The "Insanity" Excuse

just to throw some wood into the fire: alcohol intoxication is a valid defence to many so-called "specific intent" offences (drinking and driving not being one of them). Assault is not a specific intent offence, but assault with intent to resist arrest is.
 
In Montreal, the Luka Magnotta case is underway. He is holding his hand over his mouth as if he does not remember the terrible thing he has done. psychopaths can play the system like a fiddle.
 
If you want us to answer if "too many" people are getting away with "murder" via the insanity defense (not excuse, excuse is a different concept entirely), why don't you tell us how many people are doing that?

What % of cases run an insanity defense?

What % of insanity defenses are successful?

But that might actually take some thought or work...

Qooops! Don't hold your breath.
 
In that case of the dead cop, I cannot understand why he got out of his car when a lunatic was using a snowplow as a battering ram. It seems like a very silly thing to do. Clearly the snow plow guy was not acting normally..to put yourself in that situation makes little sense. Just like that York cop that died when a kid took off with him reaching in for the keys.. WTF>
 
So leave them without a criminal record and spare them jail time. But keep them in a mental health facility for a time equal to the prison sentence they would have served, "just to make sure" they are really cured of the mental health issue that sprung up when they killed, but went away again as soon as they got caught. I'm not in synch with larry, but I know the point he's trying to make, even if his "drunk" analogy is wrong.

In Canada, pleading Insanity is not a good way to get out of jail "free". It was a number of years ago, but someone started going through the cases where people pled insanity. Essentially, they were not being released.

The psychiatrist would look at the patients and say: "Can I guarantee this guy won't do x again?" The answer was no, and no one was getting released.

Things might have changed recently. However, I really doubt that any mental institution would easily release someone that committed murder.

The bigger danger is cutbacks forcing all the mentally ill onto the streets. However, Harper's overcrowded prison system is releasing criminals early too.
 
In Canada, pleading Insanity is not a good way to get out of jail "free".
I think that Vince Li is out on day parole and Dr. Guy Turcotte is also out on the street. Not sure about the guy in B.C. who killed his kids. Is it possible that these are the only ones or are there more wandering around out there?
 
I think that Vince Li is out on day parole and Dr. Guy Turcotte is also out on the street. Not sure about the guy in B.C. who killed his kids. Is it possible that these are the only ones or are there more wandering around out there?

I don't think Vincent Li's situation qualifies as day parole, he was to be accompanied at all times by at least 2 others... CBC link This item is dated May 17, 2012, I couldn't find anything more recent in my very quick google search.
 
I don't think Vincent Li's situation qualifies as day parole, he was to be accompanied at all times by at least 2 others... CBC link This item is dated May 17, 2012, I couldn't find anything more recent in my very quick google search.
May 17, 2012 is almost a year ago. I think the rules have been relaxed since then. BTW: The name of the B.C guy is Allan Schoenborn. Murdered his 3 kids and found not guilty by reason of whatever.
 
May 17, 2012 is almost a year ago. I think the rules have been relaxed since then. BTW: The name of the B.C guy is Allan Schoenborn. Murdered his 3 kids and found not guilty by reason of whatever.

No, they haven't That is still the current status.

Schoenborn is also still in custody.
 
Not really. The drunk/stoned person chooses to get stoned or drunk, and therefore has made an informed decision to accept the consequences of whatever they do. Someone who is mentally ill, on the other hand, doesn't CHOOSE to be mentally ill. It makes all the difference in the world.

What about the mentally ill person who is "perfectly" OK while on his/her medication but choses to stop taking that medication. If that person then goes on to hurt or kill another person should they be deemed to be criminally responsible and subject to a criminal prosecution with whatever jail time or do they have a life long "Not Criminally Responsible" card. I believe they should because they knew the consequences of their decision to stop the medication could result in harm coming to others (or at least they should have known).
 
Not really. The drunk/stoned person chooses to get stoned or drunk, and therefore has made an informed decision to accept the consequences of whatever they do. Someone who is mentally ill, on the other hand, doesn't CHOOSE to be mentally ill. It makes all the difference in the world.

What about the mentally ill person who is "perfectly" OK while on his/her medication but choses to stop taking that medication. If that person then goes on to hurt or kill another person should they be deemed to be criminally responsible and subject to a criminal prosecution with whatever jail time or do they have a life long "Not Criminally Responsible" card. I believe they should because they knew the consequences of their decision to stop the medication could result in harm coming to others (or at least they should have known).

Someone going of their mess should not have an impact on whether or not someone is "Not criminally responsible." It should, and does, have an impact on if/when they are released, and if they are, under what conditions.
 
Pedophilia is classed as a mental disorder. We can only assume that the pedophile's instinctive desire for sexual contact with a child is as strong as the regular guy's desire for sexual contact with an adult woman. In other words -- very strong indeed. And, just as we cannot imagine we could be "cured" of our desire for sexual contact with an adult woman, so, presumably, the pedophile cannot be "cured" of his desire for sexual contact with a child.

Yet we do not allow the accused pedophile to plead, in his defence, that desire for sex with children is in his genes. We do not listen when he says he had no choice in the matter, and he cannot control the instincts and cravings put into his mind by his genes.

