On stupidity and war

I don'y buy laying the total blame on Hamas, some of it has to be laid at the feet of Israel as well.

With respect to the air campaign and the ground incursion i do not agree. i do agree that the Israeli reaction to the kidnapping and ultimately to the murder of the 3 teenagers was overly harsh.
 
Of course. Yet in the context, do you have a more moral way for Israel to respond to Hamas attacking their civilians?


(and before you get there Hamas and many Palestinian factions are opposed to Israel existing so won't make peace with them)

Is toning down their success rate considered more moral?
 
Is toning down their success rate considered more moral?

I believe that IDF has done and is doing everything possible to minimize civilian casualties. But when you are fighting in a dense urban area against an enemy that intentionally uses houses, hospitals, and schools for military purposes, and petiole ignore warnings to get out, there are going to be a lot of civilian casualties despite the very best efforts to avoid them.
 
I believe that IDF has done and is doing everything possible to minimize civilian casualties. But when you are fighting in a dense urban area against an enemy that intentionally uses houses, hospitals, and schools for military purposes, and petiole ignore warnings to get out, there are going to be a lot of civilian casualties despite the very best efforts to avoid them.

Trust me...we all know what you believe.
 
Trust me...we all know what you believe.

Moreover I have documented reasons for my beliefs. Have you?

I defy you to name any military in any campaign that had done more to avoid civilian casualties than what we have seen IDF doing here.
 
This definite and paradoxical conclusion - the most instructive, and yet ignored of all lessons of war is categorical: Not one great power possessing superior firepower has won against a weaker, less organised and less professional resistance against occupation.

Not the French, not the English, not the Belgians, the Dutch, the Spanish, the Portuguese, the Italians, the Soviets, the Chinese, the Afrikaners, etc. Not one! In the end, they all lose. And if they don't, then it's not the end.



This is exactly the point, odd no one sees it.

To be fair, we nor the French saw it in Vietnam, the Brits didn't see it (several times)... Perhaps this is a lesson you can't learn if you are in the middle of it.
Is this entirely true. Certainly the Ottoman Turks conquered not only the Arabs but also the peoples of the Balkans. What about the Indian Rebellion and the British Raj.

Perhaps Marwan Bishara means only in the past 100 years?
 
Moreover I have documented reasons for my beliefs. Have you?

I defy you to name any military in any campaign that had done more to avoid civilian casualties than what we have seen IDF doing here.

I don't dispute that, but I also maintain they should be investigated for war crimes as suggested by the UNHRC. Just because you refute them doesn't make them illegitimate.
 
I don't dispute that, but I also maintain they should be investigated for war crimes as suggested by the UNHRC. Just because you refute them doesn't make them illegitimate.

Anyone who feels they have evidence can submit it to the only impartial, fair, transparent and sovereign court with jurisdiction.
 
Do you believe that Iraqis should have voted in the US election while they were occupied by the US? If not your ludicrous anti Israeli bias is showing.

Not the same and you know it, your racism has blinded you.
 
How exactly is his comment an example of racism?

His racism is causing him to make ridiculous reaches to support Israeli policy, however "camelshit" and "stone throwers" give us a sense of where he stands. Also his support of policy that excludes people because of their race.... Just saying.
 
His racism is causing him to make ridiculous reaches to support Israeli policy, however "camelshit" and "stone throwers" give us a sense of where he stands. Also his support of policy that excludes people because of their race.... Just saying.

Texas longhorn shit.

Stating that Gaza and the West Bank are not part of Israel and that the people living there are not Israeli citizens is not a ridiculous reach. It is in fact the official position of the UN, Israel, Palestine, the Arab League, and pretty much everyone else.

No one is excluded because of their race. They are excluded because they are not citizens nor even residents of Israel. Lots of Arabs ARE citizens and indeed they have full voting rights.
 
His racism is causing him to make ridiculous reaches to support Israeli policy, however "camelshit" and "stone throwers" give us a sense of where he stands. Also his support of policy that excludes people because of their race.... Just saying.

Strange that you have questioned fuji's anti-semitism accusations yet you just as quickly jump to the same.

And you are absolutely full of shit about the last part. Israel does not exclude people because of their race as 20% of their population can attest to.
 
Strange that you have questioned fuji's anti-semitism accusations yet you just as quickly jump to the same.

you don't think camel shit and stone throwers are racist? how do you feel about spear chuckers of whops?

