Should Banks Lend More

Rockslinger said:
Everytime I watch TV or read the newspapers, people are crying out for the banks to open the LOAN faucet to "save" the economy. Isn't bank overlending that got us into this mess in the first place. More lending now is like throwing more water on a drowning man. Yes?


Banks should immediately pay $300 to every bona fide hobbyist to be spent on his favourite or second favourite SP.
 
barca said:
Wow...talk about volunteering information unecessarily!

And yes, banks have a reporting obligation to the US...your words caused them to add on a heap of paperwork that they are legally bound to fufill.

I'm just curious:confused: ? What was Rockslinger supposed to do? Lie to the loans officer and say he was still employed when in fact he is "between projects."?

If RS got the loan under false pretenses wouldn't that be a problem as well?
 
MarkII said:
No the banks shouldn't lend more but they should be forced into lower interest rates on credit cards. While we're at it Banks should also be reigned in on service charges.

It will never happen...but it's christmas so I can ask for what I want!


The rates on Credit Cards are not going to drop
There are two reasons the credit card rates are high
1. There is a large % of people who default on CC debt
2. The bank / Credit Card company must make a return on its invested capital, otherwise they deploy their capital elsewhere.

Every month a very large amount of outstanding credit card debt is sold off by the credit card companies (for pennies on the dollar) to debt collectors. The actual amounts are surprisingly high (It depending on who they give these cards to but all portfolios have a significant write factor). This is bad business to lend out $ and then receive less than you paid out

A large % of card holders pay the outstanding balance every month, The CC company does not make any money on these guys and has to fund their purchases for a month. (I have had a on going balance of over $1,500 on my cards (note the plural- cards )for 15 years, yet I have never paid a dime in interest).
So in order to make a profit they have to charge high rates on the card that maintain an outstanding balances. In fact they can expect a much higher rate of defaults


I know many left leaning individuals will say # 2 is bullshit and they are more than profitable, however, assume you are the CEO of a bank and you have two choices each requiring $100MM of capital to invest
A. Small business loans program
B. Credit Card operation

Based upon the predictions you are given both will provide a return of approx 10% every year on the 100MM. (Thats a good return)
In both cases you have received warnings that defaults in both businesses could significantly increase because of problems with the economy.

Then the government puts a cap on the credit card rate of say 8-10% APR
You run through the numbers again and your return is now 1% on the 100MM invested in the credit card business. It cost the bank more than that to obtain the capital.
Its a no-brainier, you put the capital into small business loans or some other project that makes more money, Mutual Funds, Insurance, Student loans etc

So unless the govt forces banks to issue credit cards along with caps on the rate the banks would simply stop issuing credit cards, squeezing credit even more
 
the immediate issue with the banks is that they have shut off credit for good customers as well as bad . Large numbers of good business customes have had their credit lines reduced or cancelled through no fault of their own. These business then go under because they can not make payroll or can not buy materials to complete an order. One friend of mine sold his business last year when the canadian dollar went up, his american recievables dropped due to the exchange rate the bank told him he had to make up the difference. He had been a customer for 30 years.

The central bank dropped the rates that they charge the commercial banks normally the commercial banks drop thier primne rates bby the same ammount, this tiome they did not do it twice. The first time public preasure got teh rest of the rate drop this time not so much. They also popped up with the comment that the govt had to drop the banks business taxes , it might have gone over better if they had not just reported billion dolar quarterly profits.

The bottom line is that unless the crdeit crunch relaxes we are in for a long nasty winter. The finance minister has a meeting with the CEO's of teh big 5 this week I would like to be in on the discussion./
 
squash500 said:
I'm just curious:confused: ? What was Rockslinger supposed to do? Lie to the loans officer and say he was still employed when in fact he is "between projects."?

If RS got the loan under false pretenses wouldn't that be a problem as well?

Not necessary. If they don't ask you if you are a US citizen, there is no need to volunteer it so long as you are a Canadian one. Especially in a banking arrangement. On the investment side, if you were to open an account they will ask you anyways and yes you should be truthful.

It would not be getting a loan under any kind of false information at all so long as all your Canadian information is up to date and truthful.
 
Barca said:
If they don't ask you if you are a US citizen, there is no need to volunteer it

She explicitly asked if I am a U.S. citizen. Said it is part of their due diligence know your client process. She said that U.S. citizens have to complete and sign some kind of silly "W" form.
 
RS said:
She explicitly asked if I am a U.S. citizen. Said it is part of their due diligence know your client process. She said that U.S. citizens have to complete and sign some kind of silly "W" form.


