The LGBTQ protest thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, she is popular with that segment of the internet. Shapiro also patronizes her. And I'm sure Peterson will jump on the bandwagon. But she actually appears to be a serious researcher with academic credentials and some ideas.

She seems to have gotten her PhD then stopped doing research to become a columnist and internet pundit type.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kautilya
She seems to have gotten her PhD then stopped doing research to become a columnist and internet pundit type.
I've ordered her book from the public library and I'll see if it's credible.
 

So here's the actual source that you guys rely on for your info! 😹


Gays Against Groomers (GAG)[1] is an American far-right[2] and anti-LGBT[1][2][3][4] organization known for campaigning against gender-affirming care for minors,[2] protesting school curriculum with LGBT themes,[5] and criticizing Drag Queen Story Hour events.[6] A spokesperson for the LGBT advocacy group GLAAD has claimed that the group uses the slur "groomer" along with ambiguous messaging to characterize LGBT people as pedophiles.[7] GAG helped organize a anti-LGBTQ rally in Florida, alongside other far-right and anti-LGBTQ organizations such as Moms for Liberty, which was attended by the Proud Boys.[1][8]

GAG began in June 2022 as a Twitter account created by Jaimee Michell,[6] who had previously been employed by right-wing communications firms Arsenal Media and X Strategies and posted similar content on her personal account. The account is known for posting anti-trans rhetoric and has been compared to Libs of TikTok.[6][1] Michell filed incorporation papers for GAG in September. GAG has been banned from multiple social media and payment platforms for violating rules on hate speech;[9] they have been promoted by right-wing media outlets such as Fox News,[1] One America News Network (OANN),[1] and InfoWars.[4]

History

GAG was founded by Jaimee Michell, at the time a content creator and lead designer at marketing company Arsenal Media, a conservative media organization specializing in creating viral content.[5] GAG's Twitter account was created by Michell on June 6, 2022.[10] The account described itself as a "coalition of gays against the sexualization and indoctrination of children", with the purpose "to protect children from harm being done in our name and by those who have hijacked our community".[6]

In September 2022, Michell filed incorporation papers for GAG.[5] The group also launched a partner coalition called Trans Against Groomers.[11]

Michell has denied that anyone is funding the account,[6] and has said the organization is a non-profit. Its application for tax exemption as a 501(c)(4) non-profit was approved in March 2023. Imara Jones speculated that The Heritage Foundation was funding them, noting they have a budget of close to a million dollars and stating it could not have come organically from the community.[12]

Michell's website featured examples of her work for conservative candidates and activists.[6] Michell had previously been on the advisory board to Donald Trump's "Trump Pride coalition", and described Trump as a "pro-gay" politician. Leading up to the 2020 United States presidential election, Michell was involved in the "Stop the Steal" movement, to promote conspiracy theories that the election had been "stolen".[13][14]

Social media platforms

Michell's allegedly has a history of sharing far-right content across multiple platforms. Her personal Twitter account accused people of being "pedos" and "groomers" and echoed conspiracy theories about COVID-19 and the 2020 election. Her Reddit account had repeatedly posted racist and Islamaphobic sentiments and at one point a link to her personal website. Michell stated the account was shared, blamed such posts on her ex, and de-activated the account after White Rose AFA posted screenshots of her comment history.[6] Media Matters for America reported her personal Instagram account branded herself as an outspoken right-wing lesbian and pushed anti-trans rhetoric.[10]

By August of 2022, Twitter had suspended and reinstated the social media account four times.[9] Before Elon Musk's takeover of Twitter, the website's rules prohibited the use of "groomer" as an insult based on gender identity or expression under their hate speech policy. GAG responded by using code terms such as "broomer" and "gr__mer" and changing its screen name to "Gays Against Grewmers". Some hypothesized that someone at Twitter was manually and repeatedly overriding the suspensions.[15][9]

