I wasn't aware there was a check off on the tax form that gave anyone a choice. I'm all for sending up unmanned probes to other planets to figure out what is out there. Robotics are going to improve dramatically in the coming years, far past the current mini-rovers humping rocks on Mars, and I'm all for that. There is a reason why no one has sent a manned mission even back to our own moon in decades. It's been done, and makes no economic sense.Robio said:I would rather a portion of my tax money go to a space program then a war
See Red's post for what the Space Race gave us and I am sure there was allot more
Asterix said:I wasn't aware there was a check off on the tax form that gave anyone a choice. I'm all for sending up unmanned probes to other planets to figure out what is out there. Robotics are going to improve dramatically in the coming years, far past the current mini-rovers humping rocks on Mars, and I'm all for that. There is a reason why no one has sent a manned mission even back to our own moon in decades. It's been done, and makes no economic sense.
I don't think you can blame economics. Blame unrealistic expectations. Getting to the moon was an extraordinary feat, but I don't think anyone is pretending there is anything there that is going to benefit us anytime soon. Getting to Mars is on a completely different magnitude of difficulty, and exponentially more expensive. Remember whomever we send there we somehow also need to get back. Think for a moment about space travel and how it hasn't changed. Missile propulsion is relatively the same as it was for the Apollo missions. The rockets have simply gotten bigger.Robio said:It was very Good
unlike now
Asterix said:I wasn't aware there was a check off on the tax form that gave anyone a choice. I'm all for sending up unmanned probes to other planets to figure out what is out there. Robotics are going to improve dramatically in the coming years, far past the current mini-rovers humping rocks on Mars, and I'm all for that. There is a reason why no one has sent a manned mission even back to our own moon in decades. It's been done, and makes no economic sense.
You personally want to hump rocks on Mars, go knock yourself out.Robio said:Or is it better to go there yourself
Asterix said:Explain why it is neccessary to go to Mars to lead to improvements in technology or our way of life.
.You right space travel has not changed much without a difficult obstacle there will be no need for it to innovation and change. That’s why we need to do it and I bet we will discover all kinds of interesting things as a result of it.Asterix said:I don't think you can blame economics. Blame unrealistic expectations. Getting to the moon was an extraordinary feat, but I don't think anyone is pretending there is anything there that is going to benefit us anytime soon. Getting to Mars is on a completely different magnitude of difficulty, and exponentially more expensive. Remember whomever we send there we somehow also need to get back. Think for a moment about space travel and how it hasn't changed. Missile propulsion is relatively the same as it was for the Apollo missions. The rockets have simply gotten bigger.
Asterix said:You personally want to hump rocks on Mars, go knock yourself out.
More platitudes. I don't suppose it occurs to anyone that we need to clean up our act at home long before we will get to any place even remotely like Earth. The most barren desert on this planet likely is more teeming with life than anything else in this solar system.lookingforitallthetime said:Improvements in technology is not the reason to go to Mars, it's the inevitable by-product of going.
We are explorers. We don't need a reason to go to Mars other than it's there and we can.
Asterix said:More platitudes. I don't suppose it occurs to anyone that we need to clean up our act at home long before we will get to any place even remotely like Earth.
I'll tell you why. Because it would be contrary to our entire history. The main reason we went into new lands looking for spoils, is that we had already spoiled what we had.lookingforitallthetime said:Corny though it is, it's a fact. Man is an explorer. Besides, why can't we clean up our act at home and explore?
Asterix said:Think for a moment about space travel and how it hasn't changed. Missile propulsion is relatively the same as it was for the Apollo missions. The rockets have simply gotten bigger.
Asterix said:I'll tell you why. Because it would be contrary to our entire history. The main reason we went into new lands looking for spoils, is that we had already spoiled what we had.
Swell. Name something even close to realization.lookingforitallthetime said:This is where you're wrong. Rockets will not be carrying astronauts to Mars.
A mission to Mars would require new propulsion technology.