faked.
 
I could not do that because I'm not an american resident. From a FFL?

So all these reports on the lack of background checks at guns shows are lies and all the undercovers video showing transaction are faked.

What's actually being reported as part of the "gun show loophole" are actually private transactions which just so happen to occur at gun shows. Retailers (FFLs), whether they conduct transaction at gun shows or their brick and mortar shops, are by-and-large, already required to conduct background checks on prospective buyers.
 
What's actually being reported as part of the "gun show loophole" are actually private transactions which just so happen to occur at gun shows. Retailers (FFLs), whether they conduct transaction at gun shows or their brick and mortar shops, are by-and-large, already required to conduct background checks on prospective buyers.

Now who splitting hairs? How many sellers at gun shows are FFL and how many are private sellers. The point is guns, lots of guns, are being sold at gun shows without backgrounds checks.

However, the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms , and Explosives (ATF) reports that 30 percent of guns involved in federal illegal gun trafficking investigations are connected to gun shows.
19 of 30 private sellers, 63% broke the law by completing a sale to a buyer who they thought could not pass a background check. 16 of 17, 94% of licensed dealers approached by our investigators at gun shows were willing to sell to someone who appeared to be a straw purchaser.

Are they lying as well?
 


Now who splitting hairs? How many sellers at gun shows are FFL and how many are private sellers. The point is guns, lots of guns, are being sold at gun shows without backgrounds checks.

However, the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms , and Explosives (ATF) reports that 30 percent of guns involved in federal illegal gun trafficking investigations are connected to gun shows.
19 of 30 private sellers, 63% broke the law by completing a sale to a buyer who they thought could not pass a background check. 16 of 17, 94% of licensed dealers approached by our investigators at gun shows were willing to sell to someone who appeared to be a straw purchaser.

Are they lying as well?

Nice cut and paste job, the font doesn't even match. Did you get this from your "gunsmith buddy" too?

Point is, maybe in some cases, enforcement is shit, but the laws exist. Maybe police should be working harder at enforcing laws that already exist instead of spreading themselves out thinner by backing even more feel-good laws like registration. The only acceptable aspect of the amendment was for buyers to be able to print out and present their own background checks, to provide piece of mind, for the sellers; not that it would prevent another tragedy. Let's remember, the Newtown shooter tried buying a gun from a dealer, was denied (as in, the laws worked) and decided to steal his mother's guns instead. It's the registration scheme that killed this amendment.
 
Nice cut and paste job, the font doesn't even match. Did you get this from your "gunsmith buddy" too?

Point is, maybe in some cases, enforcement is shit, but the laws exist. Maybe police should be working harder at enforcing laws that already exist instead of spreading themselves out thinner by backing even more feel-good laws like registration. The only acceptable aspect of the amendment was for buyers to be able to print out and present their own background checks, to provide piece of mind, for the sellers; not that it would prevent another tragedy. Let's remember, the Newtown shooter tried buying a gun from a dealer, was denied (as in, the laws worked) and decided to steal his mother's guns instead. It's the registration scheme that killed this amendment.


No, not my buddy. Are you questioning the numbers? There are laws on the books, but they are incomplete. Nothing wrong with strengthenig them. You won't stop all scenario such as stealing a parents gun, but let's at least stop what we can. I guess your position is since we can't stop all, let's not stop what we can. The parents in Newtown know the new laws won't save their children, but should save someone else's.
 
No, not my buddy. Are you questioning the numbers? There are laws on the books, but they are incomplete. Nothing wrong with strengthenig them. You won't stop all scenario such as stealing a parents gun, but let's at least stop what we can. I guess your position is since we can't stop all, let's not stop what we can. The parents in Newtown know the new laws won't save their children, but should save someone else's.

Maybe we already "stop what we can", after all, despite firearms purchases increasing in the US, violent crime has been decreasing. As previously noted in other discussions, events like those are already so rare; they're just blown out of proportion when the fear mongering, disarmament agenda rears its ugly head. Let me pull a page out of your playbook:

https://www.google.ca/search?q=dimi...t=safari&redir_esc=&ei=2MF0UZjbMcTD2AWxtIGYCg

:eyebrows:

In before any "if it just saves one life" bullshit.
 
Maybe we already "stop what we can", after all, despite firearms purchases increasing in the US, violent crime has been decreasing. As previously noted in other discussions, events like those are already so rare; they're just blown out of proportion when the fear mongering, disarmament agenda rears its ugly head. Let me pull a page out of your playbook:

https://www.google.ca/search?q=dimi...t=safari&redir_esc=&ei=2MF0UZjbMcTD2AWxtIGYCg

:eyebrows:

In before any "if it just saves one life" bullshit.

Maybe? Violent crime isn't necessarily gun crime. The shining example of stronger gun laws help in reducing death is Chicago, down ~70%. Are you thinking it would have been the same reduction without the new laws in Chicago?