When Elon Musk bought Twitter, GAG reverted to its old name, tweeted "OK GROOMER", and purchased a verified badge. In October 2022, the account directly thanked Musk for helping them further their agenda. Before Musk's purchase, tweets using hate terms averaged at most 84 per hour over a week. After the purchase, users tweeted hate speech 4,778 times from midnight to noon.[16][17][18] A report from the Human Rights Campaign found that the GAG Twitter account had seen an increase of nearly 300% in their use of the slur "groomer" when comparing the two months before and after Musk's purchase.[19]

Venmo, PayPal, and Google have banned the group from raising funds on their platforms due to their policies prohibiting hate speech. As a result, GAG began to use the fundraising platform Donorbox.[20][21]

Activities
Protests and rallies

In September, in response to a California school district's decision to paint Progress Pride murals on all school buildings and the administration office, GAG called for a mass protest at their school board meeting.[22][23]

On September 3, a coalition of far-right groups including GAG, Babies Lives Matter, the Proud Boys, LEXIT, the Palmdale Freedom Coalition, and White Lives Matter planned a QAnon themed "Save the children" rally. The marchers were met by counter-protesters and the confrontation between the groups produced little excitement.[24]

In September, the Miami-Dade School Board decided against declaring October LGBTQ+ History Month. GAG had targeted the school and drove trucks around the city claiming the district teaches "radical gender ideology". Members of the Proud Boys harassed people with hateful rhetoric outside the school board's headquarters.[25]

On December 3, a group of far-right individuals including GAG, Moms for Liberty, and Florida Fathers for Freedom organized and hosted a rally in Fort Lauderdale, Miami. Jordan Toste, the southeast regional leader of GAG, was one of the scheduled speakers. Approximately 20 Proud Boys were also present and showed white power symbols during the protest. The event was promoted by OANN, Breitbart News, and the Goyim Defense League. A counter rally of approximately 50 people was hosted including youth organizers and elected officials, who blamed such rallies on Governor Ron DeSantis' anti-LGBT politics and rhetoric. An organizer of the rally was recorded to have aggressively taunted high school students and attempted to intimidate a student organizer of the protest.[26][8][27][28]

Legislation

On August 19, 2022, Michell told OANN that they are working toward a federal ban on gender-affirming care for minors.[15]

In January 2023, the head of the Arizona chapter of GAG, Robert Wallace, voiced his support for Arizona Senate Bill 1001, which would prohibit teachers and school officials from using students' preferred pronouns if they do not match their gender assigned at birth without written permission from parents. It would also permit school employees to ignore pronoun preferences if it would otherwise violate their "religious and moral convictions".[29] The group was cited by Arizona lawmakers in support of Arizona Senate Bill 1030, which targets drag performances.[30] Similar legislation restricting drag performances has been introduced in at least 11 states as of February 2023.[31]

The same month, Ryan Woods, a drag artist also known as Lady MAGA USA, represented GAG in support of a ban on gender-affirming care for minors in Utah, saying children were being groomed and referring to Chloe Cole, who also spoke in favor of the bill.[32]

Other
Harassment of individuals

In December, GAG also retweeted footage of Rep. Katie Porter which had been doctored to claim she supported pedophilia. Porter had spoken out against how Twitter had been used to falsely label people as pedophiles.[19]

Public disruptions

On October 24, a Wauwatosa school board meeting was infiltrated by Michell, speaking for GAG, and the right-wing group Moms for Liberty, neither of which are based in Wauwatosa. They protested the district's new human growth and development curriculum which had been approved months ago, had a 70% approval rating in the district, and was not on the agenda. Michell and Moms for Liberty accused attendees of being groomers, not actually being gay, and wanting to show explicit pictures to children, at one point bringing a 10-year-old student to tears. Both groups had advertised their plan to attend for days beforehand. Michell implied she planned to attend future board meetings and described the curriculum as "child abuse" and "grooming". Parents spoke out against the inclusion of these outside extremist groups.[4][5]

On November 17, a restaurant in San Luis Obispo received threats over advertising an over-21s drag brunch with the caption "Bring the family!" by mistake. Other establishments in the city had also received threats from the same person over drag events, including those appropriate for all ages. The message had said the sender chatted with one of the founders of GAG and they'd agreed to assist in "advertising" the event.[33]

