Peyton Manning: 2008 Mvp

Well...

Captain Fantastic said:
Walter Payton (R.I.P.) is my first NFL memory as a VERY young fan - still the greatest player I ever watched. Then Mike Singletary (and that rabid defence) and his insane eyes when I became a more knowledgeable fan who actually played the game - I played high school football while still in junior high. (BTW, those late 1980s Bears teams should have won mulitple Super Bowls instead of just one - Ditka was a bad coach and the team had poor offensive talent evaluators.) Since then, it's been pretty bleak with the occasional high(ish) points - man I was thinking upset when Devin Hester returned the opening kickoff in Super Bowl XLI.

..that certainly explains why you aren't such a bad guy...as Terbites go...:p
 
Captain Fantastic said:
Walter Payton (R.I.P.) is my first NFL memory as a VERY young fan - still the greatest player I ever watched. Then Mike Singletary (and that rabid defence) and his insane eyes when I became a more knowledgeable fan who actually played the game - I played high school football while still in junior high. (BTW, those late 1980s Bears teams should have won mulitple Super Bowls instead of just one - Ditka was a bad coach and the team had poor offensive talent evaluators.) Since then, it's been pretty bleak with the occasional high(ish) points - man I was thinking upset when Devin Hester returned the opening kickoff in Super Bowl XLI.

What has happened to Hester though. You are a Bears fan so you would have more insight into this than I but they are using Hester more on offense and I like that because it gives more chances to get the ball in his hands and he seems to have a knack for getting behind the secondary and really I think they needed to insert him into the offense more if for no other reason than the fact that the receiving corps is not that good (at least at wideout) so they needed a spark. Daniel Manning seems to have taken over the return duties though for the most part and he is doing an exceptional job. Do you think Hester is better used on offense or back on special teams where he used to pretty much play almost exclusively?
 
Captain Fantastic said:
I think the bigger problem is having 4 divisions per conference. I understand the need the divisions for travel, scheduling and rivalry (read: business) purposes, but other than that, divisions are really irrelevant. And to have 8 divisions in total is just overkill, particularly given how dysfunctional the teams in some divisions are, year in and year out... (cough, AFC & NFC West, cough) The old 3 division setup (East, Central, West) was fine for years - not sure what changed that...

I'm just waiting for some 7-9 team (will it happen in the AFC or NFC West first?) to make the playoffs and host a first-round game! :cool:

The funny thing is, I don't even care about New England per se, I just find it asinine that a garbage team can make the playoffs at the expense of a vastly superior one. I respect the hell out of what the Pats have done and how they've maintained their excellence over 8 seasons in this high-player-turnover, flash-in-the-pan era, but like most others, I find Belichick's schtick a bit much after a while.

Now I can only imagine how P.O.'d I'd be if my Bears were in the same situation...

I could be wrong as I dont remember the dates that the change was made as far as the division realignment but before when there were 30 teams and 15 teams per conf it was easier to have 3 divisions because you could have 5 teams per. But when they added jacksonville and carolina and went to 16 teams per conf it created an imbalance for a few years. Going from 3 to 4 divisions resolved that imbalance. I think this was the reason why the NFL made that change but I could be wrong. This is also raising a logistical issue as far as bringing back a team to LA. Basically I doubt the NFL would introduce one expansion franchise to the league, it is more likely that if they were gonna expand they would expand with 2 so that they could have an even number and it would make scheduling of games a lot more easier.
 
ckupets04 said:
What has happened to Hester though. You are a Bears fan so you would have more insight into this than I but they are using Hester more on offense and I like that because it gives more chances to get the ball in his hands and he seems to have a knack for getting behind the secondary and really I think they needed to insert him into the offense more if for no other reason than the fact that the receiving corps is not that good (at least at wideout) so they needed a spark. Daniel Manning seems to have taken over the return duties though for the most part and he is doing an exceptional job. Do you think Hester is better used on offense or back on special teams where he used to pretty much play almost exclusively?
Devin Hester was a defensive back in college for a reason. His hands are ... inconsistent.

How many return men have turned into good-to-great receivers? I can only think of Steve Smith.

