Proroguing Government

Oh good lets sign your sorry ass up for a stint in Afghanistan Rocky.

I can't wait for June 30, 2011 when the last of our brave men and women in uniform come home. In fact, I heard that planning is already underway for repatriation of our material and personnel. June 30, 2011 can't come soon enough.

If you are so upset about Afghan "torture", you go to Afghany and do something about it.
 
I defy you to cite a single example of legislation in the prorogued Parliament passed that the Senate modified so that it "did not resemble the original at all".

Reality check:

The House has the power to override any modifications the Senate makes. The most the Senate can do is send it back for a revote in Parliament. It cannot fundamentally alter the legislation, and if it does, Parliament can undo all of its changes.

The House cannot "override" Senate amendments to legislation. They may choose not to accept them, to accept some and not others, or to make different amendments. Whatever they choose to do goes back to the Senate for their approval. They can then choose whether or not to insist on their amendments, or make additional changes. The bill goes back and forth between the two houses until it is adopted in identical form by both chambers. Only then can it become law. In theory this ping pong can continue indefinitely unless one chamber gives in or a compromise is reached. Neither chamber can accomplish anything legislatively on their own.

Reality check x2:

The Senate has simply not even done anything like that to Harper anyway. It has used the debate on some bills to turn up the heat on the government, drawing public attention to elements of the bills that may be unpopular, and forcing them into the press. It has not, however, significantly slowed down the passage of legislation.

The Senate in fact made "significant" amendments to two pieces of legislation, C-6 and C-15. Whether or not these amendments are good is a matter for debate. In the case of C-6, they arguably have no impact on the administration of the bill, but close significant loopholes and drafting problems that could potentially allow for abuse of process. In the case of C-15, there is a more fundamental policy difference.
 
It is interesting to me that Canadians have no problem living in Provinces that have abolished their Upper House as has Ontario with the Legislative Council, yet the Senate is a sacred cow.
 
I actually think the current model of the Senate is a good model, it should remain as it is, and it should probably have its power extended slightly.

It is good and right that Senators are appointed by the current sitting PM, and sit in the Senate for a long time.

I am not a fan of a EEE Senate. For one, elected means needing money, which means sucking up and kissing ass and making deals. Equal? I'm sorry, but why the fuck should PEI have more clout than the city of Toronto? Sure, rep by pop can suck if you live in a low density area, but if you are interested in democracy it is the only way to fly.

The current Senate has all the powers it needs. It has the full powers of the Commons, with the exception of the introduction of a money bill. And the Prime Minister does not appoint the Senate, the Crown does, on the advice of the PM. From a legal POV, the GG could tell the PM to submit a new name if the GG is not comfortable with the candidate.

As for the issue of pensions, most people in the Senate have given up a much higher income position and have lost income and pension contributions. I do not have a problem with rewarding someone for public service when they retire.
 
Sure, rep by pop can suck if you live in a low density area, but if you are interested in democracy it is the only way to fly.

I disagree with that. Canada was forged out of a pledge to protect the far flung interests of all the provinces, not just the most populated. If you're not going to ensure that the smaller provinces have a significant voice, then you might as well dismantle the country because that pledge is part of what got them to join in the first place.
 
The House cannot "override" Senate amendments to legislation.

OK, well the House + PM can do it. The PM appoints a raft of new Senators and forces the legislation through. End of story.

At the end of the day the party that controls the House can control the Senate, if push comes to shove.

The Senate knows this, and by tradition, defers to the House when things come to pushing and shoving. There have been only very, very few exceptions to that principle, none of which have occurred in the current Parliament.

You can correctly say stuff about what could happen "in theory", but I mean, in theory the Governor General could unilaterally dismiss the PM and declare war on another country. The only thing stopping her from doing that is tradition: Tradition is the real foundation of Canadian democracy, and the tradition is that the Senate doesn't do that stuff that is possible in theory.

The Senate in fact made "significant" amendments to two pieces of legislation, C-6 and C-15. Whether or not these amendments are good is a matter for debate.

That's the Senate's job, it improves the legislation submitted by the House. The House almost always accepts those changes, because they are usually good, non-partisan changes.

