Proroguing Government

needinit

New member
Jan 19, 2004
1,191
1
0
Haven't followed politics much lately...whay is Harper doing this again...must be some political reasons, not just to watch the Olympics?

PS The MPs were scheduled to return on Jan 25th and are now doing so on March 3 - Do they get paid in the meantime? (I bet I know the answer, but still) why should they if they are not at work.

Yes, this probably should be in the politics thread.
 
Harper is desperate to do ANYTHING he can in order to shut down the committee that is investigating the torture of Afghans. His ministers, and probably he himself, have blatantly lied to Parliament, and potentially committed war crimes.

They will do anything and everything they can to suppress that, even to the point of killing off half their legislative agenda--which they've just done.

Among the things that they sacrificed in order to suppress that committee are the bill to kill the long gun registry, and their entire tough-on-crime legislative agenda. It all died on the order paper when Harper pulled the trigger.

I think their main objective was to kill the bill the opposition passed that required them to disclose what they know about the issue, I assume that too died on the order paper, along with everything the government was trying to do.

Clearly their efforts to resist answering questions about Afghan torture are hamstringing their ability to govern.
 
They're paid on salary. The job doesn't end when Parliament isn't sitting. They're back in their home ridings dealing with their constituents. You know how it would suck to be a landlord always dealing with tenants' complaints? Try being a politician who has to deal with the constant, "I voted for you... now what are YOU going to do for ME???"

Funny how your post seems to indicate you think they're getting paid for nothing. Many people would say they want their politicians to spend MORE time in their ridings and LESS time in Ottawa.

When Parliament sits and when it doesn't is always due to political reasons. It's never just coincidence.

Wow, that's interesting about the Afghan thing. I'm surprised they let killing the gun registry go. But let's be honest, most Canadians don't give a shit about Afghan torture. The media will love the hype, but joe average doesn't care.
 
Afgan torture - boring non-issue about some dude who got a punch in the nose. (and another dude who deserves one). The real issue is getting control of the Senate committees so some actual work gets done...
 
prorouging parliment is a tool the government can use. I doubt it is entirly the result of the Afghan committee that issue is not registering with Canadians outside of the Ottawa bubble, in spite of the spin given by some board members.

A better reason is the situation in the Senate. With Parliment out all the Senate committees collapse and when the parliment resumes the senate committes will resume . The vacant seats filled with tories the committees will now be run by the Conservative Members as opposed to the liberals and a large amount of legislation that has been stopped or changed will be able to go through.
 
landscaper, the tory appointments would have happened anyway. Prorouging parliament does not speed them up, in fact, slows them down. That is just a cover story.

The reality is that this move sets back the Tory legislative agenda enormously. The bill to kill the long gun registry, the get tough on crime legislation, all dead.

That legislation would have been passed sooner had Parliament not been prorogued: The senate can only hold it up so long, the house can always force it through, and in the same time frame Harper gets a senate majority whether or not he prorogues. The reality is much of that legislation will likely NOT be re-introduced, so it is a straight loss off the Conservative agenda.

You can say the Afghan issue is not registering with Canadians but it is a ticking time bomb. The government is sitting on some pretty explosive documents, including photographs, that it has so far resisted making public. (We know these documents exist because they have been referenced in material that has been released.) The opposition was on the verge of forcing that material out into the open, and presumably the government is afraid of that.

Having the RCMP launch a war crimes investigation, for example, might suddenly make the issue register.
 
landscaper, the tory appointments would have happened anyway. Prorouging parliament does not speed them up, in fact, slows them down. That is just a cover story.

The reality is that this move sets back the Tory legislative agenda enormously. The bill to kill the long gun registry, the get tough on crime legislation, all dead.

That legislation would have been passed sooner had Parliament not been prorogued: The senate can only hold it up so long, the house can always force it through, and in the same time frame Harper gets a senate majority whether or not he prorogues.

You can say the Afghan issue is not registering with Canadians but it is a ticking time bomb. The government is sitting on some pretty explosive documents, including photographs, that it has so far resisted making public. (We know these documents exist because they have been referenced in material that has been released.) The opposition was on the verge of forcing that material out into the open, and presumably the government is afraid of that.

Having the RCMP launch a war crimes investigation, for example, might suddenly make the issue register.

The Senate appointments would have happened, but the Senate Committees are still Liberal-dominated and they don't get disbanded until Parliament is prorogued. The current legislation would never have made it past the Committee stage anyway - it would get held up the same as the current law and order legislation.

PS: The so-called Afghan torture issue is a non-starter regardless of how the media have spun it.
 
The Senate appointments would have happened, but the Senate Committees are still Liberal-dominated and they don't get disbanded until Parliament is prorogued. The current legislation would never have made it past the Committee stage anyway - it would get held up the same as the current law and order legislation.

PS: The so-called Afghan torture issue is a non-starter regardless of how the media have spun it.

What he said
 
The Senate appointments would have happened, but the Senate Committees are still Liberal-dominated and they don't get disbanded until Parliament is prorogued. The current legislation would never have made it past the Committee stage anyway - it would get held up the same as the current law and order legislation.

Not true. If that were the case the government would not have been able to get any legislation passed. In reality they got about half their bills through the senate. The reason is that the liberal majority there is very slim, not big enough to filibuster effectively.

Everything does eventually get put to a vote, and if the senate votes it down, the house can then force it through.

Hence the C's have been very successful to date in getting their legislation passed--until now, it all just died.

