Proroguing Government

Among the things that they sacrificed in order to suppress that committee are the bill to kill the long gun registry, and their entire tough-on-crime legislative agenda. It all died on the order paper when Harper pulled the trigger.

Actually, not really true. The bill to kill the long-gun registry is a private members bill, and they survive a prorogation. As to the others, they are easilly resurected in a new session.

I think their main objective was to kill the bill the opposition passed that required them to disclose what they know about the issue, I assume that too died on the order paper, along with everything the government was trying to do.

It was not a bill, but a motion, and your assumption about it dying with the prorogation is wrong.
 
The simple answer is that Parliament was getting in Harper's way, and he realized none of the folks he counts on for votes would actually blame him for not passing all the legislation he made all those big noises about. Noises like being the most accountable government ever. This way he just does what He wants. Much better.

Unless you're unaccountably fond of messy, difficult stuff like democracy in your government.
 
Its always a bad idea to get dragged into one of fuji's little political or medical causes. One only has to recall him seriously warning us about the dangers of Russia setting up a rocket base in Mexico. For some reason he has determined that , dispite not seeing all the evidence, that a war crime has likely been committed by turning prisoners over to local authorities. He has started numerous threads on the topic in the political section, all saying pretty much the same thing.

I never said that Russia would install rocket bases in Mexico. You are lying.

For all who are unfamiliar with train's dishonest ways, what I did was link to and discuss an article that raised the possibility that Russia could turn Mexico into a failed state by supplying advanced arms, training, and intelligence to drug cartels there, creating a massive security problem on the US border.

That is quite different than trains lying, dishonest misrepresentation.

People should note this and take anything train says with a grain of salt: He is a known misrepresenter.
 
The Harper Conservatives are more than willing to ride out the full term as is. They won't be willing to pull the plug as they feel the electorate will punish them, and they also need to make it to at least summer so that the boys and girls can be eligible for pensions. Harper and Giorno are doing what they can to keep the momentum against the Liberals going. No matter how the Liberals respond to a new budget and throne speech, they will probably be losers. The other element to this is that with party finances being limited to government hand outs and individual giving, this gives the Conservatives a change to beg for more money. The idea of the "coalition" was a huge money maker for the Conservative Party. Another possibility of the Liberals throwing the Conservatives out will generate lots of income.

The Liberals are well behind in fundraising. They were too addicted to corporate donations and have not figured out how to fundraise from individuals the way the Conservatives have. In the future, political games in the House will have an element of fundraising added.
 
What a wonderful country where the RCMP feels it can go off and investigate the military for acts on the battlefield..

The issue is not acts on the battlefield, but the policy of handing detainees over to the Afghans. That occurs at the bureuacratic and ministerial level in Ottawa, or at least at the General Officer level.

The questions is what did Peter MacKay know, and when did he know it. If he knew that Afghans were likely to be tortured, and he continued to order them turned over to their torturers, he is in potentially hot water, at least with respect to the Geneva Conventions.

Peter MacKay is a minister in Ottawa, not a soldier on the battlefield.
 
Actually, not really true. The bill to kill the long-gun registry is a private members bill, and they survive a prorogation.

Yoiu're right, I am surprised by this, but it turns out you are right: Private members bills are automatically reintroduced at the same stage as they were in.
 
What a wonderful country where the RCMP feels it can go off and investigate the military for acts on the battlefield.

Pecular how the same folks who are all over the RCMP for everything else consider this perfectly appropriate.
Actually, it was the Military Police Complaints Commission, not the RCMP. Not content to merely block it in its work, Harper has left it without a new chair, since Tinsley's appointment has run out, and he shows no sign of appointing anyone else.

If its peculiar to think it wise to keep an eye on what the boys with the guns actually do with them, we're in worse shape as a free country than I thought.
 
Who needs democracy? Not Canada, it appears.
 
Actually, it was the Military Police Complaints Commission, not the RCMP.
If its peculiar to think it wise to keep an eye on what the boys with the guns actually do with them, we're in worse shape as a free country than I thought.
No, because those are two entirely different things. It isn't an investigation that I object to it is a witch hunt.
 