In November, an unidentified group put up door hangers attacking the St. Charles Public Library and School District 303 for their social-emotional learning program. The hangers said schools and libraries are "eroding parental and constitutional rights by promoting the 'sexualization' and 'gender dysphoria' in children as young as preschool, yet are exempt from the prosecution!" The hangers listed resources for people including GAG and MassResistance, which has been designated by the Southern Poverty Law Center as an anti-LGBTQ hate group.[34]

Reception
Criticism

Alejandra Caraballo, a clinical instructor at Harvard, described GAG as "a conservative funded propaganda account to push the groomer libel".[6] GAG used Caraballo's name as a discount code to sell anti-trans merchandise.[21] Them.us described it as a "Great Value version of the notoriously toxic Libs of TikTok".[35] GAG has been accused of fueling stochastic terrorism, the public condemnation of a group that leads to violent acts against the group.[36]

A spokesperson from GLAAD stated "they are coming from a place of anti-LGBT animus and bigotry" and that they characterize the "LGBTQ+ people as pedophiles falsely and maliciously with the absolutely clear intent of driving fear".[7] The Anti-Defamation League (ADL) described them as "an anti-LGBTQ+ extremist coalition" and stated "while GAG claims that they cannot be anti-gay or anti-lesbian as they themselves identify as gay or lesbian, ADL's definition of anti-LGBTQ+ extremism includes any person who pushes false claims and conspiracy theories about all or parts of the LGBTQ+ community, regardless of how they personally identify".[1]

The Southern Poverty Law Center calls Gays Against Groomers "anti-transgender" and an "extremist group". According to the SPLC, "GAG leadership, including the group's director of chapters Mario "Presents" Estrada, has been tied to the hate group the Proud Boys, members of which have previously rallied with GAG's Florida chapter leadership."[37]

Appearances in conservative and far-right media

In an August 2022 interview with OANN, the group's founder compared gender-affirming care to the experiments on Auschwitz prisoners by the Nazi SS doctor Joseph Mengele. Writing in LGBTQ Nation, Alex Bollinger criticized these comments, noting that the Nazis destroyed Magnus Hirschfeld's Institute of Sexology, which "did pioneering work on understanding LGBTQ identities, including transgender people".[38]

On November 8, Michell blamed the Colorado Springs nightclub shooting – where a gunman killed five people, including two trans people, and injured over a dozen more – on gender-affirming care. Appearing on Tucker Carlson Tonight, Michell called the shooting "expected and predictable", saying that "I don't think [the violence is] gonna stop until we end this evil agenda that is attacking children".[39] Brandon Wolf, a survivor of the Orlando nightclub shooting and press secretary of the LGBTQ+ rights group Equality Florida, wrote "here's Gays Against Groomers founder on Fox with a crystal clear threat: 'The mass murders will continue until you do as you're told'".[36]
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter


The Proud Boys were the most active militant, far-right group involved in anti-LGBTQ events last year, turning up at half of all such protests across the country. Cameron Smith/Nathan Howard/Patrick T. Fallon/Getty Images; Rachel Mendelson/Insider

  • Once a week on average in 2022, Proud Boys joined or led anti-LGBTQ protests held across the US.
  • Most of the group's demonstrating targeted drag performances; many involved violence and armed protesters.
  • Insider's interactive map shows what happened each time they joined anti-LGBTQ+ protests last year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter


Gays who “aren’t like the other gays” have always been an unfortunate faction of the LGBTQ+ community. But in recent years, as transphobia has become an animating force behind the global rise of fascism, it’s become clear that queer respectability politics are more than annoying — they can sometimes become an actual threat to the community.
On Wednesday, the Daily Dot published a report on “Gays Against Groomers,” or GAG. It’s a Twitter account that is basically a Great Value version of the notoriously toxic Libs of TikTok, except it’s run by a lesbian, Jaimee Mitchell. She is apparently a creative designer at a right-wing marketing firm, one who (surprise!) follows open white supremacists and has promoted antisemitic conspiracy theories on her personal account.


