Prostitution illegal in canada?

Harper put his Christian Evangelical slant on the new prostitution law which his government was forced to write and enact by a certain deadline because the Supreme Court of Canada struct down the previous one. The current law is a lame duck law which is ignored and not enforced for the most part. In Ontario the Attorney General under the previous Premier Wynne was instructed to ignore Bill C36, so Ontario LE did nothing. Enforcement of Bill C36 was not even on the radar as an election in the recent Doug Ford win so maybe not much will change in Ontario. Interestingly, NOW Magazine has stopped allowing prostitution ads in their backpages and they claim it is to do with the strength of online advertising over print media but it could also be due to a new government in Queens Park. There seems to be few challenges to the new law that are likely to make it to the Supreme Court at this point. In the GTA, the number of full service brothels aka, massage and holistics has gone way up since the new law has come in, particularly in York Region. Incall, Outcalls and Independants seem to be flourishing, competition is heavy. LE seems to only make arrests if the prostitutes are underage, human trafficking with foreigner working as sex workers in Canada or anything involving black pimps. All others whether they are prostitutes or their tricks seem to be giving a free pass at this point. The Bedford Case which caused the law to be changed would be ignored if it was happening today, actually similar activities are now freely operating.
 
This article is from four years ago. There were plenty of thoughts given on the matter then. Unless you're less asking for opinions on the article, and more for how opinions have changed in the four years since.
 
LE not enforcing Bill C-36 in Toronto because we have thugs with guns keeping LE busy.
 
London, Ont. court case to challenge Canada's prostitution laws

Toronto lawyer James Lockyer is representing two people charged after a bust at an escort service

Kate Dubinski · CBC News · Posted: Feb 05, 2018 3:42 PM ET | Last Updated: February 7

Canada's prostitution laws are being put to the legal test in a London, Ont. courtroom where two people are charged with advertising sexual services, profiting from the sex trade and producing a person to offer sexual services.

The first defence expert witness called in the case, academic Chris Atchison, testified that the new law, often referred to as Bill C-36, makes it less safe for people in the sex trade to do their jobs.

"I believe the application of these laws makes things worse for the most vulnerable people on the street but also for others in the sex industry," Atchison told the court.
The case before the court is that of Hamad Anwar and Tiffany Harvey. They face more than two dozen sex-related charges each, including making money from the sex trade, advertising sexual services, and forcing someone into the sex trade.

The charges relate to a bust made by London police at an escort service in November 2015.

The accused are being represented by well-known Toronto lawyer James Lockyer.

Lockyer doesn't dispute that his clients ran an escort agency. But at issue in Tuesday's proceedings are three charges under Canada's three-year-old prostitution law, often referred to as Bill C-36:

Advertising someone else's sexual services
Benefiting financially or otherwise from someone else's sexual services
Procuring a person to offer a sexual service (a charge that can be laid against a pimp, for example).

Lockyer declined several interview requests from CBC News.

'We always knew there would be a constitutional challenge'

Experts have predicted it was only a matter of time before Canada's three-year-old prostitution laws, contained in Bill C-36, were challenged.

The new laws criminalize the advertising and buying of sex — but decriminalize its sale.

Proponents say it's the right model because it punishes people who buy sex, not those who sell it.

But opponents say the laws force sex work further underground and criminalize advertising sex, which allows those in the sex trade to screen their clients ahead of a meeting.

"Prostitution is male violence against women, which is a serious barrier to gender equality and is incompatible with the internationally-accepted principles of human rights," said Megan Walker, the executive director of the London Abused Women's Centre.

"We always knew there would be a constitutional challenge. I think it's good to have some closure on this, although I recognize that getting to the Supreme Court could be years away. It will highlight the issues and I am confident that at the end of the day, the ruling will stand."

Canada's new prostitution laws were passed at the end of 2014.

'Radical feminists versus harm reduction'

On the stand, Atchison characterized the deep divide among those who are for and those who are against the country's new prostitution laws, also known as the Nordic Model, as a difference of opinion between "radical feminists" and those advocating for "harm reduction."

A witness who will testify for the Crown, Maddie Coy, "comes at this from the vantage point of seeing the sex industry as an institution of the patriarchy, and prostitution as violence against women. It's the prohibitionist, radical feminist perspective," he said.

Others, such as Atchison himself, see sex workers as "making choices and engaging in labour."

Studies that show that the sex industry has shrunk in Sweden, which has similar laws to ones enacted here, are conducted by people who have a vested interest in the laws succeeding, and don't reflect reality, Atchison said.

"The fact that there are fewer street sex workers could be attributed to technology. They went off-street with the use of cell phones and the Internet. We've seen a steady decline in the number of people working on the street for the last 20 years."

The court case continues Tuesday afternoon.

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/london/london-ontario-bill-c-36-prostitution-laws-1.4520736
 
In Ontario the Attorney General under the previous Premier Wynne was instructed to ignore Bill C36, so Ontario LE did nothing.
This is inaccurate. Wynne did refer C36 to her AG for review; I do not believe there was ever any instruction for law enforcement agencies in Ontario to simply ignore.

Police in London, Ontario (to cite one example) have been very active in targeting prostitution and trafficking offenses.
 
