Trudeau on Tax Avoidance

Perhaps granny Wynne could have used some the money she is spending on subsidizing electric car sales or paying multiples higher than market rates for wind and solar electricity

A recent study has confirmed the fallacy of the Libs grand environment policies,...only 1/3 of electric car buyers bought electric again.

So just more tax dollars burnt with no beneifit.

FAST
 
Again you are not paying attention
You are focused on the incremental tax burden from the change in tax brackets
It is the closure of the legitimate deduction which will have the greater impact upon his tax bill as it will for any professional who was claiming it.




The closure of the legitimate deduction & the tax burden from the change in tax brackets are both incremental and it will be a whole lot more than $4k per 100K


all it will take is about 5% and we shall have a real problem. 10% and we will have a crisis


I hope you recall that remark when you find out someone you care about has a two year wait for surgery


Gee I wonder who was responsible for that?
It is very odd to hear you supporting Steven Harpers policies


Business and investment will not address the doctors shortage , nor will they address the very predictable exponential increase in health care utilization

Again your scaremongering without any evidence does not cease to amaze me. Your stupid assumption about legitimate tax deduction has no basis in reality. You seem to think that you know it all. But the fact is that more Canadians will benefit from the tax deduction and the increases for the higher income earners is really not going to hurt them in reality. Someone earning $300,000 will still enjoy their lifestyle that they are accustomed to. Nearly all of them will retire with millions still in their bank accounts that they will not spend in their life time. So that is the reality. We were discussing about those who were not paying their fair share of the taxes, that you seem to think is perfectly okay to launder their money in tax shelters.

In the meanwhile show us evidence of specialists leaving to go South in their droves, as they are losing out on a couple of thousands in their bank accounts.
 
Again your scaremongering without any evidence does not cease to amaze me.
I would guess anything bright and shinny would also amaze you


Your stupid assumption about legitimate tax deduction has no basis in reality.
If they had to change the law to close it, then by definition it was a legitimate tax deduction
That is reality, plain and simple


You seem to think that you know it all.
Just more than you do

But the fact is that more Canadians will benefit from the tax deduction and the increases for the higher income earners is really not going to hurt them in reality.
Says you
You have no clue about how this is going to impact them


Someone earning $300,000 will still enjoy their lifestyle that they are accustomed to.
Stop right there
Do you have insight into how others live their lives?
Do you have special insight into how others should live their lives?

No you have a biased hate driven opinion

Someone who makes $300 K may just buy a house 3 X bigger than someone earning $100 K and mortgage it to the same level of leverage
Then along come Justin and gouges them for an extra $10-$20 K a year. More if he was a professional (ie Doctor). That has an impact

Nearly all of them will retire with millions still in their bank accounts that they will not spend in their life time.
Any idea what one must do in order to make $300K ?
No you do not

A lot of people making that kind of money are commission & they have to hustle like you have never hustled
Yet you feel entitled to make a claim on their property through the government
In addition commissions are variable and can dry up depending on the market.
there is no guarantee of retiring with millions, until you do it




You are making an uninformed value judgement about how others should view their wealth & justifying a claim on that wealth
Shame on you for that

So that is the reality.
Go hustle and make $300K and then get back to us about reality

We were discussing about those who were not paying their fair share of the taxes,
Fair share as you define it
some of these people pay more tax in a year than you will in a lifetime, yet you feel you can judge them and dictate what they should pay ????

that you seem to think is perfectly okay to launder their money in tax shelters.
Nobody said anything about laundered money. That is an entirely different matter

If the tax shelter is legal then it is legal

In the meanwhile show us evidence of specialists leaving to go South in their droves, as they are losing out on a couple of thousands in their bank accounts.
It happens all the time, do some research
The real question is has Justin gone too far and past the tipping point?
Ready Shoot aim

We shall see soon enough .

The amount you truly do not understand is sadly astounding
 
I would guess anything bright and shinny would also amaze you



If they had to change the law to close it, then by definition it was a legitimate tax deduction
That is reality, plain and simple



Just more than you do


Says you
You have no clue about how this is going to impact them



Stop right there
Do you have insight into how others live their lives?
Do you have special insight into how others should live their lives?