According to the Daily Dot, GAG has been around for less than a month, and has racked up tens of thousands of followers on Twitter and Instagram, probably because of inflammatory posts like this tweet claiming that “young boys” were being forced to participate in a “nearly-naked kinkfest.” (Translation: there was a Boy Scout troop marching in a pride parade.) Other tweets claim that pride month activities that cater toward children count as indoctrination, or that explaining to kids what “trans” means is tantamount to propaganda, all in an effort to make people think that teaching children that LGBTQ+ people exist is “grooming.”

It’s worth noting that smearing queer and trans people as inherently pedophilic is pretty much the oldest trick in the book; in fact, some of the earliest organized anti-gay movements also claimed that children needed to be saved from supposedly predatory LGBTQ+ teachers.
GAG’s Twitter claims that the LGBTQ+ community “has been hijacked by radical activists who are now pushing extreme concepts onto society, specifically targeting children in recent years,” according to a mission statement of sorts that it posted on Twitter on Wednesday. It claims that the acceptance of trans people has set the rest of the (cis) LGB community back; namely, GAG claims that the supposed sexualization of children includes “drag queen story hours, drag shows involving children, the transitioning and medicalization of minors, and gender theory being taught in the classroom.”


In an almost hilarious mischaracterization of the history of queer activism, the account writes that in the LGBTQ+ fight for equality, “our goal was to successfully integrate ourselves into society, but now these radicals aim to restructure it entirely in order to accommodate a fringe minority, as well as seek to indoctrinate children into it their ideology.”

Despite being a transparently right-wing account, GAG claims that being against child predation should be a non-partisan issue, and that anyone who questions the motivations of supposed “anti-grooming activists” is inherently suspect. GAG insinuated as much in a tweet from Friday morning, claiming that people who are trying to label them as a “far-right” organization are “just outing themselves as pro-grooming.”
This would certainly be true if anyone here were actually concerned about protecting children. But there’s nothing predatory about drag queen story hours or Boy Scouts marching at Pride; this is just another way for conservatives to claim that children merely being exposed to queer and (especially) trans people is harmful.
While GAG’s attempts to stoke conservative outrage are certainly pathetic, it’s also just another reminder that not all gay people, nor all people who claim to care about children, actually has either of those groups’ best interests in mind.
 

So here's the actual source that you guys rely on for your info! 😹


Gays Against Groomers (GAG)[1] is an American far-right[2] and anti-LGBT[1][2][3][4] organization known for campaigning against gender-affirming care for minors,[2] protesting school curriculum with LGBT themes,[5] and criticizing Drag Queen Story Hour events.[6] A spokesperson for the LGBT advocacy group GLAAD has claimed that the group uses the slur "groomer" along with ambiguous messaging to characterize LGBT people as pedophiles.[7] GAG helped organize a anti-LGBTQ rally in Florida, alongside other far-right and anti-LGBTQ organizations such as Moms for Liberty, which was attended by the Proud Boys.[1][8]

GAG began in June 2022 as a Twitter account created by Jaimee Michell,[6] who had previously been employed by right-wing communications firms Arsenal Media and X Strategies and posted similar content on her personal account. The account is known for posting anti-trans rhetoric and has been compared to Libs of TikTok.[6][1] Michell filed incorporation papers for GAG in September. GAG has been banned from multiple social media and payment platforms for violating rules on hate speech;[9] they have been promoted by right-wing media outlets such as Fox News,[1] One America News Network (OANN),[1] and InfoWars.[4]

History

GAG was founded by Jaimee Michell, at the time a content creator and lead designer at marketing company Arsenal Media, a conservative media organization specializing in creating viral content.[5] GAG's Twitter account was created by Michell on June 6, 2022.[10] The account described itself as a "coalition of gays against the sexualization and indoctrination of children", with the purpose "to protect children from harm being done in our name and by those who have hijacked our community".[6]

In September 2022, Michell filed incorporation papers for GAG.[5] The group also launched a partner coalition called Trans Against Groomers.[11]

Michell has denied that anyone is funding the account,[6] and has said the organization is a non-profit. Its application for tax exemption as a 501(c)(4) non-profit was approved in March 2023. Imara Jones speculated that The Heritage Foundation was funding them, noting they have a budget of close to a million dollars and stating it could not have come organically from the community.[12]

