The "Insanity" Excuse

I don't agree with "put to death" but I gotta admit that letting somebody out who only "won't kill" if he/she manages to stay mentally healthy, seems like a risk not worth taking..

I still think we should be spending more money on trying to cure/treat the mentally ill..

But those who have killed have shown how far their disease could take them if left unchecked.. Maybe they shouldn't be punished like criminals, but I don't think they should be allowed back out into society under ANY circumstances.

there would be lots of extra money for such studies if we stopped coddling people in jail. there would be lots of money left over if we could get rid of that. do we really need to keep people that can't ever function normally alive ?
 
it is a win/win you either put crazy murderers to death or you put sane murderers to death. either way murderers are put to death. use the money elsewhere on people who didn't throw away their chance in life.


I have for many years been of the similar "Viscious Dog" opinion in that anyone who has demonstrated their ability to kill someone is too great a risk to have in society. Even prison society.

But then I began to see the hypocrisy in government itself becoming a murderer.

It is a futile discussion, but well worth really having deep internal thoughts with yourself over. Nobody is ever going to convince anyone to change their mind. It is something that you might do after your own long philosophical consideration, and without emotion.
 
there would be lots of extra money for such studies if we stopped coddling people in jail. there would be lots of money left over if we could get rid of that. do we really need to keep people that can't ever function normally alive ?

Ahhhh. You're not arguing anything other that your desire for revenge against those who murder.. My bad.
 
Ahhhh. You're not arguing anything other that your desire for revenge against those who murder.. My bad.

it's not revenge on those who murder. i feel the same about rapists and kid fuckers as well. it's people that are given a chance in life and the best thing they can do with it is fuck up other peoples lives. once you have shown you are not worth the chance you have been given why should the province/country/gov't spend any money keeping you fed and alive ? it is a waste of funds to keep someone alive in prison for any extended period of time and that money could be used for any other number of things.
 
I have for many years been of the similar "Viscious Dog" opinion in that anyone who has demonstrated their ability to kill someone is too great a risk to have in society. Even prison society.

But then I began to see the hypocrisy in government itself becoming a murderer.

It is a futile discussion, but well worth really having deep internal thoughts with yourself over. Nobody is ever going to convince anyone to change their mind. It is something that you might do after your own long philosophical consideration, and without emotion.
it is more me seeing it as a pathetic waste of money. the gov't is wasting tax dollars that could be put to far better use on people that don't deserve it. they were given a chance and fucked up, why waste more. hospitals could use money, so could fire dept's, after school programs to keep kids out of the violent paths, clean up rough area's. all sort of things to help prevent and improve the country, instead we are using the money to keep people that don't deserve it locked up, fed and warm.
 
Visceral emotions for vengence are not part of our Canadian criminal laws. You might want to cut the balls off a sex offender or beat the shit out of a thug but the laws of our civilized country are diametrically opposed to that.

Perhaps you might be happier in an islamic country where thieves have their hands cut off, where rape victims are buried up to their heads in sand and stones thrown at them until their heads are so smashed that their brains spill out?
Sad to say, but this is the favourite tactic of this poster. Lots of gratiutious comments that are unrelated to the subject. But, he does have his fan club who thinks he walks on water.
 
Sad to say, but this is the favourite tactic of this poster. Lots of gratiutious comments that are unrelated to the subject. But, he does have his fan club who thinks he walks on water.

Schlong cannot walk on water. However on occasion he has been know to take a whiz in his swimming pool.
 
It really isn't so black and white.^
Don't take this personally but criminal defense lawyers love to argue this when their criminal clients are guilty as sin. Let's throw a lot of mud at the wall and maybe some of it will stick. No downside (the client is guilty anyway), but maybe some upside.