No you have a biased hate driven opinion

Someone who makes $300 K may just buy a house 3 X bigger than someone earning $100 K and mortgage it to the same level of leverage
Then along come Justin and gouges them for an extra $10-$20 K a year. More if he was a professional (ie Doctor). That has an impact


Any idea what one must do in order to make $300K ?
No you do not

A lot of people making that kind of money are commission & they have to hustle like you have never hustled
Yet you feel entitled to make a claim on their property through the government
In addition commissions are variable and can dry up depending on the market.
there is no guarantee of retiring with millions, until you do it




You are making an uninformed value judgement about how others should view their wealth & justifying a claim on that wealth
Shame on you for that


Go hustle and make $300K and then get back to us about reality


Fair share as you define it
some of these people pay more tax in a year than you will in a lifetime, yet you feel you can judge them and dictate what they should pay ????


Nobody said anything about laundered money. That is an entirely different matter

If the tax shelter is legal then it is legal


It happens all the time, do some research
The real question is has Justin gone too far and past the tipping point?
Ready Shoot aim

We shall see soon enough .

The amount you truly do not understand is sadly astounding

Nothing that is bright and shiny has come from your direction, other than speculation coupled with scaremongering. Stop being pompous.
The honest Canadians who pay the taxes have nothing to worry about, so stop the scaremongering.
You mention nothing about the tax cuts upto the $200,000 that benefits us Canadians. So keep on living in denial. No you do not know more than me. Keep dreaming.
I have more knowledge about the high earners and how it will impact them. They get a lot more back from the Government when they instead invest in research. I know that from first hand, so again you are thinking along a narrow path. Widen your train of thought.

Once again I know first hand about the multimillionaires who have paid their mortgages, and do not necessarily go and buy huge properties like you stereotype them. Again you think so narrowly it is hilarious. Yes, they have the multiple properties as well, but they are far more prudent than you credit them with.

Again there are lots of Canadians making $300,000 plus in regular salaries including huge bonuses. They know that bonuses are based on the performance of their companies and how they grow them. So once again they save for a rainy day and not go overboard like you are implying. You go and try making a salary of $300,000. As for me I have no problem with how much I make. I do not complain the way you do :) So do not judge how much I make as you have no clue. If those people pay more in taxes than I do in a lifetime, then good for them. They won't be complaining the way you do.

Not all tax shelters are legal. If they are legal then there is no problem, otherwise The CRA will be coming to get them.
 
People who have lots of holdings can afford a crafty accountant and shirk taxes. Some of these loopholes need to be closed. And why do self employed people get to write off their vacations ( disguised as conventions), while others can't? Does that seem fair?
 
I think this is an interesting update on tax evasion.

Tax-cheat crackdown nets $1-billion more than expected, CRA data show

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...xpected-total-cra-data-shows/article29795295/


The agency’s success at raising nearly $1.6-billion from a $15-million budget measure likely explains why the government moved aggressively in the most recent budget to crack down further.

The 2016 budget announced $444.4-million over five years for the CRA to boost enforcement and forecasts a revenue gain of $2.6-billion over five years as a result of these measures.

Countries acting through the G20 and the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development have beefed up their efforts to share data on taxes and financial transactions in an effort to reduce the erosion of the tax base used to fund government programs.
 
Nothing that is bright and shiny has come from your direction, other than speculation coupled with scaremongering. Stop being pompous.
You can not continue to tax people at an ever increaing rate
They will take action
Stop being so foolish


The honest Canadians who pay the taxes have nothing to worry about, so stop the scaremongering.
They have lots to worry about
Justin now wants $0.55 out of the next incremental dollar
It will not end there as he is also borrowing at an alarming rate without any real need
How long before it is 60% on income over $175,000
or
How long before it is 70% on income over $150,000
Does he stop when he gets close to what Teachers are making?