Basically, the Bears painted themselves into a corner by either cutting or not signing / drafting any wideouts and were forced to use Hester in a role he's not ready for or suited for.

Let's be honest, Ron Turner's a mediocre offensive coordinator at best with marginal talent to utilize. Hester should be used occasionally (15-20 snaps/game) from a variety of positions - wildcat QB (if he can throw at all), running back, flanker, wideout. I think someone like Mike Mularkey or Ken Whisenhunt/Russ Grimm, a guy from the Belichick offensive coaching tree or even Dan Henning and the Dolphins staff could find ways of using him effectively without using him up and exposing him as a mediocre every-down player.

I want him returning kicks again full-time, but there are a few things that may be wrong:

1. it's impossible to be a full-time receiver and full-time special teams returner - too much of a toll on the body and too much to remember, playbook-wise.
2. teams started going to ridiculous lengths to kick away from him.
3. Hester started to become more tentative returning kicks. He may have been shaken up one too many times, or maybe he wanted to ensure he got a couple of big paydays, but either way, he's not the same reckless, go-for-broke returner he once was. I don't blame him, just pointing out what i see.
 
ckupets04 said:
I could be wrong as I dont remember the dates that the change was made as far as the division realignment but before when there were 30 teams and 15 teams per conf it was easier to have 3 divisions because you could have 5 teams per. But when they added jacksonville and carolina and went to 16 teams per conf it created an imbalance for a few years. Going from 3 to 4 divisions resolved that imbalance. I think this was the reason why the NFL made that change but I could be wrong. This is also raising a logistical issue as far as bringing back a team to LA. Basically I doubt the NFL would introduce one expansion franchise to the league, it is more likely that if they were gonna expand they would expand with 2 so that they could have an even number and it would make scheduling of games a lot more easier.
Actually Houston (Texans) was the last expansion team. Before them, the Browns (Ver. 2.0). The league fluctated from 29-31 teams for a while.

I was just thinking of splitting the league roughly by time zones/geographic areas - that's how much I hate the way the playoff system is set up right now where a useless team gets a free home game because they were lucky enough to be the best of a terrible division. (Yes, I feel strongly about this.)
 
Captain Fantastic said:
Actually Houston (Texans) was the last expansion team. Before them, the Browns (Ver. 2.0). The league fluctated from 29-31 teams for a while.

I was just thinking of splitting the league roughly by time zones/geographic areas - that's how much I hate the way the playoff system is set up right now where a useless team gets a free home game because they were lucky enough to be the best of a terrible division. (Yes, I feel strongly about this.)

Ah yes, my bad, forgot about the Texans. They were the most recent expansion team but basically I think they just went to the 4 divisions to have things even, it also makes schedulilng games easier, otherwise you have an unbalanced schedule.

About Hester, yeah I remember he actually played in some nickel or dime packages with the Bears a few years ago as well didnt he? If I'm not mistaken. He is still wearing his DB jersey number too, he should change that.
 
robbierobinson said:
Thank god they got this one right. No other player in the league is more important to his team than Manning. This is not opinion. This is FACT. I don't know why they have a vote. They should give it to him every year before the season starts. I don't care who has these stats and those stats. He is more valuable to his team.

LOL...do you need a moment alone or did you already have that? Can you say shill? LOL
 
this is all cut and paste from si.com. they both suck. Watch the tom show next year. put 1,000 early future 09/10 at 75/1 and be happy.
 
Peyton Manning is a successful Jim Kelly.

Their on-field styles strike me as occasionally very similar.


Probably that young Atlanta quarterback may have been as important to his team given their recent provenance and last year dive into the basement, since replaced by the stupendously bad Buffalo Torontos.
 
notanerd said:
I 2nd that.

put 1,000 dollars on ne to win the super bowl next year when brady gets back. moss is waiting for him. 1,000x75(very early odds) when they win. watch and see. wings also win the stanly cup this year.
 
antaeus said:
Peyton Manning is a successful Jim Kelly.

Their on-field styles strike me as occasionally very similar.


