Subordinated Debt

"Junk bonds" is not a deragatory term, it merely identifies a segment of the market, sort of like calling something a "penny stock". Rock's intention wasn't to insult you, but I do believe his characterization is correct.

Thanks Barca, you are correct. There was no intention to insult, I was merely using a common market terminology.

I think what is happening here is the U.S. Private equity firm issuing a sub-debt with a 13% coupon (at a time when prime is 2.25%) to a Cdn bank to raise $4MM to buy out our fellow TERBIE's private company.
 
Canadian banks don't issue bonds of any sort at 13% BELIEVE me, not when prime is 2.25%.

This is quite obviously not a Canadian bank note, not a Sched I bank at least.

Sched II or lower? Maybe...but then it wouldn't be a Canadian bank right?
 
Canadian banks don't issue bonds of any sort at 13% BELIEVE me, not when prime is 2.25%.

I think the Canadian bank is the LENDER and the U.S. private equity firm is the borrower in our friend's scenario. I can see a Canadian "Big 6" collecting 13% interest but not paying 13% interest. But, a sub-debt is higher risk and lower quality and I am surprised that a "Big 6" bank would want such a loan on its books.
 
Thanks Barca, you are correct. There was no intention to insult, I was merely using a common market terminology.

I think what is happening here is the U.S. Private equity firm issuing a sub-debt with a 13% coupon (at a time when prime is 2.25%) to a Cdn bank to raise $4MM to buy out our fellow TERBIE's private company.

You guys are driving me crazy.

The US PE firm is borrowing at 13% from a CDN bank. The rest of the loan is Sr. Term debt from a bank at prime plus one percent.

It is a tier one bank that is lending money to a US company. Prime is not a factor. Loan is secured by a second charge against equipment behind the main bank.

Is this clear?

I should have known better than to get advice from simply minded people, but I thought some of you are intelligent. I guess I was wrong.
 
The quick answer is low teens seems to be in the right range. Now my bigger concern for DH, why did you not want to approach your CA on this topic? And what does he have to do with your hobbying? As a CA myself, I am deeply offended that you automatically assume CAs are not hobbyists, BS! As a matter of fact, my CA designation is a specialist designation, "CA-TERB".

Hope I have not pissed you off, if I can help you, please let me know, I am looking forward to a piece of that commission.

Any other CAs on TERB?

Nofah Kingway, CA

I generally don't trust people who aren't overt in their hobbying. I asked my CA if he hobbies, and the answer was "no", so I moved on to you guys.
 
I am sorry for having to correct you, but according to your own statement, this is incorrect.



"Junk bonds" is not a deragatory term, it merely identifies a segment of the market, sort of like calling something a "penny stock". Rock's intention wasn't to insult you, but I do believe his characterization is correct. A sub-debt with an interest rate of 13% is indeed a high yield note, or to use a no-longer used term, "junk bond".

This is not being "issued" by a bank, it is being "underwritten" which is completely different. To "issue" a note, the bank would have to be that "private equity firm" that is buying your business, and I don't believe that is the case is it? I'd be surprised. Canadian banks don't normally take on equity positions like that in any run-of-the-mill company, unlike something like Maple Leaf Sports and Entertainment.

In your case, I am guessing that the bank is underwriting the note but it is the private equity firm that is guaranteeing it (meaning the bank has no obligation once the note is issued) hence making the equity firm (maybe a venture capitalist) the "issuer". Am I correct?


As discussed, you are wrong. The bank is lending the money, hence they have risk ,and they are underwriting it. The US PE firm is the direct borrower.

As to banks not investing equity in small to mid sized businesses, you are wrong. At BMO they have Bank of Montreal Capital Corp, at Scotia, they have RoyNat. Every major bank has a wholly owned sub that does this.
 
I asked my CA if he hobbies, and the answer was "no", so I moved on to you guys.

I don't understand why someone can't go to a CA to discuss the sale of their company. What does the fact whatever your hobby is have anything to do with selling your business. I'm confused.

I've sold 5 small businesses in my time and all with the help of my accountant. I hobby, he doesn't, so is there something I'm missing here? What does one have to do with the other? :confused: Just sounds weird to me, unless you're not disclosing something.
 
