Sex Work is Work

In this climate of uncertainty I cannot help but notice a major increase in whorophia. Sex work has always been stigmatise but some of us sometimes step up for our community like in this article in The Star yesterday.

I felt touched by her words as I can clearly relate receiving threats and others on a daily basis. Maybe sharing that here will open further discussion in the right direction.

The Ontario government shut down strip clubs. More so, they’ve continued to dehumanize sex workers, like myself

ByxxBarbara SarpongxxContributor

Fri., Oct. 2, 2020

I have to admit when I was initially approached to write this article, I was very reluctant. As a dancer in a strip club, the current media attention, as well as our government’s actions surrounding sex work, has been dehumanizing for me and my peers.

In this time of a pandemic — when we’re all doing our best to stay afloat — bars can remain open, casinos can reopen, but sex work continues to be mocked. As fellow dancer Nicki Rampage said, “We just want to keep our regulated safe work environment. We are happy to continue with mask wearing, all the safety precautions, and the new curfew. We just don’t want the industry to be singled out and shut down.”

If those other establishments are allowed to open, why aren’t we able to continue working?

As a Black woman, a dancer, and a mother, I hope to bring to light the unseen and unheard struggles. I am hopeful we can move toward the destigmatization of the industry, because after all, sex work is work.

The day starts when my alarm goes off. I get up, meditate, exercise, squeeze in a healthy breakfast, and set goals for the day. I am on my way to work, but I don’t walk into an office. I walk into a strip club. The morning routine remains the same whether it’s 9 a.m. or 9 p.m.

My job is solely commission based. I go to work, typically not expecting a pay cheque. As an independent contractor, I receive no company benefits, and have to pay a floor fee the establishment charges to work there. If I do not gross any commission from the evening’s sales and gratuities from customers, I'll be leaving work with less money than I came with. It is literally the cost of doing business.

It is a risk that dancers face on a regular basis. There can be many hidden costs of doing business within the industry. Some direct out of pocket expenses consist of licensing fees, criminal background checks, transportation and accommodation if working out of town. Add hair, makeup, wardrobe and it can sometimes feel like a full performance art production.

Other realities are less visible, such as struggling to fill a resume, as well as the generally accepted misogynistic attitude toward sex workers in our society. Constant rejection and being judged on a regular basis allows one to develop a thick skin, and, an entertainer definitely needs one. But why is my work different than yours if it feeds my family and I?

Another common question a dancer gets asked is ‘Do you like your job,’ or ‘Why are you doing this?

I enjoy my job. My coworkers have become a part of my social circle. We share stories, create memories, build relationships. This job has given me the opportunity to network, travel, expand my knowledge, cross things off my bucket list, develop business etiquette, and form bonds with regulars who are supportive of the industry. It has also allowed me to be in control of my schedule as much as one would hope to be. To be honest, it would be my dream job if I could do it forever. Who wouldn’t be enticed by the opulence and the freedom often displayed on social media being an entertainer?

Ironically, I didn’t aspire to be a dancer. It usually wasn’t a common aspiration for someone who grew up in a small town. But I had trouble finding a job in spite of my educational background, and was facing lingering student loan debt. So when I realized that I was in my mid 20s, still living at home with $500 to my name, I made the conscious decision to give dancing a try.

I noticed right away that locating a Gentleman’s Club that was eager and willing to hire a Black girl with a darker complexion proved to be difficult. It was an industry reserved for the blond and blue, and this was an obvious roadblock for me. I’ve even had one club charge me $10 more because of a silly technicality that prohibits a certain amount of Black girls from being able to perform on stage at certain times, yet charges dancers in general a penalty of $10 for not doing shows. I’ve been straightforwardly told “no Black girls,” by certain clubs. I’ve even been set up and sabotaged by bouncers and other staff who did not want me to make money in their club. Intersectionality within the industry has always been an issue. Thankfully, the best establishments have understood the need for diversity.

My shift typically starts with preparation in the change room if I don’t show up ready from home. This has been where I’ve personally gotten to know the dancers best because we can talk the most candidly about our experiences. Coming with little information about what a stripper is really like, I discovered that most were regular everyday women who desired moderate returns in their income, and needed flexibility in their schedule. One of the greatest ironies is that some of the most capable athletes, artists, psychologists, and sales representatives work in Gentlemen's Clubs right now, and we might not even realize it. Many move onto other professional ventures. It’s the stigma of stripping that holds us back.