You mention nothing about the tax cuts upto the $200,000 that benefits us Canadians.
What a dope
You might see some of that money this year, but Justin & Granny wynne are sure to extraxt well over that amount via new "Revenue Tools"

So keep on living in denial. No you do not know more than me. Keep dreaming.
The average high school kid knows more than you

I have more knowledge about the high earners and how it will impact them. They get a lot more back from the Government when they instead invest in research.
??
are you aking about labour sponsored investments?
You will have to explain this better

I know that from first hand, so again you are thinking along a narrow path. Widen your train of thought.
Again please explain your oh so vast experience

Once again I know first hand about the multimillionaires who have paid their mortgages, and do not necessarily go and buy huge properties like you stereotype them. Again you think so narrowly it is hilarious. Yes, they have the multiple properties as well, but they are far more prudent than you credit them with.

Far more prudent than the ready shoot aim PM who now demands 55% of their income so he can spend beyond his means

Again there are lots of Canadians making $300,000 plus in regular salaries including huge bonuses. They know that bonuses are based on the performance of their companies and how they grow them. So once again they save for a rainy day and not go overboard like you are implying.
Strange way of justifying targetng them for taxation at 55%


You go and try making a salary of $300,000. As for me I have no problem with how much I make. I do not complain the way you do :)
You complain about how much others make
You complain how thay have to pay their fair share as you define it
You complain if they attempt to leagaly shelter the money
You add no value yet you complain

besides I do not give a rats ass what you make.
My point is you should walk a mile in someones shoes before deciding what they can afford to live on comfortably
You should also walk a mile in their shoes to see ho much you have to hustle to make $300 K and watch as the government takes more than half of it

So do not judge how much I make as you have no clue.
When you apply judgement on how much tax others should pay you open your self up to scurtiniy
I do not give a rats ass what you make.
Howevr i can say with confidence it is no where near the $200K level
If it was you would apprciate how messed up your thinking is
If those people pay more in taxes than I do in a lifetime, then good for them. They won't be complaining the way you do.
Sure they will, go ask one or two

Not all tax shelters are legal. If they are legal then there is no problem, otherwise The CRA will be coming to get them
That is a diferent tune from when you did not distingusih betwenn tax avoidance and tax evasion
The CRA actually loses the majority of tax cases which go to court
 
Last edited:
I saw it on a documentary which aired this past week
Channel 2 I beleive
Right. I thought that you would have used more reliable sources. I read the bulletins on a regular basis where I work, and the reviews from the sources that I have quoted do not reflect that statement from Channel 2. Tax Hyperion is published by Carswell, and Knotia is from Chartered Professional Accountants of Canada and E&Y, not necessarily shabby experts in tax matters, including litigation. Don't trust Channel 2 documentaries, please.
 
I think this is an interesting update on tax evasion.

Tax-cheat crackdown nets $1-billion more than expected, CRA data show

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...xpected-total-cra-data-shows/article29795295/


The agency’s success at raising nearly $1.6-billion from a $15-million budget measure likely explains why the government moved aggressively in the most recent budget to crack down further.

The 2016 budget announced $444.4-million over five years for the CRA to boost enforcement and forecasts a revenue gain of $2.6-billion over five years as a result of these measures.

Countries acting through the G20 and the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development have beefed up their efforts to share data on taxes and financial transactions in an effort to reduce the erosion of the tax base used to fund government programs.
That, my dear friend, is an excellent business case, net savings of $1.6 billion, to justify spending the $444.4 million more to fight tax evasion.
 
Right. I thought that you would have used more reliable sources. I read the bulletins on a regular basis where I work, and the reviews from the sources that I have quoted do not reflect that statement from Channel 2. Tax Hyperion is published by Carswell, and Knotia is from Chartered Professional Accountants of Canada and E&Y, not necessarily shabby experts in tax matters, including litigation. Don't trust Channel 2 documentaries, please.

It was an extremely biased documentary, implying tax havens are breaking the law
Lots of loonie lefties expressing their disgust at missed opportunity to fund more government waste
The primary focus was transfer pricing

In the end they lamented that fact that CRA case files would have maybe 1-2 lawyers working on them while the defendant company would have a team of 10-20 top bay street lawyers
The were quite clear indicating CRAs record in tax court was abysmal as CRA simple can not match legal resources that corporations will assign to the issue.

