No More Free Speech?

No, the case cited in the original thread raises interesting questions about whether organizations should be more accepting of diverse views.

However, freedom of speech is about having the right to express your views without fear of state censorship. There was no state censorship in this case.

The title of the thread is "no more free speech?" If anything, taking discussion away from free speech is what will derail it.
 
i am not sure why people are being coy about his resignation. he was forced to resign- which is the same as being fired. it was a constructive firing. i am not sure why those that support the peer pressure which caused this to happen, shy away and pretend he woke up one day and thought "oh i don't like being ceo, I am going to quit". he was forced out because of the mob. some people thinks thats ok and some don't but don't pretend he wasn't fired, or that downloading isn't stealing or that wearing your pants with your underwear showing doesn't mean you are not an idiot
Exactly. He had only been CEO of Mozilla for 1 month, why would he then suddenly quit, and on top of that tell the whole world he quit because he gave some donation to an anti-gay cause.

Makes no sense to any rational person. He was pushed out by the gay mafia, end of story
 
I think it's time people revisit the Boy Scouts of America v Dale case. Eich has freedom of speech, but Mozilla has freedom of association. I'm not sure how California will interpret it, but no state law can supersede or overrule the constitution, and the Boy Scouts v Dale case was determined under the constitution's freedom of association. They can ban gays joining because they can associate with whoever they want. Likewise, since the CEO is part of the Board, the Board can chose to associate with who they want.

A lot of the comparisons and analogies and arguments ignore the fact that Eich was CEO, as if it's somehow irrelevant. If your argument doesn't address the problem that as CEO everything he does represents the company and there is no such thing as "his own free time", then your argument is invalid.

And those are to cover the argument that he was "fired", but I also find it difficult to imagine that Mozilla is blatantly lying.

Corporate Counsel's Marlisse Silver Sweeney adds, 'Mozilla is adamant that the board did not force Eich to resign, and asked him to stay on in another role. It also says that although some employees tweeted for his resignation, support for his leadership was expressed by a larger group of employees. And this is all a good thing for the company from a legal standpoint.'

Surely CEO's aren't "offered other positions" on a handshake. There's a paper trail somewhere. I don't for one second believe he was told to "leave Mozilla or you're fired", because if they had the legal right to fire someone and wanted them gone, they'd just do it. He decided to leave. That's all we know. Any argument that this was more than a mutually-agreed upon decision is speculation. Even Eich says he left voluntarily. If you want to call everyone that was there a liar, that's fine. But they're all telling a very similar story and I'm more inclined to believe what Eich says about his leaving than I am an anonymous someone on an internet forum.
 
Exactly. He had only been CEO of Mozilla for 1 month, why would he then suddenly quit, and on top of that tell the whole world he quit because he gave some donation to an anti-gay cause.

Makes no sense to any rational person. He was pushed out by the gay mafia, end of story

Because he didn't realize how much pressure he would be under? Because he wanted to get out of the spotlight all the shit had caused? Because he wasn't really aware what the job would be when he started? Because he got a better offer at another company?

What makes no sense is calling the guy a liar. If he was "forced out" and it's "illegal and unfair", why not let them fire him and then turn around and sue? You say it makes no sense to a rational person, but I'd consider myself to be rational and the idea that he volunteered to leave if it was so obviously illegal instead of making them fire him doesn't make sense to my rational mind. Is it possible that "rational" can have more than side? Eich says he quit. I take Eich's word over yours and red's, no offence.
 
And that's mostly true... Unless you spread hate speech or any other form of speech that limits your right, or unless you're the representative of a company, like CEO, in which case your job is to represent that company. In that case, your opinion is the company's opinion. And if the company doesn't like it, you've failed at your job. So even if Eich had been fired, which he wasn't, there is no guarantee that what happened would've been unfair, unconstitutional or wrong.

If "your opinion is the company's opinion", the correct thing, if 'the company' (= the other employees) don't like your opinion, would be for the other employees to leave.
 
Because he didn't realize how much pressure he would be under? Because he wanted to get out of the spotlight all the shit had caused? Because he wasn't really aware what the job would be when he started? Because he got a better offer at another company?

What makes no sense is calling the guy a liar. If he was "forced out" and it's "illegal and unfair", why not let them fire him and then turn around and sue?
Because he probably got some type of large severance package
 
If "your opinion is the company's opinion", the correct thing, if 'the company' (= the other employees) don't like your opinion, would be for the other employees to leave.

They aren't other employees, they are the stakeholders, ie "The Company". They, collectively, are what make up the corporate entity known as the company. They hired you to represent them. If you fail to represent them because your opinions or values aren't in line with theirs, you are no longer doing the job they pay you for. Why should they leave because you fail to do your job?
 
