Social costs?

happygrump

Once more into the breach
May 21, 2004
820
0
0
Waterloo Region
I've been dancing around with this in my head for a while, and even as I post this I don't know if it will be taken with the good intent in which it's offered. So, fellow TERBites, I beg your grace for a few moments.

I have no doubt that the vast majority of hobbyists treat their ladies with dignity, care and respect. After all, when it's good for them it's good for you too. But there's a much larger social issue that, I think, needs to be examined.

It seems that most of the women in the business are there by choice, because the money's good and they like what they do. But, let's face it, we all know of the stories of other women, in other places, who are forced into a life they would not otherwise choose because of financial or other pressures. And the involvement of organized crime in the biz is well established.

Anyone who has spent any time on the downtown east side of Vancouver - the Main & Hastings area, specifically, right by the police station (ironic, isn't it?) - knows full well the toll that drugs and rough prostitution have taken on the people that frequent the area.

Many have simply disappeared, possibly the victims of some sort of violent end. Nobody really knows for sure, though there are suspicions and charges laid in a few cases.

Women have come a long, long way since Rosie the Riveter built aircraft and tanks and refrigerators during the Second World War when the men were off fighting and dying in Europe. Women can now hold high office, are world and corporate leaders, and nobody really gives it a second thought. Much remains to be done, of course, but women's place in society is far more advanced than, say, fifty years ago.

So, I ask you this: Do hobbyists unintentionally advance the subjugation of women when we search them out for service? Does it hinder the advancement of women in the fields of business, politics and social commitment when hobbyists continue to hire them for their services?

Hobbyists and SP's, what do you think?

<donning asbestos suit...>
 
happygrump said:
So, I ask you this: Do hobbyists unintentionally advance the subjugation of women when we search them out for service? Does it hinder the advancement of women in the fields of business, politics and social commitment when hobbyists continue to hire them for their services?

On the contrary, IMO it is a means to an end. If anything, we as hobbyists are assisting the ladies by paying for their education so they can attain prestigious careers. Keep in mind, I am only speaking from my experience which involves a select group of ladies who may not be an accurate representation of the whole.

That said, I mainly see ladies who are university students putting themselves through school. Moreover, no one would even suspect them of being an escort as they are the quintessential girl next door.

While there is a dark side to the industry, there is a world of difference between that element and the ladies we know on Terb, for instance. As long as the ladies are here of their own volition, it's a win - win situation.
 
There is a *world* of difference between a street hooker on East Hastings and the kind of things people generally talk about on terb. The kinds of problems they face, the dangers they face, their reasons for getting into the business are almost entirely unrelated.

That said there is a serious social cost to being a prostitute, even an upscale one, and that is quite simply why the prices you pay for the service are high. Women in this industry need to be compensated for the loss of other job opportunities, stigmatization, fallout with family, future marital grief, etc., that often follow from having been a prostitute.

Whether you see the hobby as part of the problem or not really depends on how you answer some horribly complicated ethical questions which could be and might well be debated here for ever without any end. First you have to decide whether you think there is anything inherently degrading about being a prostitute, ignoring the social costs. Second, you have to ask whether the social costs are justified or whether they amount to unfair persecution. Third, even if it's unfair persecution, you have to decide whether it's acceptable to knowingly subject someone to unfair persecution.

There are easy and simple answers to these questions, but I don't think there are any satisfying answers--just like there are no satisfying answers to many questions you face when you get into the realm of "public morals" and their effect on people.
 
happygrump said:
Anyone who has spent any time on the downtown east side of Vancouver - the Main & Hastings area, specifically, right by the police station (ironic, isn`t it?) - knows full well the toll that drugs and rough prostitution have taken on the people that frequent the area.
To learn what the girls at Main & Hastings think of the business, have a look at the report referenced in Pivot Legal Society Report Urges Decriminalization
Originally posted by happygrump
So, I ask you this: Do hobbyists unintentionally advance the subjugation of women when we search them out for service? Does it hinder the advancement of women in the fields of business, politics and social commitment when hobbyists continue to hire them for their services?
Occasionally yes. Occasionally no. I have no grounds on which to make an informed judgement, so I assume that my counterparty in the transaction is able to make up her own mind in the matter - unless I have at least some evidence to the contrary.

I would love to have the ability to run other people`s lives for them, but my hands are pretty full with my own.