Kadie,
My longer response was lost in cyber space so a shorter response to your question. I liked the way the man points were summarized.
Overall, if the intent is to tighten restrictions around the trade so that women can be safer and LE has specific guidelines within which they oprate, I am ok with that. Getting exploiters (pimps and traffickers) out of the game works for me. I am left with one area of discomfort, I.e. It puts a lot of power in the hands of LE to decide ndvdually who to arrest, or who not to. Rather like speed enforcement on the highway. And given that 'buyers' are their target I am a tad intimidated. But then again maybe turn about is fair play, as for so long the target of their attention was the women.
 
This is inaccurate. Wynne did refer C36 to her AG for review; I do not believe there was ever any instruction for law enforcement agencies in Ontario to simply ignore.

Police in London, Ontario (to cite one example) have been very active in targeting prostitution and trafficking offenses.

Have the police in London made any arrests and successfully convicted anyone who has purchased sex which would have an automatic five year sentence? I think that the answer is no, unless the prostitute was underage. Local community standards are at play in London, they want fronts for prostitution driven out of their municipality without LE directly using Bill C36. Kathleen Wynne said :

"The legal opinion that was provided to me is privileged, so I'm not going to express every single detail that was in the legal opinion, but the importance to you is that it's constitutionally sound,".

However, the only visible result of Bill C36, is that street action in major cities, namely Toronto has virtually disappeared. The number of full service brothels has mushroomed in the GTA, so customers from areas like London often travel to the GTA for service. This phenomenon seems to speak to the weakness of Bill C36 and the difficulties that LE would have in getting a conviction. Prostitutes have virtually immunity from prosecution and the johns have little fear of being arrested or convicted.
 
Oddly enough, I feel we were better off under the old laws, at least in the short term. Granted, they weren’t perfect but they were workable. Buying sex was legal, and it isn’t now. Having the ultra- Cons re-write the laws was an unmitigated disaster which we may be stuck with for some time. Politicians of all stripes will not initiate any change in the current law unless they are forced to, as it’s a political hot potato. That leaves another court challenge as the only way forward, which may be a long time coming before we see any light at the end of the tunnel. Part of the difficulty lies in the fact that politicians manipulate the law to suit their own ends. We saw it in the Bedford decision. Technically we won, but we really didn’t, as things are worse now than they were before - all a detriment to this industry. I hope for the best, but let this be a lesson that poking the bear can lead to unforeseen and unwanted consequences.
 
Hundreds of thousands of transactions are occurring every year as was the case with the old law. The society, government and LE are relatively tolerant of prostitution as long as under aged prostitutes or black pimps are not involved.
 
Hundreds of thousands of transactions are occurring every year as was the case with the old law. The society, government and LE are relatively tolerant of prostitution as long as under aged prostitutes or black pimps are not involved.

Lomotil,
I was somewhat taken aback by your comment. My question is not a smartass one, I really don't know..... Are black pimps targeted more than non-black pimps. Based on the stories we hear of sex traffickers from Asian countries or Eastern Europe, I would think that the worst pimps are not black.
 
Lomotil,
I was somewhat taken aback by your comment. My question is not a smartass one, I really don't know..... Are black pimps targeted more than non-black pimps. Based on the stories we hear of sex traffickers from Asian countries or Eastern Europe, I would think that the worst pimps are not black.

I didn't say or imply that the worst pimps are black. LE goes after the lowest hanging fruit and are happy to prominently display on the media black pimps that they have arrested to show that they are doing their job. Most madams and pimps in the GTA are not black, LE knows who they are they are giving a free pass for the most part. These individuals are aware of this privileged in this regard. LE averts the gaze to Asians pimping Asians, Caucasians pimping anybody, but there is little tolerance for Asians pimping Caucasians and zero tolerance for black pimps what so ever.
 
This articles was just updated with maybe some minor corrections. Remember that the outgoing PM Harper was extremely disappointed with the manner in which Bill C-36 was not rigorously enforced, meaning that if he got re-elected, then there would have been a major clampdown on this trade. "Johns" would be arrested and charged just for paying for the sexual services. There was a lot of scaremongering that under the present Trudeau Government, there would be "numerous brothels" offering sex on corner stores etc. This obviously has not occurred either. That is why Local Councils still licence Massage Parlours to the fullest extent provided they abide by the strict MP Rules, otherwise they would technically be illegal under Bill C-36.

So to answer OP's original question, nothing has really changed. The cops have enough on their plates, but no doubt they will me monitoring any obvious trafficking and will take action accordingly.
 
Kadie,
My longer response was lost in cyber space so a shorter response to your question. I liked the way the man points were summarized.
Overall, if the intent is to tighten restrictions around the trade so that women can be safer and LE has specific guidelines within which they oprate, I am ok with that. Getting exploiters (pimps and traffickers) out of the game works for me. I am left with one area of discomfort, I.e. It puts a lot of power in the hands of LE to decide ndvdually who to arrest, or who not to. Rather like speed enforcement on the highway. And given that 'buyers' are their target I am a tad intimidated. But then again maybe turn about is fair play, as for so long the target of their attention was the women.


Haha! I love how you say “cyber space”, yup I totally lost track of this thread. I didn’t anticipate so many responses but this is awesome! So I wonder if prostitution is legal? It’s so weird that it’s legal for us SPs but not for the gentlemen. That makes no sense to me lol. I think this raises the point that hobbyists should 100% stick to ladies they know and are comfortable with. If a hobbyist is taking risks by meeting random SPs with no reviews, it gives him a larger chance of something happening with the LE. Thays just my opinion! Maybe I’m wrong or maybe I’m right. Who knows! And yes, I’d hope that women is their target especially the under age women who are trapped etc.