Trudeau on Tax Avoidance

They aren't leaving in great numbers, you are making things up.

Dont be stupid
The fact that some are leaving as a result of high taxes is proof positive that Justins tax targeting of professionals could turn out to be a Healthcare distaster.

So is it policy development via Ready shoot aim & cross your fingers to hope it does not backfire?

If anyone leaves as a result of high taxes you should clue in to the fact our taxes are just plain too high

Driving out those who support your nanny state will be the destruction of your nanny state
i.e the nanny state is not sustainable
Not unless you achieve world wide domination comrade
 
Last edited:
King of scaremongering. You do worship an ex PM that got whipped by the judge in the Duffy trial.

King of the irrelvant propaganda
Get back to us when you have something worth discussing that is relavant to this post

You lack the intellegence to make arational point without an attack on ex-PM Harper.
How sad
 
King of the irrelvant propaganda
Get back to us when you have something worth discussing that is relavant to this post

You lack the intellegence to make arational point without an attack on ex-PM Harper.
How sad

Practice what you damn preach. From day one after Trudeau was selected as the leader of the Liberal Party you had no problem with your biased right wingie attacks on him. So when you come out with your stupid speculation of where Canada is or is not going, a comparison to what actually occurred is not irrelevant to this post. I am putting out facts while you are not short of fiction with your speculative arguments.

In plain go back to yawning. That is the best formula for you.
 
They aren't leaving in great numbers, you are making things up.

The fact that the average salaries for doctors in Canada is around $100,000 lower than the USA of even Great Britain has always meant that doctors like every other professions will pursue better opportunities. However, there are many doctors who cannot get into the profession and will be happy to do so once a position has been vacated. But once again King of Speculation on this board the Larue guy will try to work everything as being the fault of the Liberal Government. In 2011 under the height of the previous conservative government, an orthopedic surgeon made $208000 in Canada, $440,000 in the USA and $324,000 in Britain. Now why is it that such a disparity is the norm under one Government but if the new tax law comes into place , those at the lower end of $200,000 will hardly pay anymore in taxes. So pure speculation.
 
Practice what you damn preach. From day one after Trudeau was selected as the leader of the Liberal Party you had no problem with your biased right wingie attacks on him. So when you come out with your stupid speculation of where Canada is or is not going, a comparison to what actually occurred is not irrelevant to this post. I am putting out facts while you are not short of fiction with your speculative arguments.

In plain go back to yawning. That is the best formula for you.

Mr. Harper is no longer our PM
Justin is

If you can figure out how Justin's actions are far more relevant than Mr. Harpers reactions to a fat senators misdeeds 5 years ago then you do not have a clue about what is important
 
The fact that the average salaries for doctors in Canada is around $100,000 lower than the USA of even Great Britain has always meant that doctors like every other professions will pursue better opportunities. However, there are many doctors who cannot get into the profession and will be happy to do so once a position has been vacated. But once again King of Speculation on this board the Larue guy will try to work everything as being the fault of the Liberal Government. In 2011 under the height of the previous conservative government, an orthopedic surgeon made $208000 in Canada, $440,000 in the USA and $324,000 in Britain. Now why is it that such a disparity is the norm under one Government but if the new tax law comes into place , those at the lower end of $200,000 will hardly pay anymore in taxes. So pure speculation.

Bullshit
As you point out an orthopedic surgeon makes less than half of what a comparable surgeon makes in the USA
factor in the exchange rate and the much higher taxes and his take home is probably about 1/4 to 1/3 relative to the USA doctor

Now Justin has just eliminated a legitimate tax deduction for doctors in order to appear to be sticking it to the rich
So if that loss of the deduction will have no impact, why make the change?
If it will have a significant impact then the Canadian Doctor is settling for maybe 20% of what his take home would be in the USA

So when faced with a take home of 5X and golf year round in Scottsdale Arizona vs. sticking his finger up some rednecks ass in Itchy Butt Sask (The mosquito capital of the world) for a take home of 20% anyone in their right mind would consider it
& the loonie lefties are just getting warmed up on the tax the rich witch-hunt

Ready shoot aim
 
The fact that the average salaries for doctors in Canada is around $100,000 lower than the USA of even Great Britain has always meant that doctors like every other professions will pursue better opportunities. However, there are many doctors who cannot get into the profession and will be happy to do so once a position has been vacated. But once again King of Speculation on this board the Larue guy will try to work everything as being the fault of the Liberal Government. In 2011 under the height of the previous conservative government, an orthopedic surgeon made $208000 in Canada, $440,000 in the USA and $324,000 in Britain. Now why is it that such a disparity is the norm under one Government but if the new tax law comes into place , those at the lower end of $200,000 will hardly pay anymore in taxes. So pure speculation.

