US Senate Wimps Out

Note that the anti side is also responsible for the failure to bring common sense legislation. They brought a proposal designed to be a first step towards registration rather than one that could not used that way.
....

How horrible. Guns registered? What a crazy idea.
 
Considering the government has never said they were going to do that, nor ever has, why even consider it. I know, they might.

The "government" has not said so, but several of the lobby groups that backed the legislation actually did. They outlined their game plan.

1. Create a federal regime to manage the purchase of firearms
2. Turn that regime into a registry
3. Put in controls on what sorts of firearms can be purchased
4. Confiscate

That is in fact the game plan of some of the lobby groups backing the legislation.

Now that certainly isn't the opinion of moderates. I am sure that there are lots of moderates around who just wanted to see people pass a background check before getting firearms, but like many issues in the firearms debate this one has become a political football being kicked back and forth by the extremists on each side.

At any rate, the above game plan is why the legislation called for federally managed background checks as opposed to just having people present evidence they'd passed one. The latter approach does not lead to step #2 and so wasn't appealing to the authors of the legislation, even if it would perfectly satisfy the moderates.

If we could ditch the extremists, the Bloomberg's and the NRA, everybody else could probably figure out something sensible.
 
Of course that logic pre-supposes that the government wants to confiscate them and not even our Northern Socialist paradise does that.

Revisionist history is a peculiar thing; it's funny that people act as if registration won't result in confiscation when it already has. Chretien's Firearms Act reclassified and confiscated some half million guns from law abiding citizens. For more recent examples, why not google "Norinco Type 97", "Walther G22", "Armi-Jäger AP80" or "BD-38" then tell which classification they currently fall under in the Firearms Act?
 
Revisionist history is a peculiar thing; it's funny that people act as if registration won't result in confiscation when it already has. Chretien's Firearms Act reclassified and confiscated some half million guns from law abiding citizens. For more recent examples, why not google "Norinco Type 97", "Walther G22", "Armi-Jäger AP80" or "BD-38" then tell which classification they currently fall under in the Firearms Act?

Stay with the class CL, we're talking about the US of A, not Canada.

The US government is not saying anything about confiscating all firearms. As it is proposed, you buy a gun at a show you have a background done, Then you sell it privately, no check, so much the information. The paranoid pointy hat fits you well.
 
Stay with the class CL, we're talking about the US of A, not Canada.

The US government is not saying anything about confiscating all firearms. As it is proposed, you buy a gun at a show you have a background done, Then you sell it privately, no check, so much the information. The paranoid pointy hat fits you well.

So you mean to tell me that

OUR Northern Socialist paradise

Is a new pet name for the "US of A"? Are you guys posting from Mexico, how's strict gun control working down there?
 
So you mean to tell me that

Is a new pet name for the "US of A"? Are you guys posting from Mexico, how's strict gun control working down there?

Mexico has already been discussed in past thread and shown that gun control doesn't work down there because of the scale of criminal activity, far in excess of anything the US.

I guess we now look at traffic laws being useless because generally law abiding people will regularly break those laws.

Those guns you listed were a small selection of guns that were deemed dangerous, not a whole confiscation programs of guns. The reistration was not a bad idea, just badly run.
 
Revisionist history is a peculiar thing; it's funny that people act as if registration won't result in confiscation when it already has. Chretien's Firearms Act reclassified and confiscated some half million guns from law abiding citizens. For more recent examples, why not google "Norinco Type 97", "Walther G22", "Armi-Jäger AP80" or "BD-38" then tell which classification they currently fall under in the Firearms Act?

The Canadian government decided that several types of guns were more dangerous than justifiable and banned them? They all look like assault weapons to me, not hunting weapons. One essentially is an AK-47, another a copy of the WWII German MP-38, a third the assault weapon of the Chinese army. And where has Canada moved towards banning all guns?

p.s. after googling, it seems a 'new' variant of the 97 is legal in Canada as is the Walther g22 (one stock design isn't).
 
The Canadian government decided that several types of guns were more dangerous than justifiable and banned them?

The Canadian regulation isn't really sane. At its heart there was initially a coherent idea--ban all full automatic weapons, along with pistols with too short a barrel, and so on. And so that was done in the act, but in addition there were a list of firearms that were banned "by name" -- they're simply listed in an Order in Council. That list is a hodge podge and comprises firearms that would otherwise be entirely legal under Canadian law, while other nearly identical firearms that weren't named remain fully legal and in some cases are just non-restricted rifles, subject to the least restrictive regime. They have no special features or attributes that make them particularly more dangerous than other firearms that weren't named, they just sounded/looked scary.

It would be a lot more sensible to have firearm policy based on the attributes / capabilities of the firearm, rather than just banning an arbitrary list of firearms because they look scary.

But CL is right -- the Canadian government did indeed confiscate quite a few firearms from people who had legally owned them up until that point.
 