There are many elements to the job. It’s not just dancing and collecting money, like many out there seem to think. The ability to communicate, present oneself, build rapport and set realistic goals which all are elements not just sex work, but any employment opportunity.

My sharing isn’t to simply glorify sex work, but at the very least, humanize sex work. With recent restrictions and shutdowns within the industry, it’s important that voices are heard. Many sex workers are not readily able to share their stories, and there is constant resistance from those who argue to invalidate the industry in general.

At the end of the day, we are all human. Let’s challenge each other to amplify understanding and rise up against the stigmatization of sex work, because sex work is work!

​

Sex work is work and I agree with her points of SW's being stigmatized by our government and the general public as a whole, I also agree with the experiences she posts about and it's sad to read and see it's still happening in the strip club industry but her argument about strip clubs being unfairly targeted currently during the pandemic is false.

What people need to understand regarding strip clubs re-openings and subsequent shutdowns is this:

The Ontario government (Conservative Doug Ford) was more than fair with the strip clubs about re-openings.
Strip clubs were allowed re opening their establishments before the government allowed bars/nightclubs to reopen which shows that the government treated them more fairly than others, they put the onus on the strip club owners/management, staff (including dancers) and customers to follow the guidelines, but the very high majority in every single category Owners/Management, Staff/Dancers, Customers failed the test miserably.

The strip club owners failed in making sure their staff and customers were adhering to the guidelines. The staff (including dancers) failed in following and enforcing the guidelines on customers. The customers failed in following the set guidelines. But this shouldn't be of any surprise to anyone as the way strip clubs operate (stage shows/contact dances) is something that doesn't combine well with the preventive measures needed (Social distancing/masks) against COVID.

These guidelines are adhering to mask, social distancing rules on the premises meaning not just the floor, but also the VIP and change rooms for staff and having customers follow these rules, as well as other contact tracing and other preventive measures.
Non compliance issues of COVID-19 guidelines is evidence of it and so are the numerous posts on this board. They (owners, staff, customers) have no one to blame but themselves.

When you have someone writing an article using the false argument of "strip clubs are being unfairly targeted" as an attempt to bring awareness to SW's being stigmatized by the general public and our government it takes away her credibility and doesn't help their cause in any way, they are not going to gain any support from the general public which is what is needed if they ever want any changes to the current system, they will even drive people's support away who understand a part of their argument is false.

Important thing to note today SW's are significantly less stigmitized by the general public not withstanding the politicians than they were 10, 20, 30 or even more years ago, view of SW has become a lot more tolerant and understanding in the last few decades in Canada and specially in Ontario.


As fellow dancer Nicki Rampage said, “We just want to keep our regulated safe work environment. We are happy to continue with mask wearing, all the safety precautions, and the new curfew. We just don’t want the industry to be singled out and shut down.”

If those other establishments are allowed to open, why aren’t we able to continue working?
​


Strip club owners, dancers and the strip club industry in general from the beginning should have taken the guidelines the government set in the fight against the Coronavirus more seriously rather than now claiming they are willing to follow the set guidelines of masks and social distancing as well as others when they didn't to begin with.

They didn't follow the guidelines and now they are complaining and wondering why they are facing secondary shutdowns. The lack of self awareness as a whole by those in the strip club industry is mind boggling.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: squeezer and fall
How much would CRA charge to do your taxes? Right now I pay a firm about $1000 with no cheating...maybe I’ll get a better deal with the CRA...haha

Nothing. They do it already to check what you send in.
Instead, they would just send you their file, and if you want to do it yourself to add deductions and other things they wouldn't apply themselves, you do so.
If you have a basic one, you just check it against what your boss sent you and go "Yup! looks good" and ignore it.

The only reason this doesn't happen already is the tax preparing companies like HR Block and Intuit or Quicken or whatever they are called have lobbied the fuck against it because it would cut into their business.
 
Nothing. They do it already to check what you send in.
Instead, they would just send you their file, and if you want to do it yourself to add deductions and other things they wouldn't apply themselves, you do so.
If you have a basic one, you just check it against what your boss sent you and go "Yup! looks good" and ignore it.