Not correct. I said "generally" because each note is different and subordinated only indicates rank, not collateralization.

That's why when issued, most notes have an additional classification such as "unsecured subordinated debt" but then the "unsecured" part generally gets dropped for the sake of expediency. But technically it's still there.

Bank sub-debt is generally unsecured FYI. Very few sub-debt issues are secured. That's usually why they are subordinated as opposed to senior debt.



Incorrrect again. Junk bonds does not take into account whether something is subordinated or note, it merely describes the credit rating and yield of a bond. You can have junk bonds that are senior ranked. Private or public issuance has nothing to do with it.

FYI almost all subordinated loans are secured to rank them ahead of all other unsecured debtors i.e suppliers etc. They take what ever security they can get and sign an interlendor agreement. They may not have any collateral after the senior lendors are taken care of but they take the junior security positions just in case. And I am talking about subordinated loans by banks and I can guarantee they are always secured allbeit behind the senior lendors.
 
You guys are driving me crazy.

The US PE firm is borrowing at 13% from a CDN bank. The rest of the loan is Sr. Term debt from a bank at prime plus one percent.

It is a tier one bank that is lending money to a US company. Prime is not a factor. Loan is secured by a second charge against equipment behind the main bank.

Is this clear?

I should have known better than to get advice from simply minded people, but I thought some of you are intelligent. I guess I was wrong.

Actually when you take into account fees, equity give and the coupon the return is probably closer to 20%.
 
I deal with many professionals and professions on a daily business and "hobbying" never comes up. Why would anyone ask: "Do you use the services of prostitutes". How bizzare is that?

They are service providers. Hobbyists know the terminology, and I for one use a different set of criteria when it comes to those I do business with.

Hobbying is part of my lifestyle, and I enjoy doing business with those that have common interests such as myself.

It is not to suggest that they may not be very capable, it is because I don't trust them, unless I know I either a) are like them in some way, or b) have leverage on them. It is how I ran my business, and it is what made me successful.

I appreciate it sounds bizarre, but it is what it is.

It is no different that hanging out with friends who share a common interest in football. You might work together, but only hang out with guys that like to watch football on Sunday.

There are plenty of CA's out there, but I prefer to get advice off of those that hobby.

There is good info in this thread, and perhaps I did not describe my situation as carefully as possible, but people are showing a genuine interest. On other boards where hobbying is not the focus, I doubt I would have received such detailed responses, which provides validity in my point, that hobbying and business are a good combo.
 
Hobbying is part of my lifestyle, and I enjoy doing business with those that have common interests such as myself.

It is not to suggest that they may not be very capable, it is because I don't trust them, unless I know I either a) are like them in some way, or b) have leverage on them. It is how I ran my business, and it is what made me successful.

I appreciate it sounds bizarre, but it is what it is.

There are plenty of CA's out there, but I prefer to get advice off of those that hobby.

Are you saying you do business only with business associates that see escorts regularly? This is the most bizarre criteria I've ever heard of in my business life, and it's a long and diversified one. Weird man, just plain weird, more like eerie. :eek:
 
The US PE firm is borrowing at 13% from a CDN bank.

That is exactly what I said in my post. I also went on to say that 13% is VERY EXPENSIVE money. And some of us oldtimers still call "high coupon" debt "junk bonds" (no offense intended and hopefully none taken).
 
I should have known better than to get advice from simply minded people, but I thought some of you are intelligent. I guess I was wrong.

WTF? Did you not then go on to say that the information here is better than you got elsewhere? Make up your mind, are we morons or not?

My CA does not appear to hobby, but he likes to live vicariously(?) through his customers. I have sent a couple of my ATFs to see him for tax returns, he does not seem to charge me much for it, hopefully it makes tax time a little more interesting for him.
 
You better start searching the board for a hobbiest that can work on your heart when you start seeing 14 or 15 SP's a day. I'm sure you wouldn't want to trust this to any old doctor with all us terbites ready to help you out.
WTF? Call a CA.
 
You guys are driving me crazy.

The US PE firm is borrowing at 13% from a CDN bank. The rest of the loan is Sr. Term debt from a bank at prime plus one percent.

