Pet Held For Ransom

SPQR said:
Does that mean I am not up to the challange of building a relationship with a person. Absolutely not, but it does not change in any way that generally animals are easier.

And we all know...if something is hard to do, then its just not worth doing.

Good God man. Re-read your post. Its all about "YOU", not about others.
That's the problem with "animal=people" type attitude.
Of course people are difficult. But they also sing, dance, paint, express, build, write, laugh..and LOVE.
 
Diode said:
No. Anyone who finds it easier to "love" animals more than humans has a problem.

The equation to solve your problem is:

Human + complexity + not always forthcoming with emotion = difficult.

Animals + very transparent + always show how they feel = easier.

That's why its easy.
 
Diode said:
And we all know...if something is hard to do, then its just not worth doing.

Thanks Dad. I'm not going to even both responding, cause that comparison is just silly.

Good God man. Re-read your post. Its all about "YOU", not about others.
That's the problem with "animal=people" type attitude.
Of course people are difficult. But they also sing, dance, paint, express, build, write, laugh..and LOVE.

The best way I can express my opnion is how the experiences I have had demostrate the point.

I have 2 dogs in my life. That doesn't mean I don't have a large group of family and friends that I interact with. Each of them serve a purpose.

What I am trying to drill in your head is to have respect for animals and that treating animals should be no different than any other living thing.
 
Ok...

SPQR said:
The equation to solve your problem is:

Human + complexity + not always forthcoming with emotion = difficult.

Animals + very transparent + always show how they feel = easier.

That's why its easy.

..I agree.

I guess what I was REALLY saying was "worthwhile". If someone says they like MOST animals and dislike MOST humans, my guess is that they find difficulty developing relationships with humans and as a result find said relationships not "worthwhile". I guess I am saying I am suspect of people who enjoy their relationships with animals more than they do with humans...be it because they find the human relationships more difficult to form, or becuase they find they "don't like most humans".

I guess that it just strikes me as somehow dysfunctional to be of the mindset that you "dislike most humans" if you are one...
 
Just to be clear...

SPQR said:
What I am trying to drill in your head is to have respect for animals and that treating animals should be no different than any other living thing.

...I would NEVER advocate abusing an animal. And note that I never said that holding the cat ransom was right - I just agreed with Diode that the notion of physically abusing a human (which some were advocating) for such an act was ridiculous.

I am always curious when I hear people say they put human and animals life on the same plane - do you have a wife and kids? Because invaribly in my experience people who think that way do not...but my experience is obviously limited...
 
MLAM said:
I guess that it just strikes me as somehow dysfunctional to be of the mindset that you "dislike most humans" if you are one...

Well I think the fact the Human are complex, and the fact we obviously interact with them since the day we were born, scars are built up along the way. Bad experiences, happen to the best of us.

Unless you have been bitten attacked by animals then its hard to build up the same dislike. Assuming of course they viewed animals in the some what of an equal light.
 
SPQR said:
I have 2 dogs in my life. That doesn't mean I don't have a large group of family and friends that I interact with. Each of them serve a purpose.

What I am trying to drill in your head is to have respect for animals and that treating animals should be no different than any other living thing.

Notice what you wrote. I have dogs in my life and the People ( family and friends) you mearly Interact with

Which animal life has value. ILook out my parking lot and see hundreds of dead bugs on my car. Do you care?
I ran over a chipmunck last week ( an accident). Do you care?
My neighbour's dog threatened my children. Scared the hell out of them, oh yeah..on MY property. I could have killed it as easliy as swating a fly.( I didn't but could have.) Would I have been wrong?
I value YOUR life over any farking animal. Am I wrong?
I care but you don't seem to.
 
Humans and animals are equal in their right to freedom. You may appreciate differences and similarities between humans and in several ways, just as long as you respect the animals.
 
And yet...

SPQR said:
Well I think the fact the Human are complex, and the fact we obviously interact with them since the day we were born, scars are built up along the way. Bad experiences, happen to the best of us.

Unless you have been bitten attacked by animals then its hard to build up the same dislike. Assuming of course they viewed animals in the some what of an equal light.

"Well I think the fact the Human are complex, and the fact we obviously interact with them since the day we were born, scars are built up along the way. Bad experiences, happen to the best of us."

...most of us muddle through.

If a person cannot find themselves forming relationships with humans, that would be dysfunctional, and they should seek assitance. I say that without malice...but lets call it what it is.

If a person CHOSES to not muddle through because they prefer the company of animals, then that person has a social dysfunction, and I just as well not have anything to do with them. Fortunately they probably feel the same way about me. Also, fortunately, such people tend to "mark" themselves in other ways, such as adopting an anti-social appearance, behavior, etc. These people usually don't think much of me (I'm too dull, square and narrowminded) and I don't think much of them (I'm with Thoreau on this one to some degree...plus I think such people find it easier to be different and then blame the world for not embracing them rather than dealing with their anti-social issues...)
 
MLAM said:
"Well I think the fact the Human are complex, and the fact we obviously interact with them since the day we were born, scars are built up along the way. Bad experiences, happen to the best of us."

...most of us muddle through.

If a person cannot find themselves forming relationships with humans, that would be dysfunctional, and they should seek assitance. I say that without malice...but lets call it what it is.