That is substantially different than the claim made by someone else up thread, though, that the Senate has been blocking Conservative legislation or making it unrecognizably different. It has NOT been doing that. Conservative legislation has been getting passed without any real obstruction from the senate.

Partisanship in the Senate in this Parliament has been limited to slowing things down in more symbolic ways, and in using Senate debates to highlight potentially unpopular aspects of government policy or legislation.

At the end of the day the Conservative legislation was getting passed, and passed in a reasonable time frame.
 
What I find curious are all the apologists for the Liberal Party - who wanted to dissolve Parliament and call a new election this past fall - complaining that the House won't sit for two whole months.
 
What I find curious are all the apologists for the Liberal Party - who wanted to dissolve Parliament and call a new election this past fall - complaining that the House won't sit for two whole months.
Oh the horror! A hypocritical politician?! :eek:

Show me a politician and I'll show you a hypocrite... yes, the 2 terms are completely interchangeable... they stand for one thing one day and a completely opposite thing the next depending one what viewpoint will get them another vote.
 
What I find curious are all the apologists for the Liberal Party - who wanted to dissolve Parliament and call a new election this past fall - complaining that the House won't sit for two whole months.

Same thing then and now: A minority PM once again afraid to meet with, and always unwilling to get along with, the House of Commons that reperesents all the people. So instead he hides away with his rump-reperesenting Yes Men, who he says are unable to draft a budget and sit in the House at the same time. Or would just rather rather watch the ice dancers.

Rather than contradict yourself about who's afraid of elections, you might recall that the coalition proposition was to form a government that would represent a majority of the electorate, without another useless election (of the self-serving sort Harpo promised w'd never have again—thanks to his Fixed Elections Act).
 
I defy you to cite a single example of legislation in the prorogued Parliament passed that the Senate modified so that it "did not resemble the original at all".

Reality check:

The House has the power to override any modifications the Senate makes. The most the Senate can do is send it back for a revote in Parliament. It cannot fundamentally alter the legislation, and if it does, Parliament can undo all of its changes.

Reality check x2:

The Senate has simply not even done anything like that to Harper anyway. It has used the debate on some bills to turn up the heat on the government, drawing public attention to elements of the bills that may be unpopular, and forcing them into the press. It has not, however, significantly slowed down the passage of legislation.


I will let Thompo69 's answers stand saves the research

The current Senate has issues major ones and the addition of more powers to it would be a major problem.

Fixed terms with a term longer than the maximumterm fa government ( the reason for the 6 years I like) stops the standard musical chairs that occurs when a party is the government for more than 5 years.

Using a distribution that will allow the smaller provinces to ahve a say in the way legislation is done and you will have a usable system.

The American system of allocation of Senate seats as a counter balance to the congress ( rep by pop) is a good place to start.

We do need a cvounter balance to to government in power running around changing things at the behest of a single province where their seats are and the Governor General does have the power to refuse to sign a bill into law it has never been used in recent memory .
 
Harper is desperate to do ANYTHING he can in order to shut down the committee that is investigating the torture of Afghans. His ministers, and probably he himself, have blatantly lied to Parliament, and potentially committed war crimes.

They will do anything and everything they can to suppress that, even to the point of killing off half their legislative agenda--which they've just done.

Among the things that they sacrificed in order to suppress that committee are the bill to kill the long gun registry, and their entire tough-on-crime legislative agenda. It all died on the order paper when Harper pulled the trigger.

I think their main objective was to kill the bill the opposition passed that required them to disclose what they know about the issue, I assume that too died on the order paper, along with everything the government was trying to do.

Clearly their efforts to resist answering questions about Afghan torture are hamstringing their ability to govern.

http://transmontanus.blogspot.com/2009/12/news-managers-here-in-canada-have.html

Interesting Article with referencxes from someone who is both knowledgable and acknowledged in the Afghan issues.
 
I will let Thompo69 's answers stand saves the research

I wouldn't if I were you. As fuji correctly pointed out, the two examples I cited are indicative that the Senate has done its job, not that they have amended any legislation to the point that it no longer resembles the original (which they haven't).

