On stupidity and war

Do you realize how hillarious that is coming from a Zionist?

Zionism is based on legal immigration. The Zionists entering the Ottoman empire followed Ottoman immigration law, those who entered when it was British adhered to British law, and now Israeli immigration law applies.

You will have to let go of the one state hate fantasy.
 
Rabin would tell Abbas that's a good idea if he could.

If Isreal can't negotiate a two state solution then it will be one state. Right of return is huge, hard to argue you can run someone off their land, steal their land and the peace settlement doesn't involve them being able to go home...

Fuji is quite happy (as apparently are others) to keep the current devastating poverty and violence going indefinitely as long as this serves the Jewish interests. I don't think of it as a demographic bomb, I think landslide is better, I'm sure Qutar would help fund Arab mothers having 10 kids, how long would it take?

Bomb/landslide whatever there will NEVER be one state and the so called right of return will NEVER be acceptable to Israel. Those are just immutable facts and whether the Palestinians like it or not or agree of not it will NEVER change. that being eh case they will have to decide if and when compromise is desirable. Israel will have to make compromises which are equally hard for them. in the meantime the Israelis have a state and the Palestinians have the status quo.

And by the way i do not accept your characterization of how the Palestinian refugee situation arose. Regardless of which narrative you accept in terms of why Arabs left Israel can you point to another situation in which people have been kept in camps for 60 years and deprived of any rights by the host country. There have been many millions of refugees created over the years. No one in history has been treated as poorly by the host countries. No one has their own dedicated UN agency. This is a problem created by the Arab neighbors who have used the Palestinians as their pawns for 60 years and created the misery in which they now find themselves. The two state solution offers the only hope for both sides but both sides will have to compromise and among the compromises the Palestinians will have to make is the sol called right of return. That is just a fact whether you think it is right or just or fair or whatever. Just an immutable fact.
 
Bomb/landslide whatever there will NEVER be one state and the so called right of return will NEVER be acceptable to Israel. Those are just immutable facts and whether the Palestinians like it or not or agree of not it will NEVER change. that being eh case they will have to decide if and when compromise is desirable. Israel will have to make compromises which are equally hard for them. in the meantime the Israelis have a state and the Palestinians have the status quo.

....

This is why some (you'll note not me) have called Israel an apartheid state...
 
Zionism is based on legal immigration. The Zionists entering the Ottoman empire followed Ottoman immigration law, those who entered when it was British adhered to British law, and now Israeli immigration law applies.

You will have to let go of the one state hate fantasy.

Sad that you think one person one vote and equal rights are a hate fantasy....
 
This is why some (you'll note not me) have called Israel an apartheid state...

That would be because they bastardize the use of the word in order to mobilize public sentiment against Israel and in the process dishonor those in South Africa who suffered and those who fought for its abolition.
 
The Israelis don't have to win, merely manage the situation until the Palestinians come around to accepting a two state peace. A messy temporary solution but their only other option is to pack up and abandon their country.

If these guys keep bombing the shit out of each other for 50 years, there won't be a country left that's worth living in. How long can the situation be "managed" before there is nothing left for either side to fight for?
 
I think his analysis fails early:

Hamas remains a formidable force in Palestine

Everything I am reading says otherwise. In fact many analysts say that the only reason they entered a "unity government" is because they were too weak to continue on their own. Egypt has turned against them and turned off their money tap. They certainly get almost nothing via Syria now. Hamas may be more vulnerable now than at any time in their existence.

On another interesting note, the tunnels the Israelis have been engaged with dug by Hamas are full of concrete and reinforced steel that has been put in within the last two or three years. Excellent evidence that the embargo against these products is indeed rational and a defensive act.
 
If these guys keep bombing the shit out of each other for 50 years, there won't be a country left that's worth living in. How long can the situation be "managed" before there is nothing left for either side to fight for?

You may not have noticed but the only place which is getting the shit bombed out of it is Gaza. Hamas is intentionally sacrificing the Gazans and their homes etc for a fight they cannot win and I do not believe most Gazans or Palestinians want. This is a true tragedy unfolding before our eyes.
 
You may not have noticed but the only place which is getting the shit bombed out of it is Gaza. Hamas is intentionally sacrificing the Gazans and their homes etc for a fight they cannot win and I do not believe most Gazans or Palestinians want. This is a true tragedy unfolding before our eyes.

So Hamas isn't bombing Israel? If not, what are they defending themselves against?
 
...

If Isreal can't negotiate a two state solution then it will be one state. ...

No it won't since the Palestinians and Israelis are both immensely opposed to it. If the Palestinians like Hamas refuse to accept the idea of peace then the occupation will continue indefinitely.
 
So Hamas isn't bombing Israel? If not, what are they defending themselves against?

Hamas is doing its damnedest to bomb the shit out of Israel. It just isn't succeeding. The Iron Dome has been pretty successful. As well Isreal has used its concrete to build bomb shelters for its people instead of tunnels through which terrorists can enter Israel to kill civilians. Big difference.
 
... Right of return is huge, hard to argue you can run someone off their land, ...

Except that historians on both sides agree that most left because of fear, not actually forced out. The same goes for Jews who fled their homes in Arab lands. Do they get a right of return too?
 
Hamas is doing its damnedest to bomb the shit out of Israel. It just isn't succeeding. The Iron Dome has been pretty successful. As well Isreal has used its concrete to build bomb shelters for its people instead of tunnels through which terrorists can enter Israel to kill civilians. Big difference.

Israel is clearly more advanced with it's weaponry, no question. It's a war, there are no winners. Lives are being lost on both sides, have been for years and will continue to be for years. Very sad.
 
If these guys keep bombing the shit out of each other for 50 years, there won't be a country left that's worth living in. How long can the situation be "managed" before there is nothing left for either side to fight for?

Israel seems to do a pretty good job. They continue to grow economically. The West Bank seems to be doing okay with new construction and trade. Seems to be only Hamas ruled Gaza that is suffering. Maybe if Hamas gave up on their destructive goals...of course if they did that there would be a two state peace.
 
Israel is clearly more advanced with it's weaponry, no question. It's a war, there are no winners. Lives are being lost on both sides, have been for years and will continue to be for years. Very sad.

I agree there are no real winners and it is very sad. the loss of lives on both sides is tragic. But the cycle will continue at least until Hamas stops trying to sell the Palestinians the dream of pushing the Jews into the sea.
 
Israel seems to do a pretty good job. They continue to grow economically. The West Bank seems to be doing okay with new construction and trade. Seems to be only Hamas ruled Gaza that is suffering. Maybe if Hamas gave up on their destructive goals...of course if they did that there would be a two state peace.

They are so far but the opinions of the world seem to be shifting somewhat and countries who categorically supported Israel in the past are softening that position. If this continues for a few more decades, how will that softening change and how will it impact the economy of Israel?
 
I agree there are no real winners and it is very sad. the loss of lives on both sides is tragic. But the cycle will continue at least until Hamas stops trying to sell the Palestinians the dream of pushing the Jews into the sea.

I don'y buy laying the total blame on Hamas, some of it has to be laid at the feet of Israel as well.
 
I don'y buy laying the total blame on Hamas, some of it has to be laid at the feet of Israel as well.

Of course. Yet in the context, do you have a more moral way for Israel to respond to Hamas attacking their civilians?


(and before you get there Hamas and many Palestinian factions are opposed to Israel existing so won't make peace with them)