Perhaps you were reading about CRA's record vs. individuals as oppose to corporations

Perhaps you may consider asking clarifying questions before deterring a source is not valid
 
It was an extremely biased documentary, implying tax havens are breaking the law
Lots of loonie lefties expressing their disgust at missed opportunity to fund more government waste
The primary focus was transfer pricing

In the end they lamented that fact that CRA case files would have maybe 1-2 lawyers working on them while the defendant company would have a team of 10-20 top bay street lawyers
The were quite clear indicating CRAs record in tax court was abysmal as CRA simple can not match legal resources that corporations will assign to the issue.

Perhaps you were reading about CRA's record vs. individuals as oppose to corporations

Perhaps you may consider asking clarifying questions before deterring a source is not valid
Maybe, you should look up Knotia and Tax Hyperion. The likes of multinationals, large and small corporations and sometimes (but rarely) individuals against the CRA are discussed, and the TCC judgements. These two sources are reliable and serve very important clientele in the tax field. Furthermore, they often have very important and thorough commentaries on many, many important tax topics, both domestic and international.

My sources are most valid, unbiased, factual, and respected in the taxation field, as opposed to the documentary that you, yourself have questioned with respect to its neutrality. I will tell you that you should not weigh too heavily any TV documentary over published facts as they are presented by the likes of the CPA

https://www.cpacanada.ca/ Chartered Professional Accountants of Canada (CPA Canada) is the national organization established to support a unified Canadian accounting profession. We represent highly qualified professionals who demonstrate an ongoing commitment to providing the highest standards of accounting, ethics and best business practices.

and Carswell

www.carswell.com/ Carswell is a Thomson Reuters business that develops professional resources for the Canadian legal, tax, finance and human resources markets.

as two examples.

Check your sources, before you comment, for your own good, and your credibility. And, don't assume that you are more expert than anyone else on this board in everything business.
 
Last edited:
You can not continue to tax people at an ever increaing rate
They will take action
Stop being so foolish



They have lots to worry about
Justin now wants $0.55 out of the next incremental dollar
It will not end there as he is also borrowing at an alarming rate without any real need
How long before it is 60% on income over $175,000
or
How long before it is 70% on income over $150,000
Does he stop when he gets close to what Teachers are making?



What a dope
You might see some of that money this year, but Justin & Granny wynne are sure to extraxt well over that amount via new "Revenue Tools"


The average high school kid knows more than you


??
are you aking about labour sponsored investments?
You will have to explain this better


Again please explain your oh so vast experience



Far more prudent than the ready shoot aim PM who now demands 55% of their income so he can spend beyond his means


Strange way of justifying targetng them for taxation at 55%



You complain about how much others make
You complain how thay have to pay their fair share as you define it
You complain if they attempt to leagaly shelter the money
You add no value yet you complain

besides I do not give a rats ass what you make.
My point is you should walk a mile in someones shoes before deciding what they can afford to live on comfortably
You should also walk a mile in their shoes to see ho much you have to hustle to make $300 K and watch as the government takes more than half of it


When you apply judgement on how much tax others should pay you open your self up to scurtiniy
I do not give a rats ass what you make.
Howevr i can say with confidence it is no where near the $200K level
If it was you would apprciate how messed up your thinking is

Sure they will, go ask one or two


That is a diferent tune from when you did not distingusih betwenn tax avoidance and tax evasion
The CRA actually loses the majority of tax cases which go to court

You are displaying how much of a dope you are. People took action by booting out Harpo, so what action are you muttering about now?
Again you are talking about Rt. Honourable Trudeau spending record amounts. When Harpo has done much more borrowing to the tune of 160 billion, you crawl back into your crevice as if to say that was okay because he is a conservative. As usual your 60%, 70% etc. Is total rubbish. You won't be in that category anyway so you can sleep tight.