The only reason this doesn't happen already is the tax preparing companies like HR Block and Intuit or Quicken or whatever they are called have lobbied the fuck against it because it would cut into their business.
When I was younger and a single employee I did my own taxes, it was easy and never disputed...later on their was more money involved and other people involved so I had a private firm do it so it was done properly.

Back to escorts, their tax returns are not that complicated...lots of cheating opportunities due to overblown expenses...
 
This isn’t about buying something at Wal-mart...
OK, if buying sex is not the same as buying goods from Walmart, but it sure similar to hiring a plumber or a cleaning services or getting haircut. It is providing the service for money. Yes, it is sex, so, maybe, additional regulations (like for alcohol sales) should be in place, but this is it. As soon as we change this attitude "buying sex is a completely different thing", the things will be much better. And SPs should be the first to change this attitude.
 
OK, if buying sex is not the same as buying goods from Walmart, but it sure similar to hiring a plumber or a cleaning services or getting haircut. It is providing the service for money. Yes, it is sex, so, maybe, additional regulations (like for alcohol sales) should be in place, but this is it. As soon as we change this attitude "buying sex is a completely different thing", the things will be much better. And SPs should be the first to change this attitude.

The chances of contracting an STD from any of those services are zero, and they all have your contact info.
 
I really don't know what should be close or open. In fact, I feel like they don't know either. In my book, when you don't know something you don't take a decision based on bias, pushing a part of the industry on the edge like we don't deserve the same consideration as any other business owner. Ignorance can be so hurtful. We are part of this economy too.

The government didn't take the decision of shutting down strip clubs based on bias, the exact opposite they saw an industry where for the most part wasn't following the set guidelines they had set for them to operate their business safely during a pandemic without it affecting the health and safety of the public negatively.
Unfortunately the government doesn't have the luxury of doing nothing during a pandemic to jeopardize other people's health.
The government knows and there is scientific data from around the world that proves places like strip clubs, bars and indoor spaces like restaurants where exposure to one another is for extended duration of times, and group exposures are unavoidable to be of significantly higher risk.

They can not be blamed for their decision to shut down strip clubs. That blame is on the shoulders of the owners, management, staff, and customers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: squeezer
The government didn't take the decision of shutting down strip clubs based on bias, the exact opposite they saw an industry where for the most part wasn't following the set guidelines they had set for them to operate their business safely during a pandemic without it affecting the health and safety of the public negatively.
Unfortunately the government doesn't have the luxury of doing nothing during a pandemic to jeopardize other people's health.
The government knows and there is scientific data from around the world that proves places like strip clubs, bars and indoor spaces like restaurants where exposure to one another is for extended duration of times, and group exposures are unavoidable to be of significantly higher risk.

They can not be blamed for their decision to shut down strip clubs. That blame is on the shoulders of the owners, management, staff, and customers.

Exactly! The numbers don't lie.
 
  • Like
Reactions: doggystyle99
The government didn't take the decision of shutting down strip clubs based on bias, the exact opposite they saw an industry where for the most part wasn't following the set guidelines they had set for them to operate their business safely during a pandemic without it affecting the health and safety of the public negatively.
Unfortunately the government doesn't have the luxury of doing nothing during a pandemic to jeopardize other people's health.
The government knows and there is scientific data from around the world that proves places like strip clubs, bars and indoor spaces like restaurants where exposure to one another is for extended duration of times, and group exposures are unavoidable to be of significantly higher risk.

They can not be blamed for their decision to shut down strip clubs. That blame is on the shoulders of the owners, management, staff, and customers.

To me it is little politic to satify the public opinion.

There was 1 outbreak in 1 stripclub. How many outbreak in restaurant, school, bar? We are just closing restaurant and bar. How many outbreak in hotels and Massage parlours?

The stripclub made the news. The public opinion is that we are higher risk when there is no valid statistic or research proving that. Some says that being in a crowded close environnement more than 15 min with someone is risky. However some will say that gym as a rate of 0.0023% of infection, intense physical activities kill the virus...maybe dancing or having ferocious sex is not that bad. But we don't know for sure lol.

