E
buckloner said:As for Todd, what he did was cowardly and brutal, but what do you expect from a guy who was probably taught that way (with hundreds of other Canadian guys) as his ticket to the bigs. Sad commentary on the state of Canadian hockey, but I think it has improved since he came up.
Lots of blame here, the league, the coaches, management, they are all guilty IMHO.
Bring on the world Juniors.
I can forgive him for what he did.TP_MANAGEMENT said:Yup.
And Ranger, I see what you're saying, but Bertuzzi is a great talent to see. You mean to say you can never forgive him for what he did? He lost control, and he would probably be the first to admit it. I bet you he had no idea he was going to do the damage that he did to this guy. If this guy just got up and skated off the ice to his bench would you be saying all that?
I hope Steve Moore returns, and don't give a rat's ass about Todd Bertuzzi, frankly.TP_MANAGEMENT said:I'm just saying, I hope he returns and generates some positive interest again.
It's perfectly reasonable to treat circumstances differently when the results are different.TP_MANAGEMENT said:Imagine Forsberg is in the corner going for the puck. Now imagine Chelios is in behind him trying to take it off of him. Imagine Forsberg throws 3 or 4 elbows at Chelios and the last one hits him square in the mouth. It knocks one of his teeth loose, and Chelios swallows it and dies. Should Forsberg be banned from hockey when those types of elbows happen all the time? Bertuzzi used his fists. And I may be mistaken, but were his gloves not on? That happens all the time.
What I'm saying is let justice be served, then let this guy come back and aim to win the Lady Bing. Whatever! All I'm saying is the guy is sorry and I thought he was a great player since day one.
How do you know that? I guess you have never lost your temper before, eh Ranger? I'm going to withdraw from this thread after this point. I know you couldn't give a "rats ass" about Bertuzzi, but I do. He is a great Canadian talent, who made the biggest mistake of his life over a 30 second span. I highly doubt he felt anything good when he saw the stretcher come out and scoop up his damage. I want to see the league make an example out of him. I want to see the league scare other players from doing this kind of thing again.Ranger68 said:He's sorry all this bad stuff has happened to *him*, not to Steve Moore.
eyeofthedragon said:She reminds me of Karla Homolka
Sure I've lost my temper. So? I'm still accountable for my actions.TP_MANAGEMENT said:How do you know that? I guess you have never lost your temper before, eh Ranger? I'm going to withdraw from this thread after this point. I know you couldn't give a "rats ass" about Bertuzzi, but I do. He is a great Canadian talent, who made the biggest mistake of his life over a 30 second span. I highly doubt he felt anything good when he saw the stretcher come out and scoop up his damage. I want to see the league make an example out of him. I want to see the league scare other players from doing this kind of thing again.
But I want Bertuzzi to return. He is a fantastic Canadian talent that I do give a "rats ass" about.
Moore had been confronted by the Canucks all game long, and had already fought.Bud Plug said:
As to Bertuzzi's actions, they way I saw it was:
1. Moore refused to be confronted by Bertuzzi.
2. Bertuzzi got frustrated that Moore wouldn't turn around, so he punched him in the back of the head.
3. No-one knows whether Moore was knocked out by the punch, or by the fall to the ice.
4. The fall to the ice was greatly worsened by Bertuzzi and one of Moore's teammates falling on top of him. I don't believe that Bertuzzi meant to pile on, but rather that he was forced to fall on top of him when the teammate tackled Bertuzzi.
So, according to the law, he's TOTALLY responsible. The punch, which caused the entire chain reaction, was NOT purely accidental. In fact, it was arguably TOTALLY premeditated.Bud Plug said:
In other words, Bertuzzi meant to punch Moore, but I don't think he meant to seriously injure him. He probably thought that the punch would force Moore to turn around and face him. The fall to the ice, which is mostly responsible for the severity of Moore's injuries, was purely accidental.
Tell me about a "common bar fight" which ends with one of the parties having a broken vertebra and no charges were laid. What bullshit! It's OBVIOUSLY the severity of the injuries caused which has led to the outcry. And Bertuzzi, despite your sophistry, is TOTALLY accountable.Bud Plug said:
I disagree with posters who think that this incident illustrates an unacceptable level of violence in the game, or that throwing a punch is a serious criminal matter. If the police ever even bother to lay charges in a common bar fight, the charges inevitably are dropped or plead to conditional or absolute discharges.
What's particularly galling is that Moore wasn't given his rights as a victim. Galling and baffling. It's all about Todd, all about how poor Todd has suffered enough. Nothing about Moore.Bud Plug said:
I'm satisfied with what happened to Bertuzzi. I think losing a year of salary is more than penalty enough for what is more an error of judgement than a calculated intent to injure.
Bullfighting.tboy said:
I have yet to see anyone in any sport "pull a knife" on an opponent.
Hunting.tboy said:I have yet to see anyone in any sport "pull a knife" on an opponent.






