Support For One State Solution Grows

gryfin

New member
Aug 30, 2001
9,632
0
0
While what Gideon Levy proposes may seem heretical to the Zionist crowd, it is, in fact, only the way we all live in Canada today. What he proposes are bedrock Western value. No more biblical fantasy.

"If you will it, it is no dream: one just state for two peoples. The establishment of a Jewish State was perceived as something no less crazy less than 100 years ago. Subversive? The establishment of a Palestinian state was considered no less subversive even less than three decades ago.

One state for two peoples? It has already existed for a while now. More than two peoples live in it - Jews and Arabs; ultra-Orthodox Jews; religious Zionist and secular Jews; Jews of Middle-Eastern descent and Jews of European descent; settlers and Palestinians. Over time, the distance that separates these communities grows larger.

Somehow, they live together in one state, but one where justice and equality are absent. This, though, is how an imaginary, just state would appear: It would grant everyone the right to vote, and have a democratic constitution that would protect the rights of all communities and minorities - including an immigration policy like that of all other nations.

Such a state would have a legislature that would reflect the mosaic of the country, and an elected government formed by a coalition of the communities and the two peoples' representatives. Yes, a Jewish prime minister with an Arab deputy, or vice versa.

The end of the world? Why? Arabs and Jews already live together today, but discrimination, inequality, past tensions, racism, nationalism and mutual fear hinder relations between them. These will gradually dissipate, and most of the dangers currently in store for the country will disappear with one state for two peoples.

At home, an egalitarian country like this would defuse most of the hatreds that bubble up from within. Arab citizens and Palestinians, with equal rights, will lose their subversive drive against the state that alienated them and dispossessed them of their rights. It will become their country. The Jews are likely to find that most of their fears were for naught: the moment that justice is established, the dangers - real and imagined - will be subdued.

Even more dramatic will be the disintegration of external threats. Iran, Syria, Hezbollah, Hamas and the rest of the "Axis of Evil" will lose the basis for their hatred. Who, then, will Iran threaten? A Jewish-Palestinian state? And who will Hezbollah and Hamas fire their missiles at? Against a Jewish-Palestinian consensus? Even the international stature of the new state will change in an instant: the world will excitedly embrace it and hurry to funnel large-scale aid to it.

This country will prosper when the massive budgets invested by both sides in preserving their own security will be redirected to other goals. Its fault lines will run, like in every other country, between the rich and poor, the educated and uneducated, the success stories and laggards. In the initial period, these successes will be the country's Jews, who will prosper because their society is more developed, but the equality of opportunity can't help but gradually bridge the gaps.

These imagined goals won't be achieved in one day alone. The realization of this fantasy will be achieved through a long, difficult and complex process of liberation from old beliefs and values that were destructive for both nations. It will also require the overcoming of deep fears that are no less destructive, and drawing a line under the past.

The Jews will be forced to give up the dream of a national state, likewise the Palestinians. This will be the end of Zionism in its existing form, something very painful for those who have grown used to believing that it is the only way. But it will be replaced by something incomparably more just and sustainable.

The moment Israel's Jews are persuaded that the Palestinians are humans like them, with everything this implies, the path will become a shorter one and become possible if a new leadership arises among the two peoples. Not a new politics of old and bad thinking, but truly revolutionary leadership that shatters old and bad paradigms and neutralizes fears.

At least two are required for this tango, and at present there isn't even one. This dance will require a great deal of courage and imagination: right now, there is neither one nor the other. But think of the alternative - where does it lead? To another round in this bloody dance? And another round after that? But what about afterward? There aren't many Israelis today who know how to answer which way the county is headed. To them, let it be said: If you wish a single, just state, it is no dream."

http://www.haaretz.com/opinion/time-to-be-single-minded.premium-1.517887#
 
Its just shocking how mentioning equal rights for all sets some people off, even those who claim to support western values.
But really, it is the only hopeful plan for a true and lasting peace.
 
I would agree that a one state solution is the only workable option, the problem is both sides want to expel the other under their own terms.... not a healthy co-habitation situation.

OTB
 
Just a reminder, 71% of Palestinians are opposed to a one state solution with equal rights for all.
http://www.pcpsr.org/survey/polls/2013/p47e.html

As a Canadian I would think it great if people would want to get along and accept each other as equal but there is way too much hatred. As it is, significant parts of both groups support a two state solution; the problems being Israeli settlers and Hamas, Islamic Jihad, PFLP and even parts of Fatah refusing to accept any peace that includes a noticeable Jewish presence in the region. One problem is more easily solved than the other.


Oh yeah, the same survey has 40% of Palestinians supporting attacks on Israeli civilians.
 
I would agree that a one state solution is the only workable option, the problem is both sides want to expel the other under their own terms.... not a healthy co-habitation situation.

If the Palestinians do not renounce violence I think the most viable outcome, for them, is a no state solution.

I don't see any magic green giant that's going to come and force Israel to integrate a hostile terrorist organization into its borders. I do think that if the Palestinian State fails, the UN could be persuaded to expand the UNRWA to the level of being a proxy government, to administer the territory until anybody can figure out what to do with it.

And I can see that situation dragging on another hundred years.
 
Right.
That's called apartheid, which is pretty much what they've got now.


israel is not apartheid. arab mps are in parliament, sharia law are used by israeli muslims for family matters in israel, etc
 
israel is not apartheid. arab mps are in parliament, sharia law are used by israeli muslims for family matters in israel, etc

Not only its not apartheid , but its too late to integrate for the Palestinians on the Gaza side. They're already set in with Hamas and its desire to destroy Israel, they follow a strict Islamic code (see your link on Hamas beating people over modesty) and many just hate the Jews because they are told to do so by their Imams.
Even Abbas said no Jews were going to be allowed to live in a Palestinian state.
 