Ford has to do something because the media were hungry of sensationalism that morning and yes indeed the people visiting /management ect. did not do their job but so a ish load of establishement of any kind. On the other hand, they are just fined and allowed to open 2 weeks later. This is where I feel they are targetted.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jenesis
To me it is little politic to satify the public opinion.

There was 1 outbreak in 1 stripclub. How many outbreak in restaurant, school, bar? We are just closing restaurant and bar. How many outbreak in hotels and Massage parlours?

The stripclub made the news. The public opinion is that we are higher risk when there is no valid statistic or research proving that. Some says that being in a crowded close environnement more than 15 min with someone is risky. However some will say that gym as a rate of 0.0023% of infection, intense physical activities kill the virus...maybe dancing or having ferocious sex is not that bad. But we don't know for sure lol.

Ford has to do something because the media were hungry of sensationalism that morning and yes indeed the people visiting /management ect. did not do their job but so a ish load of establishement of any kind. On the other hand, they are just fined and allowed to open 2 weeks later. This is where I feel they are targetted.

There is no sex in strip clubs :), Hence, clients are at high risk due to been in indoor setting for long period of time.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Josephine Grey
To me it is little politic to satify the public opinion.

There was 1 outbreak in 1 stripclub. How many outbreak in restaurant, school, bar? We are just closing restaurant and bar. How many outbreak in hotels and Massage parlours?

The stripclub made the news. The public opinion is that we are higher risk when there is no valid statistic or research proving that. Some says that being in a crowded close environnement more than 15 min with someone is risky. However some will say that gym as a rate of 0.0023% of infection, intense physical activities kill the virus...maybe dancing or having ferocious sex is not that bad. But we don't know for sure lol.

Ford has to do something because the media were hungry of sensationalism that morning and yes indeed the people visiting /management ect. did not do their job but so a ish load of establishement of any kind. On the other hand, they are just fined and allowed to open 2 weeks later. This is where I feel they are targetted.

Actually there were 2 different situations with 2 different strip clubs out of 50 in the whole province. Yes 2/50 strip clubs had cases with one being issued notice of non compliance for multiple infractions of not following the guidelines. There were also many if not all other strip clubs in the GTA who were not following the set guidelines which was quite surprising to me, but I am guessing they knew that the government had it's hands full and wasn't able to fully enforce these guidelines, and they took advantage of it.

If they were outbreaks at hotels or massage parlours as I've said numerous times we would have heard about it. The rate of transmission at places like hotels or even massage parlours is substantially lower than businesses like strip clubs, bars/restaurants, there is scientific data for this.
Understanding how the virus spreads and the importance of adhering to the set guidelines for each industry should and would answer this question of yours.

The strip clubs Coronavirus cases made the news because unlike other businesses who have notified the public right away when cases happened, in both strip clubs instances they did not notify the public of the positive cases right away, again the strip clubs did not notify the public through social media or press releases, it was the Public Health Agency who made the announcement a few days later for the protection of the general public and the media picked up on the news specialy after they found out they were issued non compliance notices.
That's not sensationalism by the media, that is the media doing their job of relating important news to the public, just like they did with covering the numerous restaurants and fast food joints having cases or breaking the guidelines or the gyms, or the Ontario farms having outbreaks and so on.

As for Ford needing to do something, as much as people like to ignorantly complain about the Provincial government not doing enough and then simultaneously complain they are overstepping with the measures they are undertaking, Ford has done a great job at making sure he is not rash in his decision making, he has carefully taken the recommendations of Public Health officials based on science and carefully thought out his response on what to do so that the economical part of the province is not too adversely affected.

It's disingenuous to have sympathy for these owners or any other businesses for the matter who broke the set guidlines jeopardizing people's health and are now suffering the consequences of their actions and rightfully so for it by subsequent shutdowns, meanwhile these businesses and people are the cause of actually prolonging any sense of normalcy or prolonging economic recovery.
 
Actually there were 2 different situations with 2 different strip clubs out of 50 in the whole province. Yes 2/50 strip clubs had cases with one being issued notice of non compliance for multiple infractions of not following the guidelines. There were also many if not all other strip clubs in the GTA who were not following the set guidelines which was quite surprising to me, but I am guessing they knew that the government had it's hands full and wasn't able to fully enforce these guidelines, and they took advantage of it.

