I`ve been on TERB for a while and in that time I`ve seen a lot of shill posts. I`ve also seen some posts that are questionable and opinion ends up being fairly divided about their authenticity.
Recently I posted on a thread that was a good example of a post that ended up with a divided opinion:
https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?424061-Carlyn-Moore-in-TO-One-of-the-best-nights-of-my-life
It got me thinking about the criteria for a shill post. What is it that makes you suspicious about a good review?
To me, there are a few criteria:
1) Registration date: if it`s in the last month (maybe two) it has to make you wonder.
2) Post count: first post is a positive review, it has to make you wonder
3) Language: it`s harder to define but men and women may write differently, which is sometimes apparent in the post
4) The SP/MPA they are reviewing: new to business makes me a little leery of trusting the post as well
To me it isn`t any one thing or another, but usually a combination of factors. In the end, all it means is that in some cases I`ll discount the review entirely. Even if a SP/MPA did put up a shill review, it doesn`t mean that they aren`t worth a chance. It could be a mistake in judgement that has no bearing on the actual experience of a visit
There are some other factors I`ve thought about, but discounted:
Positive or Negative review: doesn`t matter. It could be a shill to promote business, or it could be a competitor trying to ruin someone else`s business.
Availability of SP/MPA: if they are going on vacation / have gone away when the review comes out then to me that doesn`t matter either. Any publicity is good publicity, especially if the review is referenced down the road
That isn`t to say that a person can use TERB to do research, pick an SP and then try to contribute by posting a review (either positive or negative). I`m sure that happens. If that describes your situation, please post your review and just realize some people make not put much weight into it. Don`t let it stop you, and you`ll be vindicated in the end.
But I`m curious what others think and thought it might be an interesting discussion. What makes you think a post may be / is a shill?
Recently I posted on a thread that was a good example of a post that ended up with a divided opinion:
https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?424061-Carlyn-Moore-in-TO-One-of-the-best-nights-of-my-life
It got me thinking about the criteria for a shill post. What is it that makes you suspicious about a good review?
To me, there are a few criteria:
1) Registration date: if it`s in the last month (maybe two) it has to make you wonder.
2) Post count: first post is a positive review, it has to make you wonder
3) Language: it`s harder to define but men and women may write differently, which is sometimes apparent in the post
4) The SP/MPA they are reviewing: new to business makes me a little leery of trusting the post as well
To me it isn`t any one thing or another, but usually a combination of factors. In the end, all it means is that in some cases I`ll discount the review entirely. Even if a SP/MPA did put up a shill review, it doesn`t mean that they aren`t worth a chance. It could be a mistake in judgement that has no bearing on the actual experience of a visit
There are some other factors I`ve thought about, but discounted:
Positive or Negative review: doesn`t matter. It could be a shill to promote business, or it could be a competitor trying to ruin someone else`s business.
Availability of SP/MPA: if they are going on vacation / have gone away when the review comes out then to me that doesn`t matter either. Any publicity is good publicity, especially if the review is referenced down the road
That isn`t to say that a person can use TERB to do research, pick an SP and then try to contribute by posting a review (either positive or negative). I`m sure that happens. If that describes your situation, please post your review and just realize some people make not put much weight into it. Don`t let it stop you, and you`ll be vindicated in the end.
But I`m curious what others think and thought it might be an interesting discussion. What makes you think a post may be / is a shill?

