MarkII said:
No the banks shouldn't lend more but they should be forced into lower interest rates on credit cards. While we're at it Banks should also be reigned in on service charges.
It will never happen...but it's christmas so I can ask for what I want!
The rates on Credit Cards are not going to drop
There are two reasons the credit card rates are high
1. There is a large % of people who default on CC debt
2. The bank / Credit Card company must make a return on its invested capital, otherwise they deploy their capital elsewhere.
Every month a very large amount of outstanding credit card debt is sold off by the credit card companies (for pennies on the dollar) to debt collectors. The actual amounts are surprisingly high (It depending on who they give these cards to but all portfolios have a significant write factor). This is bad business to lend out $ and then receive less than you paid out
A large % of card holders pay the outstanding balance every month, The CC company does not make any money on these guys and has to fund their purchases for a month. (I have had a on going balance of over $1,500 on my cards (note the plural- cards )for 15 years, yet I have never paid a dime in interest).
So in order to make a profit they have to charge high rates on the card that maintain an outstanding balances. In fact they can expect a much higher rate of defaults
I know many left leaning individuals will say # 2 is bullshit and they are more than profitable, however, assume you are the CEO of a bank and you have two choices each requiring $100MM of capital to invest
A. Small business loans program
B. Credit Card operation
Based upon the predictions you are given both will provide a return of approx 10% every year on the 100MM. (Thats a good return)
In both cases you have received warnings that defaults in both businesses could significantly increase because of problems with the economy.
Then the government puts a cap on the credit card rate of say 8-10% APR
You run through the numbers again and your return is now 1% on the 100MM invested in the credit card business. It cost the bank more than that to obtain the capital.
Its a no-brainier, you put the capital into small business loans or some other project that makes more money, Mutual Funds, Insurance, Student loans etc
So unless the govt forces banks to issue credit cards along with caps on the rate the banks would simply stop issuing credit cards, squeezing credit even more