If they were outbreaks at hotels or massage parlours as I've said numerous times we would have heard about it. The rate of transmission at places like hotels or even massage parlours is substantially lower than businesses like strip clubs, bars/restaurants, there is scientific data for this.
Understanding how the virus spreads and the importance of adhering to the set guidelines for each industry should and would answer this question of yours.

The strip clubs Coronavirus cases made the news because unlike other businesses who have notified the public right away when cases happened, in both strip clubs instances they did not notify the public of the positive cases right away, again the strip clubs did not notify the public through social media or press releases, it was the Public Health Agency who made the announcement a few days later for the protection of the general public and the media picked up on the news specialy after they found out they were issued non compliance notices.
That's not sensationalism by the media, that is the media doing their job of relating important news to the public, just like they did with covering the numerous restaurants and fast food joints having cases or breaking the guidelines or the gyms, or the Ontario farms having outbreaks and so on.

As for Ford needing to do something, as much as people like to ignorantly complain about the Provincial government not doing enough and then simultaneously complain they are overstepping with the measures they are undertaking, Ford has done a great job at making sure he is not rash in his decision making, he has carefully taken the recommendations of Public Health officials based on science and carefully thought out his response on what to do so that the economical part of the province is not too adversely affected.

It's disingenuous to have sympathy for these owners or any other businesses for the matter who broke the set guidlines jeopardizing people's health and are now suffering the consequences of their actions and rightfully so for it by subsequent shutdowns, meanwhile these businesses and people are the cause of actually prolonging any sense of normalcy or prolonging economic recovery.
To me it is little politic to satify the public opinion.

There was 1 outbreak in 1 stripclub. How many outbreak in restaurant, school, bar? We are just closing restaurant and bar. How many outbreak in hotels and Massage parlours?

The stripclub made the news. The public opinion is that we are higher risk when there is no valid statistic or research proving that. Some says that being in a crowded close environnement more than 15 min with someone is risky. However some will say that gym as a rate of 0.0023% of infection, intense physical activities kill the virus...maybe dancing or having ferocious sex is not that bad. But we don't know for sure lol.

Ford has to do something because the media were hungry of sensationalism that morning and yes indeed the people visiting /management ect. did not do their job but so a ish load of establishement of any kind. On the other hand, they are just fined and allowed to open 2 weeks later. This is where I feel they are targetted.

I honestly believe the underlying problem is the blue kleenex and string everyone is wearing for masks. When the pandemic was at is worst the word was minimum N-95 of which I have several and the difference between the N-95 and the garbage people are wearing is substantial.

Fast forward and we now see people wearing this rediculous plastic contraption for whatever bizarre reason, on top of that protecting the mucous membrane of the eye is a thing of the past where once everyone had glasses or goggles on now only prescription eye wearing people are properly suited up.

LJ
 
To me it is little politic to satify the public opinion.

There was 1 outbreak in 1 stripclub. How many outbreak in restaurant, school, bar? We are just closing restaurant and bar. How many outbreak in hotels and Massage parlours?

The stripclub made the news. The public opinion is that we are higher risk when there is no valid statistic or research proving that. Some says that being in a crowded close environnement more than 15 min with someone is risky. However some will say that gym as a rate of 0.0023% of infection, intense physical activities kill the virus...maybe dancing or having ferocious sex is not that bad. But we don't know for sure lol.

Ford has to do something because the media were hungry of sensationalism that morning and yes indeed the people visiting /management ect. did not do their job but so a ish load of establishement of any kind. On the other hand, they are just fined and allowed to open 2 weeks later. This is where I feel they are targetted.
I think another factor in the open/closure issue is how essential is the business...
 
You guys had the legal right to purchase sex for years, while the ladies were criminalized, you had your turn to make yours voices heard during all the C-36 hearings and now that the deed is done, you want to say that sex work is not real work because NOW it affects you? Ok pumpkin.