And you are absolutely full of shit about the last part. Israel does not exclude people because of their race as 20% of their population can attest to.

Dude, fucking follow along if you're going to wade in. fuji is proposing to keep only the land Isreal wants and chuck the rest (that with the highest Arab population) to someone else so that Israel demographics don't get skewed.... that's racist.
 
you don't think camel shit and stone throwers are racist? how do you feel about spear chuckers of whops?

I did not use "stone thrower" to describe Palestinians as you seem to be implying, quite slanderously. I used the term to describe violent Palestinian protesters as opposed to armed militants.

fuji is proposing to keep only the land Isreal wants and chuck the rest (that with the highest Arab population) to someone else so that Israel demographics don't get skewed.... that's racist.

No, that is potentially illegal annexation of land. And I am not proposing it, I am proposing a two state solution based on negotiated borders with equitable land swaps.

However that is the most likely alternative if no deal is reached. If the Palestinians won't negotiate borders Israel will eventually just set them unilaterally and move on. It won't invite all the Palestinians to move to Tel Aviv to take over.
 
you don't think camel shit and stone throwers are racist? how do you feel about spear chuckers of whops?
Camels shit maybe though it seems to be directed at Hamas, not Palestinian in general. I would have gone with just shit to describe their behaviour. Stone throwers is an accurate description of many Palestinian protests.

Dude, fucking follow along if you're going to wade in. fuji is proposing to keep only the land Isreal wants and chuck the rest (that with the highest Arab population) to someone else so that Israel demographics don't get skewed.... that's racist.
Dude, fucking follow reality. Israel will keep pre'67 Israel and whatever land is swapped in negotiations (if Palestinian factions ever accept peace). The West Bank and Gaza are not part of Israel and the people there don't want to be Israeli so why should they be forced to be part of a state they don't want? Palestinians are massively opposed to a One State solution with equality for all as is shown in regular polling.

Yes his idea that Jordan or Egypt have any desire to reoccupy their former territories will never happen because those countries aren't interested in having Palestinian citizens either (and no, it's not because of Jewish or American money like you want to believe).

If you want to discuss racism in choice of words, I could ask why you chose to describe Israel as "the Jews" in one of your posts.
 
Camels shit maybe though it seems to be directed at Hamas, not Palestinian in general. I would have gone with just shit to describe their behaviour. Stone throwers is an accurate description of many Palestinian protests.


Dude, fucking follow reality. Israel will keep pre'67 Israel and whatever land is swapped in negotiations (if Palestinian factions ever accept peace). The West Bank and Gaza are not part of Israel and the people there don't want to be Israeli so why should they be forced to be part of a state they don't want? Palestinians are massively opposed to a One State solution with equality for all as is shown in regular polling.

Yes his idea that Jordan or Egypt have any desire to reoccupy their former territories will never happen because those countries aren't interested in having Palestinian citizens either (and no, it's not because of Jewish or American money like you want to believe).

If you want to discuss racism in choice of words, I could ask why you chose to describe Israel as "the Jews" in one of your posts.

There are a few Jews in Israel, it is a Jewish republic after all.... I'm not sure there are many Zionist Arabs.....

That said, I meant no offense, my SO is Jewish, many of my friends are Jewish - my observation is though, that most Jews are nuts on the Israel issue - fucking nuts. Normal, progressive, well educated intelligent loving generous people turn into lunatics on only one issue (well, maybe abortion as well, but not to the same level) and that's Israel. No difference of opinion is allowed, I had a Jewish friend of mine say that the Jon Stewart clip I linked to here made him an "ashamed Jew" (whatever the hell that is).
 
Camels shit maybe though it seems to be directed at Hamas, not Palestinian in general.

I was directed at OTB, not Palestinians at all. I just looked for a middle eastern themed alternative to bullshit to describe the nonsense he was spouting off. As he is sensitive about it, I will call his nonsense texas longhorn shit from now on.

It was in response to this: "[Gaza] along with the West Bank are occupied territories, if Israel can't negotiate a two state deal (which they desperately need) there will be one state, soon with an Arab majority." As outlined on this thread that is what Chomsky called "pie in the sky", and what I call bullshit. Or camelshit since we're discussing the Middle East. But it certainly was directed at OTB and not at Palestinians (and I am under the impression that OTB is a white male American.)