Support For One State Solution Grows

Can you confirm the report you cite says clearly at the beginning that it cannot make any legal finding?

Only the Turkel report had that power. None of the others did.

Are you saying the Turkel report should therefore be considered the most important?
 
Only the Turkel report had that power. None of the others did.

Are you saying the Turkel report should therefore be considered the most important?

So, lickspittle, which report were you citing then in post #218?
 
That is the report from the UN Secretary General, the highest authority outside of Israel to have looked into the matter so far.

Would you like a quote from Turkel as well?
 
Only the Turkel report had that power. None of the others did.

Are you saying the Turkel report should therefore be considered the most important?


From the Palmer report:
It needs to be understood from the outset that this Panel is unique. Its methods of inquiry are similarly unique. The Panel is not a court. It was not asked to make determinations of the legal issues or to adjudicate on liability.

and
The Panel will not add value for the United Nations by attempting to determine contested facts or by arguing endlessly about the applicable law. Too much legal analysis threatens to produce political paralysis.


And they certainly aren't guilty of 'too much legal analysis'.
 
Do you understand the difference between a legal determination and a legal opinion?

They gave a legal opinion that the blockade is legal--the highest authority to have given such an opinion. No-one has made any legal determinations, only a court or perhaps the UN SC could do that, and none have.

Turkel has come closest to making a legal determination, as he was actually empowered under the sovereign authority of the State of Israel to do so.
 
That is the report from the UN Secretary General, the highest authority outside of Israel to have looked into the matter so far.

Would you like a quote from Turkel as well?

So, why were you using the UN SG Report to prove a legal argument when you admitted in the next post that the report states that it cannot make any legal determination, lickspittle.

Looks like we've caught you again.
 
Because their legal opinion, which they have indeed given, carries more weight than yours. And their legal opinion was that the blockade is legal.

I suspect that you are just too stupid to know the difference between "opinion" (from a report) and "determination" (from a court making a ruling).

No court has ruled on the legality of the blockade, in part because Turkey ran away from filing the case the ICJ as fast as they could. (Israel might have accepted voluntary jurisdiction just to get a clear decision on what would obviously be an open and shut case in Israel's favour.)

Turkel however did have some legal ooomph as he was empowered by the sovereign State of Israel and had many of the powers of a court. He also concluded it was legal--would you prefer to call that one a determination?
 
Do you understand the difference between a legal determination and a legal opinion?

So your only basis of legality comes from the opinion of a probable war criminal?

And you ignore these reports:
The UN agencies involved in Thursday’s joint statement are the office of the Humanitarian Coordination/Resident Coordinator for the occupied Palestinian territory, the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR), the UN Children’s Fund (UNICEF), the UN Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO), the UN Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA), the UN Entity for Gender Equality and the Empowerment of Women (UN Women), and the World Health Organization (WHO).

Not to mention a host of other organizations and NGO's.
Your only defense is the word of a probable war criminal?
 
Here's the fact, whether you like it or not, the highest UN authority to look into the legality of the naval blockade gave an opinion that it was legal. That is the highest, best opinion we have.

I note that in the quote you use, they are clearly referring to the border policy rather than the blockade, although they used the word "blockade", it appears not to mean "naval blockade" in that context, but rather the policy of restricting what goods are allowed through the land crossings.

Note that the border closure can (and probably at some point will) be lifted without lifting the naval blockade. Presumably then Israel would continue a regime of inspecting all shipments into Gaza for weapons, but without other restriction. Such an inspection regime would still require the naval blockade to have all shipments enter through Ashdod for delivery over the land crossings.

Nobody in their right mind would argue for unrestricted shipping of Iranian missiles to Hamas.
 
I'm pretty sure that in this thread grog was accusing Israel of targeting journalists.



Museum to ‘reevaluate’ honors to Hamas cameramen

‘Questions have been raised’ over whether Gaza duo ‘were truly journalists or were engaged in terrorist activities,’ says Newseum spokesman


NEW YORK — A Washington journalism museum will “reevaluate” its decision to honor two Hamas-affiliated cameramen killed in an Israeli airstrike in November 2012 as journalists who died in the line of duty.

“Serious questions have been raised as to whether two of the individuals included on our initial list of journalists who died covering the news this past year were truly journalists or whether they were engaged in terrorist activities,” Newseum spokesman Jonathan Thompson said in a statement sent to The Times of Israel on Monday.

...