I realize that. What I was asking was to those claiming this will allow the government to swing to a conservative majority in the Senate to stop the Senate killing bills a list of "killed" bills. I don't recall a Harper bill that the Senate killed.

there are half a dozen bills most with all party agrrement that have gone to the senete and been adjusted or delayed in committee that is the problem
 
some were so changed they did not resemble the original at all, the big point was the unelected senate changing the will of the peoples elected representatives
 
some were so changed they did not resemble the original at all, the big point was the unelected senate changing the will of the peoples elected representatives

The big point was the Senate doing its job. Sober second thought and all...
 
sober second thought I could live with , unfortunatly a lot of what they did was partisan politics, both sides are guilty of it and it is reason I am all in favour of term limits 6 years sounds good to me . Also lose the pensions, benefits etc.,
 
But let's be honest, most Canadians don't give a shit about Afghan torture. The media will love the hype, but joe average doesn't care.

Screw the Afghan thing.
Screw Afghanistan.
Screw the Taliban.
Screw Ignatieff, Rae and Layton.
Screw the Geneva Convention.

Afghan "torture", eh? I've suffered more pain, including broken bones, playing hockey. What a bunch of pussies.
 
Screw the Afghan thing.
Screw Afghanistan.
Screw the Taliban.
Screw Ignatieff, Rae and Layton.
Screw the Geneva Convention.

nah, don't bother running around. Screw yourself.
 
sober second thought I could live with , unfortunatly a lot of what they did was partisan politics, both sides are guilty of it and it is reason I am all in favour of term limits 6 years sounds good to me . Also lose the pensions, benefits etc.,

Reading talking points again I see...
 
I realize that. What I was asking was to those claiming this will allow the government to swing to a conservative majority in the Senate to stop the Senate killing bills a list of "killed" bills. I don't recall a Harper bill that the Senate killed.

You are correct. The Senate has not blocked one single solitary bill. It has delayed some a little, but only a little. Overall the Conservatives had not had any real trouble getting their legislation passed.
 
some were so changed they did not resemble the original at all, the big point was the unelected senate changing the will of the peoples elected representatives

I defy you to cite a single example of legislation in the prorogued Parliament passed that the Senate modified so that it "did not resemble the original at all".

Reality check:

The House has the power to override any modifications the Senate makes. The most the Senate can do is send it back for a revote in Parliament. It cannot fundamentally alter the legislation, and if it does, Parliament can undo all of its changes.

Reality check x2:

The Senate has simply not even done anything like that to Harper anyway. It has used the debate on some bills to turn up the heat on the government, drawing public attention to elements of the bills that may be unpopular, and forcing them into the press. It has not, however, significantly slowed down the passage of legislation.
 
sober second thought I could live with , unfortunatly a lot of what they did was partisan politics, both sides are guilty of it and it is reason I am all in favour of term limits 6 years sounds good to me . Also lose the pensions, benefits etc.,

I actually think the current model of the Senate is a good model, it should remain as it is, and it should probably have its power extended slightly.

It is good and right that Senators are appointed by the current sitting PM, and sit in the Senate for a long time.

The Senate reflects kind of an averaging of the views of Canadians over time. The longer Canadians keep a certain party in power, the greater that party's power in the Senate grows--and that power remains for decades after the government leaves office. The effect of this is essentially that past administrations sit in an advisory capacity over the present government. That is wonderful.

People who think we should have an elected senate are wrongly influenced by American policies where the Senate has a geographic constituency, rather than a temporal constituency. A geographic senate would not perform the same function; it too would reflect the administration and fad of the day, rather than an averaging of many ideologies over time.

It is proper that as the Conservatives remain in power longer their strength in the Senate will grow to a majority, and it is proper too that when the Conservatives finally lose, and the Liberals or whoever gain power, that they will have to deal with a strong Conservative constituency in the Senate.

Note too that the Conservative voice in the Senate will not simply be a Harper voice in the Senate, but will include a contingent of Senators appointed by past Conservative administrations as well, with slightly different ideological views.