Shill Posts

anonemouse

Well-known member
Aug 23, 2002
953
366
63
Toronto
I`ve been on TERB for a while and in that time I`ve seen a lot of shill posts. I`ve also seen some posts that are questionable and opinion ends up being fairly divided about their authenticity.

Recently I posted on a thread that was a good example of a post that ended up with a divided opinion:

https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?424061-Carlyn-Moore-in-TO-One-of-the-best-nights-of-my-life

It got me thinking about the criteria for a shill post. What is it that makes you suspicious about a good review?

To me, there are a few criteria:

1) Registration date: if it`s in the last month (maybe two) it has to make you wonder.

2) Post count: first post is a positive review, it has to make you wonder

3) Language: it`s harder to define but men and women may write differently, which is sometimes apparent in the post

4) The SP/MPA they are reviewing: new to business makes me a little leery of trusting the post as well

To me it isn`t any one thing or another, but usually a combination of factors. In the end, all it means is that in some cases I`ll discount the review entirely. Even if a SP/MPA did put up a shill review, it doesn`t mean that they aren`t worth a chance. It could be a mistake in judgement that has no bearing on the actual experience of a visit

There are some other factors I`ve thought about, but discounted:

Positive or Negative review: doesn`t matter. It could be a shill to promote business, or it could be a competitor trying to ruin someone else`s business.

Availability of SP/MPA: if they are going on vacation / have gone away when the review comes out then to me that doesn`t matter either. Any publicity is good publicity, especially if the review is referenced down the road

That isn`t to say that a person can use TERB to do research, pick an SP and then try to contribute by posting a review (either positive or negative). I`m sure that happens. If that describes your situation, please post your review and just realize some people make not put much weight into it. Don`t let it stop you, and you`ll be vindicated in the end. :)

But I`m curious what others think and thought it might be an interesting discussion. What makes you think a post may be / is a shill?
 
You are pretty much on the right track with your analysis, I use the same criteria. One thing I notice in many shill reviews is the line, "treat her well guys and she will return the favour", or something along those lines.
 
I use the same criteria and I also check a posters history if they don't have many posts, regardless of join date. Sometimes an old handle without many posts makes you wonder what makes them start reviewing now or the fact that they have always stood tall on one lady in particular.
The thread you linked to I remember and it did look suspect and sometimes it is the nature of the beast that is TERB. It is difficult to look at a newbie posting a good review and then accusatiions of shill come out, as do the WK's, especially a review of a girl who has very little intel on her here. This sort of thing makes me scratch my head. I don't want to besmirch a girls reputation, but I think that reviews like these can sometimes lend a hand at giving one pause to wonder about her a little more. They do more harm than good imo.
 
Along the same lines as dirkd101, if a poster has a limited number of posts and they're almost all about one provider, that's a hint. If their other posts are just useless comments and not reviews, that's another hint.
 
Agreed on the Join Date. There are lots of old handles created and held in reserve by shit disturbers. I find that many are used by owners to snoop and ask questions via pm.

Another indicator is the named. It's not a hard and fast rule, but names with numbers in them make me skeptical. I've noticed (moreso on other sites) that such names tend to be fake handles (used to shill or generate forum activity).
 
Along the same lines as dirkd101, if a poster has a limited number of posts and they're almost all about one provider, that's a hint. If their other posts are just useless comments and not reviews, that's another hint.

Yes, good point. Useless comments or negativity about other SPs in their history I red flag as well.
 
To me, there are a few criteria:

1) Registration date: if it's in the last month (maybe two) it has to make you wonder.

2) Post count: first post is a positive review, it has to make you wonder

3) Language: it's harder to define but men and women may write differently, which is sometimes apparent in the post

4) The SP/MPA they are reviewing: new to business makes me a little leery of trusting the post as well

I think these are great points if you want to weed out the amateur shills. But the real professional shills have more experience and are a lot more careful. Most of them will come off has long time members and will have lots of previous reviews. They will make sure they don't have the obvious mistakes like listed above.


I think anyone who relies on other peoples reviews as their main source of research should spend some time on other review sites like TripAdvisor or Yelp. Its totally possible to have one review say the place is 2 while another rates it a 10.. it makes you wonder who's telling the truth? In many cases they both are.. The fact is that everyone's tastes and preferences are different. What is a 10 to one guy is a 3 to another. Now add that with the fact that every guy treats their own appointment differently and you will see that totally relying on reviews is not the best way to make sure you have a great time.