I've never heard of a canadian bank asking if someone was a US citizen when applying for a line of credit in Canada?
 
squash500 said:
I've never heard of a canadian bank asking if someone was a US citizen when applying for a loan in Canada?

I was applying for a PLC and I think that if my PLC was ever in a credit balance (very unlikely), the Bank would pay me credit interest and would have to report this income to the U.S. IRS if I am a U.S. citizen. I'll call her tomorrow and say that my TERB friends told she asked an inappropriate question concerning my citizenship.
 
Rockslinger said:
I was applying for a PLC and I think that if my PLC was ever in a credit balance (very unlikely), the Bank would pay me credit interest and would have to report this income to the U.S. IRS if I am a U.S. citizen. I'll call her tomorrow and say that my TERB friends told she asked an inappropriate question concerning my citizenship.

Actually it's a perfectly legal question and since they know you are a dual citizen they need to put through the proper paperwork.

That being said...if you live and work here, it really doesn't affect you all that much other than the IRS knows where you are and what you are doing.
 
JohnLarue said:
...A large % of card holders pay the outstanding balance every month, The CC company does not make any money on these guys and has to fund their purchases for a month....

This is not entirely correct. CC companies charge merchants various fees for each transaction. One could say the CC does not "make any mney" on these but they do cover expenses.

Also, CC companies are similar to Insurance Companies in the manner of managing $$. The CC makes money off your payments since they do not carry your monthly debt. Any charge you make is not paid to the merchant for 1 - 2 months after your purchase.
 
hairyfucker said:
This is not entirely correct. CC companies (ie bank owned recieveables) charge merchants various fees for each transaction. One could say the CC does not "make any mney" on these but they do cover expenses.

Also, CC companies are similar to Insurance Companies in the manner of managing $$. The CC makes money off your payments since they do not carry your monthly debt. Any charge you make is not paid to the merchant for 1 - 2 months after your purchase.

Fair enough, however the merchant discount is actually charged by the transaction company (Visa / Master card). If the CC company takes a bite it is small. (like 0.25% of the purchase value- Visa/Master card takes approx 1.0% to 1.75%)

I am not as familiar with the merchant side of the business so I will have to assume you are correct
Bottom line is the write offs are a killer and are the main driver behind rates north of 15-20%
With the economic turmoil resulting in massive layoffs, the CC companies can expect huge write offs 6 to months down the road
 
JohnLarue said:
...Bottom line is the write offs are a killer and are the main driver behind rates north of 15-20%
With the economic turmoil resulting in massive layoffs, the CC companies can expect huge write offs 6 to months down the road

Totally agree on both statements.

The goal of the CC company is to get a customer that consistently makes(minimum) payments.

Customers that pay in full each month are not a profit center and customers that default cause the high interest rates due to write offs.
 
hairyfucker said:
Totally agree on both statements.

The goal of the CC company is to get a customer that consistently makes(minimum) payments.

Customers that pay in full each month are not a profit center and customers that default cause the high interest rates due to write offs.

That's why they keep increasing the limits for those customers, to give them the impression it's ok to carry a balance because as a percentage of their available credit, it's small. Some people think because they are not tapped out on the cards, they should keep spending. A CC company's dream.
 
Barca said:
And yes, banks have a reporting obligation to the US...your words caused them to add on a heap of paperwork that they are legally bound to fufill.


Please clarify: How could the phrase "between projects" possibly have caused the loans officer to think the OP was not a Canadian citizen?

Don't get me wrong, I think there is a whole lot more that the OP is not disclosing here. And if you are asked about your employment status and answer you are "between projects", then of course you would be considered unemployed.
 
hoser1970 said:
Please clarify: How could the phrase "between projects" possibly have caused the loans officer to think the OP was not a Canadian citizen?

No, the two issues are not related. The female loan officer (a real cutie) had 40,000 questions (I was in her office for 90 minutes) and one of her questions was: "Are you an American citizen?". Another question was: "Who is your employer?"

She also asked me if I am married. Is she allowed to ask maritial status (Human Rights Commission and all that)?
 
hairyfucker said:
maybe she was looking for a sugar daddy.

But, I am "between projects". That is why I need the PLC in the first place. However, I did think it strange that she kept me in her office for 90 minutes for a $10,000 PLC.
 
Spokesman for the Canadian Bankers association says Canadian bank lending is actually up year over year...where lending has decreased is in trade credit and other types of credit, leasing, etc.
 
Who says that banks don't have a heart? Received a Christmas card in the mail from the cute female loan officer today. (I was hoping it would be a cheque for $10,000 instead.)
 
she digs ya dude. go close the deal. i'd take some nookie over a loan anyday,