Support For One State Solution Grows

Turkey only objected after they lost, but they were on board with the process.

.

True, they didn't know how much the PA was going to screw up the report, as they did with the Goldstone report.
They also didn't expect Palmer to go to bed with probable war criminal Uribe, either.

Certainly the UN HRC report was the only one that had unbiased authors with legal crediblity.
 
True, they didn't know how much the PA was going to screw up the report, as they did with the Goldstone report.
They also didn't expect Palmer to go to bed with probable war criminal Uribe, either.

Certainly the UN HRC report was the only one that had unbiased authors with legal crediblity.

Did Israel have a chance to look into the UNHRC authors and verify that? If not they are under a black cloud of suspicion.
 
Again, the UNHRC is not a court, the panel were not judges, it was rendering an opinion. Without buy-in from both Israel and Turkey that opinion is just worthless.

Especially when you consider the history of UNHRC as being an agency essentially at war with Israel, as a proxy of the Arab League.
 
We'll discuss the ICC when they actually do something, and there's something to discuss. I'm sure whichever way it goes there will be a big thread -- right now there's really nothing to discuss there. We don't know if the ICC will even take up the case, and we don't know whether Israel will agree to participate in the process if they do, nor do we know what conclusion they will reach -- so that's all just speculative right now.

The point that was being made above is that a non-binding opinion from UNHRC is worth absolutely nothing considering it failed to engage with all the major stakeholders, and thus essentially is just a statement of one partisan view of the conflict, rather than an unbiased non-partisan analysis.
 
The point that was being made above is that a non-binding opinion from UNHRC is worth absolutely nothing considering it failed to engage with all the major stakeholders, and thus essentially is just a statement of one partisan view of the conflict, rather than an unbiased non-partisan analysis.

Again, the UN HRC is the only report to have used non-biased and legally qualified authors who could even have respectable opinions.
 
Again, the UN HRC is the only report to have used non-biased and legally qualified authors who could even have respectable opinions.

Sorry cannot claim they are unbiased. The enemies of Israel went shopping for "judges" most likely to return an anti Israeli result. They then proved their bias by carrying on without Israeli input

In fact, anyone agreeing to work with UNHRC is inherently biased as unbiased people would refuse to deal with such a partisan organization.
 
Sorry cannot claim they are unbiased. The enemies of Israel went shopping for "judges" most likely to return an anti Israeli result. They then proved their bias by carrying on without Israeli input

In fact, anyone agreeing to work with UNHRC is inherently biased as unbiased people would refuse to deal with such a partisan organization.

You say that but have never found even the slightest criticism of the people they chose.
Your argument rings hollow.
 
Given how hostile UNHRC is though it is a safe bet they met with the authors on advance to confirm their anti Israeli sentiments before appointing them.
 
Given how hostile UNHRC is though it is a safe bet they met with the authors on advance to confirm their anti Israeli sentiments before appointing them.

Now you're just peddling conspiracy theories.
If you have a concrete criticism, lets hear it.
 
Now you're just peddling conspiracy theories.
If you have a concrete criticism, lets hear it.

The organizing that appointed Richard Falk cannot be trusted to make unbiased appointments. The panel needed to be properly vetted by all sides. The UNHRC has systematically excluded Israelfrom any participation and had a history of producing belligerent propaganda that parrots the Arab League.

Who knows what private information went into screening candidates, the UNHRC has kept that process secretive, and no one else was able to review it.
 
The organizing that appointed Richard Falk cannot be trusted to make unbiased appointments. The panel needed to be properly vetted by all sides. The UNHRC has systematically excluded Israelfrom any participation and had a history of producing belligerent propaganda that parrots the Arab League.

Who knows what private information went into screening candidates, the UNHRC has kept that process secretive, and no one else was able to review it.

Again, if you have anything concrete, other then this conspiracy theory, bring it out.
 
Again, if you have anything concrete, other then this conspiracy theory, bring it out.

The UNHRC'a history of persecuting Israel is well documented, in fact evident in the incredibly biased mandate given for the report. The bias is very clear and permeates the whole report.

That is why the UN rebuffed it when the final report was drafted.
 
Again, if you have anything concrete, other then this conspiracy theory, bring it out.

You mean other than the number of condemnations against Israel vs. the number against other countries?

The HRC is a political body, not a rights body. How else do you explain the only motion approved by them about Sudan during the Darfur crisis was to thank Sudan's government for cooperating in their investigation.
 
The UNHRC'a history of persecuting Israel is well documented, in fact evident in the incredibly biased mandate given for the report. The bias is very clear and permeates the whole report.

That is why the UN rebuffed it when the final report was drafted.

Like I said.
If you have anything concrete as criticism of the authors of the UN HRC flotilla report, lets hear it.
Not criticism of the UN HRC, that's not the issue here.
 
Like I said.
If you have anything concrete as criticism of the authors of the UN HRC flotilla report, lets hear it.
Not criticism of the UN HRC, that's not the issue here.

I have given you concrete criticisms. They were cherry picked by countries that are at war with Israel. How about next time we let Israel pick all the authors? I can find some reports like that, bet you will object..

The bias of the report speaks for itself as well. They openly confesdbti being one sided, and although they admit the mandate is biased, they actually didn't change it.

Nothing from UNHRC can be trusted, the organization is essentially at war with Israel.
 
I have given you concrete criticisms. They were cherry picked by countries that are at war with Israel. How about next time we let Israel pick all the authors? I can find some reports like that, bet you will object..

Once again, you have issues with the way they picked the authors, but in fact cannot find a single criticism about the authors that they did pick.
If you have anything concrete as criticism of the authors of the UN HRC flotilla report, lets hear it.