You are displaying your political bias in the manner in which you draw Kathleen Wynn into the mix. What relevance does she have with respect to "tax avoidance"? You want to bring provincial politics into play, so let's throw great grandpa Harris into the mix and how he as good as sold the 407ETR that costed $104 Billion to acquire the land and construct the highway. He leased it for 99 years for less than $4 billion, a net loss of $100 billions to us taxpayers. You right wing loonies then praise such a transaction.

"Strange way of targeting them for taxation"? What on earth again are you waffling about? You seem to be going at a tangent as is the usual case with all your strange retorts.

Who has complained about anything that is legal? You on the other hand have complained about the Government trying to recoup the taxes from illegal tax shelters. Once again you are not in that tax bracket, and so there is nothing to worry about. The majority of Canadians are paying less, not more.

The CRA loses the majority of cases that go the court?? Then the rich have nothing to worry about if they take the CRA to court using your usual myths that the CRA loses most cases in courts. Your rants are hilarious at times.
 
Check your sources, before you comment, for your own good, and your credibility. And, don't assume that you are more expert than anyone else on this board in everything business.

http://tvo.org/video/documentaries/the-great-canadian-tax-dodge
tune into 39 mins 40 seconds +/-

They explicitly state the tax courts & supreme courts more often than not favour the tax avoiders (ie the defendants)

If your source states differently you are more than welcome to investigate the credibility of TVO
 
http://tvo.org/video/documentaries/the-great-canadian-tax-dodge
tune into 39 mins 40 seconds +/-

They explicitly state the tax courts & supreme courts more often than not favour the tax avoiders (ie the defendants)

If your source states differently you are more than welcome to investigate the credibility of TVO
Read the sources that I have cited. If you don't believe the tax experts over journalists that you, yourself accused of bias, then there is no hope for you.
 
You are displaying how much of a dope you are. People took action by booting out Harpo, so what action are you muttering about now?
Again you are talking about Rt. Honourable Trudeau spending record amounts. When Harpo has done much more borrowing to the tune of 160 billion, you crawl back into your crevice as if to say that was okay because he is a conservative. As usual your 60%, 70% etc. Is total rubbish. You won't be in that category anyway so you can sleep tight.

Strange way of targeting them for taxation? What on earth again are you waffling about? You seem to be going at a tangent as is the usual case with all your strange retorts.

Who has complained about anything that is legal? You on the other hand have complained about the Government trying to recoup the taxes from illegal tax shelters. Once again you are not in that tax bracket, and so there is nothing to worry about. The majority of Canadians are paying less, not more.

The CRA loses the majority of cases that go the court?? Then the rich have nothing to worry about if they take the CRA to court using your usual myths that the CRA loses most cases in courts. Your rants are hilarious at times.
Do we really want to waste time to argue with this guy? He contradicts himself in one reply, at least to me, and prefers to believe journalists over the acknowledged experts. What more can I say?
 
You are displaying how much of a dope you are.
I do not think so

People took action by booting out Harpo, so what action are you muttering about now?
They stop making more than $199,999 you moron
It is not worth the extra risk time & effort if you have to give more than half to the government

Again you are talking about Rt. Honourable Trudeau spending record amounts.
He is going to, no doubt about it

When Harpo has done much more borrowing to the tune of 160 billion, you crawl back into your crevice as if to say that was okay because he is a conservative.
It was not $160 B and it was in response to the worst economic crisis in 80 years

As usual your 60%, 70% etc. Is total rubbish.
Personal income tax in Canada was started to pay for the first world war as temporary measure
It has become permanent
Nobody would have believed 55% would fly a couple of years ago
The marginal tax in France is 75-85%, as per the loonie left

You won't be in that category anyway so you can sleep tight.
You know nothing about my income because I choose to keep that private
So your statement is without basis, like so many of your other statements

Strange way of targeting them for taxation? What on earth again are you waffling about?
Re-read it I said Strange way of justifying targeting them for taxation at 55%
You seem to be going at a tangent as is the usual case with all your strange retorts.
Not my fault if you can't read or comprehend properly

Who has complained about anything that is legal?
You were indifferent between tax avoidance and tax evasion
If they were rich and successful you wanted them punished
You on the other hand have complained about the Government trying to recoup the taxes from illegal tax shelters.
You assume they are illegal
That is for a court to decide
Once again you are not in that tax bracket, and so there is nothing to worry about.

