The "Insanity" Excuse

While I would be proud to be RLD's partner in crime, I haven't posted today.
Not you, the other guy. They make up the tag team. Anyways, let's not get distracted again.
Looks like the government is listening to the people and Bill C-54 is supposed to address some or all of the concerns about overusing the "insanity" defense (50% increase in the 10 years ending 2004). I also find the Sun poll interesting in that only 3% out of almost 1,600 people support releasing Dr. Turcotte.
 
Lock em up in the looney bin, or lock them up in jail. I don't really care.

But they should be locked up for life in either.

No, "oh, you're better now (3 years later), you're free to go"
 
Not as headline making as the Vincent Li or the Dr. Turcotte cases but a husband and wife were found murdered in their Toronto home yesterday. The allege killer is their son. What kind of son murders his own parents? Maybe he will also use the "insanity" defense?
 
Not as headline making as the Vincent Li or the Dr. Turcotte cases but a husband and wife were found murdered in their Toronto home yesterday. The allege killer is their son. What kind of son murders his own parents? Maybe he will also use the "insanity" defense?


Go on, tell us oh wise one. You seem to have enough information already so perhaps save us taxpayers the money and pronounce the verdict and propose and pass new laws to correct whatever the outcome is.
 
It appears in the James Holmes case that the state will seek the death penalty. Let's see if he will be successful in his "insanity" defense.
 
I've never understood why "insanity" is a legal defense. One could argue that every murderer is not right in the head.
 
if some one needs to be locked up for life you should just put them to death and spend the money on something useful.
 
I've never understood why "insanity" is a legal defense. One could argue that every murderer is not right in the head.
There might have been a good reason way back when but now it seems that everybody and his brother are using the "insane" defense as a "Hail Mary" (for those who watch football). James Holmes is using the "Hail Mary" in a disparate attempt to save his miserable life.

I wouldn't be surprised if that 26 year old man in Scarborough who killed his parents were to also argue "insanity". One of the tenants in that house said he is "weird", doesn't work and stays in his room all day.
 
I've never understood why "insanity" is a legal defense. One could argue that every murderer is not right in the head.
Needless to say true. The heart of the matter is do you recognize that killing people without a lawful excuse is wrong. Almost all people, even the not right in the head people so recognize.
 
this is an area where Canada is doing better than the U.S. where far to many people are "cured" in a relatively short period of time.
Canada is doing fantastic. Dr. Turcotte who murdered his two kids was "cured" within 18 months of entering the Pinel Institute in Montreal. Hey, maybe he was never mentally ill in the first place.
 
Canada is doing fantastic. Dr. Turcotte who murdered his two kids was "cured" within 18 months of entering the Pinel Institute in Montreal. Hey, maybe he was never mentally ill in the first place.


Rocky, in the face of so much considered, intelligent analysis you remain steadfastly and simple mindedly ignorant.

It has to be either so blissful to live in your cocoon of ignorance, or frustratingly lonely when people just give up on you.
 
, in the face of so much considered, intelligent analysis you remain steadfastly and simple mindedly ignorant.
Based on a survey of the posts in this thread, 658 people agree that too many people are abusing the "insanity" defense and 2 people disagree (RLD and Schlong). The people have spoken. Also, the federal government is moving ahead to implement legislation (Bill C-54) to tighten the rules the release of "insane" criminals.
 
Based on a survey of the posts in this thread, 658 people agree that too many people are abusing the "insanity" defense and 2 people disagree (RLD and Schlong). The people have spoken. Also, the federal government is moving ahead to implement legislation (Bill C-54) to tighten the rules the release of "insane" criminals.


Visceral emotions for vengence are not part of our Canadian criminal laws. You might want to cut the balls off a sex offender or beat the shit out of a thug but the laws of our civilized country are diametrically opposed to that.

Perhaps you might be happier in an islamic country where thieves have their hands cut off, where rape victims are buried up to their heads in sand and stones thrown at them until their heads are so smashed that their brains spill out? Or in the United States where johns, petty criminals and marijuana users are often imprisoned for decades. Funny thing is that the US, Arab and third world prisons are overflowing and their crime rates are higher than Canada's.
 
It really isn't so black and white.^


It is to Rockslinger.

You need only refer to his first post in any thread to know what is "right". His opinion never changes. Ever. Not in light of any new information, not inl light of any photograph, not in light of another opinion from anyone that may be more informed or seasoned in the matter. In fact, he proudly ignores such information.

Dictionary definition of ignorant.
 
if someone is insane enough to kill then they should be put to death. i bet you see a lot of people stop taking that defense.
 
if someone is insane enough to kill then they should be put to death. i bet you see a lot of people stop taking that defense.

I don't agree with "put to death" but I gotta admit that letting somebody out who only "won't kill" if he/she manages to stay mentally healthy, seems like a risk not worth taking..

I still think we should be spending more money on trying to cure/treat the mentally ill..

But those who have killed have shown how far their disease could take them if left unchecked.. Maybe they shouldn't be punished like criminals, but I don't think they should be allowed back out into society under ANY circumstances.
 
Do you see the hypocrisy in that?

it is a win/win you either put crazy murderers to death or you put sane murderers to death. either way murderers are put to death. use the money elsewhere on people who didn't throw away their chance in life.