The "Insanity" Excuse

Are they really mentally incompetent and have no control over their actions? They were competent enough to kill people.


I am competent enough to bang my fingers on a keyboard but that doesn't mean my words aren't crazy.

The serious answer is a resounding YES. Just because someone can drive a truck doesn't mean he was sane. Look at this case in particular.

1. Many people said he was acting weird in the past year.

2. Prior to his rampage he sought help as he was worried that he may have lost his ability to control his actions and would do something bad.

3. He ran out in the freezing cold, onto icy snow covered ground from a homeless shelter at 4:00 am!!! Does this sound like a person in a mid that can even look out for his OWN interests?

4. He THEN encountered the idling snowplow and impulsively hopped in and drove off. He was driving recklessly and when bouncing off many otehr people and things was heard to yell imcoherently at them. He never went back to kill anyone, not even the cops that were chasing him. Does this sound like anyone who has any sense of reality?

5. There was no evidence whatsoever that he had any motive to kill a cop, nor kill anyone. So absent a motive, what drove him to act so recklessly?



Sure, tell that to the mothers of the children killed by Li, Schoenborn and Turcotte and the wife of the husband killed by Kachkar. BTW: Li and Turcotte are not "locked away".


And that is why society takes away the justice process from the victims.
 
"The defence of mental disorder is codified in section 16 of the Criminal Code of Canada which states, in part:

16. (1) No person is criminally responsible for an act committed or an omission made while suffering from a mental disorder that rendered the person incapable of appreciating the nature and quality of the act or omission or of knowing that it was wrong.


To establish a claim of mental disorder the party raising the issue must show on a balance of probabilities first that the person who committed the act was suffering from a "disease of the mind", and second, that at the time of the offence they were either

1) unable to appreciate the "nature and quality" of the act, or

2) did not know it was "wrong".


The meaning of the word "wrong" was determined in the Supreme Court case of R. v. Chaulk [1990] 3 S.C.R. which held that "wrong" was NOT restricted to "legally wrong" but to "morally wrong" as well.[/I]
Which is a pretty standard M'Naghten rule. Given which I fail to understand how the jury found that Mr. Kachkar did not know that it was morally wrong to run down Sergeant Russel or that he was unable to appreciate that running someone over with a snowplow was both wrong and would kill them.
 
Addiction is also a disease like mental health.

While addiction is a disease in the medical sense, it is not grounds for a finding of not guilty in the legal sense.

As usual Mr. RS chooses not to understand the topics he discusses.
 
Are they really mentally incompetent and have no control over their actions? They were competent enough to kill people.

Sure, tell that to the mothers of the children killed by Li, Schoenborn and Turcotte and the wife of the husband killed by Kachkar. BTW: Li and Turcotte are not "locked away".

I note that you still simply cherry pick cases and are too lazy to come up with a single statistic.

i also should point out at this time that you don't suggest any alternative to the current system to solve this mythical problem you have identified, or even come close to discussing the issues at the core of this law.
 
While addiction is a disease in the medical sense, it is not grounds for a finding of not guilty in the legal sense.
Why not? Are some diseases more equal than others under our laws? Are we not all equal under the law?
 
Pedophilia is classed as a mental disorder. We can only assume that the pedophile's instinctive desire for sexual contact with a child is as strong as the regular guy's desire for sexual contact with an adult woman. In other words -- very strong indeed. And, just as we cannot imagine we could be "cured" of our desire for sexual contact with an adult woman, so, presumably, the pedophile cannot be "cured" of his desire for sexual contact with a child.

Yet we do not allow the accused pedophile to plead, in his defence, that desire for sex with children is in his genes. We do not listen when he says he had no choice in the matter, and he cannot control the instincts and cravings put into his mind by his genes.

But we do allow the accused murderer to plead that he had/has an uncontrollable urge to commit homicide. We regard being killed by a homicidal maniac the same way we regard being killed by a gorilla. We don't blame the gorilla. When it comes to murder, we are quite happy to go with "I am not responsible - my mental disorder made me do it."

We bar pedophiles from invoking that defence -- yet psychiatry defines pedophilia as a mental disorder.

We say to the murderer - we understand - your genes made you do it - it's not your fault. We say to the pedophile - it's your own fault you have these cravings - you should have learned how to curb your desires - you must keep your cravings in check - you cannot escape responsibility and blame.

IMO, if we cannot accept mental disorder as excusing pedophilia, then we should not accept mental disorder as excusing murder. Murder is a worse crime than pedophilia. We bar the mental-disorder defence for molesting children -- let's bar the mental-disorder defence for murder.

You clearly do not understand how this defense works.

And no where does the law suggest that "genes" have anything to do with this defense.

It would be perfectly possible for someone accused of pedophilia to raise this defense. There is no such bar.
 
