Should Bertuzzi be re-instated?

Should Bertuzzi be re-instated?

  • Yes

    Votes: 15 28.3%
  • No

    Votes: 31 58.5%
  • Last season shouldn't count...

    Votes: 8 15.1%
  • Don't care.

    Votes: 3 5.7%

  • Total voters
    53
shack said:
The point is not that the pertpetrator has to know the exact outcome to be guilty. The point is that the perpetrator very well knew beforehand that throwing a punch at someone from behind "could possibly" cause injury even if he doesn't know the extent. The purpose of a punch is to cause harm. He threw a punch at a man, who at that very moment could not defend himself, of his own volition. He willingly initiated an action intended to cause harm. Unfortunately, he got more than he bargained for.

You haven't really responded to my point. This isn't about a punch to the head causing more damage than intended. It's about the relative relationship to the ultimate injuries of: a) the punch to the head (Bertuzzi's fault, which he's on the hook for), and b) the tackle/pile on (which Bertuzzi is not solely at fault for).

Secondly, the issue is no longer about whether Bertuzzi is "guilty" (that was the subject of the criminal case, which is over). It's now about how much of Moore's monetary damages Bertuzzi should be liable for. It's a completely different question.
 
Bud Plug said:
You haven't really responded to my point. This isn't about a punch to the head causing more damage than intended. It's about the relative relationship to the ultimate injuries of: a) the punch to the head (Bertuzzi's fault, which he's on the hook for), and b) the tackle/pile on (which Bertuzzi is not solely at fault for).

Secondly, the issue is no longer about whether Bertuzzi is "guilty" (that was the subject of the criminal case, which is over). It's now about how much of Moore's monetary damages Bertuzzi should be liable for. It's a completely different question.
I understand your point and my response was in my answer in that Bertuzzi initiated a sequence of violent events, that occurred within 1-2 seconds, with a violent act that was premeditated. The fact that we don't know exactly which of these acts directly did the damage is not the overriding point. If he doesn't attack Moore none of the other stuff happens. He was the only one trying to hurt Moore (at that moment) and Moore was the only one that got hurt. No one else directly hit Moore, except for Bertuzzi who even took another shot at him while he was on the ice. The bodies that piled on were initially Moore's teammates trying to protect him and then others in response to that. As well, the other players acted reflexively to something that had just happened as opposed to Bertuzzi who followed Moore for a while before mugging him. His action was premeditated, the other players' was an instinctive response. In my mind, he's almost entirely to blame for everything that happened. Bud, you obviously see it differently.

BTW, I'm not real hardline as to his suspension, he should miss whatever he would have missed without the lockout. He would have probably missed anther 15-20 games with no lockout. That's not outrageous. That lost season should count for nothing. I just have trouble seeing how people try to justify his actions and/or say he's not responsible for Moore's injury. Just voicing my opinion. (Still trying to decide if it's humble or not.)
 
shack said:
The point is not that the perpetrator has to know the exact outcome to be guilty. The point is that the perpetrator very well knew beforehand that throwing a punch at someone from behind "could possibly" cause injury even if he doesn't know the extent. The purpose of a punch is to cause harm. He threw a punch at a man, who at that very moment could not defend himself, of his own volition. He willingly initiated an action intended to cause harm. Unfortunately, he got more than he bargained for.

Bud Plug said:
I can't buy the logic. If I let an empty shopping cart go rolling down a hill I can predict the kind of damage that might result. If a third party throws a 200 lb set of weights in the cart as it rolls along, much more serious damage will be done. How could I predict that?

You gotta love it when the lawyers try to settle a debate......