"One State Solution" can really be translated without being far from the truth as "drive the non-Muslims into the sea!"
 
I think it's telling that this buffoon is your intellectual passenger, Israel's Cabana Boy

The kinship is readily apparent.

Here’s something that came as a surprise to me, but in retrospect I suppose it shouldn’t. Israel actually has official, publicly funded Sharia courts for Muslims, just as they have rabbinical courts for Jews. That makes sense, in a way, because if you’re going to allow religious courts to adjudicate certain issues, you have to allow them for all religious groups.
Not only is sharia law officially recognised by the justice system in Israel in everything regarding the personal status of Muslims, but the judges of the sharia courts are officially appointed by a joint ministerial-parliamentary committee and their salaries paid for by the state. Ironically, this arrangement originates from the days when Britain was the Mandate power in Palestine.
Most matters of personal status, especially marriage and divorce, are ruled in Israel by religious courts. For three religious groups, Jews, Muslims and Druze, there are official, state-appointed courts, who rule on these matters. For Christians, there are private ecclesiastical courts whose rulings are recognised de facto by the civil authorities…
“It works quite well,” says **********h Badir Raed, who often appears before the sharia courts on behalf of Muslim clients in divorce hearings. “The Israeli authorities, the police and social services will almost always respect an order issued by the sharia court. I am currently writing a book on this system in Arabic, because I think that this is the best example of a Muslim minority getting its religious rights while respecting the law of the land. The only problems are when the civil law is different from sharia law as in the case of wills and for security reasons when we are dealing with a couple, one of whom lives in the Palestinian territories.”
But Dr Aviad Hacohen, a constitutional law expert from Hebrew University and the head of the Mosiaca centre on state and religion, believes Israel’s system “has two main shortcomings.
“The first is that it creates a twin-track system of religious and civil law that are not always compatible.” Over-ruling of the religious courts by the Supreme Court is not uncommon, and in 1992, in the landmark case Bavli v Bavli, the Supreme Court ruled that civil courts take precedence over religious courts.
“The second shortcoming is that the system isn’t good for everyone. It can’t deal with mixed marriages, or those who are not recognised as belonging to a religion.”
We have the same thing in this country, at least for Jewish communities; they’re called beth din courts. And there are circumstances in which they are legitimate, such as handling wills or contracts where both parties agree to have their actions bound by religious law. But there are also many situations where they are clearly illegitimate, especially when they violate the rights of one of the parties before such courts.
Divorce proceedings are a perfect example; before either rabbinical or Sharia courts, women simply do not have anything like equal protection in divorce proceedings. American courts have been resolute in forbidding such discrimination, routinely overturning decisions that violate the constitution. And that is at it should be.


http://freethoughtblogs.com/dispatches/2012/05/08/israel-has-sharia-law/


There have been Israeli Arab members of the Knesset since the first Knesset elections in 1949. The following is a list of the sixty-nine past and present members. Some Israeli Druze dispute the label "Arab" and consider Druze a separate ethnic group, however they are still included in this list.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Arab_members_of_the_Knesset
 
israel is not apartheid. arab mps are in parliament, sharia law are used by israeli muslims for family matters in israel, etc

The only way you can make that argument is to base it off of Israel living within the 1967 borders. As soon as you admit that Israel is running the OCToP, and has been for about half a century, and as soon as you admit that Israel has planted half a million people there, walled off lots of the land and taken most of the water, then you have to judge them on the borders that they control and have for half a century. The US has given them 2 years to settle for a two state solution, if there is no two state solution then its apartheid as it is, as has been warned by numerous Israeli's, including ex-PM Olmert.

And then you have to admit there are two legal systems, walled in bantustans and a host of other identifiers of apartheid policy.
 
Groggy, Afghanistan was not part of the United States when it was occupied, nor was Japan, Germany, or Iraq.

You continue to try and make this very dishonest claim that just because the territories are occupied that somehow magically it has all become part of Israel, through some big fantastic waving giant magic wand.

There is no time limit on occupation, so long as it is driven by military necessity--and Hamas has seen to it pretty well that it is absofuckinglutely necessary.
 
There is no time limit on occupation, so long as it is driven by military necessity--and Hamas has seen to it pretty well that it is absofuckinglutely necessary.

No time limit = permanent annexation.

which means apartheid.
 
Nope. You made that up.

Here's the definition from wiktionary

For a limited time, ephemeral, not constant; transient

So if there is no time limit, its not temporary.
And if its not temporary, then its an apartheid state.
 
"One State Solution" can really be translated without being far from the truth as "drive the non-Muslims into the sea!"

I actually think the opposite. I think if the palestinians declared that they wanted a single state solution, official recognition of Gaza and the West Bank as being part of Israel proper and all it's inhabitants to have equal rights under Israel law they would get universal international support. This would go from a occupation resistance to a human rights headache for the Israelis.

Then all the Palestinians would need to do is "make love, not war" and breed themselves a majority..... would take less time than the two state fiasco has been in the works.

OTB
 
I actually think the opposite. I think if the palestinians declared that they wanted a single state solution, official recognition of Gaza and the West Bank as being part of Israel proper and all it's inhabitants to have equal rights under Israel law they would get universal international support. This would go from a occupation resistance to a human rights headache for the Israelis.

Then all the Palestinians would need to do is "make love, not war" and breed themselves a majority..... would take less time than the two state fiasco has been in the works.

OTB
Of course the problem with the thinking is (according to Palestinian polling) the vast majority of Palestinians (71%) are opposed to a pluralistic one state solution.