Support For One State Solution Grows

Where by "the occupation" you mean "the existence of the State of Israel".

Thanks for confirming that the Palestinian attacks are totally illegitimate and illegal violence, a continuation of the Palestinian war of aggression that began in 1947 and which is being justly, properly, and legally contained by the occupation.
 
Where by "the occupation" you mean "the existence of the State of Israel".

Thanks for confirming that the Palestinian attacks are totally illegitimate and illegal violence, a continuation of the Palestinian war of aggression that began in 1947 and which is being justly, properly, and legally contained by the occupation.

So, lickspittle, given your definition of the "occupation" it seems that you regard the Occupied Territories as part of the "State of Israel"

Another believer in Eretz Israel.
 
Just confirm this please:

You agree that Israel has a right to exist where it is as a Jewish State, and that its existence within 1967 borders is not an occupation of Palestinian land.

Yes or no?
 
It would be fun watching gryf squirm but we know he will avoid the question.

Based on his posting history (well over 6,000 anti-Israel posts, zero on any other topic) it is quite clear what gryf's views are, that Jews have no right of self determination, Israel should be destroyed, and any Jew in Israel is a valid target for Palestinian terror.

Neither he nor grog would even accept the tiny Jewish state that the Arabs rejected in the 1937 Peel Commission.
 
Just confirm this please:

You agree that Israel has a right to exist where it is as a Jewish State, and that its existence within 1967 borders is not an occupation of Palestinian land.

Yes or no?

Those are different questions.
No state has 'right' to exist.
As the United Church says, demanding recognition of Israel as a Jewish State is a ridiculous demand (they don't use that word, but similar).
Israel's existence within the partition plans are the only borders sanctioned by the UN, but if both parties agreed to the 1967 borders it would be fine.
 
You got it, lickspittle. Resistance to the occupation, to the ethnic cleansing, to the theft of land and property, to humiliation and degradation.

Groggy, I and asking Gryfin to clarify this post. Hamas considers all of Israel to be occupied territory.

I am asking Gryfin whether he thinks Israel has a right to exist within 1967 borders as a Jewish State, or whether this resistance he justifies includes resistance to the existence of Israel?
 
Israel's existence within the partition plans are the only borders sanctioned by the UN, but if both parties agreed to the 1967 borders it would be fine.

In fact the UN has issued resolutions demanding the 1967 borders.

As for "Jewish State" the Church had adopted a more nuanced position. It has dropped that phrase but advocated for a solution that maintains the "demographic integrity" of Israel.

In other words the Church recognizes that a mass influx of Palestinians into Israel would be unjust as it would represent the destruction of Israel.
 
It has dropped that phrase but advocated for a solution that maintains the "demographic integrity" of Israel.

In other words the Church recognizes that a mass influx of Palestinians into Israel would be unjust as it would represent the destruction of Israel.

But it also calls on Israel to give equal rights to all the people there and to allow the right of return to be fulfilled.
 
Israel is responsible for the conditions in the occupied territory only to an extent -- it has a legal obligation to ensure the basic needs of the population are met. Nothing more.

The Palestinians are responsible for their own actions, and for the consequences of those actions. Their commitment to terrorism, war crime, and atrocity has left them destitute and occupied, a condition they fully brought on themselves through their racist belligerence.

They will remain in that condition, and it will continue to be entirely their own fault, until they renounce terror and atrocity and seek meaningful, durable peace with their neighbours.

If I was in that prison, you can bet if I could not leave I would be a full on terrorist. Anyone, or any nation that fucks me over that badly is my enemy and I would be prepared to die fighting for my freedom.
 
I read this:


Is that not what you meant?
Are you not equating the state of Israel with the occupation?

No. I am asking Gryfin if that is what he thinks. Learn how to read, a ? at the end of a sentence means it is a question, not a statement.

My view has been made clear many times: The territories are not part of Israel.

I am asking Gryfin if he think Israel is included in the area he considers "occupied".
 
But it also calls on Israel to give equal rights to all the people there and to allow the right of return to be fulfilled.

Did you carefully read what they said about ensuring the demographic integrity of Israel? They are not advocating for a right of return that would see millions of Palestinians flood in and destroy the Israeli state.

I know that is what you are hoping for -- your goal is the destruction of Israel. Unlike you, their goal is peace. I disagree with some of their points, but I respect them as a moderate voice -- unlike you and Gryfin.
 
If I was in that prison, you can bet if I could not leave I would be a full on terrorist. Anyone, or any nation that fucks me over that badly is my enemy and I would be prepared to die fighting for my freedom.

I am quite sure that you put yourself firmly on the "reprehensible war criminal" side of the ledger of morality. You've made that clear before. You are antithetical towards Canadian values and international law -- clearly.
 
Did you carefully read what they said about ensuring the demographic integrity of Israel? .

The demographic integrity of Israel is only really at risk with present path towards a single apartheid state.
 
Overwhelmingly Israeli voters DO NOT want to annex the territories. It won't happen.

Its true that its not very likely that they will do a Jewish Home type all out annexation and ethnic cleansing.
But its also true that they are in the middle of a long and slow process of what the UN calls 'de facto annexation'.
 
I am quite sure that you put yourself firmly on the "reprehensible war criminal" side of the ledger of morality. You've made that clear before. You are antithetical towards Canadian values and international law -- clearly.

Canadian. Values are a myth. We do what we are told to do by our American overlords. You have no ability to put your self in the shoes of others.