Once again you make an assumption without any basis
You do not know how much I make and you never will
The majority of Canadians are paying less, not more.
Dream on
Once Justin and Granny Wynne apply their "Revenue Tools", that election gift will be recaptured

are you incapable of any independent thought?
Are you incapable of looking down the road when the bill for Justin & granny's Wynn's spending comes due?

What a naïve dope !!!


The CRA loses the majority of cases that go the court??
As per TVO
Then the rich have nothing to worry about if they take the CRA to court using your usual myths that the CRA loses most cases in courts.

Nothing to worry about????
How about the millions they need to spend on lawyer?
How about having their name dragged through the mud & having pinheads like you assume they are guilty ?
How about the time and energy required to defend oneself or your company that could be spent creating wealth?

Your rants are hilarious at times.

Yours are truly scary as it is difficult to believe an educated person can be so stunned
If you are still in high school we can give a let
 
Do we really want to waste time to argue with this guy? He contradicts himself in one reply, at least to me, and prefers to believe journalists over the acknowledged experts. What more can I say?

I opened both of your links
Nothing specific about CRA success rate in court was displayed
I will not spend hours searching on your say so

Provide specifics with direct links or take a far less hostile tone with me
 
I do not think so


They stop making more than $199,999 you moron
It is not worth the extra risk time & effort if you have to give more than half to the government


He is going to, no doubt about it


It was not $160 B and it was in response to the worst economic crisis in 80 years


Personal income tax in Canada was started to pay for the first world war as temporary measure
It has become permanent
Nobody would have believed 55% would fly a couple of years ago
The marginal tax in France is 75-85%, as per the loonie left


You know nothing about my income because I choose to keep that private
So your statement is without basis, like so many of your other statements


Re-read it I said Strange way of justifying targeting them for taxation at 55%

Not my fault if you can't read or comprehend properly


You were indifferent between tax avoidance and tax evasion
If they were rich and successful you wanted them punished

You assume they are illegal
That is for a court to decide


Once again you make an assumption without any basis
You do not know how much I make and you never will

Dream on
Once Justin and Granny Wynne apply their "Revenue Tools", that election gift will be recaptured

are you incapable of any independent thought?
Are you incapable of looking down the road when the bill for Justin & granny's Wynn's spending comes due?

What a naïve dope !!!



As per TVO


Nothing to worry about????
How about the millions they need to spend on lawyer?
How about having their name dragged through the mud & having pinheads like you assume they are guilty ?
How about the time and energy required to defend oneself or your company that could be spent creating wealth?



Yours are truly scary as it is difficult to believe an educated person can be so stunned
If you are still in high school we can give a let

You have overhyped the extra 4% on anything above the $200,000 taxation as if it is a huge burden on the haves. It is quite not 55% if you take into account the fact that they are clawing back an extra 1.5% on their $150,000. Look at the overall picture. Your right wing bias once again seems to speculate what the present Government will or will not do in the future. In plain the usual right wing nonsense from you.

I comprehend very well about your narrow train of thought, and for the millionth time, if people pay their fair share of the taxes, without any illegal tax sheltering then that is what the majority of Canadians want and support. Why would we pay for the rich who illegally shelter their taxes? The CRA are clawing back almost a billion and a half of it. Do you think that they are wrong to do so?

So once again practice what you preach. You speculated what I do or do not make, but are very irate if the tables are turned. Do not worry, as no one gives a damn what you make. Just pay your fair share of the taxes.

Once again great grandpa Harris and that Harpo dude had no problems spending record amounts on the 407 ETR loss and the $160 billion debt. What Rt. Honourable Trudeau and the Rt. Honourable Ms. Wynn spends, pales into comparison. So bring some more facts, not useless scaremongering or speculation. You can trot back to high school to learn more about facts and get some of those myths out of that head of yours.