Support For One State Solution Grows

Canadian. Values are a myth. We do what we are told to do by our American overlords. You have no ability to put your self in the shoes of others.

And if you were in the shoes of a people who were faced with continual terrorism from a group that refuses to make peace, how would you deal with it?
 
Canadian. Values are a myth. We do what we are told to do by our American overlords. You have no ability to put your self in the shoes of others.

Actually I make my own choices every single day. Maybe you are a slave. I'm not.

On top of that I'm quite willing to call out what is right and what is wrong, I'm no moral relativist, and certainly I have been deeply critical of the Americans on several topics, as well as supportive on several other topics.

Targeting civilians is wrong, and you are reprehensible for your support of terrorism, war crime, and atrocity.
 
Targeting civilians is wrong, and you are reprehensible for your support of terrorism, war crime, and atrocity.

Yet you constantly justify them.

Bomb on Tel Aviv bus - you said it was okay because the route went near military headquarters
School bus hit by RPG - you said it was okay because the road is sometimes used by IDF patrols
Attack on greyhound like bus - you said it was okay because soldiers on leave use the route
Attack on a school - you said it was okay because they support settlements
Murder of family in their sleep - you said it was okay because they were living in the West Bank
Murder of pregnant woman and her family driving down the road - you said it was okay because they were living in the West Bank
Rock throwers putting a child in intensive care - you said it was okay because they were living in the West Bank
Rocket attacks on pre-67 Israel cities - you said it was okay because they don't kill very often.

I'm sure I missed some.
 
I don't support any of those things, liar.

You support the blockade - collective punishment and a war crime
You support the illegal detaining of children - atrocity
You support state terrorism - a long list here from sonic bangs in the middle of the night to human shields to assassination.
 
Yet you constantly justify them.

Bomb on Tel Aviv bus - you said it was okay because the route went near military headquarters
School bus hit by RPG - you said it was okay because the road is sometimes used by IDF patrols
Attack on greyhound like bus - you said it was okay because soldiers on leave use the route
Attack on a school - you said it was okay because they support settlements
Murder of family in their sleep - you said it was okay because they were living in the West Bank
Murder of pregnant woman and her family driving down the road - you said it was okay because they were living in the West Bank
Rock throwers putting a child in intensive care - you said it was okay because they were living in the West Bank
Rocket attacks on pre-67 Israel cities - you said it was okay because they don't kill very often.

I'm sure I missed some.

Israel's Cabana Boy....why is Israel using their own citizens as human shields to fulfill the biblical fantasy of Eretz Israel in the West Bank?

If only Israel would not break international law regarding the occupation and the transfer of its its citizens not the occupied territory.
 
Yes gryf, we all know you think killing Jews in Israel is okay. Thankfully much of the world disagrees.


p.s. You might notice that the majority of the examples took place withing pre-67 Israel.
 
Yes gryf, we all know you think killing Jews in Israel is okay. Thankfully much of the world disagrees.


p.s. You might notice that the majority of the examples took place withing pre-67 Israel.


Pre-67 Israel? You mean the place where 800,000 Palestinians were ethnically cleansed from and where all their homes exist. The place where all the personal property and homes of those people exist? You think that the ethnic cleanser's should have a safe zone, half wit?
 
Last edited:
You support the blockade - collective punishment and a war crime
You support the illegal detaining of children - atrocity
You support state terrorism - a long list here from sonic bangs in the middle of the night to human shields to assassination.

The blockade is not collective punishment, I do not support the illegal detaining of children, and I do not support state terrorism.

I also most certainly do not support YOUR hate fantasy version of events in most of those examples.

Sorry to have to say this, but you are lying again -- you are attributing to me beliefs I do not have, and claiming I support things that I clearly have said I don't.
 
The blockade is not collective punishment, I do not support the illegal detaining of children, and I do not support state terrorism.

I also most certainly do not support YOUR hate fantasy version of events in most of those examples.

Oh, you mean the 'hate fantasy' that the rest of the world reports and that you pretend isn't reality?
 
I just checked again and the rest of the world, the UN, still considers the blockade legal.

Really?
14 June 2012 – As the Israeli blockade of the Gaza Strip enters its sixth year, several UN agencies today joined a group of international charities in unanimously calling for the lifting of the blockade.

“For over five years in Gaza, more than 1.6 million people have been under blockade in violation of international law. More than half of these people are children. We, the undersigned, say with one voice: ‘end the blockade now,’” the 50 organizations and agencies said in a joint statement.

“The government of Israel is facing mounting international criticism for the Gaza blockade and this unanimous statement from some of the most world’s most respected international organizations is likely to increase pressure for the blockade to be lifted,” they added.

Israel imposed the blockade on Gaza for what it called security reasons after the Hamas group, which does not recognize Israel’s right to exist, ousted the Fatah movement from the Strip in 2007.

The UN agencies involved in Thursday’s joint statement are the office of the Humanitarian Coordination/Resident Coordinator for the occupied Palestinian territory, the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR), the UN Children’s Fund (UNICEF), the UN Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO), the UN Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA), the UN Entity for Gender Equality and the Empowerment of Women (UN Women), and the World Health Organization (WHO).

http://www.un.org/apps/news/story.asp?NewsID=42227#.UZELQJVZX0A

Whoops.
 
I had another look, the report still says the blockade is legal. And yup, the report did take that into its mandate and did make a decision on it.