how do you know this are these gross or net or more likely pure bullshit
 
Bullshit
As you point out an orthopedic surgeon makes less than half of what a comparable surgeon makes in the USA
factor in the exchange rate and the much higher taxes and his take home is probably about 1/4 to 1/3 relative to the USA doctor

Now Justin has just eliminated a legitimate tax deduction for doctors in order to appear to be sticking it to the rich
So if that loss of the deduction will have no impact, why make the change?
If it will have a significant impact then the Canadian Doctor is settling for maybe 20% of what his take home would be in the USA

So when faced with a take home of 5X and golf year round in Scottsdale Arizona vs. sticking his finger up some rednecks ass in Itchy Butt Sask (The mosquito capital of the world) for a take home of 20% anyone in their right mind would consider it
& the loonie lefties are just getting warmed up on the tax the rich witch-hunt

Ready shoot aim

Bullshit, if they are earning in the low $200000 then anything over 200,000 that figure gets taxed at the higher rate, whereas they get an extra 1.5 percent for the taxable income upto the $200,000. Now if they were making the $400,000 in the first place then that would have been different. So is the Rt. Honourable Trudeau reponsible for the drop in the value of the Canadian dollar and Harpo had no responsibility?

Okay so you are saying no more infrastructure spending, no more garbage pickups, let the rich and poor pay for medical expenses, as the Health is now privatised, privatise all the schools public transport, get rid of parliament, no more spending on armies, navy , airforce, abolish the police force, and finally let us only have toll highways. So this would be your ideal nation, as no more taxes. Yes, so is this what you want Canada to be?
 
Bullshit, if they are earning in the low $200000 then anything over 200,000 that figure gets taxed at the higher rate, whereas they get an extra 1.5 percent for the taxable income upto the $200,000. Now if they were making the $400,000 in the first place then that would have been different. So is the Rt. Honourable Trudeau reponsible for the drop in the value of the Canadian dollar and Harpo had no responsibility?

It is frustrating to see your supposed mind at work
The incremental increase in a doctors marginal tax rate is a different problem. A nasty unjustified grab at over half of his incremental income over $200K, however a different tax burden than the one under discussion here
It is the closure of the legitimate deduction which will have the greater impact upon his tax bill as it will for any professional who was claiming it.

so again the questions to you are:
If the incremental tax burden on a doctor due to the closure of the professional deduction is negligible, then why make the change?
or
If the incremental tax burden on a doctor due to the closure of the professional deduction is significant, then why is that not a greater risk of more doctors moving to a more reasonable tax jurisdiction?



Okay so you are saying no more infrastructure spending, no more garbage pickups, let the rich and poor pay for medical expenses, as the Health is now privatised, privatise all the schools public transport, get rid of parliament, no more spending on armies, navy , airforce, abolish the police force, and finally let us only have toll highways. So this would be your ideal nation, as no more taxes.

Did I say any of that ?
No

When you start making a claim of greater than 50% on someone's income , then some real tough incentive questions start having considerably more weight

Why see 30 patients a day instead of 20 if the govt gets 55% of each next dollar?
I can take home 5X as much and get paid in US greenbacks & I can golf year round if I practice medicine in Scottsdale Arizona ?


Yes, so is this what you want Canada to be?
Given we have an aging population and the utilization of healthcare services is expect to grow almost exponentially, what I do not want for Canada is to be short on qualified experienced doctors
I am sure most sane rational (aging) Canadians would agree

So taxing them at a higher rate and closing off a legitimate tax deduction does seem to be somewhat of a risky move
A move one might make if one makes policy decisions without careful consideration
A sort of Ready, Shoot Aim approach
 
When you talk about salaries, it is always referred to the gross, not net.

When making a sound business decision it is the net cash flow that really matters
Do you understand what NPV analysis is?
know what a hurdle rate is?

Do not forget that these doctors are running an independent professional business in addition to practising medicine
 
When making a sound business decision it is the net cash flow that really matters
Do you understand what NPV analysis is?
know what a hurdle rate is?

Do not forget that these doctors are running an independent professional business in addition to practising medicine

When you apply for a job like the majority of Canadians do they calculate your net salary and tell you that this is what you will be earning during the interview? Let's for once talk about the middle income earners who stand to benefit. The Doctors are still going to live comfortably at $ 200,000 plus. We should be worried about the lower incomes who you dont seem to care an iota about. They voted for Trudeau so suck it up. There are the indigenous part of the population who are having the highest suicidal rates in the developed nations and the poverty is alarming. I guess you do not care for such Canadians, who have basically been ignored, but you are worried more about the haves rather than the have nots. Your train of thoughts are alarming.
 
