No More Free Speech?

No, you don't think he was asked to leave. You've made that very clear
Yes, I do think he was asked to leave.

Whether you're asked to leave, asked to leave or told you're gonna get fired, or whether you're fired altogether. Makes no difference to me. Its the same monkey just dressed up in a different skirt
 
Yes, I do think he was asked to leave.

Whether you're asked to leave, asked to leave or told you're gonna get fired, or whether you're fired altogether. Makes no difference to me. Its the same monkey just dressed up in a different skirt

I guess your parent's skipped this part when you were growing up:

ea019affd66a910592f65415277434d414f4141.jpg


I don't know how many times I have to say, I was asked to leave a job once and said no. You can always say no. You have a choice. If you say no and they don't fire you, then in what way were you treated unfairly? If you say no and they subsequently fire you, you may or may not have a case. If you say yes... Then you quit. You chose to leave. And the responsibility for leaving falls squarely on your shoulders, no one else's.
 
I guess your parent's skipped this part when you were growing up:

ea019affd66a910592f65415277434d414f4141.jpg


I don't know how many times I have to say, I was asked to leave a job once and said no. You can always say no. You have a choice. If you say no and they don't fire you, then in what way were you treated unfairly? If you say no and they subsequently fire you, you may or may not have a case. If you say yes... Then you quit. You chose to leave. And the responsibility for leaving falls squarely on your shoulders, no one else's
The point is he was still asked to leave because of his political beliefs, which in California is against the law.

So yes, he couldve said no I want to stay, but maybe he felt it wouldve blackballed him throughout the entire software industry. Even winning a lawsuit for wrongful dismissal may not have been worth it to him. Not everybody in the US is sue-happy, although that would probably put him in the minority :biggrin1:
 
The point is he was still asked to leave because of his political beliefs, which in California is against the law.

So yes, he couldve said no I want to stay, but maybe he felt it wouldve blackballed him throughout the entire software industry. Even winning a lawsuit for wrongful dismissal may not have been worth it to him. Not everybody in the US is sue-happy, although that would probably put him in the minority :biggrin1:

It's not illegal to be asked. Reread the section of the law you quoted in red. Oh wait, I forgot, you don't read your references 'cause you post from work and don't have time. I'll summarize. It's illegal to threaten to fire people for political reasons or adopt policies that encourage employee's political views and actions. If they didn't threaten anything, they didn't break the law. And as of right now, there is no indication that there were any threats other than speculation. Whatever his reasons were he CHOSE to leave. That puts the responsibility squarely on his shoulders. He eats it now unless he can prove he was coerced.

And frankly, it's hilarious and sad at the same time that so many people are up in arms "supporting" a guy who doesn't seem too upset about it all. You'd think if he was treated so unfairly, and if this represents the end of freedom of speech at the workplace, he'd be a little miffed, but he seems rather serene about it all.

There has also been no defense mounted by you to my argument that Eich failed his job as CEO as could, arguably, have been terminated for cause, even though he wasn't, be not representing the views of the company. There seems to be multiple holes in your arguments. Starting with "asking" and "telling" mean the same thing down to ignoring that he failed in fulfilling his job description.
 
It's not illegal to be asked. Reread the section of the law you quoted in red. Oh wait, I forgot, you don't read your references 'cause you post from work and don't have time. I'll summarize. It's illegal to threaten to fire people for political reasons or adopt policies that encourage employee's political views and actions. If they didn't threaten anything, they didn't break the law. And as of right now, there is no indication that there were any threats other than speculation. Whatever his reasons were he CHOSE to leave. That puts the responsibility squarely on his shoulders. He eats it now unless he can prove he was coerced
He was pushed out, you idiot. Almost every media article either confirms this or hints at it.

God, you're stupid
 
He was pushed out, you idiot. Almost every media article either confirms this or hints at it.

God, you're stupid

Maybe I'm an idiot, maybe I'm stupid, but at least I didn't admit I don't read things and then turn to those things for defense. Let's take a sampling.

Forbes makes it very clear in this opening paragraph: "First, though, there’s a matter that we should all be clear about: Brendan Eich was not fired. After his appointment, there was backlash from the Mozilla Community. He came under pressure to resign and he did."

Huffington Post covers it in their title: "Brendan Eich's Resignation: Did Mozilla CEO Step Down Because Of A 'Gay Mafia'?"