Many people don't seem to realize that its almost impossible for an Escort to recreate the same experience every time for every person they meet. There is just too many varying factors. Those that do try can often come off as being mechanical. So reading a review and then going expecting the same experience is often a recipe for disappointment. I am not saying not to trust reviews, but to use them only as a guide. Many times if you have the right attitude and a few things, then I can almost guarantee that you will have an amazing experience.

Here are a few points that I feel will help ensure you have an amazing time every time. Most of this is based on feedback from I get from the girls.


1. Act like your going on a date with a girl you wanna impress. Personal grooming and good hygiene is very attractive to any female. Good experiences go both ways, and the more you give can often mean the you get.

2. Make sure you shower before you leave and another shower when you get to the location. Use lots of soap and make sure you pay extra special attention to all the cracks and crevices, especially your bum. I know two showers might seem much, but I think its better to be extra clean then just clean. Do Remember the last time you went down on a girl that smelled? Well I am pretty sure if she knew she smelt she wouldn't let you go there. This could also happen to you... So make sure its squeaky clean. (the biggest complaints I hear from the ladies are guys with smelly bums)

3. Brush your teeth and chew some gum. It also doesn't hurt to spray some cologne and try to make sure your nails are clean and trimmed. It also wouldn't hurt to trim your man bush.

4. There is nothing wrong with talking about your sexual preferences, but don't make it like an interview.. Going through an ABC list of services the moment you first meet can sometimes be a turnoff. Don't be afraid ask her what really turns her on and what totally turns her off and tell her what really turns you on or off.. I find that telling what you like or stuff your into is better than asking directly do you do this or that.. Many times there's a chance she might do something during the heat of the moment they she wouldn't do with others. The chances of this happening are increased dramatically if you follow points 1 to 3.

5. Treat her with the same respect you would give your wife or your mom. I know it sounds crazy, but some of you guys forget that many times your a complete stranger and these ladies are not only letting you into their place but is also sharing something that many consider very intimate. Making the girl feel like a whore(unless she wants to be) is not help with making sure you have the best time possible.


These are just a few points and there are many more. The most important point to remember is that you always have the choice of keeping your money and canceling the appointment. If you get to the appointment and you have any doubt in your mind then its better to cancel and save your money. Its impossible for every lady to make sure every guy they meet has the most amazing time. Sometimes people just don't click, so I feel its better to walk away then to stay, have a bad time and then blame the lady.




Thanks


Nicole
 
That's some very good advice Nicole.

I agree that there could be handles that are being held in reserve, and I'm living proof that they don't expire after periods of inactivity :)

Checking the post history is a good idea, and worth adding to the list. There are some members here that have post counts in the thousands, but very few are outside of the General forums.

Thanks again Nicole, great point of view
 
So let me get this straight you encourage new members to post reviews and get involved but your not going to believe a fucking work we say.
Makes perfect sense to me :confused:
 
So let me get this straight you encourage new members to post reviews and get involved but your not going to believe a fucking work we say.
Makes perfect sense to me :confused:

don't give a fuck what anyone says and you will be happier
 
3) Language: it's harder to define but men and women may write differently, which is sometimes apparent in the post

That's the red flag for me. I find that men rarely call other men "gentlemen" on here, although it does happen. Pair that with beautiful (rather than hot/sexy), foreplay (rather than cbj/bbbj/daty), and ladyparts (rather than pussy) and I seriously start to question a post's authenticity. Plus, I think that's the first time I've ever heard a man describe sex as "lovely". Maybe the OP is just a feminine writer?
 
So let me get this straight you encourage new members to post reviews and get involved but your not going to believe a fucking work we say.
Makes perfect sense to me :confused:
Write your honest opinions, conveying as true a sense as you can of the experience, with as much accurate detail as you can recall, and share as you feel moved to. Or not.

What anyone else cares to respond in good judgement or bad is their problem. It's pointless to argue, and demeans you to insult, although you may well earn karma by lighting their error-filled darkness a bit more than you did in your earlier post.

And by proof-reading the words you thought were so important that TERB should read them, and by showing a grasp of intensifiers thinking adults use that might make your old teacher proud instead of despairing.