It is frustrating to see your supposed mind at work
The incremental increase in a doctors marginal tax rate is a different problem. A nasty unjustified grab at over half of his incremental income over $200K, however a different tax burden than the one under discussion here
It is the closure of the legitimate deduction which will have the greater impact upon his tax bill as it will for any professional who was claiming it.

so again the questions to you are:
If the incremental tax burden on a doctor due to the closure of the professional deduction is negligible, then why make the change?
or
If the incremental tax burden on a doctor due to the closure of the professional deduction is significant, then why is that not a greater risk of more doctors moving to a more reasonable tax jurisdiction?





Did I say any of that ?
No

When you start making a claim of greater than 50% on someone's income , then some real tough incentive questions start having considerably more weight

Why see 30 patients a day instead of 20 if the govt gets 55% of each next dollar?
I can take home 5X as much and get paid in US greenbacks & I can golf year round if I practice medicine in Scottsdale Arizona ?



Given we have an aging population and the utilization of healthcare services is expect to grow almost exponentially, what I do not want for Canada is to be short on qualified experienced doctors
I am sure most sane rational (aging) Canadians would agree

So taxing them at a higher rate and closing off a legitimate tax deduction does seem to be somewhat of a risky move
A move one might make if one makes policy decisions without careful consideration
A sort of Ready, Shoot Aim approach

So the increase from 29% to 33% is going to break the camels back? Ie $4000 more per year on an extra $100,000 that will send them South of the border. Are they going to live in poverty if they lose that extra $4000 per year? If they wanted to go South to earn that extra $200,000 then they would have left quite sometime ago. Many of them do not want to live in the USA as they prefer the Canadian way of life, and this is where they will live. There are many more doctors who are willing to work in Canada, so if some want to go so be it. Remember that Canada's Corporate tax is lower than the USA and the lowest among developed nations so do expect Corporations and businesses to continue to invest here. You just missed this one point that matters. Anyway your scaremongering keeps on rising by the second.
 
When you apply for a job like the majority of Canadians do they calculate your net salary and tell you that this is what you will be earning during the interview?
If you are also weighing a competitive opportunity in the USA, then yes the net is what really matters
WTF?
Have you graduated high school yet?

Let's for once talk about the middle income earners who stand to benefit. The Doctors are still going to live comfortably at $ 200,000 plus.

Oh so you get to judge what someone who spends 7 years of university and 4 years as an intern should make?

Well I say it should be quite a bit more than 2X what someone who does a 3 year BA and then a year @ clown college earns
Doctors do not take the summer off and do not work to rule

We should be worried about the lower incomes who you dont seem to care an iota about.
Are they going to perform live saving by pass surgery ?


They voted for Trudeau so suck it up.
Is there a correlation between income and intelligence?
There are the indigenous part of the population who are having the highest suicidal rates in the developed nations and the poverty is alarming.
And driving doctors out of the country via taxation fixes this how?

You will never ever solve all of the world problems
And it certainly will not happen via taxation


I guess you do not care for such Canadians, who have basically been ignored, but you are worried more about the haves rather than the have nots.
The haves and he have not's will both require doctors

Your train of thoughts are alarming.

Your inability to rationally view an issue with getting confused by emotion is truly scary and an indictment of our education system
 
doctors in Ontario generally do not get paid a salary. It's a fee for service arrangement

bver-hunter does not have a clue what he is talking about
All he sees is higher taxes on the rich and he is all for it, regardless of unintended consequences
He is an idealist and pragmatic logic is not part of the equation for him
 
So the increase from 29% to 33% is going to break the camels back? Ie $4000 more per year on an extra $100,000 that will send them South of the border.
Again you are not paying attention
You are focused on the incremental tax burden from the change in tax brackets
It is the closure of the legitimate deduction which will have the greater impact upon his tax bill as it will for any professional who was claiming it.


Are they going to live in poverty if they lose that extra $4000 per year? If they wanted to go South to earn that extra $200,000 then they would have left quite sometime ago.

The closure of the legitimate deduction & the tax burden from the change in tax brackets are both incremental and it will be a whole lot more than $4k per 100K

Many of them do not want to live in the USA as they prefer the Canadian way of life, and this is where they will live.
all it will take is about 5% and we shall have a real problem. 10% and we will have a crisis

There are many more doctors who are willing to work in Canada, so if some want to go so be it.
I hope you recall that remark when you find out someone you care about has a two year wait for surgery

Remember that Canada's Corporate tax is lower than the USA and the lowest among developed nations so do expect Corporations and businesses to continue to invest here.
Gee I wonder who was responsible for that?
It is very odd to hear you supporting Steven Harpers policies

You just missed this one point that matters. Anyway your scaremongering keeps on rising by the second.
Business and investment will not address the doctors shortage , nor will they address the very predictable exponential increase in health care utilization
 
I hope you recall that remark when you find out someone you care about has a two year wait for surgery



Business and investment will not address the doctors shortage , nor will they address the very predictable exponential increase in health care utilization


I am willing to give you the benefit of the doubt in some of the other points but the issue of wait times etc. are a pet peeve of mine.