Daily Beast says: "Eich resigned presumably because he and his company figured the bad publicity they were getting from this, and the financial knock-on on their business, would be adversely affected by the revelation of his Prop 8 donation." The "he and his company" bit sure makes it sound like a mutual decision.

This is how CNN introduced the subject: "Just ten days after taking the job, Brendan Eich has resigned as CEO of Mozilla after sparking outrage over his donation to an anti-same-sex marriage campaign."

CBC had this to say: "Mozilla co-founder Brendan Eich is stepping down as CEO and leaving the company following protests over his support of a gay marriage ban in California."

MSNBC says: "Under fire from all sides, Mozilla’s newly appointed CEO has stepped down over a donation he made in support of California’s former ban on same-sex marriage."

Sounds to me like they are making it very clear that he chose to leave. The CotB of Mozilla went so far as to say this: “I think there has been pressure from all sides, of course, but this is Brendan’s decision.” No one, media or otherwise except anonymous blog and forum posts, has challenged that statement.

In fact, let's go to the most inane, ridiculous, right-wing media outlet there is. Surely they and their anti-Liberal viewpoint will back you up, right?

Fox News: "Just 10 days after taking the reins as CEO, Eich made what was probably the most difficult decision of his career and quit the company he loved."

If you have an anti-socialist, anti-liberal opinion and even Fox isn't agreeing with you, you know you're in trouble. The media is not confirming he was forced out, they aren't hinting at it, they are make it unequivocally clear that he chose to go.
 
You guys are all wrong. Especially oldjones.
At least learn California law before you post endless drivel.

To fire someone for their political beliefs is illegal in California. So what I suspect happened was Eich was asked to "quit", he probably received a huge severance package, and the only condition was he kept quiet about his "firing".

See California law: http://market-ticker.org/akcs-www?post=228921
Thanks for telling us "…what [you] suspect happened", but your suspicions aren't worth anything more than anyone else's random thoughts. Even mine.

However you have clearly stated yet again, that Eich was not fired. So it's utterly drivelous to discuss your imaginings about what might have been his 'constructive dismissal', but was at least as likely to have been a mutually agreed parting of the ways. In any case it was demonstrably not a firing, the only circumstance in which the California law (which you needlessly cited) might apply.

You haven't established a firing, you haven't established anyone's speech was not free. Just what is the point you are trying to make? That expressed opinions should matter to no one, and get no one aroused enough to respond? Just what remedy might be applied to correct exactly what evil in this instance?
 
He was pushed out, you idiot. Almost every media article either confirms this or hints at it.

God, you're stupid
So you say from thousands of miles away. The folks who were there around the table have publicly stated differently. Aren't you glad you are free to spout your foolishness as you choose? However in any forum that mattered, it would be for the participants to say whether push came to shove.

May I point out that the personal level you're taking the discussion to is just the sort of inappropriate response you're condemning the anti-Eich folks for. If you seek to convince others to your views you have to offer something more solid than your personal suspicions more persuasive than insults.
 
Here you go guys, on April 2nd 2014 Eich says the following:

http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/apr/01/mozilla-ceo-brendan-eich-refuses-to-quit

Mozilla CEO insists he won't resign over 'private' support for gay marriage ban.

Brendan Eich declines to discuss donation to campaign against gay marriage in California but says he will not resign.

“I think I'm the best person for the job and I'm doing the job.”

Then less than a week later Eich suddenly quits after heavy pressure from OKcupid and gay groups.
You have to be a complete moron to not see whats going on here.

Also, look at all the sites who either claim Eich was pushed out, or hint at the fact:

https://www.google.ca/search?as_q=e...=any&safe=images&tbs=&as_filetype=&as_rights=

Thats the last I'm gonna say on this.
You guys either too naive or too dumb to smell the coffee. And I cant fix stupid
 
We are arguing over semantics. Fired or resigned under duress.

It's like arguing that the people who jumped from the twin towers on 9/11 committed suicide.http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...ca-wants-forget-victims-fell-Twin-Towers.html

Of course they did, they decided to jump. Or are you saying let's go back to the dark days of self-delusion when we said "…while the balance of their mind was disturbed" because we couldn't accept the reality. Sometimes suicide seems very sensible. A very poor example.

If Eich is complaining about being fired, then he gets to say it was under duress. You and I don't get to make that case for him. Nor can you persuade anyone not pre-disposed to think as you do by simply repeating it without evidence. To continue your sad comparison, you'd be saying then that everyone should have held on to be actually consumed by the flames of the attack? Or are you suggesting that jumpers were like quitters and so their deaths weren't the result of attack?