Once the 'Shill!' accusations start flying to and fro, only psychologists specializing in juvenile sociopathology have anything to gain from reading further. The rest of us already made our own evaluation of the OP and of any useful responses that it provoked.
 
Besides many of those factors, the one thing I will look at is other reviews. If an experienced member whom I trust has a similar encounter, I am inclined to believe the review.
 
Anything that contains a lot of superlatives is gonna be sketchy.
Anybody who is constantly posting about the same place, and hijacks threads to discuss the place (or places) he is plugging.
And beware the White Knights. By their deeds shall ye know them.
 
So let me get this straight you encourage new members to post reviews and get involved but your not going to believe a fucking work we say.
Makes perfect sense to me :confused:

That's pretty much it, and it's not so hard to understand. I'm not the voice of the entire TERB community.

I'm not going to necessarily believe a new members first review. Others might. Down the road you could get proven right and the SP/MPA could be a gem. I may look a little deeper and check your other posts, and decide from there. The more experienced the user (and the more reviews they have given) the more weight I give to a review.

If you don't like it, move on. I'm not very worried what you or anyone on here thinks of me. If you're posting things on an anonymous message board like TERB and you're worried about what other people think of you then you're going to have an unpleasant time eventually. My advice is to learn to develop a thicker skin.
 
I'm not going to necessarily believe a new members first review. Others might. Down the road you could get proven right and the SP/MPA could be a gem. I may look a little deeper and check your other posts, and decide from there. The more experienced the user (and the more reviews they have given) the more weight I give to a review.

If you don't like it, move on. I'm not very worried what you or anyone on here thinks of me. If you're posting things on an anonymous message board like TERB and you're worried about what other people think of you then you're going to have an unpleasant time eventually. My advice is to learn to develop a thicker skin.

I'm quite glad that you don't care what anyone here thinks of you because if you use anonymity to be a bully and rude to others, you're a coward... but of course, you don't care what I think.
 
So let me get this straight you encourage new members to post reviews and get involved but your not going to believe a fucking work we say.
Makes perfect sense to me :confused:


Not exactly as black and white as the way you put it. There are times when new users come up to write an amazing review about a certain lady and after that they vanish. Never to post again. Bottom line... Reviews are not really for the sake of telling you to go see someone, but its more for the sake of giving you an idea of what to expect. A shill review sorta seems more like an ad then someone explaining a session.
 
I'm quite glad that you don't care what anyone here thinks of you because if you use anonymity to be a bully and rude to others, you're a coward... but of course, you don't care what I think.

I'm not sure if you're attempting to call me a bully and/or a coward. Either way, you're right I don't care. You're entitled to your opinion.

To move off the derail, I was considering what Nicole posted above and the idea of "professional shills" led to me something else: endorsements. I recall in the past reading about long-standing TERB members who would try for discounts for a positive review (which I suppose would presumably have some weight behind it if they were experienced, respected, posted lots of reviews, etc.). I seem to recall reading something about that a long time ago, an SP/MPA saying they had been approached with the offer. Does anyone else remember that, or have you heard of something similar?

The problem with this scenario is that it would be pretty tough to weed those out. Hopefully no one stoops to it, and SP/MPA's report it.
 
For me, it is really easy to tell if a newbie's review is a shill or not. I find that pretty easy to see through and ignore.

The bigger problem is the high post guys who post reviews designed to suck up for "favours". It takes time to figure out who they are so you can ignore them. Frankly, I discount any review where it is obvious that the lady in question knows, or can easily figure out, which client wrote the review.

Join dates and low post counts aren't the exclusive domain of the shill.
 
I think one thing all you vets forget was what it was like when you first found TERB, found the hobby, found that SP that actually did her job and did it well.

Guys can get just as school yard crushie as a woman can. You guys get all smiles and giggles, and on that high and then write that glowing review and it does come across as too good to be true, but really, it was just written on the high.

Same with negative reviews. So mad that the disdain, disrespect, hurtful words come out because you feel that negative feeling.

Try waiting and writing your review with no emotion. It is just a review after all. Stick to the facts, leave the emotion at that door and be as honest and tasteful as possible. I also think that if the lady knows you and your TERB handle prior to the appointment, it should be posted in the review. It will help with what the wangbang said about suck up reviews.