Is it legally binding? No. And neither are any of the other things you have mentioned -- there is no legally binding declaration one way or another anywhere on whether the blockade is legal. There is no court with jurisdiction to take up the question, and the UN Security Council hasn't either. Although I would note that Turkey ran as fast as it could away from going to the ICJ where it no doubt would have had its ass handed to it in a ruling that the blockade is clearly legal.

Anyway, what we do know is that the highest UN authority to have looked into it has declared it legal.

I also note the wide array of nations that support Israel's blockade, I guess they are all not part of the "rest of the world".
 
I had another look, the report still says the blockade is legal. And yup, the report did take that into its mandate and did make a decision on it.

Is it legally binding? No. And neither are any of the other things you have mentioned -- there is no legally binding declaration one way or another anywhere on whether the blockade is legal. There is no court with jurisdiction to take up the question, and the UN Security Council hasn't either. Although I would note that Turkey ran as fast as it could away from going to the ICJ where it no doubt would have had its ass handed to it in a ruling that the blockade is clearly legal.

Anyway, what we do know is that the highest UN authority to have looked into it has declared it legal.

I also note the wide array of nations that support Israel's blockade, I guess they are all not part of the "rest of the world".

All sputter, no content. Groggy produced content. As usual, you produced nothing, lickspittle.
 
Actually this is the content, Gryfin:

81. The Panel therefore concludes that Israel’s naval blockade was legal. In this
regard, the Panel reaches a different conclusion to that of the Turkish investigation into
the incident. The legal arguments in the Turkish report were also clearly and extensively
put to the Panel by the Turkish Point of Contact,283 and were supported by the Turkish
member of the Panel. Those arguments differed from the conclusions of the Panel on
several key matters of interpretation on the facts, most significantly: whether there can
be considered to be an international armed conflict between Israel and Hamas; whether
the extent and duration of the naval blockade were adequately notified; whether the naval
blockade was a proportionate military measure, and in particular whether it had a
disproportionate impact on civilians in Gaza; and whether it amounted to collective
punishment. On these two latter points, the conclusions reached in the Turkish report
mirror those of the fact-finding mission established by the Human Rights Council.284 The
Panel notes, however, that the reasoning of both reports rested on an analysis that the
naval blockade formed an indivisible part of Israel’s land restrictions policy, a factual
conclusion that the Panel does not share for the reasons described above. In addition, the
Panel notes that the Human Rights Council fact-finding mission did not receive any
information from Israel and did not have the opportunity to consider the Israeli report or
the additional material that has been made available to the Panel. In reaching its
conclusion, the Panel emphasizes, however, the fundamental importance of the principle
of the freedom of navigation, particularly in areas such as the eastern Mediterranean, and
recommends that this be borne in mind by Israel with respect to the ongoing application
and enforcement of its naval blockade.

82. The fundamental principle of the freedom of navigation on the high seas is
subject to only certain limited exceptions under international law. Israel faces a real
threat to its security from militant groups in Gaza. The naval blockade was
imposed as a legitimate security measure in order to prevent weapons from entering
Gaza by sea and its implementation complied with the requirements of international
law.
 
I had another look, the report still says the blockade is legal..

Relying on the good work of probable war criminal Uribe again?
Strange how that's the only UN report to think the blockade is legal, despite not being mandated or qualified to make such a distinction.

Better rely on the report that wasn't done by probable war criminals.
Or better yet, just accept the words of the more recent UN statement above:
For over five years in Gaza, more than 1.6 million people have been under blockade in violation of international law.
 
Actually this is the content, Gryfin:

81. The Panel therefore concludes that Israel’s naval blockade was legal. In this
regard, the Panel reaches a different conclusion to that of the Turkish investigation into
the incident. The legal arguments in the Turkish report were also clearly and extensively
put to the Panel by the Turkish Point of Contact,283 and were supported by the Turkish
member of the Panel. Those arguments differed from the conclusions of the Panel on
several key matters of interpretation on the facts, most significantly: whether there can
be considered to be an international armed conflict between Israel and Hamas; whether
the extent and duration of the naval blockade were adequately notified; whether the naval
blockade was a proportionate military measure, and in particular whether it had a
disproportionate impact on civilians in Gaza; and whether it amounted to collective
punishment. On these two latter points, the conclusions reached in the Turkish report
mirror those of the fact-finding mission established by the Human Rights Council.284 The
Panel notes, however, that the reasoning of both reports rested on an analysis that the
naval blockade formed an indivisible part of Israel’s land restrictions policy, a factual
conclusion that the Panel does not share for the reasons described above. In addition, the
Panel notes that the Human Rights Council fact-finding mission did not receive any
information from Israel and did not have the opportunity to consider the Israeli report or
the additional material that has been made available to the Panel. In reaching its
conclusion, the Panel emphasizes, however, the fundamental importance of the principle
of the freedom of navigation, particularly in areas such as the eastern Mediterranean, and
recommends that this be borne in mind by Israel with respect to the ongoing application
and enforcement of its naval blockade.

82. The fundamental principle of the freedom of navigation on the high seas is
subject to only certain limited exceptions under international law. Israel faces a real
threat to its security from militant groups in Gaza. The naval blockade was
imposed as a legitimate security measure in order to prevent weapons from entering
Gaza by sea and its implementation complied with the requirements of international
law.

Can you confirm the report you cite says clearly at the beginning that it cannot make any legal finding, lickspittle?