Sex work is real work. Period. You try it and tell me different. Until then, you clearly have no clue what you are talking about and are just acting out of selfishness.
Not the best attitude cause you present yourself as a victim ? You choose to do this job so make your way in society and stop complaining?
is many luxuries in working in the sex game let’s be honest you all make real good ( quick) money
You make your own schedules and if you are any good pick your clients right ?
i agree shutting down strip bars in this times is bullshit but again we have to own up to our choices
This is a great time to look yourself in the mirror and ask is my chosen career considered a must have ? Or are you worthless like let’s say waitress or bartender ?
sorry
 
  • Angry
Reactions: Jenesis
Not the best attitude cause you present yourself as a victim ? You choose to do this job so make your way in society and stop complaining?
is many luxuries in working in the sex game let’s be honest you all make real good ( quick) money
You make your own schedules and if you are any good pick your clients right ?
i agree shutting down strip bars in this times is bullshit but again we have to own up to our choices
This is a great time to look yourself in the mirror and ask is my chosen career considered a must have ? Or are you worthless like let’s say waitress or bartender ?
sorry

Who’s complaining???? Who’s playing victim??? All I see is guys complaining and playing victim because they are now criminalized.

Remember exactly who you are talking to bubba. Seriously. I own my own business and do this for funzies as a form of safe and secure paid dating. I just did an interview where I explained why I have never had a bad date and only two time wasters in my career since 2014. Because I am privileged enough to be able to choose my clients “right”. Many do not have the same privilege and it has nothing to do with success but everything to do with outside sources and influences impacting their life or career. Judging them for it is beyond rude, ignorant and ridiculous.

Also I would not call waitresses or bartenders worthless. That is a very elitist attitude to have. Maybe you should take some time to reflect on your attitude towards people and their jobs.

Clearly you have some issues about people that you need to work out. Calling people worthless based on their job.... like can you have anymore of an entitled elitist attitude. It is disgusting. Check yourself buddy. With an attitude like that, you just may very well be the person who is worthless in this world.
 
Last edited:
Actually there were 2 different situations with 2 different strip clubs out of 50 in the whole province. Yes 2/50 strip clubs had cases with one being issued notice of non compliance for multiple infractions of not following the guidelines. There were also many if not all other strip clubs in the GTA who were not following the set guidelines which was quite surprising to me, but I am guessing they knew that the government had it's hands full and wasn't able to fully enforce these guidelines, and they took advantage of it.

If they were outbreaks at hotels or massage parlours as I've said numerous times we would have heard about it. The rate of transmission at places like hotels or even massage parlours is substantially lower than businesses like strip clubs, bars/restaurants, there is scientific data for this.
Understanding how the virus spreads and the importance of adhering to the set guidelines for each industry should and would answer this question of yours.

The strip clubs Coronavirus cases made the news because unlike other businesses who have notified the public right away when cases happened, in both strip clubs instances they did not notify the public of the positive cases right away, again the strip clubs did not notify the public through social media or press releases, it was the Public Health Agency who made the announcement a few days later for the protection of the general public and the media picked up on the news specialy after they found out they were issued non compliance notices.
That's not sensationalism by the media, that is the media doing their job of relating important news to the public, just like they did with covering the numerous restaurants and fast food joints having cases or breaking the guidelines or the gyms, or the Ontario farms having outbreaks and so on.

As for Ford needing to do something, as much as people like to ignorantly complain about the Provincial government not doing enough and then simultaneously complain they are overstepping with the measures they are undertaking, Ford has done a great job at making sure he is not rash in his decision making, he has carefully taken the recommendations of Public Health officials based on science and carefully thought out his response on what to do so that the economical part of the province is not too adversely affected.

It's disingenuous to have sympathy for these owners or any other businesses for the matter who broke the set guidlines jeopardizing people's health and are now suffering the consequences of their actions and rightfully so for it by subsequent shutdowns, meanwhile these businesses and people are the cause of actually prolonging any sense of normalcy or prolonging economic recovery.

One-third of Toronto’s community outbreaks related to bars and restaurants, says new COVID-19 data


By Jennifer PagliaroCity Hall Bureau
Thu., Oct. 8, 2020timer5 min. read

JOIN THE CONVERSATION (
3

)
Of the 80 current community outbreaks of COVID-19 in the city, 27 of them are related to bars and restaurants, the Star has learned.
The latest data from Toronto Public Health, current to Oct. 7, shows that bars and restaurants in Toronto remain responsible for a significant number of outbreaks — 34 per cent — at a time when the city’s top doctor has urged the province to intervene to reduce virus spread, including prohibiting indoor dining.
Previously, TPH had linked 44 per cent of outbreaks between Sept. 20 and 26 to bars, restaurants and entertainment venues.


