UFC Fight Tonight

dcbogey said:
Manji - I agree with you about the difference the weight classes make. I have a question, though. As I understand it the weigh-in was the day before the fight - how could GSP put on 20 lbs in such a short time and not affect his performance?


I only have a passing knowledge of weight cutting....
But these days they have weight cutting and the resulting sudden weight gain down to a science...

If it was a fighter's first time it would definitely affect his performance....but after certain amount of time it doesn't really become an issue as the fighter becomes used to it....
That's why wrestlers have the easiest time with it as weight cutting is a huge part of their sport....

In fact its the weight cutting that usually takes it toll on the body (and mind) and not the weight gain....

The extra day is extremely beneficial for guys who do extreme cuts in weight as they have the whole day to recover (rehydrate and eat like a fucking pig)
 
The higher weight will slow him down a bit. And i think Anderson Silva will fuck him up. They better do it quick because he says he'll retire at 35.
 
According to Sherdog, BJ's brother went back to his room...took his shoes off...laid on his bed for 10-20 minutes...and then fucked himself.
 
Total domination by GSP.
Too strong, too skilled, too fast.
Penn had no chance, he just got punished for 20 minutes.
BJ's brother did the right thing and threw in the towel.

For all of you who think Alves has a chance?
Forget it. He's not skilled enough.

GSP is now in the superstar stratosphere with Spider and Fedor.

As for Anderson? No way Spider comes down in weight. It would have to be GSP going up and that will never happen.

As for the other big fight of the night?
Machida looked great. A decent challenge for Rashad.
 
Manji said:
I wanted Penn to win that fight but I knew that GSP was gonna be physically too strong for him.....Though I thought Penn would last the five rounds (and he might have if it wasn't for the corner stoppage)

All of you guys who said Penn didn't show up for a fight and just went to collect a paycheck don't what you're talking about...

What most of you guys don't understand is what a huge difference a weight class makes....Especially MMA weight classes.....
The jump between 155 and 170 is huge (technically there should be at least one weight class between the lightweight and welterweight)....

St Pierre may have weighed in at 170 but he probably entered the ring at around 190....Penn just got worn down by GSP's wrestling, strength and size....
It took a lot of energy/physical effort to stuff GSP's takedowns in the first round (Penn's takedown defense was impressive)..
.
Once a fighter's physically worn down then there's little he can do in mounting a decent offense or even a decent defense (especially after the grounding and pounding that GSP's gave BJ)

If Penn was there to collect a paycheck he would have quit by the third round (and most fighters would have including GSP - GSP did tap get knocked down by Serra)...Instead he showed a shitload of heart and kept on fighting til his corner stopped the fight after the doctor's recommendation....


Penn comes from a rich family...he doesn't have to fight to feed his daughter....he could have retired from fighting and still live comfortably for the rest of his life)

And if anyone knows BJ Penn....They know he likes to shit talk....Its just who he is....He likes to hype the fight and get himself hyped up for the fight....
Thank you for posting. I had to take a deep breath and wait until today because I would have written something regrettable about those who obviously know little about MMA and even less about BJ Penn - a true legend and one of the greatest fighters ever - and his motivations.

What people fail to realize (and by calling BJ a quitter, etc., not respecting GSP's skill) is that in addition to the huge size difference (and to the guy who claimed in another thread that size shouldn't matter, it does!) GSP continues to exponentially get better each fight into his career. Fighters are not supposed to be able to make the improvements that he has in such a relatively short period of time. It's a testament to St. Pierre's will to improve and his ability to absorb new training techniques.

Really, GSP has two fluke-ish losses in his career: a lucky punch by Serra and in the first Hughes fight, he was overwhelmed by the moment and left an arm in there too long against a guy at the top of his game and then to further exacerbate matters, he didn't realize he only had 4-5 seconds left to hang on at the end of the round. That's all that separates Georges St. Pierre from 20-0.