But we do allow the accused murderer to plead that he had/has an uncontrollable urge to commit homicide. We regard being killed by a homicidal maniac the same way we regard being killed by a gorilla. We don't blame the gorilla. When it comes to murder, we are quite happy to go with "I am not responsible - my mental disorder made me do it."

We bar pedophiles from invoking that defence -- yet psychiatry defines pedophilia as a mental disorder.

We say to the murderer - we understand - your genes made you do it - it's not your fault. We say to the pedophile - it's your own fault you have these cravings - you should have learned how to curb your desires - you must keep your cravings in check - you cannot escape responsibility and blame.

IMO, if we cannot accept mental disorder as excusing pedophilia, then we should not accept mental disorder as excusing murder. Murder is a worse crime than pedophilia. We bar the mental-disorder defence for molesting children -- let's bar the mental-disorder defence for murder.
 
We bar pedophiles from invoking that defence.
No, we don't. There have been cases where a pedophile has been found unfit to stand trial and/or not criminally responsible. Not only that, but you are trying to compare apples and oranges here. Having a disorder that compels you to want to do something wrong/illegal is NOT the same thing as having a disorder that renders you incapable of understanding what you are doing.
 
In Montreal, the Luka Magnotta case is underway. He is holding his hand over his mouth as if he does not remember the terrible thing he has done. psychopaths can play the system like a fiddle.

won't be too hard to prove him guilty... with all his coverups, running from authorities, elaborate plans to deceive.. that can't be possible with the mentally aloof
 
.. we regard being killed by a gorilla. We don't blame the gorilla. ...
i've heard several times that wild animals get "put down" after they attack humans. so while we may not blame them, we don't let them off the hook. i think you were stretching a bit in the post. legally, we could do anything. the law says drunks are responsible even tho it's obvious to anyone that they are not. in terrible heinous crimes, the average citizen wants the perp punished. severely. even if he was completely mentally-not-there. so far, the law doesn't say that. it could. we have enough small-town type politicians to pass anything if re-election depends on it.
 
Pedophilia is classed as a mental disorder. We can only assume that the pedophile's instinctive desire for sexual contact with a child is as strong as the regular guy's desire for sexual contact with an adult woman. In other words -- very strong indeed. And, just as we cannot imagine we could be "cured" of our desire for sexual contact with an adult woman, so, presumably, the pedophile cannot be "cured" of his desire for sexual contact with a child.


A good argument on the surface but it fails in the first paragraph.

Must the drive for heterosexual, homosexual or pedophilic sex lead to non-consesnual sex? Is an underlying sex drive ever a defence to non consensual sex?


A pedophile may indeed have strong sexual desires but he must keep them under control and prevent himself from acting upon them just as a horny heterosexual /homosexual has to.

Unless the underlying mental problem is specifically one that causes the offender to not be able to understand that what he is about to do is wrong and illegal, then it is irrelevant to the defence.


Here is a good wikipedia entry into this specific mental illness defence. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mental_disorder_defence

From that entry:

"The defence of mental disorder is codified in section 16 of the Criminal Code of Canada which states, in part:

16. (1) No person is criminally responsible for an act committed or an omission made while suffering from a mental disorder that rendered the person incapable of appreciating the nature and quality of the act or omission or of knowing that it was wrong.


To establish a claim of mental disorder the party raising the issue must show on a balance of probabilities first that the person who committed the act was suffering from a "disease of the mind", and second, that at the time of the offence they were either

1) unable to appreciate the "nature and quality" of the act, or

2) did not know it was "wrong".


The meaning of the word "wrong" was determined in the Supreme Court case of R. v. Chaulk [1990] 3 S.C.R. which held that "wrong" was NOT restricted to "legally wrong" but to "morally wrong" as well.
 

16. (1) No person is criminally responsible for an act committed or an omission made while suffering from a mental disorder that rendered the person incapable of appreciating the nature and quality of the act or omission or of knowing that it was wrong.
With the recent successes of Vince Li, Dr. Guy Turcotte, Allan Schoenborn and Richard Kashkar and maybe others, can we expect more "insanity" defenses? If the Newtown shooter was still alive, he could probably argue insanity as did James Holmes.

P.S. All 6 of the culprits named in my post are males, is this a typical pattern? Do insane males commit more murders than insane females? Or, are there fewer insane females than males:confused:?
 
With the recent successes of Vince Li, Dr. Guy Turcotte, Allan Schoenborn and Richard Kashkar and maybe others, can we expect more "insanity" defenses? If the Newtown shooter was still alive, he could probably argue insanity as did James Holmes.


And what is your point?

That mentally incompetent people should be held criminally responsible for actions they do not have control over? They are most likely to spend their lives deprived of their liberty anyways. does your sense of vengence require they be put in prison rather than a secure psychiatric facility (locked down looney bin)?

There is a good reason that people SMARTER than you make and interpret these laws.
 
That mentally incompetent people should be held criminally responsible for actions they do not have control over?
Are they really mentally incompetent and have no control over their actions? They were competent enough to kill people.

There is a good reason that people SMARTER than you make and interpret these laws.
Sure, tell that to the mothers of the children killed by Li, Schoenborn and Turcotte and the wife of the husband killed by Kachkar. BTW: Li and Turcotte are not "locked away".