It is a tier one bank that is lending money to a US company. Prime is not a factor. Loan is secured by a second charge against equipment behind the main bank.

Is this clear?

I should have known better than to get advice from simply minded people, but I thought some of you are intelligent. I guess I was wrong.

It's a shame you needed to get personal with the insults just because you didn't provide all the information and simply assumed people would "get" the details of the arrangement. Nobody here is a mind-reader. I would say that the fault is on your side not the reader's for failing to provide sufficient information and then chastising the reader for making assumptions in the absence of facts.

I think you need some research. These are issued by CDN banks.

We (I) have been in business for over 32 years and am not levered, which is why a CDN bank is doing it in this economy.

My company employs hundreds of workers in the GTA. Shame on you for suggesting we are involved in something like junk bonds.

This is the statement that started the whole argument, and it is evident by this statement alone that you do not understand what a "junk bond" is. Again, this whole issue that you are now regretting discussing caused confusion because of a) lack of information about the deal on your part and b) lack of knowledge on your part on what a "junk bond" actually is. Nortel employes hundreds of times more people than you do and their bonds are classified as "junk". Company size has nothing to do with credit analysis.

Now...you asked about subordinated debt. Being as it's the PE firm that has the debt arrangement with the bank, why do you care whether it is subordinated, junk, senior, high, low whatever? Are you paying the 13%? Aren't you the seller? This is just a weird thread coming from a seller. As long as you get your money, what do you care what interest rate the PE firm pays on borrowed money?
 
FYI almost all subordinated loans are secured to rank them ahead of all other unsecured debtors i.e suppliers etc. They take what ever security they can get and sign an interlendor agreement. They may not have any collateral after the senior lendors are taken care of but they take the junior security positions just in case. And I am talking about subordinated loans by banks and I can guarantee they are always secured allbeit behind the senior lendors.

You are talking about ranking not securitization. "Unsecured" means nothing more than claims on specific assets, it has nothing to do with ranking. Sure sub-debt traditionally ranks ahead of suppliers, but it doesnt mean they are secured against assets. You admit that they "may not have any collateral" which is the very definition of whether the note is secured or not, there is no getting around that.

I issued subordinated debt for years for one of the largest financial institutions in Canada and I can assure you, they are not always "secured" as you claim. Quite the opposite, they are almost always not secured. Yes, they RANK immediately behind senior debt, but senior debt is traditionally secured against assets of the corporation or institution, hence the reason why they are senior in ranking in the first place. While senior debt is traditionally likened to a mortgaged propert, sub-debt is normally considered the highest ranking "IOU", a promissary note without collateral to guarantee the note. That is also a reason why they are traditionally known as "notes" whereas senior secured debt is more accurately known as a "bond".
 
You are talking about ranking not securitization. "Unsecured" means nothing more than claims on specific assets, it has nothing to do with ranking. Sure sub-debt traditionally ranks ahead of suppliers, but it doesnt mean they are secured against assets. You admit that they "may not have any collateral" which is the very definition of whether the note is secured or not, there is no getting around that.

I issued subordinated debt for years for one of the largest financial institutions in Canada and I can assure you, they are not always "secured" as you claim. Quite the opposite, they are almost always not secured. Yes, they RANK immediately behind senior debt, but senior debt is traditionally secured against assets of the corporation or institution, hence the reason why they are senior in ranking in the first place. While senior debt is traditionally likened to a mortgaged propert, sub-debt is normally considered the highest ranking "IOU", a promissary note without collateral to guarantee the note. That is also a reason why they are traditionally known as "notes" whereas senior secured debt is more accurately known as a "bond".

THey will still have a GSA which is the registered security, whether or nto someone senior has a GSA that covers all the assets. Secured debt is debt that has registered security not one that has valid collateral. Man you look at things from the bank issuing its own debt versus the ban k lending to a business.
 
THey will still have a GSA which is the registered security, whether or nto someone senior has a GSA that covers all the assets. Secured debt is debt that has registered security not one that has valid collateral. Man you look at things from the bank issuing its own debt versus the ban k lending to a business.

Correct TN. You are right.
 
Give it to me....I'll make sure it is kept in a safe place for you:D