US Senate Wimps Out

Meanwhile clones of AK-47 and MP-38 have no function other to kill people

The most important feature of any military rifle is its reliability and ease of maintenance. They keep working even if they get dirty, or are fed bad ammunition. If they do malfunction most problems can be solved in the field without tools. If a part needs to be replaced that can usually be done by the user by hand without tools.

This is why the AK series is so popular, not its automatic capabilities but its reliability and simple maintenance.

Ditto the AR15.

I dispute that this level of reliability and simplicity isn't valuable to the civilian market. Having an easy to maintain rifle that I can repair myself without needing a gunsmith is useful.

Military rifles also tend to be the safest to operate because they have been so thoroughly torture tested and any design flaw long since corrected. So they are less likely to explode in your face when you pull the trigger, or if they do explode, their design directs the force of the blast away from your face. These considerations, and more importantly, this level of testing, does not happen outside the military.

The automatic fire on some is a secondary concern. Civilian designs simply do not have the same level of debugging of their operation.
 
The Senate simply took a pass on amendments that would have little/no impact on gun violence in the US. The POTUS hails from a city that had 500 murders last year, a magazine limit, "assault" weapon ban or expanded background checks would have no impact. If he wants to address the issue, vs whining like a bitch, he might try and understand why almost all of those murders were young black and Hispanic men shooting each other..... But that would be an uncomfortable conversation for him and would rub against his childish liberal world-view.

You might want to update your knowledge of Chicago since the latest gun laws were put in place there. It might be surprising to you. The murder rate has fallen a tad, ~70% last month over March of 2012 and it fell every month this year over last; down ~30% in February and I believe a similar amount in January. The murder rate in February hadn't been seen since 1957. Let me guess, it wasn't the new laws, but was because of the weather.
 
The most important feature of any military rifle is its reliability and ease of maintenance. They keep working even if they get dirty, or are fed bad ammunition. ...

And what kind of hunter would not take care of his rifle? I've seen some pretty old bolt action hunting rifles that are just as accurate and functional as the day they were made.

If someone is too incompetent to care fore their weapon, I don't think they should have any.
 
So you are saying that people incapable of maintaining a hunting rifle should be allowed to have semi-autos?
 
So you are saying that people incapable of maintaining a hunting rifle should be allowed to have semi-autos?

Here we go again with the unfounded semi-auto bashing. We may as well outlaw automatic transmissions in vehicles or any of the other unnecessary, commonplace and convenient innovations in our daily lives. After all, automatic transmissions allow more opportunities for distractions from driving. If you don't want to develop the skill set and focus granted by constantly working a clutch and gearbox, maybe you're part of the problem and have no business operating a motor vehicle anyways.
 
So you are saying that people incapable of maintaining a hunting rifle should be allowed to have semi-autos?

It also isn't a matter of "incapable". Why should I spend 20 minutes cleaning and maintaining a civilian spec rifle when I could save time and do the same task in 1 minute with a military spec one? Why wouldn't I prefer to have a rifle where I can repair a broken firing pin or operating rod myself, without requiring the expense of a gunsmith? And so on.

Maybe you have forgotten how we got on this topic--you wrote that the only reason why someone would want a rifle like an AK47 was to kill people. I pointed out that such rifles are better than civilian alternatives for a lot of reasons. Ease of maintenance and reliability is a very good reason why someone might opt for that rifle over a more traditional semi-automatic hunting rifle.

I am just pointing out that there are LOTS of reasons beyond "killing people" why those are good, useful rifles for many people.
 
Here we go again with the unfounded semi-auto bashing. We may as well outlaw automatic transmissions in vehicles or any of the other unnecessary, commonplace and convenient innovations in our daily lives. After all, automatic transmissions allow more opportunities for distractions from driving. If you don't want to develop the skill set and focus granted by constantly working a clutch and gearbox, maybe you're part of the problem and have no business operating a motor vehicle anyways.

Actually they allow you to pay more attention to what's happening on the road, one less thing to do and keep both hands on the steering wheel more often. This would explain a lot about your ability to understand some simple things. Why do you thing auto transmission are more poplar? Really CL, you're stretching your credibility somethin' fierce.
 
Actually they allow you to pay more attention to what's happening on the road, one less thing to do and keep both hands on the steering wheel more often.

Semi automatics offer similar benefits to shooters. You can maintain your cheek weld and shooting grip while making follow on shots.
 
