race to mars

Asterix said:
Swell. Name something even close to realization.

Nuclear propulsion is one option being explored.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
Nuclear propulsion is one option being explored.
Being explored? This idea has been kicked around since the 60's. So far I haven't heard anything new that puts this anywhere near reality'
 
Asterix said:
Being explored? This idea has been kicked around since the 60's. So far I haven't heard anything new that puts this anywhere near reality'

There are other options too. I'm not a NASA engineer I just know a manned trip to Mars would not be in a conventional rocket. The journey would begin from Earth's orbit.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
No, because history says so. Columbus was looking for a better trade route, not "new lands to spoil".
Let's be real here. Columbus was expected to bring back something of value, not simply give the King some crude maps to China. Once it became clear a new land had been discovered the looting began in earnest.
 
Asterix said:
Let's be real here. Columbus was expected to bring back something of value, not simply give the King some crude maps to China. Once it became clear a new land had been discovered the looting began in earnest.

Columbus was expected to find a better trade route to India. Finding the Americas was an accident.

How about Sir Edmund Hillary? What riches was he to find and loot in the antartic?

Since we're being real.......
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
Columbus was expected to find a better trade route to India. In the process he would prove the earth was round. Finding the Americas was an accident.

How about Sir Edmund Hillary? What riches was he to find and loot in the antartic?

Since we're being real.......
It was Amundsen, Scott, and Shackleton that went to the Antarctic first. Btw, if you would like a really good read on Scott's failed attempt to get to the South Pole and back, "The Worst Journey in the World" is likely the best chronicle of exploration I have ever read. Very highly reccommended. I have a great respect for explorers. The motivations of those behind them I am far less confident. And yes, to be real, Europeans pretty much took the Americas as a land of spoils.
 
Asterix said:

I have also "heard" of something called an ion drive. Then there's the worm hole principal that I'm sure they are investigating (that's where you create a fold in the space time continuium (spelling?) and instead of travelling the 2 million kilometers, you travel 53 kms or something like that.

There was a physicist in Brazil I think it was who wrote the formula that proves you can create an artificial worm hole. Now to actually do it is another story.
 
tboy said:
I have also "heard" of something called an ion drive. Then there's the worm hole principal that I'm sure they are investigating (that's where you create a fold in the space time continuium (spelling?) and instead of travelling the 2 million kilometers, you travel 53 kms or something like that.

There was a physicist in Brazil I think it was who wrote the formula that proves you can create an artificial worm hole. Now to actually do it is another story.

They explained the part about creating a fold in the space time continuium and instead of travelling the 2 million kilometers, you travel 53 kms or something like that. in the movie Event Horizon.

That's how the space ship travels over extreme distances. It created a fold in the space time continuum. The guy in the movie explained it in detail, how it works.

if anyone has seen the movie. He explained it perfectly, that instead of travelling 2 milliion kilometers, you bend space itself to shorten the distance.
Except something went catastrophically wrong. I can't say, because then I'd be giving away the spoiler to the movie..

Oh and to answer the question to this thread, as to why we would even bother going to mars?

Simple answer. I'm surprised nobody figured it out.

The simple and extremely basic answer is to avoid the scenario in Armageddon starring Bruce Willis or that other lame meteroid copycat movie that came out in the same year, I believe.
 
tboy said:
We're spending trillions of dollars on getting there when we should be concentrating on taking care of the planet we live on.

No one is spending trillions on space. The NASA budget at the height of Apollo was about 4% of the US national budget, and it very quickly (since the early 1970s) declined to between 0.5 and 1.0% and has stayed that way ever since. The 2007 budget is $17 billion, just 0.58% of the total U.S. budget. Here's some actual facts, instead of some random guy talking out of his ass: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NASA_Budget

The U.S. in 2003 spent about the same amount (perhaps more) on the Iraq war as the *entire* 50 year history of the U.S. space program.

Fixing Earth first? Just what more do you think will be done with that extra 0.58% ($17B) that wasn't accomplished by all the money annually spent by the NSF ($6B) and NIH ($28B), or the hundreds of other research agencies around the world? Or perhaps you think it should be put into social programs? Social programs that already eat up 52% of the U.S. annual budget?

If anything, we should be spending more on space. With things like space-based solar power we'd both put a cap on global warming and achieve energy independence from the oil interests. With a telescope on the moon or in deep space, we could spot asteroids that are on a collision course with earth and possibly do something about it, avoiding mass extinction of ourselves and all other macroscopic life on the planet. And by going to Mars, we can learn about the planet most like our own in the solar system, and if there is or isn't life now or in the past, that will tell us a lot about the universe and the possibility for life in it; we can also settle there and elsewhere, so that all our eggs are not in this one basket. Studying Venus and Mars taught us about global warming and global cooling. It's called comparative planetology. It allows us to understand other worlds that have simpler atmospheres and climates, providing a useful baseline for theories about the Earth's environmental systems. If we want to "take care of the planet we live on" then we have to do all these things in space. Not doing so would be suicide.