First, let me qualify that overall, taxes in Canada are too high, and government waste and inefficiency contributes to many Canadians frustrations with our tax structure.

For those who are not aware, the supply of doctors is highly regulated in Canada. Essentially, the # of students who are able to enter Medical School in Canada is limited by many
things, but one major factor is the CMA and Provincial Governments. The CMA also puts up incredible obstacles for foreign doctors to practice in Canada (this is not a bad thing).
So we start off with a very limited supply of doctors in our country. So the laws of supply and demand are skewed in the doctors favor.

Our country invests heavily in the training of our doctors, and Med School Fees are heavily subsidized. We would hope that our doctors would take that into consideration when
they consider the options of moving down to the US for more money. My issue is with anyone who receives benefits from a socialist system, then decide that they should not
be constrained by that socialist system. i.e. doctors in Canada don't get paid enough, so I am going to go the US where I can make more money and pay less taxes. Anyone who
has funded their education with their own money should be a free agent.

The issue with wait times is quite simple, the budget for healthcare if fixed. If your administration staff and bureaucracy eat up too much of that budget, you limit the amount available to pay doctors.
This issue is exacerbated by abuse of the system, as well as an aging and more demanding population.

Your budget for doctors is filtered down from there. If you only have a 1 million for a certain specialist, and those specialists want $500,000/year, then you can only hire
2 specialists.

As far as your doctors shortage is concerned, open up the 2 tiered healthcare system, and we can have a true debate.

Finally, there is no talk about nurses, who are the backbone of our healthcare system. Now if anyone should get a raise, it is these people.
 
I am willing to give you the benefit of the doubt in some of the other points but the issue of wait times etc. are a pet peeve of mine.

First, let me qualify that overall, taxes in Canada are too high, and government waste and inefficiency contributes to many Canadians frustrations with our tax structure.
Agreed


For those who are not aware, the supply of doctors is highly regulated in Canada. Essentially, the # of students who are able to enter Medical School in Canada is limited by many
things, but one major factor is the CMA and Provincial Governments. The CMA also puts up incredible obstacles for foreign doctors to practice in Canada (this is not a bad thing).
So we start off with a very limited supply of doctors in our country. So the laws of supply and demand are skewed in the doctors favor.
The regulations originate with the government
If the regulations are skewing the demand /supply dynamic and preventing Canadians from receiving Health Care ,then fix the regulations


Our country invests heavily in the training of our doctors, and Med School Fees are heavily subsidized. We would hope that our doctors would take that into consideration when
they consider the options of moving down to the US for more money.
That same can be said for anyone attending a college or University in Canada.
People will migrate to other countries based upon the opportunities available and their personal preferences.
Doctors do not owe to Canada anymore than an oil engineer or an accountant

My issue is with anyone who receives benefits from a socialist system, then decide that they should not
be constrained by that socialist system. i.e. doctors in Canada don't get paid enough, so I am going to go the US where I can make more money and pay less taxes.
Get over it
All of our educational programs are subsidized


Anyone who has funded their education with their own money should be a free agent.
Free agency is driven by demand and there is no way in he world you can control / limit anyone's ability to maximize their wealth


The issue with wait times is quite simple, the budget for healthcare if fixed. If your administration staff and bureaucracy eat up too much of that budget, you limit the amount available to pay doctors.
This issue is exacerbated by abuse of the system, as well as an aging and more demanding population.
again a government driven problem. The amount of bureaucracy in our Health Care system is ridiculous

If it limits the amount available to pay doctors , then slash the bureaucracy or be prepaid to lose good doctors
Tax targeting them will only accelerate their departures

Your budget for doctors is filtered down from there. If you only have a 1 million for a certain specialist, and those specialists want $500,000/year, then you can only hire
2 specialists.

Again an issue within the control of government and one which will not be addresses by placing a higher tax burden on Doctors

As far as your doctors shortage is concerned, open up the 2 tiered healthcare system, and we can have a true debate.

Irrelevant wrt tax targeting of doctors

Finally, there is no talk about nurses, who are the backbone of our healthcare system. Now if anyone should get a raise, it is these people.
Nurses have not been tax -targeted, so their compensation is not relevant.

Should nurses get a raise?
Perhaps they are deserving, however not when the province is running a deficit
Perhaps granny Wynne could have used some the money she is spending on subsidizing electric car sales or paying multiples higher than market rates for wind and solar electricity
 
Should nurses get a raise?
Perhaps they are deserving, however not when the province is running a deficit
Perhaps granny Wynne could have used some the money she is spending on subsidizing electric car sales or paying multiples higher than market rates for wind and solar electricity

LOL.. Agree with the Wynne comment.

RE: Subsidizing education, agreed again, but some education is more highly subsidized than others.

I am not really debating the tax policies. I personally believe that we are becoming too much of a nanny state.