BJ Penn is a guy who should be fighting at 160lbs (155 is a tough cut for him - I wouldn't go so far as to call the brother fat, I mean he got a weight problem. What's the brutha gonna do? He's Hawaiian, ya know?*) and who has always challenged himself to fight against the best in the world at other weight classes - Matt Hughes, Rodrigo Gracie, Lyoto Machida (who weighed 215 when they fought!) and now GSP. He's all about the fight in its purest form, not worrying about weight classes, etc., but he happened to come across a guy with incredible skill and will who also had about 20lbs on him on fight night and is naturally 25-30lbs heavier. I picked Penn to win, as I thought his conditioning was the only thing that kept him from destroying GSP in 2006, but I have mad respect for St. Pierre and the crazy improvements he continues to make in his short career as a top fighter.
Manji said:
There's no way that Anderson can come down to 170....He originally fought at 170 but now I really think its impossible for him to drop to Welterweight - The Spider walks around at about 210 or 220....

GSP would have to go up a weight class and fight at 185....And if they fought "The Spider" would crush St Pierre....

Thiago Alves will be a good fight for GSP....Should be a good one can't wait for it....
This fight, if they make it (and you're right, it will not be at 170 - although they've talked about a 180lb catchweight), is going to be the true dream match of all-time.

But I have to respectfully disagree with your assessment that Anderson Silva would "crush" Georges St. Pierre. Everyone who has trained with GSP says he's insanely strong for his size - including two big 205lbers in Keith Jardine and Rashad Evans. I believe his wrestling, hip strength and BJJ are good enough to hold Anderson down. Now whether he can do it for five rounds and do enough damage to keep Silva down, let alone win, is another thing altogether. But I think that fight would be a lot more competitive than last night's.

I'd be more concerned about the fight after that at 170 for GSP. It's hard to come back down after putting on 10+ pounds of muscle.

But what the fuck do I know, I picked BJ Penn to win last night?!


*Paraphrased from Pulp Fiction.
 
forget all the excuses from the penn followers.

facts are, penn shot his mouth off for months, ramped it up even more the last few weeks leading into the fight. what he should have been doing instead of shooting his mouth off, was train, and train hard.

GSP was an absolute man possessed training for this fight, and it showed. watching the fight last nite, the shape of the two fighters was very apparent to see. GSP was in amazing shape, while penn had alot of flab in the mid-section.

penn did all the talking, and GSP shut him up, in dominant fashion. there are no excuses.

Plyrs99

PS - have to agree with CF about GSP, and the strides he has made in his career in a short amount of time. his learning curve has yet to plateau, and he obviously takes great pride in his craft. i had a healthy respect for GSP before last nite's fight, but have to say, i gained that much more respect for the man after his demolition of penn.
 
GSP looked great last night , I didn't think it was going to be that lopsided.
I think Anderson Silva vs GSP would be like GSP fighting BJ Penn ,though. he'd have a really hard time.

Machida also put on a good show , Rashad Evans would be a good next fight for him. His counters are awesome.
 
plyrs99 said:
forget all the excuses from the penn followers.

facts are, penn shot his mouth off for months, ramped it up even more the last few weeks leading into the fight. what he should have been doing instead of shooting his mouth off, was train, and train hard.

GSP was an absolute man possessed training for this fight, and it showed. watching the fight last nite, the shape of the two fighters was very apparent to see. GSP was in amazing shape, while penn had alot of flab in the mid-section.

penn did all the talking, and GSP shut him up, in dominant fashion. there are no excuses.
(Deep breath. Exhale.)

*Note: this is not directed solely at the above-quoted poster, but at all UFC/MMA "fans" that don't seem to understand some fundamentals of the sport and the business aspects of it.


BJ Penn has learned that MMA - and especially the UFC - is a business. Since his payouts are based on live gates and PPV revenues, he knows that he has to "sell" the fight. That generally means there needs to be a good guy and a bad guy. The so-called "purists" may not like that aspect of MMA, but it's a fucking business, so grow the fuck up and learn to deal with it. BJ Penn had his role and played it well - particularly when it comes to Canadian UFC "fans", it appears.