I note that you still simply cherry pick cases and are too lazy to come up with a single statistic.
If you look at my original post, it was a QUESTION and not a statement. Anyway, I'll put you down as "too many people are not getting away with murder by using the mental disorder" defense. BTW: I vaguely recall a defense lawyer saying that the "mental disorder" defense is Plan B because they know that Plan A (a straight defense) will fail.
 
If you look at my original post, it was a QUESTION and not a statement. Anyway, I'll put you down as "too many people are not getting away with murder by using the mental disorder" defense. BTW: I vaguely recall a defense lawyer saying that the "mental disorder" defense is Plan B because they know that Plan A (a straight defense) will fail.

Sure, you want other people to do the work for you, and when you don't like where it is going, you cherry pick some cases.

I doubt you heard such things from a defense lawyer. Seems about as accurate as your bizarre posts on non-existent TV shows about health issues.

Put me down wherever you like. But if you want people to think you are more than a deluded joke there is a value in learning the basics of what you are talking about. Unless you need someone to change your diapers as well.
 
Thank you for proving you have not bothered to understand even the basics of this defense.
Isn't that why we ask questions? If we knew all the answers then why bother having a discussion on any subject? There are no stupid questions, only stupid answers.

We ask questions so "experts" like you can stand on your soapbox and teach/lecture the unwashed masses.
 
Isn't that why we ask questions? If we knew all the answers then why bother having a discussion on any subject? There are no stupid questions, only stupid answers.

We ask questions so "experts" like you can stand on your soapbox and teach/lecture the unwashed masses.

Your uninformed and misleading comments show you have not even bothered to read the code section you want to talk about.

And your history of bizarre and inaccurate posting doesn't help you at all.

There are actually people who are interested in learning things. They don't go out of their way to post false and misleading statements.

Does it help your ego to make things up? Is it against your worldview to learn something about a topic you are interested in without needing to be spoonfed?
 
There are actually people who are interested in learning things. They don't go out of their way to post false and misleading statements.
What false statements are you talking about? Li, Kachkar, Schoenborn and Turcotte were all found not criminally responsible.
 
Isn't that why we ask questions? If we knew all the answers then why bother having a discussion on any subject? There are no stupid questions, only stupid answers.

We ask questions so "experts" like you can stand on your soapbox and teach/lecture the unwashed masses.


You don't ask questions to have discussions nor learn. You frame your simpleton expressions of your strong opinions as "questions". And then you proceed to defend your original flawed opinion even in the glaring SPOTLIGHT of the correct information being shoved under your nose.

rld is a lawyer. He KNOWS THE LAW BETTER THAN YOU! And he (as many others who have more than a passing knowledge of such things) laughs at your idiocy. Not for not knowing. That is excusable. But we laugh at you for slamming your face in your own stupidity when you are given correct information.

It's like a prideful ESL person INSISTING that the word "banana" means telephone even after a hundred native english speakers tell and show him otherwise.

banana.gif
 
Do you think there too many people are getting away with murder by using the "insanity" excuse? If someone cuts off your head or the head of a loved one, do you really care if the killer is "insane", drunk, was abused as a child, declined BBBJ by his wife, etc., etc.? Shouldn't we all be held accountable for our actions:confused:?

BTW: The U.S. has the death penalty as a negotiating tool:thumb:. Apparently, the mass murderer James Holmes is sane enough to plea bargain guilty in exchange for the authorities taking the death penalty off the table.

Insanity is a defense, not an excuse.

It is abused but it's still valid. It's how the system works, going down to the core reasoning behind the system.
 
Insanity is a defense, not an excuse.
It is abused but it's still valid.
I think most rationale Canadians will agree that the current law is being abused. It was public outrage over the Vincent Li and Dr. Guy Turcotte cases that spurred the federal government to table Bill C-54 (The Not Criminally Responsible Reform Act).
According to Rob Nicholson, there was a 50% increase in the number of cases from 1994 to 2004 where the accused was found not criminally responsible and unfit to stand trial.
 
I think most rationale Canadians will agree that the current law is being abused. It was public outrage over the Vincent Li and Dr. Guy Turcotte cases that spurred the federal government to table Bill C-54 (The Not Criminally Responsible Reform Act).
According to Rob Nicholson, there was a 50% increase in the number of cases from 1994 to 2004 where the accused was found not criminally responsible and unfit to stand trial.

I think the case of Guy Turcotte is being appealed.

http://www.torontosun.com/2013/03/1...nto-case-of-quebec-doctor-who-killed-his-kids
 
I think the case of Guy Turcotte is being appealed.
Thanks Ceiling Cat, I notice that the paper also had a poll and roughly 1,600 people voted and 95% voted no release for Dr. Turcotte.
P.S. Now that RLD and his partner in crime have left the room, we are back to having a reasoned and rational discussion on the subject.