Michell's website featured examples of her work for conservative candidates and activists.[6] Michell had previously been on the advisory board to Donald Trump's "Trump Pride coalition", and described Trump as a "pro-gay" politician. Leading up to the 2020 United States presidential election, Michell was involved in the "Stop the Steal" movement, to promote conspiracy theories that the election had been "stolen".[13][14]

Social media platforms

Michell's allegedly has a history of sharing far-right content across multiple platforms. Her personal Twitter account accused people of being "pedos" and "groomers" and echoed conspiracy theories about COVID-19 and the 2020 election. Her Reddit account had repeatedly posted racist and Islamaphobic sentiments and at one point a link to her personal website. Michell stated the account was shared, blamed such posts on her ex, and de-activated the account after White Rose AFA posted screenshots of her comment history.[6] Media Matters for America reported her personal Instagram account branded herself as an outspoken right-wing lesbian and pushed anti-trans rhetoric.[10]

By August of 2022, Twitter had suspended and reinstated the social media account four times.[9] Before Elon Musk's takeover of Twitter, the website's rules prohibited the use of "groomer" as an insult based on gender identity or expression under their hate speech policy. GAG responded by using code terms such as "broomer" and "gr__mer" and changing its screen name to "Gays Against Grewmers". Some hypothesized that someone at Twitter was manually and repeatedly overriding the suspensions.[15][9]

When Elon Musk bought Twitter, GAG reverted to its old name, tweeted "OK GROOMER", and purchased a verified badge. In October 2022, the account directly thanked Musk for helping them further their agenda. Before Musk's purchase, tweets using hate terms averaged at most 84 per hour over a week. After the purchase, users tweeted hate speech 4,778 times from midnight to noon.[16][17][18] A report from the Human Rights Campaign found that the GAG Twitter account had seen an increase of nearly 300% in their use of the slur "groomer" when comparing the two months before and after Musk's purchase.[19]

Venmo, PayPal, and Google have banned the group from raising funds on their platforms due to their policies prohibiting hate speech. As a result, GAG began to use the fundraising platform Donorbox.[20][21]

Activities
Protests and rallies

In September, in response to a California school district's decision to paint Progress Pride murals on all school buildings and the administration office, GAG called for a mass protest at their school board meeting.[22][23]

On September 3, a coalition of far-right groups including GAG, Babies Lives Matter, the Proud Boys, LEXIT, the Palmdale Freedom Coalition, and White Lives Matter planned a QAnon themed "Save the children" rally. The marchers were met by counter-protesters and the confrontation between the groups produced little excitement.[24]

In September, the Miami-Dade School Board decided against declaring October LGBTQ+ History Month. GAG had targeted the school and drove trucks around the city claiming the district teaches "radical gender ideology". Members of the Proud Boys harassed people with hateful rhetoric outside the school board's headquarters.[25]

On December 3, a group of far-right individuals including GAG, Moms for Liberty, and Florida Fathers for Freedom organized and hosted a rally in Fort Lauderdale, Miami. Jordan Toste, the southeast regional leader of GAG, was one of the scheduled speakers. Approximately 20 Proud Boys were also present and showed white power symbols during the protest. The event was promoted by OANN, Breitbart News, and the Goyim Defense League. A counter rally of approximately 50 people was hosted including youth organizers and elected officials, who blamed such rallies on Governor Ron DeSantis' anti-LGBT politics and rhetoric. An organizer of the rally was recorded to have aggressively taunted high school students and attempted to intimidate a student organizer of the protest.[26][8][27][28]

Legislation

On August 19, 2022, Michell told OANN that they are working toward a federal ban on gender-affirming care for minors.[15]

In January 2023, the head of the Arizona chapter of GAG, Robert Wallace, voiced his support for Arizona Senate Bill 1001, which would prohibit teachers and school officials from using students' preferred pronouns if they do not match their gender assigned at birth without written permission from parents. It would also permit school employees to ignore pronoun preferences if it would otherwise violate their "religious and moral convictions".[29] The group was cited by Arizona lawmakers in support of Arizona Senate Bill 1030, which targets drag performances.[30] Similar legislation restricting drag performances has been introduced in at least 11 states as of February 2023.[31]