If I was American, I'd think that's worth a lot more than the 58 cents out of every $100 in taxes I'd be paying.

As a Canadian, the measly $375M we spend annually on the Canadian Space Agency is embarrassingly small, more like 1 cent for every $100 in taxes.
 
red said:
wasn't sir edmund hilary the first to scale everest?

Yes.

He also travelled to the south pole (amoung other adventures). I thought he was a good example of an explorer not interested in the spoils of conquest.
 
Asterix said:
It was Amundsen, Scott, and Shackleton that went to the Antarctic first. Btw, if you would like a really good read on Scott's failed attempt to get to the South Pole and back, "The Worst Journey in the World" is likely the best chronicle of exploration I have ever read. Very highly reccommended. I have a great respect for explorers. The motivations of those behind them I am far less confident. And yes, to be real, Europeans pretty much took the Americas as a land of spoils.

I used the example of Sir Edmund Hillary because in my opinion he is an example of an explorer in the purest sense. Very good book indeed. I've read it. Thanks.

The desire to explore is a noble human trait, it demonstrates a willingness to face the unkown in a quest for knowledge. The majority of history's explorers were motivated by being the first to go where no man has gone before, not by conquest or pillaging.

You say Europe took the Americas as a land of spoils, I won't argue that. The discovery of the Americas however came from a willingness and desire to venture into the unkown.
 
Ok twentynine a couple of points:

Where did I say "only the US" was spending money? Please point it out because I didn't.

Using your link, the US alone has spent $359 BILLION dollars. Now one would have to assume that the Russians have spent a similar amount so add another $359 BILLION dollars and if my memory is correct, it was stated that to get to mars would cost over 1 trillion dollars. So, do the math: 1.72 trillion dollars just for two countries. EOS my friend, I'm not talking out of my ass. Now I KNOW you're going to come back with the fact that the $359 B wasn't spent only getting to mars, but really, anything over 1 is a plural so (with typical budget overruns) just getting to mars will cost trillions of dollars.

Now I realize that many medical, communication, and technological innovations are a result of the various space programs but let's think for a second: take 1% of that money and buy food. One could probably feed every starving person on the planet for their lifetime with that. Take another 1% of that and put it into alternative fuels research and we'd solve our greenhouse gas problem. Believe me I'm not a social renegade or bible thumper but I see a LOT of waste in how money is spent.

For eg: I read somewhere that during WWII, we used as much energy during the war that we had spent up until that point. During Ken Burn's series "The War" they stated that for every mile the army advanced in Europe they burned something like 100,000 gallons of gasoline.

As for the movie reference to folding space. Yes, that was where I first heard of it but there was also a show out on the discovery channel on various topics and one segment was on folding space or creating an artificial wormhole.
 
tboy said:
Ok twentynine a couple of points:
Where did I say "only the US" was spending money? Please point it out because I didn't.

I never said you did. Now you are imagining things out of thin air.
I used the U.S. as an example because they've spent the vast majority of the total spend on space -- I'll prove it below.

Using your link, the US alone has spent $359 BILLION dollars. Now one would have to assume that the Russians have spent a similar amount so add another $359 BILLION dollars and if my memory is correct, it was stated that to get to mars would cost over 1 trillion dollars.

You're memory is not correct. There is no plan to spend $1 trillion or more on going to Mars. That is entirely fictitious, and not unexpectedly, pulled right out of your ass. I know the space industry, and I know the costs. A human landing on Mars can be done for $20-30 billion. NASA's current plan calls for about $140 billion, which would be spent as $5B per year over 28 years.

Your assumption about the Russians is also completely wrong (definitely pulled out of your ass). The Russians have never landed on the moon so they have not had that expense. The Russians don't have a space shuttle that cost $500-650 million to launch each time like the Americans do -- they're Soyuz costs about $60-80 million, but it's not reusable. The entire annual budget of the Russian Space Agency is $900 million, which is not even 3 times the size of Canada's.

So, do the math: 1.72 trillion dollars just for two countries.

That's really funny. "doing the math" on fictitious numbers.

The total annual amount spent on space by all countries worldwide this century is $25B annually. The U.S. spends $17B of that, or 68%.

So based on the U.S. number of $359B it might be reasonable to project that the world expenditure over the past 50 YEARS would be about $528B -- however, most nations only got started in the 90's, so it's probably less that $500B total.

