Shill Posts

If you don't like it, move on. I'm not very worried what you or anyone on here thinks of me. If you're posting things on an anonymous message board like TERB and you're worried about what other people think of you then you're going to have an unpleasant time eventually. My advice is to learn to develop a thicker skin.

first of all my skin is plenty thick. When this board first got started (and yes I was here pretty much from the start, under a different name) it was set up to be a forum to exchange information and ideas so we could explore this hobby safely and get value for our money. From what Im seeing most of these so called veterans and regular posters dont do a whole lot of reviewing, They seem to spend their time posting about daily news events,taking shots at each other and posting some of the weirdest shit Ive seen since I owned a dirty book store on Young street in the seventies. My point is if you want an honest exchange you should encourage new people not criticize so much but maybe encourage more. And as for the vets maybe a few more reviews.
 
first of all my skin is plenty thick. When this board first got started (and yes I was here pretty much from the start, under a different name) it was set up to be a forum to exchange information and ideas so we could explore this hobby safely and get value for our money. From what Im seeing most of these so called veterans and regular posters dont do a whole lot of reviewing, They seem to spend their time posting about daily news events,taking shots at each other and posting some of the weirdest shit Ive seen since I owned a dirty book store on Young street in the seventies. My point is if you want an honest exchange you should encourage new people not criticize so much but maybe encourage more. And as for the vets maybe a few more reviews.

You raise a couple of good points. The post count on some people is crazy high, but it's all in these general forums. I get that for some people this is a part of their daily lives and they live in this community a lot more than I do. Thankfully, some people hobby a lot more than I do and they share their experiences frequently. But there are a lot of people with high post counts that you don't see in the review sections.

As for encouraging new people, re-read my first post:

"That isn't to say that a person can use TERB to do research, pick an SP and then try to contribute by posting a review (either positive or negative). I'm sure that happens. If that describes your situation, please post your review and just realize some people make not put much weight into it. Don't let it stop you, and you'll be vindicated in the end."

Telling people to please post their review, cautioning them against the inevitable shill accusations and telling them they will be vindicated is pretty encouraging.

You're also right that waaay back there was a much better exchange of info, fewer people asking if anyone had seen someone yet and saying that someone else should TOFFT. I noticed a big shift when Craigslist and Backpages became popular. Now there are a ton of ads out there, which to be makes TERB more relevant than ever. I do my best to post reviews although I tend to stick to well reviewed SP/MPA's since I haven't got the $ to spread around and don't want to waste it on a bad experience. Again.

As to what Ms.FemmeFatale wrote, I guess that I'd always considered a negative review to be a YMMV situation but hadn't considered the "puppy love" aspect of glowing reviews. It's a fair point, and worth considering. :)
 
+1. sounds true to me.

I think one thing all you vets forget was what it was like when you first found TERB, found the hobby, found that SP that actually did her job and did it well.

Guys can get just as school yard crushie as a woman can. You guys get all smiles and giggles, and on that high and then write that glowing review and it does come across as too good to be true, but really, it was just written on the high.

Same with negative reviews. So mad that the disdain, disrespect, hurtful words come out because you feel that negative feeling.

Try waiting and writing your review with no emotion. It is just a review after all. Stick to the facts, leave the emotion at that door and be as honest and tasteful as possible. I also think that if the lady knows you and your TERB handle prior to the appointment, it should be posted in the review. It will help with what the wangbang said about suck up reviews.

 
One difficulty I have is posting negative reviews. I had one less than great experience with a high profile Indy, and even though she kind of left me cold, I didn't want to be insulting. Also half thought I did something wrong that meant my mileage varied. I know I owe it to the members, but I like the idea of praise and quiet.

Thoughts?
 
I think these are great points if you want to weed out the amateur shills. But the real professional shills have more experience and are a lot more careful. Most of them will come off has long time members and will have lots of previous reviews. They will make sure they don't have the obvious mistakes like listed above.