If you believed the shit you saw on the UFC-produced hype show, then you're just another mark. And if you believe that every non-ripped fighter is a loser and out of shape (especially when he moved up a weight class) then you're nuts. Ever hear of a guy named Fedor Emelianenko? You do realize that there are different body types out there?

GSP was the bigger, better man last night. 'Nuff said. A highly-skilled bigger man will ALWAYS beat a highly-skilled smaller man if their abilities are even remotely close.



Here's a good investigative piece from a couple of weeks ago on the CBC on the UFC and how they pay and look after their fighters: http://www.cbc.ca/sunday/2009/01/011109_5.html. That's why these guys need to make their money while they can.
 
Just want to talk a bit about the fight. First off I want to say that I am a huge GSP fan and and he looked awesome. Secondly I want to say that I hate BJ and the way he carries himself is classless.

Now, I will be the first to admit that BJ is a great fighter. One of the best ever. He was simply overmatched in every way, size, conditioning, game plan and yes heart. Heart does not only show when you are getting a beating and don't quit. It shows from day one in training and thats where BJ struggles. As we all know genetics plays a part in conditioning and just becasue BJ was not cut like georgie does not mean he didn't train hard. He could never look like geroge physically . His cardio can not match GSP's . BJ was simply outclassed.

As far as Anderson goes. He is too big for GSP. It would be a huge advantage for Anderson as he be cutting and GSP has to go up. Its the same thing that just happened to BJ. BJ came up to 170 and walks into the ring 15 pounds lighter than GSP(20 was a stretch). Although I would like to see it, I hope GSP does not move up to fight Anderson. I think Anderson is too big but I would give GSP a shot as his gameplans are always top notch.

As far as cutting weight goes, guys generally put on 10 - 15 pounds between weigh in and the fight.This is only for the guys who are cutting weight. If they put on more than that it usually shows that they cut too much and is usually reflected in thier performace( low energy). Guys who move up in weight often drop a fe wpounds afther the weigh in.
 
A note for the above poster: Georges St. Pierre was 187 lbs just before the fight. BJ weighed in at 168 and didn't put on or lose significant weight. That's 19 pounds - close enough to 20 for you? :)

Then there's Thiago Alves, who has weighed as much as 199 lbs for a welterweight fight after making weight at 171 lbs. GSP will actually be the smaller man in that welterweight title fight... if Alves can make weight, which is a serious concern. (He's missed weight twice that I know of, including in the Matt Hughes fight in London.)

As I stated, I don't think GSP can beat Anderson, but I think he'll put up a better fight than BJ did last night - unless he gets caught with a big punch/kick early, then it'll be Serra:redux with a much more vicious striker.
 
wow that was impressive by gsp. total domination. alves is going to be a very tough next opponent though.

machida deserves a title fight for sure. i predict he will win. a very smart tactical fighter, similar to rashad.

let's not forget clay guida. one of my favorite fighters. he was stuck like glue on diaz.
 
(deep sigh...try once again)

fuck the showmanship excuses, the weight excuses, blah-blah. when you open your mouth, you better be able to back it up. penn could not do that, and was destroyed last night.

this was not the first meeting between the two, so penn knew what GSP was all about. quite simply, one fighter has evolved from the fight in canada, while one has not.

anymore excuses, captain fantastic? i did not watch the UFC-hyped post game show at all. i know penn has a more natural body type than georges, but i look at what penn looked like in montreal, to what he looked like in vegas, and you can see the difference.

once again, one guy opened his mouth, the other guy closed it for him, pretty convincingly. all other explanations are just excuses.

Plyrs99
 
plyrs99 said:
fuck the showmanship excuses, the weight excuses, blah-blah. when you open your mouth, you better be able to back it up. penn could not do that, and was destroyed last night.

this was not the first meeting between the two, so penn knew what GSP was all about. quite simply, one fighter has evolved from the fight in canada, while one has not.

anymore excuses, captain fantastic? i did not watch the UFC-hyped post game show at all. i know penn has a more natural body type than georges, but i look at what penn looked like in montreal, to what he looked like in vegas, and you can see the difference.

once again, one guy opened his mouth, the other guy closed it for him, pretty convincingly. all other explanations are just excuses.
As noted, some people just don't get the business end of UFC. It wasn't about any real hatred or animosity, it was a way to sell a fight. If you can't figure that out, then there's nothing I or anyone else can say to you.