Actually they allow you to pay more attention to what's happening on the road, one less thing to do and keep both hands on the steering wheel more often. This would explain a lot about your ability to understand some simple things. Why do you thing auto transmission are more poplar? Really CL, you're stretching your credibility somethin' fierce.

Went right over your head didn't it? Not surprised, I've come to expect as much from your mental migetry.
 
I am surprised it is only 40%. I have never bought a gun in a gun shop. All my purchases are done through online orders, or private purchases off other gun owners.

In fact with guns private purchases are a really big deal, because a well kept gun will last well over 100 years. One of my rifles, in perfectly good working condition, was made in 1943 and has seen a lot of use ever since, and still works perfectly well. As a result private sales are commonplace--why buy new, when you can buy a perfectly good used gun from someone else?

I don't really understand the opposition in the US to background checks. I haven't looked into it--maybe the particular implementation of this check was odious. Maybe it was an attempt to establish a federal registry of all firearms owners, or something like that, rather than a decentralized requirement to have a police certificate in hand in order to transact.

Gun owners quite rightly view any attempt to create a registry of any kind as a first step towards confiscation, and perhaps this was an attempt to create a registry in disguise? There are indeed ways to implement background checks that do not result in having any lists of gun owners around, and I just can't see the objection to that.

The assault rifle ban was just full on retarded and wasn't ever going to do any good.

It is too bad they didn't pass the mandatory background checks. I think it would be possible to construct a background check regime that does not invade anyone's privacy and does not result in a registry of gun owners. Just have the police produce certificates that an individual has passed a background check, and allow individuals who wish to purchase firearms to present those certificates. There are lots of reasons why someone might get a police background check and only some of them involve purchasing firearms. Others would be applying for security sensitive positions, or filling out a visa to emigrate to another country. The police don't need to know why you got a background check.

I just don't see why anyone would object to that. Maybe the way it was being implemented.

After a discussion with peers, I'd like to further explore this idea of background checks without registration. As it has been practiced so far, after the abolition of the Long Gun Registry, onus to provide a valid PAL falls on the buyer and unless an illegal transfer is caught in the act, it would be difficult to prove that the seller transferred a non-restricted firearm illegally. I have no problem with this as I believe that sellers should not be responsible for the misuse of a firearm by the buyer. I'm not against the idea of licensing and mandatory training, however, I am also aware of how the aforementioned methods an be abused and make it overly restrictive.
 
The Senate has not allowed the gun amendment to pass, even though 90%+ of Americans supported it. The lies from the NRA have left their mark. Something is broken in the US.

what EXACTLY do 90% of Americans support? certainly not this piece of legislation.

I get that 90% of Americans support the notion that crazy people and criminals should not get guns. The Toomey Manchin legislation was not about that. YOU Blackrock are misrepresenting and distorting the facts. And demagoguing the NRA.
 

Blackrock's infamous "type it into Google and present it as if it were a peer reviewed study" trick is becoming old hat. Just like typing ".50 calibre hunting" into Google somehow meant that the CSSA advocated .50 BMGs for everyone. What he doesn't show is that 90% of a cherry picked sample size that doesn't even represent a fraction of a percentage of the US population was in favour of "stronger background checks" which didn't even detail how such background checks were going to be implemented. Involving a government third party in private sales which would be recording information like make, model, serial number and personal information from both parties. That's registration, what's that saying about lipstick on a pig again?
 
Blackrock's infamous "type it into Google and present it as if it were a peer reviewed study" trick is becoming old hat. Just like typing ".50 calibre hunting" into Google somehow meant that the CSSA advocated .50 BMGs for everyone. What he doesn't show is that 90% of a cherry picked sample size that doesn't even represent a fraction of a percentage of the US population was in favour of "stronger background checks" which didn't even detail how such background checks were going to be implemented. Involving a government third party in private sales which would be recording information like make, model, serial number and personal information from both parties. That's registration, what's that saying about lipstick on a pig again?

Not at all, I just want to show there's all sorts of sources out there that show 'what the 90% support', which is what was asked for. No peer review needed. So now you're going to attack the methodology of the polls. I don't know whether that a sign of weakness or desperation of your part. Just like your automatic transmission amnalogy was.
 
Not at all, I just want to show there's all sorts of sources out there that show 'what the 90% support', which is what was asked for. No peer review needed. So now you're going to attack the methodology of the polls. I don't know whether that a sign of weakness or desperation of your part. Just like your automatic transmission amnalogy was.

"Stronger background checks at gun shows" is a pretty vague, feel-good/fear mongering phrase which exploits the ignorance of the fence sitters...kind of like the term "assault rifle".