If "your opinion is the company's opinion", the correct thing, if 'the company' (= the other employees) don't like your opinion, would be for the other employees to leave.

Other employees aren't the company. Other employees are other employees. The company is the legal entity whose actions, including the determination of the company's morals and opinions, are determined by the stakeholders. The stakeholders hire the CEO to represent the company to the outside world (among other things). If the CEO is no longer representing the company values as determined by the stakeholders, than the CEO is no longer doing the job for which he isn't being paid. The idea that stakeholders should change companies is laughable.
 
Because he probably got some type of large severance package

So..they blackmailed him is what you're saying? Or was it a mutual decision they made that Eich should leave but he should get some compensation? I mean, what about this severance made him leave against his will if that was the case? Or was the severance so good and so fair that he had no problem leaving? Because if it was so good that he had no problem leaving.... you're still stuck with the fact he "chose" to leave.

How do you account for the fact that he didn't say no? If it was so wrong, and he was "forced" out, why not say no, let them fire him, and then take it to court? As it stands now, if he wanted to take them to court, he'd have to justify why he didn't do exactly that, why did he volunteer to go if it was so wrong?
 
They aren't other employees, they are the stakeholders, ie "The Company". They, collectively, are what make up the corporate entity known as the company. They hired you to represent them. If you fail to represent them because your opinions or values aren't in line with theirs, you are no longer doing the job they pay you for. Why should they leave because you fail to do your job?

Other employees aren't the company. Other employees are other employees. The company is the legal entity whose actions, including the determination of the company's morals and opinions, are determined by the stakeholders. The stakeholders hire the CEO to represent the company to the outside world (among other things). If the CEO is no longer representing the company values as determined by the stakeholders, than the CEO is no longer doing the job for which he isn't being paid. The idea that stakeholders should change companies is laughable.

I was commenting on your point that "your opinion is the company's opinion".
 
So..they blackmailed him is what you're saying? Or was it a mutual decision they made that Eich should leave but he should get some compensation? I mean, what about this severance made him leave against his will if that was the case? Or was the severance so good and so fair that he had no problem leaving? Because if it was so good that he had no problem leaving.... you're still stuck with the fact he "chose" to leave.

How do you account for the fact that he didn't say no? If it was so wrong, and he was "forced" out, why not say no, let them fire him, and then take it to court? As it stands now, if he wanted to take them to court, he'd have to justify why he didn't do exactly that, why did he volunteer to go if it was so wrong?
Blue, have you been following this case up close, because it doesnt like it. Here's the timeline:

Eich becomes CEO approximately 1 month ago at Mozilla.
Gay groups dig up info on Eich about his $1K contribution through FOI records.
The dating website OKcupid gets wind of this, and decides to boycott Firefox browser from accessing their site.
Other gay groups join the pile-on.
Eich suddenly "quits", only 1 month into his employment.

Now what do you think happened here, BL??
You think he just quit because the cafeteria food sucked at Mozilla corporation??
 
Blue, have you been following this case up close, because it doesnt like it. Here's the timeline:

Eich becomes CEO approximately 1 month ago at Mozilla.
Gay groups dig up info on Eich about his $1K contribution through FOI records.
The dating website OKcupid gets wind of this, and decides to boycott Firefox browser from accessing their site.
Other gay groups join the pile-on.
Eich suddenly "quits", only 1 month into his employment.

Now what do you think happened here, BL??
You think he just quit because the cafeteria food sucked at Mozilla corporation??

Actually

In March 2012 it was publicized that in 2008 Eich had donated $1,000 to the campaign for California Proposition 8.[12] This revelation provoked some criticism at the time in social media, particularly Twitter.[13]

Controversy over the donation appeared again when Eich became CEO of Mozilla Corporation in 2014. In the ensuing public debate, some LGBT activists called for a boycott of the company.[14] A number of Mozilla employees asked him to step down, while others spoke out on their blogs in his favor.[15][16]

Three of Mozilla Corporation's five directors resigned following Eich's appointment,[17][18] which the Mozilla Foundation attributed to "a variety of reasons. Two of the board members had been planning to leave for some time, one since January and one explicitly at the end of the CEO search, regardless of the person selected."[19] On April 3, 2014, Eich stepped down as CEO.[20][21] In his personal blog, Eich posted that "under the present circumstances, I cannot be an effective leader."
 
^^^^^ right, but nothing in your post conflicts with what I'm saying
 
I was commenting on your point that "your opinion is the company's opinion".