There were no excuses for BJ Penn. He's a man and can live with himself. All I stated was that a great bigger man will beat a great little man 99% of the time. And it happened again last night. And it will probably happen if and when GSP faces Anderson Silva.

As for all the other nonsense about guys shutting other guys up: keep living in your phony macho dream world. It's business, nothing more - think WWE.

PS - They didn't fight in Canada. BJ only came Montreal to be at the event and to Toronto and promote the fight. No shirt off or anything else, so I'm not sure what you're talking about... and I'm beginning to think that you don't either. ;)
 
Royce Gracie

I was not an MMA fan when Gracie was fighting. However, I have seen some amazing videos of Gracie defeating good fighters that were 30+ lbs heavier than him..

The talk about the weight difference between GSP and Penn is valid.
But it was not just about weight differences.

GSP was a hell of a lot stronger than Penn (yes, I know that a heavier person is normally stronger than a lighter person)

GSP looked faster than Penn

GSP boxed better than Penn

I was disappointed that Penn did not look like he prepared a good game plan for the fight..

How was Royce Gracie able to do what he did..
 
slowandeasy said:
I was not an MMA fan when Gracie was fighting. However, I have seen some amazing videos of Gracie defeating good fighters that were 30+ lbs heavier than him..

The talk about the weight difference between GSP and Penn is valid.
But it was not just about weight differences.

GSP was a hell of a lot stronger than Penn (yes, I know that a heavier person is normally stronger than a lighter person)

GSP looked faster than Penn

GSP boxed better than Penn

I was disappointed that Penn did not look like he prepared a good game plan for the fight..

How was Royce Gracie able to do what he did..

its a completely different game now, Royce would get destroyed in todays UFC if he was facing guys that much bigger than him with the same ground skills. He had a huge advantage in the early UFC's as many of the competitors didn't have a counter to his ground game.
 
How was Royce Gracie able to beat big men?

slowandeasy said:
I was not an MMA fan when Gracie was fighting. However, I have seen some amazing videos of Gracie defeating good fighters that were 30+ lbs heavier than him..

The talk about the weight difference between GSP and Penn is valid.
But it was not just about weight differences.

GSP was a hell of a lot stronger than Penn (yes, I know that a heavier person is normally stronger than a lighter person)

GSP looked faster than Penn

GSP boxed better than Penn

I was disappointed that Penn did not look like he prepared a good game plan for the fight..

How was Royce Gracie able to do what he did..

Easy. The guys Royce beat didn't know jiu-jitsu. Look at what happened when he fought Matt Hughes, an average MMA jiu-jitsu practioner, but a big, strong 170lb wrestler with decent striking who knew enough BJJ to nullify Royce. Hughes destroyed Gracie and they were the same size. Imagine if he fought someone like Anderson Silva or Quinton Jackson? It would be the first UFC death in the Octagon.
 
It would be the first UFC death in the Octagon.

lol, I wouldn't go that far. but yes would get beat up . Rickson is more of a well rounded(and supposedly best of the Gracie's) fighter. He can strike as well as grapple.
 
islandman4567 said:
lol, I wouldn't go that far. but yes would get beat up . Rickson is more of a well rounded(and supposedly best of the Gracie's) fighter. He can strike as well as grapple.
Yes, I was exaggerating as a form of humour. But it would be very ugly for the short time that the fight lasted. But as I mentioned earlier, look at the state of Royce's face and head after fighting Hughes, hardly a feared striker.

Rickson's 50, so there's no use discussing him. But having seen many of his fights in Japan, I will say that he would also stand no chance against the modern MMA fighter. He'd just last 30 seconds longer than Royce because he's so stubborn and proud! :cool:
 
GSP has no fucking chance if Silva get's him in a Mau thai clinch and slams his knees into his face.

GSP has no chance if Silva get on his back and wraps those long legs around his waist.

The only chance GSP has is if he gets on Silva's back.