I do not buy the "BJ was just hyping the fight" stuff. His comments demonstrate that he is goof, a decent person, such as GSP, would not behave that way, even if he was paid to. Penn could easily choose to be gracious, but he didn't, because he is an idiot.
But Penn is a very good fighter, I think that you can respect someone's ability without having to apologize for his character.
If Penn had chosen to train hard, and gain 15 pounds of muscle, they would have been similar sized, and it would have been a better fight, though I think that GSP would still have won. But it appears the Penn basically just gained 15 pounds of fat, so he was indeed way smaller, which makes a big difference.
I am not sure what the fight says about Penn's heart. He took a good beating, but he also did not seem to fight back as hard as he could. And was it really the corner that threw in the towel? To me, it looked like they asked him after the fourth, and he turned his back and would not answer, so they quit on his behalf.
As much as I like GSP, six months ago, I would have said that Anderson Silva would beat him easily. But after GSP beating Penn, and Silva not interested in beating Cote, I am not so sure. If Silva looks bad in Montreal (I just booked my hotel tonight, tickets on sale on the 11th), and GSP devastates Alves, then I think GSP AS could be a great fight. At 170, GSP wins. At 185, hard to say. I don't know whether GSP could gain 15 pounds of muscle, he is pretty ripped already.