What is significantly different is that Eich spoke freely, and provoked freely spoken response, which he and Mozilla then had to deal with. There was no surprise attack by unforseeable terrorists from outside. Again I ask: Whose speech was not free? What remedy are you suggesting might protect it?

It may be semantics, but if the 'victim' isn't saying he was fired, the employer isn't either, and none of the paperwork says so, just how do we apply your remedy?
 
Here you go guys, on April 2nd 2014 Eich says the following:

http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/apr/01/mozilla-ceo-brendan-eich-refuses-to-quit



Then less than a week later Eich suddenly quits after heavy pressure from OKcupid and gay groups.
You have to be a complete moron to not see whats going on here.

Also, look at all the sites who either claim Eich was pushed out, or hint at the fact:

https://www.google.ca/search?as_q=e...=any&safe=images&tbs=&as_filetype=&as_rights=

Thats the last I'm gonna say on this.
You guys either too naive or too dumb to smell the coffee. And I cant fix stupid
I assume you mean the 'stupid' to apply to Eich's change of heart. Or perhaps for once again shooting his mouth off without considering the consequences he was inviting.

Very harsh. Sorry you're going without ever suggesting what needed to be fixed here or how that might be done. Makes one wonder what you thought was the point of six pages: Perhaps to have a few pooners in TO say 'By Gad AK, Spot On! Too bad the cowardly quitter isn't handy to make an example of! Wot!'. Certainly it seemed to have nothing to do with high principles in the real world.

Anyway, you had your free speech, and now you carry the baggage you acquired by it, as we all do. So long.
 
you say this...

And there should be lemonade fountains and peppermint trees.

Dream worlds aside, was no retribution in this case, so there's nothing for you to get het up about..

In the real world speech is free. In the real world that free speech will either be ignored or have consequences. No other options. Of course you knew that, and so did Eich. It's why you spoke, because you wanted to be heard, to influence thinking and change opinions. Are you seriously advocating only agreeable speech should be free?


and this...
[Fixed the missing [/ in your first quote, TERB doesn't quote what's between quote markers as you know. Folks will have to go back to your post for the second, the Cut and Paste was too much for me]

i am not sure why people are being coy about his resignation. he was forced to resign- which is the same as being fired. it was a constructive firing. i am not sure why those that support the peer pressure which caused this to happen, shy away and pretend he woke up one day and thought "oh i don't like being ceo, I am going to quit". he was forced out because of the mob. some people thinks thats ok and some don't but don't pretend he wasn't fired, or that downloading isn't stealing or that wearing your pants with your underwear showing doesn't mean you are not an idiot.
We're making progress, you say it was constructive dismissal. Similar but different from a firing. I can see how such a case could be made. But the important thing is that he does not. At least so far, he does seem to blow hot and cold a fair bit. So there is no injury to redress in a Court. Until a Court rules, constructive dismissal (unlike firing or quitting) is a matter of opinion. Everyone has one. And we're all free to express ours.

All that can usefully be said at this point, is that a lot of intemperate language got folks seriously riled up and there was at least this one unlooked for and regrettable decision as a result. I suspect there wouldn't be much difficulty finding individuals whose life courses were as seriously altered by the misbegotten and failed effort that was Prop 8 as Mr. Eich's was.

That however is life. Speech has influence and consequences. Whose speech was not free? What improper/unlawful mechanism made it not free? What remedy are you suggesting would be proper?
--------------------------------------
Downloading is not stealing BTW. I just yesterday downloaded a new copy of Safari direct from Apple. Quite legal. What you meant to say was that unauthorized downloading of copyrighted materials without the owner's permission is illegal. Although that has some minor similarities with stealing, it's empty rhetorical hyperbole to say it is stealing, and there's an entirely distinct set of offences (with centuries of history) that address it.

But you're free to speak as inaccurately as you wish.
 
When you are CEO a different standard applies than if you are the janitor. Unlike the janitor, he is the voice of the company. Unlike the janitor, his public statements are closely associated with the company. When the CEO goes about making anti-gay remarks and openly promoting anti-gay political positions, then that reflects directly on the company. People wouldn't automatically assume that Mozilla is an anti-gay workplace just because some janitor went about making anti-gay claims. But when the CEO says it, the implicit assumption is that his views are going to be reflected in the way the company operates, even if he denies it.

To talk about this as though regular employment law applies without any consideration at all to the way, as CEO, his statements reflect on the organization, is just ludicrous. His continued presence in the company was causing grave and serious harm to its product line -- had he continued on, more and more important websites would have begun blocking firefox until it was no longer a viable business.