The same month, Ryan Woods, a drag artist also known as Lady MAGA USA, represented GAG in support of a ban on gender-affirming care for minors in Utah, saying children were being groomed and referring to Chloe Cole, who also spoke in favor of the bill.[32]

Other
Harassment of individuals

In December, GAG also retweeted footage of Rep. Katie Porter which had been doctored to claim she supported pedophilia. Porter had spoken out against how Twitter had been used to falsely label people as pedophiles.[19]

Public disruptions

On October 24, a Wauwatosa school board meeting was infiltrated by Michell, speaking for GAG, and the right-wing group Moms for Liberty, neither of which are based in Wauwatosa. They protested the district's new human growth and development curriculum which had been approved months ago, had a 70% approval rating in the district, and was not on the agenda. Michell and Moms for Liberty accused attendees of being groomers, not actually being gay, and wanting to show explicit pictures to children, at one point bringing a 10-year-old student to tears. Both groups had advertised their plan to attend for days beforehand. Michell implied she planned to attend future board meetings and described the curriculum as "child abuse" and "grooming". Parents spoke out against the inclusion of these outside extremist groups.[4][5]

On November 17, a restaurant in San Luis Obispo received threats over advertising an over-21s drag brunch with the caption "Bring the family!" by mistake. Other establishments in the city had also received threats from the same person over drag events, including those appropriate for all ages. The message had said the sender chatted with one of the founders of GAG and they'd agreed to assist in "advertising" the event.[33]

In November, an unidentified group put up door hangers attacking the St. Charles Public Library and School District 303 for their social-emotional learning program. The hangers said schools and libraries are "eroding parental and constitutional rights by promoting the 'sexualization' and 'gender dysphoria' in children as young as preschool, yet are exempt from the prosecution!" The hangers listed resources for people including GAG and MassResistance, which has been designated by the Southern Poverty Law Center as an anti-LGBTQ hate group.[34]

Reception
Criticism

Alejandra Caraballo, a clinical instructor at Harvard, described GAG as "a conservative funded propaganda account to push the groomer libel".[6] GAG used Caraballo's name as a discount code to sell anti-trans merchandise.[21] Them.us described it as a "Great Value version of the notoriously toxic Libs of TikTok".[35] GAG has been accused of fueling stochastic terrorism, the public condemnation of a group that leads to violent acts against the group.[36]

A spokesperson from GLAAD stated "they are coming from a place of anti-LGBT animus and bigotry" and that they characterize the "LGBTQ+ people as pedophiles falsely and maliciously with the absolutely clear intent of driving fear".[7] The Anti-Defamation League (ADL) described them as "an anti-LGBTQ+ extremist coalition" and stated "while GAG claims that they cannot be anti-gay or anti-lesbian as they themselves identify as gay or lesbian, ADL's definition of anti-LGBTQ+ extremism includes any person who pushes false claims and conspiracy theories about all or parts of the LGBTQ+ community, regardless of how they personally identify".[1]

The Southern Poverty Law Center calls Gays Against Groomers "anti-transgender" and an "extremist group". According to the SPLC, "GAG leadership, including the group's director of chapters Mario "Presents" Estrada, has been tied to the hate group the Proud Boys, members of which have previously rallied with GAG's Florida chapter leadership."[37]

Appearances in conservative and far-right media

In an August 2022 interview with OANN, the group's founder compared gender-affirming care to the experiments on Auschwitz prisoners by the Nazi SS doctor Joseph Mengele. Writing in LGBTQ Nation, Alex Bollinger criticized these comments, noting that the Nazis destroyed Magnus Hirschfeld's Institute of Sexology, which "did pioneering work on understanding LGBTQ identities, including transgender people".[38]

On November 8, Michell blamed the Colorado Springs nightclub shooting – where a gunman killed five people, including two trans people, and injured over a dozen more – on gender-affirming care. Appearing on Tucker Carlson Tonight, Michell called the shooting "expected and predictable", saying that "I don't think [the violence is] gonna stop until we end this evil agenda that is attacking children".[39] Brandon Wolf, a survivor of the Orlando nightclub shooting and press secretary of the LGBTQ+ rights group Equality Florida, wrote "here's Gays Against Groomers founder on Fox with a crystal clear threat: 'The mass murders will continue until you do as you're told'".[36]
Mandrill is so old he doesnt even know that anyone can edit Wikipedia.