If a person CHOSES to not muddle through because they prefer the comapny of animals, then that person has a social dysfunctional, and I just as well not have anything to do with them. Fortuately they probably feel the same way. Also, fortunately, such people temd to "mark" themselves in others, such as adopting an anti-social appearance, behavior, etc. These people usually don't think much of me (I'm too dull, square and narrowminded) and I don't think much of them (I'm with Thoreau on this one to some degree...plus I think such people find it easier to be different and then blame the world for not embracing them rather than dealing with their anti-social issues...)

Well written.
What the hell has happened to these people to make them see life upsidedown?
What has clouded their hmanity?
[BTW I'm dull, square and narrowminded as well
 
Pooontang Pie!
 
Diode said:
[BTW I'm dull, square and narrowminded as well

Nooooo, get out, you don't seem like you're a few frieds short of a happy meal...:rolleyes:
 
MLAM said:
...you don't think humans are superior to animals, then we really will have nothing to discuss...

I do believe that some species are superior to humans. Not dogs and cats persay but other. We knowingly polute ourselves with bad food, smoking, drugs, and also detroy our own habitat and environment.

I consider human life to be INFINITELY more valuable to animal life...and humans to be superior in all aspects that matter.

Lets not blur the lines of what I'm trying to say too much. If I had a choice to save a human life over an animals life, all things being equal, there's no arguement.

However if the human happen to be a child molestor or a mass murder, or a person who swindled the elderly out of their life saving, the animal's got a better shot.

I would call that instinct. Not that a mother doesn't have love for her child....but that isn't what motivates the behavior you describe. I would act to save people I didn't love if I could...

Some say love is an instinct. It all depend on how you view it.

One difference might be what you think "love" is (a point you made). I see love as a rational choice...and think little of people who say they can't control who they fall in love with. I can't MAKE myself fall in love with someone, but I certainly can decide I do NOT want to love someone. On the other hand, as I said, dogs bond with any / everyone who will care for them.

Based on this, so when a child is born, do they not build a bond with the parent, and because they take care of them, nuture them, does that not build love for that parent?

Again my interpretation of what love is maybe be different than some, so this may be a circular arguement. Though a person may not be consciously know why they are or fall in love with another, underlying that, there has to be certain subconscious criteria that was met.

With the sexual act removed, its difficult to define what love truly is, inorder to suit all people.
 
MLAM said:
I am always curious when I hear people say they put human and animals life on the same plane - do you have a wife and kids? Because invaribly in my experience people who think that way do not...but my experience is obviously limited...

I have all that, plus a very close knit and rather large (26 1st cousins) family.

I don't think you can generalize people who think like this as being loners or anti-social.
 
Diode said:
Notice what you wrote. I have dogs in my life and the People ( family and friends) you mearly Interact with

Lets not argue semantics. I interact with my dogs, and I have my family in my life as well.

Which animal life has value. ILook out my parking lot and see hundreds of dead bugs on my car. Do you care?

I have to admit, bugs are one area that I disagree with myself. But again it wasn't intentional.

I ran over a chipmunck last week ( an accident). Do you care?

No, because it was an accident, and they happen. But if I were the one to do it, I would have felt like crap for weeks.

My neighbour's dog threatened my children. Scared the hell out of them, oh yeah..on MY property. I could have killed it as easliy as swating a fly.( I didn't but could have.) Would I have been wrong?

No, you would have to do what you needed to do to protect you're own.

As I would expect a mother pitbull to attack you if you threatened its pups.

I also don't blame the Police officers for shooting the Pitbulls when they attacked a by standard.

I value YOUR life over any farking animal. Am I wrong?

Well again things being equal I would hope so. But what if I had attacked and harmed your family, what would my value be to you now?

I care but you don't seem to.

I do. But its not cut and dry, black or white. Sorry.
 
MLAM said:
...most of us muddle through.

Absolutely, and badly.

If a person cannot find themselves forming relationships with humans, that would be dysfunctional, and they should seek assitance. I say that without malice...but lets call it what it is.

Again I think that's a generalization. People can interact with society successfully, but still have a close relationship with animals.

Its obscession where therproblem lies. A person with 50 cats, then I have question why. But a person who enjoys spending their free time throwing a firsbee or taking walks with their dog, versus have a few ales at the pub with some mates I would not consider dysfunctional.
 
SPQR said:
Diode said:
Notice what you wrote. I have dogs in my life and the People ( family and friends) you mearly Interact with

Lets not argue semantics. I interact with my dogs, and I have my family in my life as well.

Which animal life has value. ILook out my parking lot and see hundreds of dead bugs on my car. Do you care?

I have to admit, bugs are one area that I disagree with myself. But again it wasn't intentional.



No, because it was an accident, and they happen. But if I were the one to do it, I would have felt like crap for weeks.



No, you would have to do what you needed to do to protect you're own.

As I would expect a mother pitbull to attack you if you threatened its pups.

I also don't blame the Police officers for shooting the Pitbulls when they attacked a by standard.



Well again things being equal I would hope so. But what if I had attacked and harmed your family, what would my value be to you now?



I do. But its not cut and dry, black or white. Sorry.

I'm starting to understand your point a bit more now.
You value animals, but don't exactly value them AS much as humans.
The point about "if you harmed my family" is interesting.
I'm convinced I could kill a person in self-defense. However, if the guy was convicted and sent to death row for hurting my family, I doubt I could "pull the switch". You know what I mean? In cold blood.
But I'd have NO problem killing the Dog that scared my kids at all.
The reason I didn't is because I like the Family, and would not want to hurt their feelings.