The Canadian government decided that several types of guns were more dangerous than justifiable and banned them? They all look like assault weapons to me, not hunting weapons. One essentially is an AK-47, another a copy of the WWII German MP-38, a third the assault weapon of the Chinese army. And where has Canada moved towards banning all guns?

p.s. after googling, it seems a 'new' variant of the 97 is legal in Canada as is the Walther g22 (one stock design isn't).

To the uninformed, they share a cosmetic similarity yet function entirely differently and in the cases of some, are chambered in one of the smallest, weakest calibres commercially available. There's nothing particularly "assaultive" about them.
 
To the uninformed, they share a cosmetic similarity yet function entirely differently and in the cases of some, are chambered in one of the smallest, weakest calibres commercially available. There's nothing particularly "assaultive" about them.

That's your opinion of course, just like you insistence that the .223 wasn't a dangerous weapon. The .22 is a favorite weapon of the assassin, is it not?

Now back to the failed amendment.
 
That's your opinion of course, just like you insistence that the .223 wasn't a dangerous weapon. The .22 is a favorite weapon of the assassin, is it not?

Now back to the failed amendment.

They're not capable of full auto, hence they aren't assault weapons. Next!

Can you find me the quote where I called the .223 "not dangerous"? What I actually called it was "one of the weakest, centrefire rifle rounds", a fact you've never been successful in countering. Virtually any centrefire hunting rifle cartridge easily exceeds the lethality of a .223 round. As for the .22 being an assassin's favourite cartridge, what have I said about movie "facts" in the past?
 
That's your opinion of course, just like you insistence that the .223 wasn't a dangerous weapon.

All firearms are dangerous, but there is no reason to single out .223 and pretend that it is any more or less dangerous than any other varmint hunting round.

The military did not adopt .223 because it was more powerful. They adopted it because it was lighter and smaller, and so soldiers could carry a lot more of it. Their logic is that firing a whole lot of less powerful .223 at the enemy is more effective than firing fewer higher powered .30 caliber rounds. You can fit more .223 rounds into one magazine, and you can carry more magazines, thus you have a lot more ammo to fire at the enemy than if you used a higher powered round such as a typical .30 caliber hunting round.

In a fully automatic military rifle being able to carry a lot more ammo is a big deal. In a hunting rifle that fires one shot for each trigger pull .223 is a lot less powerful than .30 caliber.
 
They're not capable of full auto, hence they aren't assault weapons. Next!

Can you find me the quote where I called the .223 "not dangerous"? What I actually called it was "one of the weakest, centrefire rifle rounds", a fact you've never been successful in countering. Virtually any centrefire hunting rifle cartridge easily exceeds the lethality of a .223 round. As for the .22 being an assassin's favourite cartridge, what have I said about movie "facts" in the past?


Are they capable to be made into full automatic with alteration, simple or otherwise? You had trouble with that concept with the AR-15, so one wonders if you can really answer this question. I didn't quote you, but I said in two words what you said in many, nothing more. You were trying infer weak meant not dangerous. The smaller calibre is lighter, easier to aim, and the gun is described by many sources as designed by the company as a military weapon. Never was a need to counter your point as a result.
 
To the uninformed, they share a cosmetic similarity yet function entirely differently and in the cases of some, are chambered in one of the smallest, weakest calibres commercially available. There's nothing particularly "assaultive" about them.

Then what is the functional purpose of these weapons. There are far more effective weapons for hunters. Meanwhile clones of AK-47 and MP-38 have no function other to kill people and I will not shed a tear over them being banned in Canada.
 
Then what is the functional purpose of these weapons. There are far more effective weapons for hunters. Meanwhile clones of AK-47 and MP-38 have no function other to kill people and I will not shed a tear over them being banned in Canada.

What is the harm in allowing responsible individuals to utilize inanimate objects in a responsible manner? When was the last time someone used a BD-38 or a .22LR clone of an AK in the commission of a criminal offense? Why direct focus on a group of firearms that are responsible for a nearly insignificant (less than 3%) of firearms related offenses? People will not tolerate unjust confiscation and restriction of their freedoms because of the wrongful actions of a very small group of people.
 
The Senate simply took a pass on amendments that would have little/no impact on gun violence in the US. The POTUS hails from a city that had 500 murders last year, a magazine limit, "assault" weapon ban or expanded background checks would have no impact. If he wants to address the issue, vs whining like a bitch, he might try and understand why almost all of those murders were young black and Hispanic men shooting each other..... But that would be an uncomfortable conversation for him and would rub against his childish liberal world-view.
 
Then what is the functional purpose of these weapons.

One of the prohibited rifles was bolt action.

The ones that were convertible to automatic fire were already banned by the legislation outlawing automatics. The rifles named in addition to that mostly are not capable of automatic fire.