I'm not surprised.
The Browns are doing what the Dallas Cowboys did in 1989, take a short term hit for long term gain. It worked for the Cowboys with 3 Super Bowl wins in the 1990's, if they get it right history could repeat itself.
It's an interesting trade..
Clearly in the short term it benefits the Colts. Richardson is still very young, and actually played pretty well last season (Although not well enough to justify his 3rd overall selection). He's a rarity in today's NFL in that he's a running back that can do it all (run, block and pass catch) and the Colts had a need at that position with Ballard gone for the year and Bradshaw still coming back after a foot injury. The major issue with Andrew Luck the last two years has been the number of times he's been hit. He's already on pace to be knocked down 112 times this year, by far the most in the NFL. The Colts O-Line sucks and you can't have your franchise guy be exposed to the punishment like he has. Richardson will help, both with his blocking, and by serving as a dump-off guy for short passes. As well, he is talented so defenses will have to respect him a bit and that opens up plays downfield.
From the Browns POV, between this trade, and the decision to start Brian Hoyer at QB this week (Mike Lombardi, their GM has been a big Hoyer supporter since he was Tom Brady's backup) they've given up on being competitive this year. A little surprising given that their division is weak this year, with only the Bengals as a contender. (Pittsburgh sucks, and Baltimore will have a hard time generating offense). Brandon Weeden, who the Browns traded up to grab two years ago, is not the answer at QB, they feel.
This will be one of those trades that can't be fairly judged for another few years at least. It also has the potential to benefit both teams. I still don't think the Colts are a viable Super Bowl threat, even with Richardson.
It will be a loooong season for the Browns fans though. And poor Brandon Weeden
I think what their front office and coaching staff looked at was that even with T-Rich, offensively the Browns were at most a six-win team. Without a decent QB, no receivers other than Gordon and Cameron, and a terrible O-Line, the Browns aren't going to be a playoff team. Now, they have ammunition to move up in next year's draft to grab one of the star QBs (most likely Teddy Bridgewater, or Tajh Boyd, although it's waaay too early to tell), plus with all their other picks, they can bulid depth. Running backs can be found later in the draft or even undrafted (Like Alfred Morris and Arian Foster) and Richardson didn't show enough to prove that he's that exceptional of a talent.
It's ridiculous/absurd to compare the 2 trades.
.
Another difference in the trades is the era . THe league has evolved and is very different now than it was back then. They said on TA the other day that there was more passing in the first 2 weeks of the 2013 season than there ever has been in the first 2 weeks of a season in NFL history. The value of the RB position just isn't as high as it once used to be.
Guess I am old school.
You still got to run the ball in the NFL.
Regardless if the offense is more pass orientated or run orientated, your QB must convert 3rd downs.
Let's not forget Al Davis. Outside speed to stretch the field.
Tonight, the best drive by KC was it last one where they ran down the field, after converting that big 3rd and long from their 5 yard line.
As for this trade, it is hard to believe they are giving up the Browns after week 2 this season.
Try that in the NHL!
:frusty:
Good breakdown mur11. I would also add that Trent will be seeing a lot of 2-high safeties playing in IND which means a lot of 7-man defensive fronts so that should benefit his production as well. I remember watching him when he played at Bama and thinking that his running style was reminiscent of Earl Campbell. And you are 100% correct that Trent will also benefit the passing game in IND because of his ability to be a checkdown and catch balls out the backfield and because he can pick up the blitz and do a good job in pass-pro. Moreover, when you have a good ground game play-action is always gonna be there for you and that will buy Luck an extra 1/2 second which may not seem like a whole lot but in the NFL where things happen so fast 1/2 second can be the difference between a sack or an explosive play in the passing-game. And while the league has become a passing league in the past 5-6 years and teams are passing the ball more now than ever before I still think there are benefits to having a strong ground game including the following...
a) It helps to regulate the pass-rush
b) Play-action can create some voids in the defense
c) If you run the ball well enough defenses may have to drop a safety into the box which means you now have one-on-one
matchups on the outside in the passing game
d) A good running game will benefit your 4-minute offense when you want to clock-out a game
Agree on your point about drafting running backs too. Generally I don't like to spend a high 1st round pick or even a 1st round pick for that matter on a halfback. You can usually get good value drafting a running back in a later round . Plus running backs have a short-shelf life (though that might be changing given that the league is more pass-oriented now and because most teams employ a 2-back system rather than having a feature back or bell-cow so RBs don't take as much of a beating as they once used to) and I'd rather use a 1st round pick on a player with a longer shelf-life.
Old school says, "Three things can happen when you pass the ball and two of them are bad."Guess I am old school.
Tonight, the best drive by KC was it last one where they ran down the field, after converting that big 3rd and long from their 5 yard line.
Old school says, "Three things can happen when you pass the ball and two of them are bad."
Maybe they'll start having "drives" like in the CFL, i.e. 5 plays-92 yards, 3 plays-86 yards which are basically zero ball control and one huge play for a score. The beauty of the NFL are those ball control drives of double digit plays where the offense gets first down after first down using all different sorts of tactics and the defense is playing its' heart out to try and stop them. An inexorable march down the field carries a certain drama to it.
At some point the trend will go back to the "5 yards and a cloud of dust" behind a huge O-line and a bruising fullback. With the right personnel, very tough to stop and much lower risk. Sure, everyone loves the flashy passing game, but it is fraught with peril and if the passing dominates the league, it could be too much of a good thing. Like I said, trends come and go and at some point the running game will re-emerge.
Good point about the 2-high safeties and 7-man fronts. Another reason why T-Rich has to be pretty happy right now.
It's interesting the difference of opinions about Richardson. I've heard the Earl Campbell comparisons, and I've heard Mike Mayock (who is one of the best talent evaluators right now IMHO) say he's an elite talent. There's also an article on NFL.com by Mike Lombardi who pushed for this trade now, prior to the 2012 draft (where Richardson was selected) where he says that Richardson is a 'blue-chip talent' and 'the safest pick in the draft'
But I've also heard guys like Jim Brown say that he's nothing special as a RB. Clearly Lombardi's opinion must have changed in the year or so he's watched Richardson in the NFL.
Dude are you serious? I can't stand this Mayock clown, he's so annoying. And don't even get me started, Trent Dilfer??? Let's put it this way he was a better QB than he is an analyst.Mayock is GREAT aint he? The dude talks like he is a professor. And have you seen Mayock's work during the Scouting Combine every year? This dude must watch more game-tape than anyone in the business. He is not always right on his projections but its sports not science so no one is gonna be 100% right but his opinions are as well-informed and educated as anyone's in the business. Probably one of my 3 fav color analysts in football right now is Mike Mayock. I do miss Jaws from MNF though . I was always a big fan of him and I think its too bad ESPN moved him out of the booth with Tirico and Gruden. Also, Trent Dilfer is one HELL of a good color analyst. Really enjoyed him calling that SD game in the 2nd game of the MNF double-header in week 1. I wish ESPN would allow him to call more games because he does a really good job of analysing and educating the viewers.
Dude are you serious? I can't stand this Mayock clown, he's so annoying. And don't even get me started, Trent Dilfer??? Let's put it this way he was a better QB than he is an analyst.
Love the MNF guys, Gruden is the bomb. But my fav analyst is Darryl "Moose" Johnston, former Cowboy fullback. This guy knows his stuff inside and out and is an absolute pleasure to listen to.