But criticism has come from many quarters arguing that the two men, who worked for the Hamas-funded Al-Aqsa TV, were part of the organization’s propaganda arm and were engaged in incitement to terrorism.

“We take the concerns raised about these two men seriously and have decided to reevaluate their inclusion as journalists on our memorial wall pending further investigation,” Thompson wrote. “Terrorism has altered the landscape in many areas, including the rules of war and engagement, law, investigative and interrogation techniques, and the detention of enemy combatants. Journalism is no exception.”

http://www.timesofisrael.com/museum-to-reevaluate-honors-to-hamas-cameramen/
 
Because their legal opinion, which they have indeed given, carries more weight than yours. And their legal opinion was that the blockade is legal.

I suspect that you are just too stupid to know the difference between "opinion" (from a report) and "determination" (from a court making a ruling).

No court has ruled on the legality of the blockade, in part because Turkey ran away from filing the case the ICJ as fast as they could. (Israel might have accepted voluntary jurisdiction just to get a clear decision on what would obviously be an open and shut case in Israel's favour.)

Turkel however did have some legal ooomph as he was empowered by the sovereign State of Israel and had many of the powers of a court. He also concluded it was legal--would you prefer to call that one a determination?

You tried to pawn off the report to the UN SG as a report containing a legal opinion but it does not even do that. It gives opinions but none of them are legal opinions. It was just a comparison of two reports by a pair of politicians that have no expertise in international law. They interviewed no one. They carried out no investigation. They took both national reports at face value. No cross examination. Nothing.

No wonder it provides no legal opinion.
 
I'm still waiting for the Turks or the Palestinians to take this to the ICJ or ICC as they promised years ago.
 
I'm still waiting for the Turks or the Palestinians to take this to the ICJ or ICC as they promised years ago.

Since Israel is capitulating and paying compensation for murdering the humanitarian volunteers that likely will not be needed. Israel was very afraid of being brought to justice.
 
Since Israel is capitulating and paying compensation for murdering the humanitarian volunteers that likely will not be needed. Israel was very afraid of being brought to justice.

Oh look, the Palestinian Information Minister. Just as funny as the Iraqi one.

(Pssst, blockade's still there)
 
Oh look, the Palestinian Information Minister. Just as funny as the Iraqi one.

(Pssst, blockade's still there)

Conceding the point?

The report from the UN, stating that the blockade is illegal, is still there as well.
 
The report Israel and Turkey refused to sign?
How do you even try to submit a report that the participants won't sign off on?

This is just nonsense propaganda. Nobody "signed off on" any of the reports, certainly NO ONE signed off on the UNHCR report either. Israel refused to even participate in that one!

However, the UNSG report panel, mandate, and process did get signed off by both Israel and Turkey, which is more signoff than any other report got.
 
This is just nonsense propaganda.

Sure, that's why diplomatic relations were suspended between Israel and Turkey after the report came out, and this is Turkey's statement from the report:
On the legal aspect of the blockade, Turkey and Israel have submitted two opposing arguments. International legal authorities are divided on the matter since it is unprecedented, highly complex and the legal framework lacks codification. However, the Chairmanship and its report fully associated itself with Israel and categorically dismissed the views of the other, despite the fact that the legal arguments presented by Turkey have been supported by the vast majority of the international community. Common sense and conscience dictate that the blockade is unlawful.

How surprising is it that the probable war criminal, arms client of Israel, picked a side and screwed up the report?
In recent years, according to news reports, Israel has become Colombia’s number one weapon supplier, with arms worth tens of millions of dollars, “including Kfir aircraft, drones, weapons and intelligence systems” being used against opponents of the Colombian regime (“Report: Israelis fighting guerillas in Colombia,” Ynet, 10 August 2007). According to a senior Israeli defense official, “Israel’s methods of fighting terror have been duplicated in Colombia” (“Colombia’s FM: We share your resilience,” 30 April 2010).

There is a reason that Latin Americans often refer to Colombia as the “Israel of Latin America,” and indeed why Colombian President-elect Juan Manuel Santos, ex-Minister of Defence and right hand of Uribe, expressed his pride at such a comparison (“Santos, orgulloso de que a Colombia lo comparen con Israel,” El Espectador, 6 June 2010).
 
Turkey only objected after they lost, but they were on board with the process.

You will note that the UNHCR process was so fundamentally flawed that Israel refused to even participate.

Certainly the UNSG report was the most bipartisan and the only one that all sides had supported.

The Turks lost and walked out after they lost but that is pretty transparent.