Of those, 18 were restaurants and bars, one was a nightclub and one was an adult entertainment club, the public health unit clarified Thursday.


The data TPH released Thursday doesn’t include outbreaks in schools or congregate settings like long-term-care homes.
Though health experts say time is of the essence to take measures to prevent exponential growth in new cases, the city and province still can’t agree publicly on whose responsibility that is.
Speaking to reporters on Thursday, Mayor John Tory said lawyers for both governments had met and agreed the province is in a better position to prohibit indoor dining, group gym classes and unnecessary trips outside the home as recommended by Dr. Eileen de Villa, Toronto’s medical officer of health.“Our people came out of that meeting with the recognition having been extended on the part of the provincial people that the powers the city had were not as broad as had been suggested publicly earlier on, and that the most efficient, broad-reaching powers to do things in the interest of public health and to stop the spread of COVID-19 rested with the province of Ontario,” he said. De Villa has said she could be held personally liable for taking her recommended actions herself, and that such broad measures have not been attempted by other local officers of health.

But responding to a series of questions from the Star on Thursday, Premier Doug Ford’s government outlined why it believes the city can impose these measures itself.
“Medical officers of health have the authority to issue individual or class orders under Section 22 of the Health Protection and Promotion Act where the legal test is met, which could include the closure of businesses like bars and restaurants,” said the emailed statement from Carly Luis, spokesperson for Minister of Health Christine Elliott.
“There are multiple examples of medical officers of health doing so, including when Dr. de Villa ordered mandatory home quarantine for people with COVID-19, and anyone who has had close contact with someone infected.”
The latest back-and-forth comes nearly seven days after de Villa made her request.
The Star earlier reported that a modelling study published in May in the journal Nature looked at how effective measures were, based on the timing they were implemented. When China had 114,325 cases on Feb. 29, intervening a week earlier could have meant a 66 per cent cut in cases, the authors estimated. Delaying action by even a week would have seen cases triple, they wrote.​

Rest of the article here https://toronto.ctvnews.ca/seven-covid-19-cases-tied-to-downtown-toronto-restaurant-1.5121698
https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/2020/10/08/is-this-the-best-route-east-york-homeowners-get-early-warning-their-property-is-needed-for-the-11b-ontario-line.html?li_source=LI&li_medium=star_web_ymbii


18 restaurants and bar....2 stripclubs. It just proves my point. Targeted to satisfy the public opinion.
 
One-third of Toronto’s community outbreaks related to bars and restaurants, says new COVID-19 data


By Jennifer PagliaroCity Hall Bureau
Thu., Oct. 8, 2020timer5 min. read

JOIN THE CONVERSATION (
3

)
Of the 80 current community outbreaks of COVID-19 in the city, 27 of them are related to bars and restaurants, the Star has learned.
The latest data from Toronto Public Health, current to Oct. 7, shows that bars and restaurants in Toronto remain responsible for a significant number of outbreaks — 34 per cent — at a time when the city’s top doctor has urged the province to intervene to reduce virus spread, including prohibiting indoor dining.
Previously, TPH had linked 44 per cent of outbreaks between Sept. 20 and 26 to bars, restaurants and entertainment venues.


Of those, 18 were restaurants and bars, one was a nightclub and one was an adult entertainment club, the public health unit clarified Thursday.


The data TPH released Thursday doesn’t include outbreaks in schools or congregate settings like long-term-care homes.
Though health experts say time is of the essence to take measures to prevent exponential growth in new cases, the city and province still can’t agree publicly on whose responsibility that is.
Speaking to reporters on Thursday, Mayor John Tory said lawyers for both governments had met and agreed the province is in a better position to prohibit indoor dining, group gym classes and unnecessary trips outside the home as recommended by Dr. Eileen de Villa, Toronto’s medical officer of health.“Our people came out of that meeting with the recognition having been extended on the part of the provincial people that the powers the city had were not as broad as had been suggested publicly earlier on, and that the most efficient, broad-reaching powers to do things in the interest of public health and to stop the spread of COVID-19 rested with the province of Ontario,” he said. De Villa has said she could be held personally liable for taking her recommended actions herself, and that such broad measures have not been attempted by other local officers of health.

