race to mars

tboy said:
As for natural resources: any resources they find there will be too expensive to bring back here and they could be only used there. I know they are talking about colonies but that's a long way off. I'd say they have a better chance of building a colony on the moon than mars.

As we start to run out of our own natural resources, and the cost go up, maybe the cost of bringing them back from other planets will not see so "astronomical"
 
Papi Chulo said:
As we start to run out of our own natural resources, and the cost go up, maybe the cost of bringing them back from other planets will not see so "astronomical"

LOL@ astronomical, that's a good one!

Unless they solve the lack of gravity situation (and that situation is pretty...ahem...grave indeed) and the fuel required it will be a tough sell.

But I was reading up on the logistics involved and it was stated by some rocket scientist that putting a manned craft on mars is like threading a needle in california from NYC.

But then again, I'm impressed that the engineers were/are able to compress a uranium sphere 24" in diameter to one 2" in diameter using shaped explosive charges (and the sphere is perfected round afterwards).
 
tboy said:
LOL@ astronomical, that's a good one!

Unless they solve the lack of gravity situation (and that situation is pretty...ahem...grave indeed) and the fuel required it will be a tough sell.

But I was reading up on the logistics involved and it was stated by some rocket scientist that putting a manned craft on mars is like threading a needle in california from NYC.

But then again, I'm impressed that the engineers were/are able to compress a uranium sphere 24" in diameter to one 2" in diameter using shaped explosive charges (and the sphere is perfected round afterwards).

What's impossible today may be commonplace a few years down the road.

Before the days of rail it would have been impossible to go from Toronto to Montreal and back again in the same day.

Once the train came about it could be done.

Today with the highways we could not only do it, but also spend several hours at a Montreal strip club before returning.

If man is to survive, we must expand to other planets and solar systems. No matter how good our recycling gets we will eventually run out of resources here. And even if we could achieve 100% there is always the danger of getting whacked by an asteroid or the like.

Yes the gravity well is a huge problem to overcome, but technology is moving along on solving that. "space elevators" used to be the things of SciFi, but I've seen one article that seemed to suggest the technology is there to build it, just need the $$.
 
I disagree with space exploration.
We need to realize we're stuck on Earth and we better fix the damage we've caused. All we did at the moon was leave a bunch of junk, the space station is a launching pad for nothing.
We have so many unsolved mysteries at home, why not explore them? The knowledge gained would probably help in more ways than what we got from space.
 
trisket said:
I disagree with space exploration.
We need to realize we're stuck on Earth and we better fix the damage we've caused. All we did at the moon was leave a bunch of junk, the space station is a launching pad for nothing.
We have so many unsolved mysteries at home, why not explore them? The knowledge gained would probably help in more ways than what we got from space.

And where would that leave us when we run out of resources? We can never get to 100% recycling so eventually the planet will be used up. Entropy always increases.
 
If we run out of resources, then we should accept being compost.
It will give the earth a deserved rest.
 
verbalks said:
It gives mankind something to aspire to, rather then new ways to kill each other.
So our choices are to bankrupt ourselves trying to get to a barren rock, or inventing new ways to kill ourselves. Wonderful.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
The long term gain is the development of new technologies that could one day lead us to explore the stars or at the very least, lead to improvements in our way of life.

Explain why it is neccessary to go to Mars to lead to improvements in technology or our way of life.
 
Asterix said:
So our choices are to bankrupt ourselves trying to get to a barren rock, or inventing new ways to kill ourselves. Wonderful.

This reminds me of the movie "flight of the phoenix". The survivors of a plane crash in the desert had a choice: make their water last for as long as possible on the off chance that they might be rescued (like 1 in 10,000) or use it up all at once trying to get out of the desert.
 
It brings a Nation or nations together on a common goal which stimulates the economy. Hey it is better then a War and wars do not seem to stimulate Industry as much as it did in the past .
 
Robio said:
It brings a Nation or nations together on a common goal which stimulates the economy. Hey it is better then a War and wars do not seem to stimulate Industry as much as it did in the past .
Given that most wars have been fought over gaining territory, you might want to rethink the whole nations coming together argument. Also why anyone thinks spending $Trillions to send and sustain a manned mission to Mars, which by the way is over 200 times as far from us as our own moon, is going to be beneficial to the economy is beyond me.
 
Can't wait till the elite leave earth and let the meek inherit.
 
Not all Nations

Asterix said:
Given that most wars have been fought over gaining territory, you might want to rethink the whole nations coming together argument. Also why anyone thinks spending $Trillions to send and sustain a manned mission to Mars, which by the way is over 200 times as far from us as our own moon, is going to be beneficial to the economy is beyond me.

I said Nations come together Not all the Nations come together.

You need to spend Money to make money. The Moon Mission generated allot of revenue for allot of business and contributed to the quality of life we enjoy now.

Nothing ventured, nothing gained.
 
Robio said:
I said Nations come together Not all the Nations come together.

You need to spend Money to make money. The Moon Mission generated allot of revenue for allot of business and contributed to the quality of life we enjoy now.

Nothing ventured, nothing gained.
Thanks for the slogans. Name something of significant scientific knowledge that was gained by landing astronauts on the moon that couldn't have been achieved by experiments in near outer space.
 
The Apollo program has helped change the way of life in America. Here are some of the contributions of the Apollo program:

Cool suits, which kept Apollo astronauts comfortable during moon walks, are today worn by race car drivers, nuclear reactor technicians, shipyard workers, people with multiple sclerosis and kids with a congenital disorder known as hypohidrotic ectodermal displasia.
Special kidney dialysis machines were developed as a result of a NASA developed chemical process that could remove toxic waste from used dialysis fluid.
A cardiovascular conditioner developed for astronauts in space led to the development of a physical therapy and athletic development machine used by football teams, sports clinics and medical rehabilitation centers.
Athletic shoe design and manufacture also benefited from Apollo. Space suit technology is incorporated into a shoe's external shell. A stress-free "blow molding" process adapted from NASA space suit design is also used in the shoe's manufacture.
Insulation barriers made of aluminum foil laid over a core of propylene or mylar, which protected astronauts and their spacecraft's delicate instruments from radiation, is used to protect cars and trucks and dampen engine and exhaust noise.
Vacuum metallizing techniques led to an extensive line of commercial products, from insulated outer garments to packaging for foods, from wall coverings to window shades, from life rafts to candy wrappings and from reflective blankets to photographic reflectors.
Water purification technology used on the Apollo spacecraft is now employed in several spinoff applications to kill bacteria, viruses and algae in community water supply systems and cooling towers. Filters mounted on faucets can reduce lead in water supplies.
Freeze-dried food solved the problem of what to feed an astronaut on the long-duration Apollo missions.
A hospital food service system employs a cook/chill concept for serving food. The system allows staff to prepare food well in advance, maintain heat, visual appeal and nutritional value while reducing operating costs.
A hollow retroreflector, a mirror-like instrument that reflects light and other radiation back to the source, is used as a sensor to detect the presence of hazardous gases in oil fields, refineries, offshore platforms, chemical plants, waste storage sites and other locations where gases could be released into the environment.
 
Asterix said:
Thanks for the slogans. Name something of significant scientific knowledge that was gained by landing astronauts on the moon that couldn't have been achieved by experiments in near outer space.
Proof that the moon isn't made of green cheese.

That it is easier to get things into space then to get them back to earth.

I dream of Jeannie?
 
verbalks said:
Proof that the moon isn't made of green cheese.

That it is easier to get things into space then to get them back to earth.

I dream of Jeannie?
OK, I'll give you I Dream of Jeannie. Barbara Eden was hot.