Manji said:
I wanted Penn to win that fight but I knew that GSP was gonna be physically too strong for him.....Though I thought Penn would last the five rounds (and he might have if it wasn't for the corner stoppage)
All of you guys who said Penn didn't show up for a fight and just went to collect a paycheck don't what you're talking about...
What most of you guys don't understand is what a huge difference a weight class makes....Especially MMA weight classes.....
The jump between 155 and 170 is huge (technically there should be at least one weight class between the lightweight and welterweight)....
St Pierre may have weighed in at 170 but he probably entered the ring at around 190....Penn just got worn down by GSP's wrestling, strength and size....
It took a lot of energy/physical effort to stuff GSP's takedowns in the first round (Penn's takedown defense was impressive)..
.
Once a fighter's physically worn down then there's little he can do in mounting a decent offense or even a decent defense (especially after the grounding and pounding that GSP's gave BJ)
If Penn was there to collect a paycheck he would have quit by the third round (and most fighters would have including GSP - GSP did tap get knocked down by Serra)...Instead he showed a shitload of heart and kept on fighting til his corner stopped the fight after the doctor's recommendation....
Penn comes from a rich family...he doesn't have to fight to feed his daughter....he could have retired from fighting and still live comfortably for the rest of his life)
And if anyone knows BJ Penn....They know he likes to shit talk....Its just who he is....He likes to hype the fight and get himself hyped up for the fight....
Thank you for posting. I had to take a deep breath and wait until today because I would have written something regrettable about those who obviously know little about MMA and even less about BJ Penn - a true legend and one of the greatest fighters ever - and his motivations.
What people fail to realize (and by calling BJ a quitter, etc., not respecting GSP's skill) is that in addition to the huge size difference (and to the guy who claimed in another thread that size shouldn't matter,
it does!) GSP continues to exponentially get better each fight into his career. Fighters are not supposed to be able to make the improvements that he has in such a relatively short period of time. It's a testament to St. Pierre's will to improve and his ability to absorb new training techniques.
Really, GSP has two fluke-ish losses in his career: a lucky punch by Serra and in the first Hughes fight, he was overwhelmed by the moment and left an arm in there too long against a guy at the top of his game and then to further exacerbate matters, he didn't realize he only had 4-5 seconds left to hang on at the end of the round. That's all that separates Georges St. Pierre from 20-0.
BJ Penn is a guy who should be fighting at 160lbs (155 is a tough cut for him -
I wouldn't go so far as to call the brother fat, I mean he got a weight problem. What's the brutha gonna do? He's Hawaiian, ya know?*) and who has always challenged himself to fight against the best in the world at other weight classes - Matt Hughes, Rodrigo Gracie, Lyoto Machida (who weighed 215 when they fought!) and now GSP. He's all about the fight in its purest form, not worrying about weight classes, etc., but he happened to come across a guy with incredible skill and will who also had about 20lbs on him on fight night and is naturally 25-30lbs heavier. I picked Penn to win, as I thought his conditioning was the only thing that kept him from destroying GSP in 2006, but I have mad respect for St. Pierre and the crazy improvements he continues to make in his short career as a top fighter.
Manji said:
There's no way that Anderson can come down to 170....He originally fought at 170 but now I really think its impossible for him to drop to Welterweight - The Spider walks around at about 210 or 220....
GSP would have to go up a weight class and fight at 185....And if they fought "The Spider" would crush St Pierre....
Thiago Alves will be a good fight for GSP....Should be a good one can't wait for it....
This fight, if they make it (and you're right, it will not be at 170 - although they've talked about a 180lb catchweight), is going to be the true dream match of all-time.
But I have to respectfully disagree with your assessment that Anderson Silva would "crush" Georges St. Pierre. Everyone who has trained with GSP says he's insanely strong for his size - including two big 205lbers in Keith Jardine and Rashad Evans. I believe his wrestling, hip strength and BJJ are good enough to hold Anderson down. Now whether he can do it for five rounds and do enough damage to keep Silva down, let alone win, is another thing altogether. But I think that fight would be a lot more competitive than last night's.
I'd be more concerned about the fight after that at 170 for GSP. It's hard to come back down after putting on 10+ pounds of muscle.
But what the fuck do I know, I picked BJ Penn to win last night?!
*Paraphrased from Pulp Fiction.