Probably that young Atlanta quarterback may have been as important to his team given their recent provenance and last year dive into the basement, since replaced by the stupendously bad Buffalo Torontos.

you think kelly walks around a hate filled angry man because he dont have a ring? even eli is higher than kelly by a long shot on my personal list. for some reason i dont like the brothers. i dont know why. scott norwood.
 
Dribbles said:
you think kelly walks around a hate filled angry man because he dont have a ring? even eli is higher than kelly by a long shot on my personal list. for some reason i dont like the brothers. i dont know why. scott norwood.

I'd take Kelly over either of the Mannings any day. Getting to the super bowl 4 years in a row was a huge accomplishment. Never been done before or after. Bills played very good teams in that SB run. Norwood blew it, not Kelly.
 
robbierobinson said:
Thank god they got this one right. No other player in the league is more important to his team than Manning. This is not opinion. This is FACT. I don't know why they have a vote. They should give it to him every year before the season starts. I don't care who has these stats and those stats. He is more valuable to his team.

The League MVP has been bounced from the playoffs , while other players like James Harrison and Ed Reed (great defensive players who I thought warranted serious consideration for MVP) are still in the playoffs.

I know its easy to say in hindsight but in hindsight its looking like maybe there are other players just as if not more valuable than Manning.
 
i am surprised that atlanta's matt ryan does not warrant any consideration. he simply came into a bad situation, and was a key reason the falcons turned their fortunes around.

Plyrs99
 
plyrs99 said:
i am surprised that atlanta's matt ryan does not warrant any consideration. he simply came into a bad situation, and was a key reason the falcons turned their fortunes around.

Plyrs99

I was watching NFL Network a few weeks ago and the MVP discussion came up (this was obviously before the MVP award was announced) , they had an entire panel discussing this topic and Michael Lombardi said his pick would be Matt Ryan. TD said that he thinks that Michael Turner is the MVP of that team though and that Michael Turner's ground game set up the passing game for Matt Ryan. Lombardi argued the opposite and basically said that the thinks that the prescence of Ryan helped Turner because it made it harder for teams to bring a safety into the box to make an 8-man front.

Ultimately three things would prevent me from given Ryan the MVP
1) There were better players in the league this season than him (and I feel the award should be given to the leagues best player).
2) Michael Turner and Matt Ryan were probably equally valuable to the Falcons this season so I'd have trouble giving the award to one over the other.
3) While Ryan played like a top flight NFL quarterback through the first 3/4 of the season, the last 1/4 and the playoffs he showed that he was still a rookie.


ACtually, Michael Turner and Chad Pennington finished tied for 2nd in MVP voting with 4 votes each.
 
robbierobinson said:
Thank god they got this one right. No other player in the league is more important to his team than Manning. This is not opinion. This is FACT. I don't know why they have a vote. They should give it to him every year before the season starts. I don't care who has these stats and those stats. He is more valuable to his team.

Manning is MVP this year, no doubt about that.
 
ckupets04 said:
The League MVP has been bounced from the playoffs , while other players like James Harrison and Ed Reed (great defensive players who I thought warranted serious consideration for MVP) are still in the playoffs.

I know its easy to say in hindsight but in hindsight its looking like maybe there are other players just as if not more valuable than Manning.


I'm a huge colts fan but I wanted to rip through the TV and take the MVP from Manning somehow. Sick and tired of the horrible play calling in the playoffs, year after year after year. I don't know for sure it was Manning but he gets all the credit for GOOD play calls so i'm giving him the "credit" for a 3rd and 2 on his own 4 or 5 line....all he needs is 1 first time to seal the win and they put the RB out wide? I COULDN'T BELIEVE WHAT I WAS SEEEING. THere wasn't even a possibility they would run at that point. At that one moment when Addai went wide and left the backfield empty, 11 Chargers popped the biggest hardons they'll ever have.

Every year it's the same thing, same thing. Even when Edgerrin was there, they get to the playoffs and abandon the run and that's when Edgerrin ran for 1300-1500 yards for 3 years in a row right before he left. Manning stops running and passes and loses.....FUCK!!!!!