As to your proposals for senate reform, I must strongly disagree. A 6 year term would not stop musical chairs, but rather ensure that any government that serves more than that period will have total legislative control. The present system is far from perfect, but it is also far from broken. You hold up the GG as a counter balance, but I think you misunderstand the extent of the ability of a Governor General to act independently of advice from the Prime Minister of the day, ie. virtually non-existent.
 
I think I pointed out that the GG has the power not to sign Legislation into law it has not been used in my memory and using it would cause a constitutional crisis. The 6 years is a I think a reasonable amount of time. The current plan has people their until they ossify, 6 years with a staggard start so the whole palce does not change enmass would give the PM whoever he/she/it is the use of the patronage toys involved for party faithful. That perk will never go unless the senate is removed entirely.

As to the amendment of legislation one bill comes to mind, it had all party assent and it was still amended by the senate because they did not like some parts of it. I can't remember the exact bill but that is an example of what I am talking about, the bill was voted on by parliment and given all aprty assent the Liberal senators did not like parts of it for partisan reasons.

There does need to be a counter balance to a majority government and it has to be either the Senate ( if properly constructed) or the Queens representative unfortunatly the GG 's power has diminished over the years to the point of being non existant so that leaves the senate which in its present form does not provide either sober second thought or any reason to think they will do so in the future.
 
I think I pointed out that the GG has the power not to sign Legislation into law it has not been used in my memory and using it would cause a constitutional crisis.

Yes, you did mention that, and it is what I was referring to when I said you misunderstand the GG's ability, or rather lack thereof, to act independent of advice from the PM.

The 6 years is a I think a reasonable amount of time. The current plan has people their until they ossify, 6 years with a staggard start so the whole palce does not change enmass would give the PM whoever he/she/it is the use of the patronage toys involved for party faithful.

So any PM who has served six years will have named all 105 members of the Senate. Um, yeah. Sounds like a big improvement over the current system.

As to the amendment of legislation one bill comes to mind, it had all party assent and it was still amended by the senate because they did not like some parts of it. I can't remember the exact bill but that is an example of what I am talking about, the bill was voted on by parliment and given all aprty assent the Liberal senators did not like parts of it for partisan reasons.

First I have to correct a misunderstanding. Parliament and the House of Commons are not synonymous. The House of Commons is but one part of Parliament, as is the Senate. Now, if you are actually going to enter a debate you may want to learn what you're talking about. You don't know what legislation is being referred to, what changes were made or why -- only that the Senate amendmended a bill for "partisan" reasons. Here's a newsflash -- it is their job to amend legislation. So, if you'd like to continue the debate, how about trying to explain what amendments were made, why they were unnecessary and why you believe the motivation for making them was purely partisan, as opposed as an expression of their duty to give legislation sober second thought.
 
It would have been great watching the Conservatives push through Bill C-15 while Rahim Jaffer was in court for coke possession and his wife Helena Guergis was in government. The hypocrisy would have been entertaining.
His first date in court is in January.

That's a new twist to this. Thanks for pointing it out.
 
People who think we should have an elected senate are wrongly influenced by American policies where the Senate has a geographic constituency, rather than a temporal constituency. A geographic senate would not perform the same function
However, you are overstating your argument. The Senate already has a geographic constituency. Under the Constitution, (BNA) there are four areas of the Country each with 24 Senators: Ontario, Quebec, the Maritimes (Nova Scotia and New Brunswick each with 10 and Prince Edward Island with 4), the western provinces (Manitoba, Saskatchewan, Alberta and British Columbia, each with six). Then there are also Newfoundland and Labrador with 6 senators, and the Yukon, the Northwest Territories, and Nunavut which each have a Senator.

You are making Senate reform sound far more complicated than it would be.
 
It isn't an investigation that I object to it is a witch hunt.

I totally agree. However, with the prorogation, we don't have any chance a real investigation will take place. The HOC committee can't do what they do (more of a witch hunt, I will admit) and the the MPCC won't have a chairperson appointed anytime soon.

IMHO, the parliamentary committee system needs to be given more resources and power. Perhaps the American folks here could comment on what would happen if a House or Senate committee asked for documents from the White house and they only got mostly blacked out pages.