Nicole

This...
 
anonemouse
I agree with you, I too dont have the money to tofft every time I go venturing out so I tend to go with what I know. But in the past Ive found that experienced hobbests tend to keep the good ones to themselves. I also agree that with the introduction of bp and the relaxing of the laws sites like terb and the exchange of info. is even more necessary.

As a for Ms. FemmeFatale your absolutely right Ive seen guys over the years fall hard for an sp to the point where they even post negatively to keep others away. Ive also known sps who will tell their client to post a review to the point of dictating what to say. It IS better to wait till the next day to to post a review.
There was a time years ago when I did have the money and was seeing alot of sps. Id fall in love once or twice a week. Still costs a hell of a lot less than being married
 
I'm not sure if you're attempting to call me a bully and/or a coward. Either way, you're right I don't care. You're entitled to your opinion.

To move off the derail, I was considering what Nicole posted above and the idea of "professional shills" led to me something else: endorsements. I recall in the past reading about long-standing TERB members who would try for discounts for a positive review (which I suppose would presumably have some weight behind it if they were experienced, respected, posted lots of reviews, etc.). I seem to recall reading something about that a long time ago, an SP/MPA saying they had been approached with the offer. Does anyone else remember that, or have you heard of something similar?

The problem with this scenario is that it would be pretty tough to weed those out. Hopefully no one stoops to it, and SP/MPA's report it.

PHNINE comes to mind
 
While I agree that there are some warning signs (registration date, very few posts, early hyper-positive review of a relatively unknown girl, etc.), there is one that I worry about a bit:
3) Language: it's harder to define but men and women may write differently, which is sometimes apparent in the post

Language is a funny thing. In some online communities, a lot of women talk like "typical" guys or even hide their gender to better fit the, errrr, community standard of that particular place. Gaming forums are a good example, but there are others. Conversely, some fellers like to euphemise, either because they're prissy motherfornicators or simply because they enjoy playing about with language a bit. I know several happily hetero manly-men type guys who would indeed use the term "ladyparts", and I also know some downright demure(ish) gals who will pepper their conversation with the word "cunt" no matter how much I flinch when they do. Or perhaps because I flinch. At any rate, I find language to be the least reliable indicator of shillery. Errrr, shillism. No, errr... shilliness. Fuck it, you know what I mean. Fucking language!


You are pretty much on the right track with your analysis, I use the same criteria. One thing I notice in many shill reviews is the line, "treat her well guys and she will return the favour", or something along those lines.

To me, this is another example of why language is a piss poor indicator. For example, I regularly visit that other, nicey-nice "recommendation" board. You know, the one that doesn't even allow negative reviews. You can't blink without seeing "treat her well, she's a peach/gem/princess/pokemon/whatever" type language there. And that's fine, because that is the type of community and context there is there. But sometimes, when I pop in here, I can't help but take the baggage of that similar but very different place with me. And sometimes I have had to make a conscious effort not to express myself using language that is the norm there but not here. Dollars to doughnuts some of the posts you may think are shills because of these language "tells" are actually legit posters expressing themselves using what they feel are the appropriate language conventions for a review board.
 
It's kind of hard being the new guy. I started the hobby in December. Used reviews from another board to pick my first SP. I couldn't find anything on my second SP, and toftt. The third was a well reviewed girl too, I just found the reviews after I partook of the services.

I never worried about being called a shill because what can a bunch of anonymous people really do to me on an anonymous board, other than make fun of me for not using the search function better. I mean they should attack my hygiene, weight or hairline, maybe my quick release...hahaha.

I just look at every review as a 5/10 until I personally see the SP in question.
 
It's kind of hard being the new guy. I started the hobby in December. Used reviews from another board to pick my first SP. I couldn't find anything on my second SP, and toftt. The third was a well reviewed girl too, I just found the reviews after I partook of the services.

I never worried about being called a shill because what can a bunch of anonymous people really do to me on an anonymous board, other than make fun of me for not using the search function better. I mean they should attack my hygiene, weight or hairline, maybe my quick release...hahaha.

