Sorry about the INSULT,... and I agree with you that Canada's standard of living defiantly benefits from exporting natural resource’s.
And that the price of a commodity can NOT be controlled by a government in a free country, contrary to what the socialists say.
My point was that the socialists are always saying that the big evil corps are holding on there their cash,...so how the hell could oil funds,...which is only 13% of exports, be responsible for our performance during the financial crisis ???
And if one was to "think" about it,...oil consumption AND price dropped considerably when the US shit hit the fan.
A point,...if you group auto's and parts with machinery,...oil exports are 2nd.
FAST
If you recall 2008 - 2009 oil price only dipped for no more than 6 months. It is a just a blink time frame compared to over 10 years of oil sitting above or close to $100 / barrel. And no so long ago in 1999, oil price bottomed at $10 / barrel. In the last 10 years or so, oil and other natural resources have risen significantly due to China and India growth, which Canada benefited significantly. Manufacturing sector as you say is still big chunk, but has not been growing or maybe even shrank a little during the same time period.
Majority of new jobs are created in resource and services sector, not in auto or machinery factories.
The US is a net resource consumer, and its major strength is in technology, but during this same time period, resource prices gone sky high, and the memory of dot-gone period is still fresh, plus war on Iraq and Afganistan no wonder they have had harder time recoverying. After 2008, it is the first time Canada's economy was shown to be tied more to China than the USA.
Also, if you follow stock markets closely you have seen lots and lots of speculative bubble in resource and mining sector with small drillers and exploration companies stock prices shooting up, even at slightest hint of new oil well found, or new goldmine, with or without confirmation. Not unlike the dot-com bubble we saw in the USA during the 90s. Accompanied by attracting foreign money due to the "demise" of US economy, Bay street brokers and Canadian banks saw increased foreign investment, and trading business - hence growth in banking and IT services. - but again all sit on the foundation of high resource prices.
I'm not saying government management is not good, but it is also ridiculous to give them ALL the credit for Canada's economic performance, when clearly the majority of growth came from the resource exports during this time frame.
Mike Carney got a huge promotion by moving to the UK, is more to do with "luck" rather than merit in my opinion. UK government tends to make the worst financial decisions. They always one step behind - like to emulate success of other countries AFTER the fact. like they tried to catch up to USA's dot-com boom when the bubble was about to burst, and Gordon Brown sold off almost all UK's gold reserve at $300 / oz at the bottom low prices.