He had to go. Whether he's been paid compensation, and how much compensation, will depend on the contract he signed -- and as he is a high powered guy who would have had high powered lawyers drafting that employment contract, any judge who gets near it is going to defer significantly to the terms of the contract again in a way that they wouldn't for a janitor. A janitor may be presumbed to be signing a contract he doesn't fully understand -- a CEO absolutely had a team of lawyers comb through it before he inked his signature, and knows damned well what he signed, or really has no one but himself to blame if he doesn't.
 
Here you go guys, on April 2nd 2014 Eich says the following:

http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/apr/01/mozilla-ceo-brendan-eich-refuses-to-quit



Then less than a week later Eich suddenly quits after heavy pressure from OKcupid and gay groups.
You have to be a complete moron to not see whats going on here.

Also, look at all the sites who either claim Eich was pushed out, or hint at the fact:

https://www.google.ca/search?as_q=e...=any&safe=images&tbs=&as_filetype=&as_rights=

Thats the last I'm gonna say on this.
You guys either too naive or too dumb to smell the coffee. And I cant fix stupid

Well, to use your own analogy, I bet the people on 9/11 standing in the windows didn't want to jump at first, but then their mind was changed when saw what they were up against. It's quite possible that Eich was asked to resign, and said no. In fact, if you follow on from where he said he wouldn't resign, he goes to great lengths to explain why, and how, and about Mozilla's policies. If he suddenly was unable to effectively manage under the very policies he claimed Mozilla was going to follow, why wouldn't he resign? Or do you now propose that a man can't change his mind?

The wonderful thing about the internet is that you can find anything you want if you stick the right search terms in. I provided you with links from major news media that I found on the first page of google results using the unbiased search string "Brendan Eich Mozilla". You had to stick "pushed out" into your search terms, and half the articles on the first page are refuting that claim. Once again you used a reference you apparently didn't read very closely.

I think we all see what's going on here - a CEO was no longer able to effectively be a CEO because the users of the product the company makes took a stand and he left the company, and people are angry that "the gays" won. Lots of companies have lost CEO's because the CEO ceased to be effective. The reason people have a problem with this one is because homosexuals won. If this had been a case of a guy who had joined the KKK and resigned over it, it would've played out in the news over the span of an hour and he'd have a mere fraction of the defenders he has now. If he had been found to beat his wife, he'd be gone and no one would back him up. The naive one here is the one pretending like this debate doesn't exist ONLY because the LGBT community is still marginalized and the idea that they should have equal rights isn't quite mainstream yet. If Eich had kicked in $1k towards a bill in favour of bringing back segregation, or trying to outlaw interracial marriage, this debate wouldn't be happening on this scale.

A company needs to sell product. If the CEO is the reason the product isn't selling, the CEO is not doing his job and it's perfectly fair to get rid of them. But that isn't even what happened here. Eich left and a discussion of whether it's fair for them to fire him or not becomes a hypothetical one, though you will find that Freedom of Association for a group has been upheld to overrule freedom of association and freedom of speech of an individual before in the US court system.
 
Or, they could have stayed and be roasted to death.

I don't even understand how this comparison has any merit. Was Eich's life all but certain to be ended if he stayed with Mozilla? I mean, c'mon, 9/11 is the new Hitler in the world of internet debating.
 
When you are CEO a different standard applies than if you are the janitor. Unlike the janitor, he is the voice of the company. Unlike the janitor, his public statements are closely associated with the company. When the CEO goes about making anti-gay remarks and openly promoting anti-gay political positions, then that reflects directly on the company. People wouldn't automatically assume that Mozilla is an anti-gay workplace just because some janitor went about making anti-gay claims. But when the CEO says it, the implicit assumption is that his views are going to be reflected in the way the company operates, even if he denies it.

As important members of the community, I would like to see more CEO's exercise their constitutional free speech rights to publicly express their views on a multitude pf social issues, WITH FEAR OF RETRIBUTION.

BTW: Just because one disagrees with a gay, doesn't mean one is anti-gay.
 
As important members of the community, I would like to see more CEO's exercise their constitutional free speech rights to publicly express their views on a multitude pf social issues, WITH FEAR OF RETRIBUTION.

BTW: Just because one disagrees with a gay, doesn't mean one is anti-gay.

I don't think you have ever worked in business. Your statement is very very very far away from corporate reality.