I just look at every review as a 5/10 until I personally see the SP in question.

Shill, lol!
 
One difficulty I have is posting negative reviews. I had one less than great experience with a high profile Indy, and even though she kind of left me cold, I didn't want to be insulting. Also half thought I did something wrong that meant my mileage varied. I know I owe it to the members, but I like the idea of praise and quiet.

Thoughts?
If you had a legitimately bad time I don't see the problem with posting a bad review. I read them thinking that the SP/MPA could be having an off day, or it could be a YMMV thing. There's 2 sides to every story. If everyone shared bad experiences then you would be vindicated eventually as other bad reviews piled up.

I see a lot of times where a person posts a bad review and others chime in saying they had a similar and negative experience in the past. Why not post the review at the time? You could have helped someone out. It helps add credibility, but for the community there's more value in posting a review then corroborating someone else's review.

Another thought about negative reviews is that levels of service don't stay the same all the time. It could provide some negative feedback to the SP which could help them, although that doesn't seem very likely. A negative review is more likely to be reacted to than be looked to for any feedback. And just because they provide great service in the past doesn't mean that they will forever. You could be defining the start of a decrease in service for whatever reason. I think it's a mistake to read one review (either good or bad) and make your mind up about an SP/MPA. There's 2 sides to the story, and in any event YMMV.
 
To me, this is another example of why language is a piss poor indicator.

I agree that it isn't a great indicator. You would have to know the reviewer in real life to know if they talk like that. Plus people could be traveling to T.O. and come from a different part of the world where they have different phrases etc.

I don't rely on language too much, but it does make me scrutinize the post a bit more. If it's present with other factors (brand new, 1st post, 1st review, etc.) it would certainly read like a shill even if it isn't. Personally I wouldn't discount a review entirely based on language alone since you're right, it isn't a great stand-alone indicator.
 
Sometimes the guy tells you he is going to write a review to make sure it is ok. Some girls don't want to be reviewed for one reason or another. Also if an sp is like me she searches her name and agency (if she is with one) just to see what people are saying. If I get a positive review I comment and say thank you. If I get a negative one I would want to know why.

I understand that but I still disregard any review where it is obvious that the poster is revealing themselves to the lady.

As soon as I see......."I just returned from" or "I had an appointment this morning with" I tune out. And if the lady posts in the thread and clearly knows who the poster is I tune out.
 
Unfortunately there are a lot of shills in the massage section. Actually not a lot, just a few but they post so much it becomes annoying as they really have nothing to offer but will defend their spa of choice to the end and constantly bump threads. Any reader of the massage section knows who I am referring to.
 
Unfortunately there are a lot of shills in the massage section. Actually not a lot, just a few but they post so much it becomes annoying as they really have nothing to offer but will defend their spa of choice to the end and constantly bump threads. Any reader of the massage section knows who I am referring to.

Having just gotten more into the massage realm of this business over the last 2 months, I am shocked at the all the shit that goes on there. It is clear that certain spas have there favorite client and that client will bash any other girl or spa. They will lie to no end too. I don't know how you guys even begin to filter through that crap. These Spas and their tactics are disgusting. I would hate to be a MPA or spa owner having to deal with that mess. The SP scene had its issues a few years ago where this was really bad, but agency owners got together and worked shit out and it has been better. Not so cut throat. I hope that will happen in the massage section, but I doubt it.
 
Unfortunately there are a lot of shills in the massage section. Actually not a lot, just a few but they post so much it becomes annoying as they really have nothing to offer but will defend their spa of choice to the end and constantly bump threads. Any reader of the massage section knows who I am referring to.
And ignores them.

No worries.
 
Certain accounts are known to be shills. Its sort of obvious in a few cases. I got banned on another board for pointing it out.
 
Post count, joint date...meh! Those careful shillers will try to plan very early, keep posting vague stuffs, joint from a few years before...and they are the most effective shillers, MO.