EOS my friend, I'm not talking out of my ass. Now I KNOW you're going to come back with the fact that the $359 B wasn't spent only getting to mars, but really, anything over 1 is a plural so (with typical budget overruns) just getting to mars will cost trillions of dollars.

Again with the fictitious math. Why don't you actually research your numbers before you run your mouth off?

You've acknowledged that the total wasn't spent on Mars. Do I need to say more about that and your "math"?

Now I realize that many medical, communication, and technological innovations are a result of the various space programs but let's think for a second: take 1% of that money and buy food. One could probably feed every starving person on the planet for their lifetime with that. Take another 1% of that and put it into alternative fuels research and we'd solve our greenhouse gas problem. Believe me I'm not a social renegade or bible thumper but I see a LOT of waste in how money is spent.

Yeah, you and your imaginary friends "see" a problem. You're making stuff up and "seeing" a problem! That's called a strawman argument.

In 2005 worldwide *private" investment in alternative energy technologies has been $80B. In 2006 it grew to $100B. In the past five years there has been more spent *privately* on alternative energy technologies than the world has spent on space for the past 50 years. That's not counting the amount spent by governments.

Compare it to just about *any* industry and see that less is spent on space in one year ($25B) than the thing in question:
* Pets (U.S.) -- $38B in 2006
* Gifts (worldwide) -- $50B
* Pharmaceuticals (worldwide) -- $220B
* processed Food (worldwide) -- $3.2 TRILLION
* processed Food (U.S.) -- $1 TRILLION

Tell me again how $25B annually could feed every starving person for their lifetime? How about all the fat people in the world eat 1% less -- That's $320 BILLION annually.

Do you want to admit you're wrong now, or later? C'mon, man up. If I was talking out of my ass and someone called me on it and proved what I said didn't have any basis in fact, I'd admit it, and I hope you and everyone else would too.

For eg: I read somewhere that during WWII, we used as much energy during the war that we had spent up until that point. During Ken Burn's series "The War" they stated that for every mile the army advanced in Europe they burned something like 100,000 gallons of gasoline.

Here's an interesting fact. The U.S. is paying about $1 per kW for energy used by the military in Iraq, compared to domestically produced energy at 5 cents a kW. The DoD is looking into space-based solar energy as a means to beam energy directly down to the theatre of operations so they have power at 10 cents a kW, anywhere in the world for future wars. Domestically doing the same thing would prevent wars over energy and water in the future too.
 
Ok, points one at a time:

1) How do you know what the russians spent on their space program? If you trust information on the net, you're nuts. Remember: only until in recent times the only information (or misinformation) that got out of the USSR meant that someone probably died getting it out and I don't think that someone would die for that info although stranger things have happened.
2) As for not having a lunar landing, that's arguable at best. There have been rumors that they did in fact place a lunar lander on the dark side many many years ago.
3) Remember: Russia had an orbiting space station for a hell of a lot longer than skylab. They also shuttled men and materials back and forth to it a lot longer than the US has.

So, using the above points, it is reasonable to assume that their space expenditures were very similar (although not exactly the same) as the US.

So, if you were inferring that you were only using the US as an example, why didn't you state "For eg:"??? By omitting that you insinuated (to prove your argument) that I was incorrect (if you're going to nitpick).

Here is a supporting document that supports my statement proving that I didn't pull the number "out of my ass"

http://home.marssociety.org/outreac...h_Space_Plan_TMS_Estimated_Costs_2Mar2004.pdf

SO, put THAT in your pipe and SMOKE it...(or shove it up your ass, whichever you prefer).

Now, I will admit that that document does state that the numbers can be argued as being inaccurate. But as we all know, that nothing costs what it is estimated based on past budgeting and final cost analysis of government involved projects.
 
As for the starvation statement: you even quoted it, I said probably, didn't say definitely.

I searched and couldn't find a number of how many people are actually starving right now. So, even at 10 M yeah, $25 B wouldn't be enough...you caught me, kudos *rollseyes*

I have to ask: what's your problem anyways? does it really matter if I'm off by a decimal points? It's not like you have cover the costs personally all by your lonesome!
 
To quote Dan Quayle on the importance of going to Mars "Mars is essentially in the same orbit [as earth]....Mars is somewhat the same distance from the Sun, which is very important. We have seen pictures where there are canals, we believe, and water. If there is water, that means there is oxygen. If oxygen, that means we can breathe."

So, there you have it... we can breathe on Mars, and it's not that far from us because it's in the same orbit. Who needs a spaceship... let's just jump off Earth and land on Mars. And of course, Martian water - ooooh!