Really, the law of dimishing returns? The increase in sales has only been over the last few months. Violet crime has been decreasing for a few years, but for reasons more complex than just gun sales.
 
Maybe? Violent crime isn't necessarily gun crime. The shining example of stronger gun laws help in reducing death is Chicago, down ~70%. Are you thinking it would have been the same reduction without the new laws in Chicago?

Really, the law of dimishing returns? The increase in sales has only been over the last few months. Violet crime has been decreasing for a few years, but for reasons more complex than just gun sales.

Shining example my ass, which year's statistics are being compared to one another to arrive at this 70% (homicde rates have been pretty consistent for the past decade in Chicago and firearms offenses spiked at the end of last year and the beginning of this year)? Were there significant gun control measures enacted (I don't remember any happening recently, in fact wasn't the idiotic handgun ban overturned in 2010)? The overall decrease in violent crime across the US is more complicated than looser firearms restrictions and higher rates of firearm purchases yet Chicago's supposed decrease in gun violence can be simply explained by "stricter gun control" (which you haven't elaborated upon)? Get your head out of your ass.

Law of diminishing returns, as in new bullshit laws targeting the wrong group of people will yield little if any positive results, especially considering how poorly current laws are being enforced.
 
Shining example my ass, which year's statistics are being compared to one another to arrive at this 70% (homicde rates have been pretty consistent for the past decade in Chicago and firearms offenses spiked at the end of last year and the beginning of this year)? Were there significant gun control measures enacted (I don't remember any happening recently, in fact wasn't the idiotic handgun ban overturned in 2010)? The overall decrease in violent crime across the US is more complicated than looser firearms restrictions and higher rates of firearm purchases yet Chicago's supposed decrease in gun violence can be simply explained by "stricter gun control" (which you haven't elaborated upon)? Get your head out of your ass.

Law of diminishing returns, as in new bullshit laws targeting the wrong group of people will yield little if any positive results, especially considering how poorly current laws are being enforced.

It's already been posted in this thread just two days ago. It was last years first three months. Makes one wonder about your attention span and ability to retain information. Is there really a need to elaborate on the stricter gun controls? For a guy who feels he has the finger on the pulse of the US and the gun controversy, do you really want us to believe you don't know what was done, or is it you just want me to jump through hoops and do the work.
 
Then again there were 25 shootings on Easter weekend in Chicago..... a cold snap kept the gang bangers off the streets and blackrock13 is claiming a gun control victory... talk about short attention spans.

OTB
 
Then again there were 25 shootings on Easter weekend in Chicago..... a cold snap kept the gang bangers off the streets and blackrock13 is claiming a gun control victory... talk about short attention spans.

OTB

A cold snap is the cause of the drop in shootings? You keyhole one weekend in 'April' and say that disproves the fact that shooting dropped 70% in March, must be new math, Republican style. The tin hat crowd might think the NRA is behind the shootings. Glad your back, more silly posts to laugh at.
 
Shit, you're right, Chicago is totally a shining example. Oh wait.

http://gawker.com/5974384/chicagos-murder-rate-in-2013-is-already-outpacing-2012

Way to cherry pick a few months of inactivity and tout a 70% reduction and ignore the numbers rising again afterward. So blackrock likes to use vague percentages for his shitty arguments on top of Google searches and firearms "facts" from his "gunsmith buddy".

Nobody is cherrypicking, there are only three months on record in 2013. You do know that the GAWKER article was written on January 8, 2013, right?

Well, things aren't looking any better at the start of 2013.
In the first six days of this year, 12 people were murdered in Mayor Rahm Emanuel's Chicago. That's two ahead of last year's six-day total. And at two a day, it puts us on a pace for 730 this year, which would be our highest total since 1997.
​
That number is actually now up to 13 — an unidentified man was killed last night on the city's West side.
There's still over 11 months left in the year, of course, but murder rates tend to increase as the weather warms up, so this start is far from an encouraging sign that fatal violence in Chicago is decreasing. Here, via Red Eye, are the names and stories of the 12 murder victims in the first eight days of this year.

As for choosing vague numbers, the number is rounded out for simpletons like you.

Murders fall 42 percent in America's deadliest city: Chicago - U.S. ...


It's 69% for March and 42% for the first three months. Facts not supplied by a buddy, but then you don't believe stats when supplied by the FBI or ATF or any other similar government agency.

There are no monthly numbers after March as April isn't finished nor calculated. Even with the worst January in 10 years, the first three months are still down 42%.
 
A cold snap is the cause of the drop in shootings? You keyhole one weekend in 'April' and say that disproves the fact that shooting dropped 70% in March, must be new math, Republican style. The tin hat crowd might think the NRA is behind the shootings. Glad your back, more silly posts to laugh at.

You take one months shootings ( a cold month in Chicago ) and use that to dispute the 500 murder trend from 2012 (95% of black on black and hispanic on hispanic).... I'd call it Democrat math but that's an oxymoron.

OTB