I'll give two cases which had made me very upset (then):

- A certain member most of you would know right away with the handle WN, who has quite a few posts, jointed much earlier than me... always shilling for an Asian agency in Sauga, got me decieved once with purposefully lower the age, paint a much younger age for a mid 30 yo... I challenged his review, and very surprised to see NOBODY chimed in the whole time, as if I was either the only one Terbie saw her or I was blind. You figure it out.

-When TO reborn, the very first lady got reviewed on Terb was Laura. Base on the two VETERANS who reviewed them here with raving details about her look her age and services. I took the bait WHOLE, booked 1 hour to see a late 30 yo (self-admitted) newbie from Vancouver, who did not really knew WHAT to do, looked her age too...

Where are the caring Terbies who might have seen those ladies? Only me? It is hard to continue to believe, to care for other members when at times like those NOBODY ever take stand, speak up.

So my conclusion for the OP: search, search, search... but most importantly BE PREPARED TO WALK, always.
 
I have to comment in this thread, as this has happened to me!

There is a thread I am mentioned in a few times, not really in a positive way. This is fine, I don't think it is a big deal as the people commenting are not anyone who have actually met me, so they can't speak to the type of service I provide. (It was more just a couple cranky remarks about the service I am offering. I do erotic massage, but leave my panties on during the massage, and some don't like this.) For the record, I do indicate this very clearly on my website so anyone that books with me knows exactly what to expect and what not to expect. I am very aware that when a client takes the time to meet with me, they are not only spending their money but also their valuable free time. My website lists my services very clearly to avoid any confusion or disappointment.

Anyway, this is getting a bit long winded, let me get to the point! I saw a regular client and he mentioned that he posted in the aforementioned thread to defend me. His heart was in the right place, and I do appreciate that he was trying to help me - but he's not active on terb and didn't realize that it would look as if I am posting myself. So now of course there are comments after his nice comments suggesting I posted them, which I didn't. (But then a few people who have met me and do have posting history posted some nice things...)

It's offensive that people would assume I am trying to promote myself in this way. I'm not an idiot, if I was trying to post a review of myself I certainly wouldn't make it obvious. I wouldn't bury it in a vague thread about caucasian massage girls, I'd make my own thread! ;) C'mon people! Give me some credit! I did manage to create a professional website and string a few pretty coherent sentences together for my ads and site. ;) I pay to advertise here, as well as a few other places and this keeps me happily in business. I don't want/need reviews. I can't be the only provider that feels this way. Sure some might like the spike in business that a review could create, but many of us are happily busy with regular clients and the new clients we get from our marketing efforts.

Please remember that many MANY men just lurk this board - they come to look at the ads, you don't need to be a member to just see the ads! They aren't actively posting, and they don't know that everyone gets their panties in a knot about shilling. I'm 393479392084730337% positive that many of the "shill" posts are people just like my client - people who are not active on the board. They mean well, they had a nice time, and they want to help someone they had a great time with promote their business. Give the women here some bloody credit. We're successful entrepreneurs! We understand how the board works! If we really wanted to shill we'd do a better job at it than posting something with a username that has a posting history of under 10 posts. ;)

- Allison
 
Allison, from your post you're obviously very articulate. I hesitate to expand on that further, for fear of being called a shill.

Just kidding!

But seriously though, some other SP/MPA's aren't as reasoned as you are and they've tried to register and post a positive review of themselves. I hadn't thought of it before but now I believe that many shill posts could be people "white knighting". I'm glad I created this thread, since I've learned a bit from it. :) On a related note, I've seen that kind of white knighting from some very respected members of the board as well. Between your post and the "puppy love" post from earlier it's been very informative.

But, I don't buy into any argument that generally runs "would it make any sense for me to do it"? It may not make sense to you, but people would do it anyways. Some people aren't that bright, or maybe they are and rely on the plausible deniability of the whole situation. Either way, while it's offensive to see a positive review of yourself and be offended when the person is called a shill other people have unfortunately ruined it for you.

As I said before, time will prove you right. If you're a quality SP/MPA then it will come out in the end even if people start crying "shill!" in the short term.