But responding to a series of questions from the Star on Thursday, Premier Doug Ford’s government outlined why it believes the city can impose these measures itself.
“Medical officers of health have the authority to issue individual or class orders under Section 22 of the Health Protection and Promotion Act where the legal test is met, which could include the closure of businesses like bars and restaurants,” said the emailed statement from Carly Luis, spokesperson for Minister of Health Christine Elliott.
“There are multiple examples of medical officers of health doing so, including when Dr. de Villa ordered mandatory home quarantine for people with COVID-19, and anyone who has had close contact with someone infected.”
The latest back-and-forth comes nearly seven days after de Villa made her request.
The Star earlier reported that a modelling study published in May in the journal Nature looked at how effective measures were, based on the timing they were implemented. When China had 114,325 cases on Feb. 29, intervening a week earlier could have meant a 66 per cent cut in cases, the authors estimated. Delaying action by even a week would have seen cases triple, they wrote.​

Rest of the article here https://toronto.ctvnews.ca/seven-covid-19-cases-tied-to-downtown-toronto-restaurant-1.5121698
https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/2020/10/08/is-this-the-best-route-east-york-homeowners-get-early-warning-their-property-is-needed-for-the-11b-ontario-line.html?li_source=LI&li_medium=star_web_ymbii


18 restaurants and bar....2 stripclubs. It just proves my point. Targeted to satisfy the public opinion.

You may assume 2/50 strip clubs having cases is not a significant problem, you may also assume their non compliance at an industry level is also not a problem, but Toronto Public Health certainly does think it's a problem, any epidemiologist would also agree with that assessment.

All of your assumption does not change the fact that 2 out of 50 strip clubs that we have heard about had outbreaks and neither one of them acted like other businesses have by issuing public notices right away, your assumptions also doesn't change the fact 1 strip club was issued multiple notices of non compliance, and most of the others adult entertainment clubs in Ontario weren't adhering to the set guidelines.
You may also assume they are targetting strip clubs but it also doesn't change the fact that strip clubs were allowed to reopen way before bars and nightclubs did which shows they were very tolerant of strip clubs.

None of the above is targeting the strip club industry, they are basing the closures on the facts rather than making rash decisions.
As I've said there is so much scientific data that had proved this would happen in these types of establishments (bars/clubs) in Ontario as it has happened across the world.

An important fact is these 2 strip clubs that had outbreaks are probably 2 of the more strict and cleaner venues in the city.

Also from one of your own articles it says one adult entertainment club was involved in outbreaks between September 20th-26th, that timeline does not match the Brass Rail cases as that was earlier in August or the Paradise outbreak as that was earlier in September.
So which strip club did cases happen between September 20-26?
 
Last edited:
You may assume 2/50 strip clubs having cases is not a significant problem, you may also assume their non compliance at an industry level is also not a problem, but Toronto Public Health certainly does think it's a problem, any epidemiologist would also agree with that assessment.

All of your assumption does not change the fact that 2 out of 50 strip clubs that we have heard about had outbreaks and neither one of them acted like other businesses have by issuing public notices right away, your assumptions also doesn't change the fact 1 strip club was issued multiple notices of non compliance, and most of the others adult entertainment clubs in Ontario weren't adhering to the set guidelines.
You may also assume they are targetting strip clubs but it also doesn't change the fact that strip clubs were allowed to reopen way before bars and nightclubs did which shows they were very tolerant of strip clubs.

None of the above is targeting the strip club industry, they are basing the closures on the facts rather than making rash decisions.
As I've said there is so much scientific data that had proved this would happen in these types of establishments (bars/clubs) in Ontario as it has happened across the world.

An important fact is these 2 strip clubs that had outbreaks are probably 2 of the more strict and cleaner venues in the city.

Also from one of your own articles it says one adult entertainment club was involved in outbreaks between September 20th-26th, that timeline does not match the Brass Rail cases as that was earlier in August or the Paradise outbreak as that was earlier in September.
So which strip club did cases happen between September 20-26?
Nono lol I win you lose 🙃
 
our government is led by a blackface wearing stupid racist. dont expect too much from him.
When did Ford where blackface? It wouldn't surprise me, but never heard that he did. You mean Ford right, because the shut down of strip clubs are not federal. Each province regulates the response. WOW.
 
  • Like
Reactions: doggystyle99