I remember back in the day professors would give you an automatic F if you included any wikipedia material in your term paper 😂
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: The Oracle
Mandrill is so old he doesnt even know that anyone can edit Wikipedia.

I remember back in the day professors would give you an automatic F if you included any wikipedia material in your term paper 😂

Its all the same incel, women hating crowd.
 
Thinking "oh it's a scientific paper so it must be accurate" is foolish COVID Ivermectin level thinking.

Cut your rant.
Really seem to have touched a nerve here.
Sorry you're so sensitive.

But to respond in short, yes, the replication crisis is real and touches all fields of science.
I never said otherwise and I'm not sure why you have wandered off into a tirade on the subject.

It looked like you implied in that rant that you aren't really in favor of LGB rights, you just think trying to pose as such to attack trans people is useful, but that certainly wasn't clear so could you confirm that?

You don't seem to understand that not everything can be compared to placebo, btw.

Tell you what, POST your information so we can ALL see in the open where you develop your opinions and statements from. Thus, we can evaluate, along with the nuances, your statement, "Nordic countries have not stopped puberty blockers". It's NOT that hard.

What do you want here, the formal policy papers on treatment?
Since you apparently seem to think looking things up for yourself is beneath you, I want to know what you will accept before I waste my time on things you will just pretend aren't good enough.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
No. Exposing quackery and fakery is never pathetic.

But it didn't really do that.
Yes, it was obvious to anyone who read the paper that Jimmy Concepts and friends were fakes and were bullshitting about what they found to get the media attention - but they DID get the media attention. There are still people who think they are serious and "exposed the woke social sciences". So yeah, it was pathetic. If they had been ignored and mocked, sure, it might have been useful for them to faceplant like that - but since they actually got a lot of benefits out of it, it was bad that it happened.
 
But to respond in short, yes, the replication crisis is real and touches all fields of science.
I never said otherwise and I'm not sure why you have wandered off into a tirade on the subject.
Because it's obvious you know about it but conveniently chose to ignore it in your post. Playing dumb isn't your style.

How did I ignore it?
When did it come up?

Ah yes, because ignoring your leading question is "aren't really in favour of LGB rights". I'm in favour of anyone and everyone having the same rights. That include marriage for LGB. I'm also in favour of women being able to say NO to men who pretend they are women. Women have fought too hard and too long for their sex-based rights to be over-ridden by men who want access to them. Women's protections, safe-guarding, and other sex-based rights DO take priority over men.
Women’s rights, dignity and safety are not transphobia. Asserting that gay men and lesbians are exclusively same sex attracted is not transphobia. Observing humans can’t change sex is not transphobia. Recognising that all adult males are men is not transphobia.
The manliest thing a transwoman can do is redefine womanhood in his image. Change my mind :D


You do understand that I don't really believe you on this, right?
You may be entirely sincere.
It's possible.

But I only seem to see you talk about LGB rights when you are on your anti-trans rants.
So I remain skeptical.

I will be happy to be wrong about this.

....before I waste my time on things you will just pretend aren't good enough.
It's up to you want you want to do. Getting others to decide your actions for you seems....odd. Another odd viewpoint is believing that criticism is 'not good enough'. Weird that you're uncomfortable defending your position and need my acceptance of your sources.

What a fine-tuned level of projection you have.
My statement is simple and easily looked up and verified.
But you were insistent during your little rant on me having to PROVE IT WITH SOURCES!
Since it would be trivial for you to look this up yourself, I can only assume you intend to reject any sources I provide.
Therefore, rather than waste everyone's time, I am asking you to please say what kind of source you will accept.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: John_Jacob
Status
Not open for further replies.