The so-called Afghan torture issue is a non-starter regardless of how the media have spun it.

Depends on how it develops, no? Having a Minister arrested on war crimes charges might register. If photographic material comes out, that could also change the game. People tend to be pretty stupid and fail to respond to written descriptions of torture--but all you have to do is look at how Abu Ghraib toppled Rumsfeld in the states once the pictures came out and you can see how it goes.

By proroguing Parliament the tories also quashed the opposition efforts to have that material made public..
 
Not true. If that were the case the government would not have been able to get any legislation passed. In reality they got about half their bills through the senate. The reason is that the liberal majority there is very slim, not big enough to filibuster effectively.

Everything does eventually get put to a vote, and if the senate votes it down, the house can then force it through.

Hence the C's have been very successful to date in getting their legislation passed--until now, it all just died.



Depends on how it develops, no? Having a Minister arrested on war crimes charges might register. If photographic material comes out, that could also change the game. People tend to be pretty stupid and fail to respond to written descriptions of torture--but all you have to do is look at how Abu Ghraib toppled Rumsfeld in the states once the pictures came out and you can see how it goes.

By proroguing Parliament the tories also quashed the opposition efforts to have that material made public..

You are possibly the only person in the country who thinks this is a war crime. The issue has absolutly no traction outside of Ottawa, the general population has decided the issue is being ridden for political purposed by the opposition.

The sitting committee that is investigating the issue returns in March where unlike the Senete it keeps its majority opposition composition. The senate committees collapse and are reformed as needed following prorogation with the new majority the senate committees will have a different balance as well as different leadership.

The parlimantary committes will be back in action with basically the same composition so how is that going to avoid the issues? They will still be there when parliment resumes . The opposition have the throne speach to vote against in early march. If they feel that strongly about the issue vote the government out and run an election on the issue.
 
You are possibly the only person in the country who thinks this is a war crime.

The issue was specifically raised in Parliament, it has been the subject of numerous editirials, and the RCMP have hinted that they may investigate, so I am apparently not the only person who thinks so.

I think the government is hoping that by delaying for a few months the whole thing will go away, or at least they can buy some time to shred documents and get their stories straight.
 
By the way, the Parliamentary committees will be disbanded. They will reform, but they will all start from scratch, potentially with new members, so the investigation into Afghan torture will be set back by more than the length of the prorogue.

Yes the balance of opposition to government will remain the same, because that reflects their strength in Parliament.

However it is not correct to say that the committee will continue on in March as though nothing had happened. Proroguing seriously disrupts it.
 
The RCMP have hinted that they may investigate.
What a wonderful country where the RCMP feels it can go off and investigate the military for acts on the battlefield.

Pecular how the same folks who are all over the RCMP for everything else consider this perfectly appropriate.
 
What a wonderful country where the RCMP feels it can go off and investigate the military for acts on the battlefield.

Pecular how the same folks who are all over the RCMP for everything else consider this perfectly appropriate.

Its always a bad idea to get dragged into one of fuji's little political or medical causes. One only has to recall him seriously warning us about the dangers of Russia setting up a rocket base in Mexico. For some reason he has determined that , dispite not seeing all the evidence, that a war crime has likely been committed by turning prisoners over to local authorities. He has started numerous threads on the topic in the political section, all saying pretty much the same thing.
 
The plan was in the works for a while, this is not unexpected. The government is going to have a new throne speech and bring in a new budget, giving the Liberals an opportunity to tell everyone how evil the Conservatives are. The Liberals either vote non-confidence and are stuck with an unpopular leader and despised by the electorate for forcing an election OR the Liberals suck it up and support the government, showing that they are spineless with no agenda or ideas. Either way, the Conservatives are moving ahead.

Watch for an election call in March.
 
The Conservatives are unwilling to govern and the opposition are afraid to vote them out. It looks bad on all of them.

One good thing, Bill C-15 won't get through.
 
Its always a bad idea to get dragged into one of fuji's little political or medical causes. One only has to recall him seriously warning us about the dangers of Russia setting up a rocket base in Mexico. For some reason he has determined that , dispite not seeing all the evidence, that a war crime has likely been committed by turning prisoners over to local authorities. He has started numerous threads on the topic in the political section, all saying pretty much the same thing.
Well, I don't want to be seen jumping into the same boat as fuji, if claims he Russians want to set up rocket bases in Mexico. On the other hand, I didn't notice him saying a war crime has been committed (I haven't been over in the Politics section lately), contrary to what train has said. All he's saying in this thread is that the Tories are trying to prevent an investigation into war crimes. Personally, I think war crimes are a very serious charge and would welcome an investigation. The truth needs to come out. The Canadian public might not think war crimes are an issue right now, but I think that can change rather quickly. It could destroy Harper's or McKay's political careers. And I admit, I wouldn't be sad to see either go away.
 
It would have been great watching the Conservatives push through Bill C-15 while Rahim Jaffer was in court for coke possession and his wife Helena Guergis was in government. The hypocrisy would have been entertaining.
His first date in court is in January.
 
I didn't notice him saying a war crime has been committed (I haven't been over in the Politics section lately), contrary to what train has said.
That is merely because as you said you haven't been over in the Politics section of late. Indeed he has.
 
Sorry but I am not a fan of the government not restarting becuase it is not in their best interests. I am concernd more about doing it to cut off voices other than those you want heard. I don't care who the government of the day is but when they decide it is only going to be their voice heard then it doesn't look like a democracy.