I know what you were commenting on. My point remains. Your premise was that if "the company" doesn't like the CEO's opinion, the "other employees should leave". That's exactly what you said. In other words, you're saying the "other employees" are the company. But they aren't. 'The Company' is the stakeholders. And they aren't employees. And since 'the stakeholders', ie the company, hired you to represent their opinions, failing to do so means you're failing to do your job.
 
Blue, have you been following this case up close, because it doesnt like it. Here's the timeline:

Eich becomes CEO approximately 1 month ago at Mozilla.
Gay groups dig up info on Eich about his $1K contribution through FOI records.
The dating website OKcupid gets wind of this, and decides to boycott Firefox browser from accessing their site.
Other gay groups join the pile-on.
Eich suddenly "quits", only 1 month into his employment.

Now what do you think happened here, BL??
You think he just quit because the cafeteria food sucked at Mozilla corporation??

You've read my other posts, you know exactly why I think he quit - he reached an agreement with the stakeholders. If he didn't, he would've stayed and they would've been forced to fire him. But at least now you're using the right words - he quit. Did they pay him off to leave with a severance package? Possibly. That still means he chose to take the package and leave. Unless he was blackmailed or forced out on some other grounds (like they said, "Quit or we're going to charge you with sexual harassment against several of our employees which we've paid to fabricate a case against you"), it's perfectly fair for an employee and an employer to negotiate a settlement in exchange for them leaving. It doesn't mean he was given no choice. He obviously had a choice - he could've forced them to fire him. Why the fact that he got some severance somehow means his "quitting" is the same as being fired is beyond logic.
 
When we fire someone in our company we say he or she left "for personal reasons" or "to pursue other interests". We never say we fired Joe because he said he was upset with nudity at the Gay Pride Parade.
 
I think it's time people revisit the Boy Scouts of America v Dale case. Eich has freedom of speech, but Mozilla has freedom of association. I'm not sure how California will interpret it, but no state law can supersede or overrule the constitution, and the Boy Scouts v Dale case was determined under the constitution's freedom of association. They can ban gays joining because they can associate with whoever they want. Likewise, since the CEO is part of the Board, the Board can chose to associate with who they want.

A lot of the comparisons and analogies and arguments ignore the fact that Eich was CEO, as if it's somehow irrelevant. If your argument doesn't address the problem that as CEO everything he does represents the company and there is no such thing as "his own free time", then your argument is invalid.

And those are to cover the argument that he was "fired", but I also find it difficult to imagine that Mozilla is blatantly lying.



Surely CEO's aren't "offered other positions" on a handshake. There's a paper trail somewhere. I don't for one second believe he was told to "leave Mozilla or you're fired", because if they had the legal right to fire someone and wanted them gone, they'd just do it. He decided to leave. That's all we know. Any argument that this was more than a mutually-agreed upon decision is speculation. Even Eich says he left voluntarily. If you want to call everyone that was there a liar, that's fine. But they're all telling a very similar story and I'm more inclined to believe what Eich says about his leaving than I am an anonymous someone on an internet forum.

Stay on in another role is the same as constructive termination
 
I know what you were commenting on. My point remains. Your premise was that if "the company" doesn't like the CEO's opinion, the "other employees should leave". That's exactly what you said. In other words, you're saying the "other employees" are the company. But they aren't. 'The Company' is the stakeholders. And they aren't employees. And since 'the stakeholders', ie the company, hired you to represent their opinions, failing to do so means you're failing to do your job.

blueLaser, baby, I accept your ruling. My way of saying thanks for the excellent notes you wrote about Lastpass in the other thread.
 
But at least now you're using the right words - he quit
I put quit in quotation marks. That means I don't think he quit.

He was asked to leave, thats what I think. Maybe he got a severance, maybe he didnt.
Maybe he just didnt want to upset the apple cart because he didnt wanna blackballed by the entire software industry. Or maybe he's good friends with the other CEO's and didnt wanna create a fuss.

One thing's for sure, the reason he's no longer employed by Mozilla is because of his political beliefs
 
I put quit in quotation marks. That means I don't think he quit.

He was asked to leave, thats what I think. Maybe he got a severance, maybe he didnt.
Maybe he just didnt want to upset the apple cart because he didnt wanna blackballed by the entire software industry. Or maybe he's good friends with the other CEO's and didnt wanna create a fuss.

One thing's for sure, the reason he's no longer employed by Mozilla is because of his political beliefs

No, you don't think he was asked to leave. You've made that very clear. If I ask you to pass the salt, you can tell me to get bent. It's quite clear that you believe he was fired and everything else is smoke and mirrors. I think he was asked to leave. And I think he accepted that. I think he chose to go, for whatever reason, possibly because he got a nice settlement, but chose to go all the same. Therein lies the different. What I think is supported by what everyone involved has said, what you think is supported by hypothesis and assumption.